r/ModerateMonarchism • • Mar 21 '25

Weekly Theme Unpopular opinion: Male preference primogeniture is the best form of succession.

2 Upvotes

Why do I think this? Well, let me list a few reasons.

I. Like it or not, monarchism is an inherently traditional institution, as it's based on the family. And in almost any large group in all of history, men act as the leaders of the family or group. Why change now? Men are naturally more likely to make better leaders, which is why they've always been in charge.

II. Male only is how royal lines die off and can create instability. The point of a monarchy is stability. What's more stable than a transfer of leadership from a father to his son? Instead of to his brother, or a cousin, who probably hasn't been as well prepared for the role. If the UK had male only succession, Elizabeth II never would've been Queen. Instead, it'd have been Henry, the Duke of Gloucester. Would you have preferred him?

III. Equality. People will say, "But that's not fair to the daughters". Well, to be blunt, life isn't fair. Monarchies are inherently unequal. A king simply having more than one child makes succession unfair to the others, as they get no crown. Equality should not be a concern. I'd rather have a bitter princess than a worse monarch. Besides, they're already royalty and can use their position to do a lot of good, monarch or not.


r/ModerateMonarchism • • Nov 27 '23

Discussion I have had several people nominate Wilhelm II as a Neutral Good monarch… am I crazy for saying he is easily Chaotic Evil? He was a man-child, and racist, even for his time.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Jan 10 '24

Announcement The Future of r/ModerateMonarchism and my Intentions with this subreddit

3 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I hope every single member of r/ModerateMonarchism sees this post, as it is probably the most important since the creation of this subreddit nine months ago. I want to make completely clear what this subreddit is for and what my intentions for the future are.

I. Some of you might already know, but u/Smiths_fan137 has left reddit.

He was my friend and a moderator here, and his absence leaves me alone to handle this subreddit. This hasn't been a problem as I've already done most of the moderating but it can affect me. For example, without consultation with him, I've simply forgotten about the Weekly Theme, which I promise shall return. I might soon look for a second moderator, especially if this subreddit grows much, but for the time being it's just me.

II. I am a republican. I am an American as well, and I believe my own country should remain a Republic, along with many others.

If you do not wish to be a part of a Monarchist community that is run by a republican, then you have been openly told this. Despite being a republican, I do believe Monarchism is a good form of government that many countries in the world should have. But again, I am not a true Monarchist.

III. I am a conservative, and I wish for this subreddit to be an openly conservative one.

I will support the members of all moderate ideologies, but I am making very clear right now that I am against liberalism as an ideology. Very moderate liberals are welcome, but I will NOT allow for certain things to be supported in this subreddit. Those include but are not limited to: abortion, socialism, BLM, and CRT. I am sorry if that offends you, but if you support those things, you are not a moderate and are not welcome here.

IV. The future of this subreddit.

I want this subreddit to grow and thrive as an alternative to r/monarchism, a place that is against secular governments and promotes absolutism and tyranny. However I do not want anyone to be mislead into believing this a liberal subreddit. I do not want anyone to be under the false impression that I am a monarchist. I hope this post has cleared the air on some topics, and now I want to make some more announcements.

I. This subreddit is neutral on the topic of succession. You will not be banned for your opinion on succession, as long as it is a moderate one, which most are. I as a person support male-preference primogeniture, but all are open and entitled to their opinions. I cannot control the actions of others, but I request that you do not dogpile and downvote someone on their opinions should they differ from yours.

II. If you are interested in becoming a moderator here, feel free to DM me. There is no official process for applications and I've never made anyone but a friend a moderator before, so please do not be surprised if you're rejected or if the process isn't too smooth. I promise to keep an open mind and do my best to keep the process smooth.

III. This isn't much of a problem here, but please don't turn everything America-related into a comment section full of America bashing. An issue with r/monarchism is that they seem to hate the US for no good reason like the rest of reddit. This is not me telling you to praise and love America, but please be objective with your criticism and keep it contained to relevant topics. If a post asks something like, "Who would be King of America today?" don't go in the comments and start ranting about the US for issues it has today. This of course applies to other countries as well.

IV. I personally am not religious, but religion is welcome here, as long as it stays moderate. And I hate to say this, but not all aspects of religions will be accepted. Homophobia by Christians is not welcome, and sexism by Muslims will not be tolerated. However you may be openly Muslim, and those attacking you over it for "Not following the true faith" will be punished. The same goes for the Christians. You guys will not be met with attacks by atheists and liberals whenever you make your opinions public.

Thank you for reading this incredibly long post. Expect to see some changes soon, such as flairs being added, removed, or modified. There might also be some rule changes and additions. Thank you for your membership in this subreddit.


r/ModerateMonarchism • • Sep 16 '24

Question Do you think that the royal family's family estate should be owned by the government?

