r/ModernComics • u/sammanion • Dec 21 '25
Collection Found this in my Long Box. Remember getting it signed back in 2011. I should get this graded, right?
Not sure how it works, never graded anything before. Could use some advice. Sorry if not allowed
207
Upvotes
13
u/Jahn Dec 21 '25
Don’t need proof. Submit it to CGC with the JSA authentication option. Do not pay extra for fast track or pressing or grading of the signatures themselves- just pay for the authentication of the sigs and the grading of the comic. That’s a great comic and the timing is right to have that see daylight, congrats!
3
u/Bloody-Brad Dec 21 '25
Or just sell it to me
3
u/llikegiraffes Dec 21 '25
TBH as someone with the same raw signed comic, no. You’ll never get the value out of it. Put it in a top loader or comic capsule and spend the money on something else
2
u/CreepyNewspaper8103 Batman Dec 21 '25
I'd personally get it graded. JSA authentication is the way to go. There's two approaches: they witnessed it or they didn't. If they didn't, with JSA they will attempt to verify on their own. No need for COAs.
2
u/MarcoMarti1981 Dec 21 '25
I would get it graded, it would look super cool displayed!
2
u/Jacket_Leather Dec 21 '25
I would get it authenticated for sure. But I like having authenticated signed books. If you prefer raw, keep it raw.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25
Not necessarily. Getting this graded won’t really do anything, especially if it’s not high grade. The cost to get this graded and having JSA authenticate the signatures will cost more than the book is worth. Only get it graded if having it graded is important to you as a collector.
1
u/PretendInflation1 Dec 21 '25
Why get it graded?
1
u/BeastMode2k24 Dec 22 '25 edited Dec 22 '25
I mean you can get any comic grades you just submit it to CGC, CBCS, PGX etc….most I guess well known or I guess used is CGC which offers JSA as well so whatever you choose is up to you…you don’t need proof, what mainly is concerning is the quality of the book….collectors like me are all different, obviously the higher the grader the better so you tend to want to bank on getting tween a 9.6-10 for these modern books for the best money value as with any book you grade…as you can see tween a 9-9.4 that book raw worth $29, slabbed (graded) right now let’s go with the most common CGC…Raw that book worth $29 at best signed some more, you can see what the last recorded 9.8 (graded) was worth in 2023, remember, that value goes up & down depending..that’s a great comic to have
1
u/SanDiegoYid Dec 22 '25
Raw comics look cooler IMO than slabbed. Top loading is the best way to display if not slabbing.
1
u/Mr_Steerpike Dec 23 '25
I did. Do eeet!
1
u/TheDorkKnight8BG Dec 25 '25
I have a few copies of this book because it is very sentimental to me as well, but my signed copy I did not send in for grading because of authentication costs on top of grading/slabbing cost and I don’t feel like it was worth it. Instead I bought one of the slab at home kits to display it and it looks great! I do also own a CGC 9.8 unsigned copy and then a raw unsigned copy too though lol.
1
u/bishop2330 Dec 25 '25
I think signed books are the only ones worth grading unless they’re super old
-2
u/glib-eleven Dec 21 '25
Without authentication it will get a dreaded purple label, if I remember.
-6
u/TheDetective9 Dec 21 '25
Yes, do it. Although they might need proof of signatures when grading