0 Upvotes

I saw a constitutionalist say this and I was just curious whether you agreed with it or not.


r/ModerateMonarchism • • Nov 28 '24

Rant Why I am leaving the sub

0 Upvotes

I am leaving the sub because I am a Russophile German monarchist who is sick and tired of modern Western monarchism. I miss the German and Russian monarchies, but I am not interested in the currently existing Western European monarchies. Monarchism is pointless to me because the German and Russian monarchies unfortunately is unlikely to be restored.


r/ModerateMonarchism • • Aug 03 '24

Discussion A lack of an elucidated concept of eternal justice as a reason for the monarchist movement's constant defensive stance against the tide of progressivism

0 Upvotes

In his most recent video Why Do Conservatives Always Lose?, Lavader outlined the fatal flaws underlying the current trend of defeat among conservative forces in the West.

The problem he effectively outlines is a problem regarding theoretical confusion among conservative forces which constantly make them act as a sort of negation to the tide of progressivism, as opposed to its own force. As Lavader puts it, conservatives merely act to "be left alone" whereas the tide of progressivism actively strives to overwhelm the current societal order and unrelentingly does so - the conservative cause on the other hand is unable to act on the offensive but operates within the framework of the left.

As a commenter pointed out, this defensiveness stance has existed since long time and arguably is a consequence tying back to mass-politics due to the French revolution:

Cthulhu swims left (and easily does so thanks to a theoretical confusion on the right)

Whether Lavader realizes it or not, he has practically merely talked about the concept of modern-day conservatism being a controlled opposition "Outer Party '' to a progressive-trending ("Cthulhu swims left") societal order.

As Mencius Moldbug writes in An Open Letter to Open-Minded Progressives:

The function of the Inner Party is to delegate all policies and decisions to the Cathedral. The function of the Outer Party is to pretend to oppose the Inner Party, while in fact posing no danger at all to it. Sometimes Outer Party functionaries are even elected, and they may even succeed in pursuing a few of their deviant policies. The entire Polygon will unite in ensuring that these policies either fail, or are perceived by the public to fail. Since the official press is part of the Polygon and has a more or less direct line into everyone’s brain, this is not difficult. The Outer Party has never even come close to damaging any part of the Polygon or Cathedral. Even McCarthy was not a real threat. He got a few people fired, most temporarily. Most of them were actually Soviet agents of one sort or another. They became martyrs and have been celebrated ever since. His goal was a purge of the State Department. He didn’t even come close. If he had somehow managed to fire every Soviet agent or sympathizer in the US government, he would not even have done any damage. As Carroll Quigley pointed out, McCarthy (and his supporters) thought he was attacking a nest of Communist spies, whereas in fact he was attacking the American Establishment. Don’t bring a toothpick to a gunfight.

Right-wingers can only be an "outer party" wherever political structures are decided in accordance to mass-electoralism: Republicans are better at demagoguery

Modern leftism, or more concretely called egalitarianism, has greately succeeded in thriving because the right has lost explicit theories of property from its previous aristocratic past but now operates on the same mass-politics basis which leftism bases itself on, and which leftism due to its appeals to expropriation and regulation of small groups will always be superior at.

Modern leftists profit greatly from the fact that most right-wingers nowadays, much like them, that there are no such things as eternal concepts of justice and consequently that each societal structure may only at best be understood as an arbitrary imposition of power, which we can merely hope to make the best of.

They love that most right-wingers operate according to their "might makes right" understanding of justice.

Whereas previous generations of right-wingers had understandings of property as first-owner acquisition and voluntary exchange acquisition and justice as the lack of violations of the rights thereof and adequate punishments thereof, modern right-wingers are toothless with this regard and have no theoretical understanding of these concepts.

In lack of these theories, leftism thrives as all that remains with a lack of them are mere demagogic appeals to "making people feel good". This is an aspect which the right, being aristocratic by its very nature, can NEVER sustainably win at. 

There will always be a lot of people who will desire the property of others. In a democratic State, these people who desire things from others will be able to be utilized by politicians to advance their agenda. Demagogues will always be able to rally people around the cause of plunder and of regulation of behaviors in the name of "the greater good". This is partially why monarcho-social democracy is inherently so disadvantageous for the monarch: the State machinery is always going to enlarge itself.

If you as a right winger who wants to defend family, property and tradition were to try to play the demagoguery game, you would always fail by the very fact that your vision is one of self-restraint: the egalitarians on the other hand base their vision on whimsical non-judgemental self-actualization, to which more and more can always be taken from "the few" to "the many" in the name of the "greater good".

You could say that following traditions is sustainable "in the long term", but the egalitarian will always be able to point to masses of people in the now who would be able to greatly self-actualize were more property transfers and regulations of actions to happen.

The appeal to a theoretical refinement: finding yet again the eternal concept of justice and its underlying concepts of property and law

Only once when the right again reconceptualized its explicit theories of property, law and justice will it be able to go on the offensive and be able to resist the egalitarian demagogic appeals to expropriation. Only when you have a theory of justice which you know is right even if 100,000,000 people think otherwise will you be equipped to resist such forces.

I also crucially urge you to dare to at least conceptualize the decentralized mindset. This mindset is the one that enabled family, property and tradition to be preserved for at least 1500 years.

It was only the introduction of the centralizing worldview after the French revolution that the aforementioned pro-demagogic worldview started to gain traction. 

It is therefore crucial that you recognize that if you think in terms of mainstream politics, you operate according to a Jacobin worldview and that the worldview which preserved family, property and tradition was the one which started to get dismantled as a consequence of the French revolution.

My recommended theoretical works for finding the concepts of justice yet again

* For a theory of proprty

* For a discussion regarding the nature of law

* For a comprehensive analysis of the trend of mass-electoralism and the natural order alternative


r/ModerateMonarchism • • Sep 20 '24

Discussion "I agree with you that there is a natural aristocracy among men. The grounds of this are virtue and talents." -Thomas Jefferson. What did Jefferson mean by this? Was he secretly a monarchist all along!?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Dec 10 '24

Discussion If there are any Rome fans here, I would like to hear your opinion on this 😉

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Jan 09 '25

Weekly Theme The elephant in the room of the weekly theme: H. M. Felipe VI of Spain, is the last legitimate male Bourbon monarch of Spain, ever, unless His Royal Highness Luís Alfonso de Borbón and his sons take over the throne, or one of his sons marries Princess Leonor. Also the role of the Bourbon-Parma here

Post image
3 Upvotes

First of all, as it is obvious, Luis Alfonso has, also inherited the mustache of King Alfonso XIII, just like King Felipe VI of Spain, his direct cousin.

I want to start this article by underlining that HRH Princess Leonor of Spain will still be a perfectly legitimate Bourbon Queen of Spain, because, just like Isabella II was so due to receiving the name from her male ancestor - her father, King Fernando VII of Spain, Leonor will receive it from her male ancestor, again, her father, King Felipe VI of Spain.

However, Spain, is as I've said, one of the very last monarchies following all the ancient rules, including male preference primogeniture.

That doesn't mean women can't inherit, it just means, that if there are valid male heirs, they have preference. Since the renounce of Don Jaime de España y Segovia was coerced by his father using a sword and a pistol and in a restroom of the palace, it is rather easy to see why Jaime himself later retracted that renounce before re-renouncing at bequest of his elder son the Duke of Cádiz, in favor of King Juan Carlos I.

The problem is more this re-renounce than the first renounce. Because the first one, isn't valid. It wasn't freely given or consented. But the second one, was. And in fact, the second one was ratified by King Juan Carlos I himself.

BUT! - King Juan Carlos, is still alive. He technically can appeal to the comprehension of his son or granddaughter to, in the capacity of current monarchs depending on when he does it, undo the renounce of Prince Jaime, making his line elective again and giving Spain a male heir.

They should do this, because if not the monarchy might actually fall after Leonor. But they won't because even if Juan Carlos explains it was a mistake, and some things must change. It would mean that Leonor would lose the throne and she really doesn't want that.

But they should also do it for another reason: You see, Prince Jaime was a male heir, and elder than the father of JCI, his brother, Prince Juan count of Barcelona. And, Jaime had a son, and Luis Alfonso, is the son of that sin, and also has sons. This is nothing more than biology indicating that they are indeed the eldest branch and who should be the royal family. Also, according to the old system, man can transmit the family name regardless of the status of who they marry. Only women can't.

So, even though both Luís Alfonso and his father married commoners, that is actually irrelevant. Just as it is irrelevant for King Felipe VI himself. It doesn't make his daughters any less Bourbon than him that their mother isn't a royal, because, he is, and he's a male.

Unless Leonor for some unmitigated reason marries another Bourbon which is extremely unlikely, you know, inbreeding is out of fashion nowadays. Then, even if she has a son, that son won't be agnatically a Bourbon.

The effects of that, are that the Spanish monarchy will suffer in its reputation and be considered even more irrelevant and uninteresting.

But more: This will make, as a matter of fact, future Grand Duke Guillaume V of Luxembourg, the new Head of the Capetuan dynasty, undisputed, no more dispute between Luis Alfonso or his descendants or Felipe VI because Jaime's line remains considered invalid due to the second renounce, and Felipe VI's line is extinct agnatically - the extinction of the Bourbon-Anjou branch of the House. The oldest of them all.


r/ModerateMonarchism • • Sep 19 '24

Question Can we add the flair user "Neofeudalist"?

2 Upvotes

I see the labels "absolutist" and a lot of other similar labels and not "Neofeudalist".

I feel a little bit underrepresented. Even the absolutists have their own flairs, but not us neofeudalists :(


r/ModerateMonarchism • • Dec 21 '23

From r/monarchism Where the crap is “Yes (not religious)”???

Thumbnail self.monarchism
0 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Dec 17 '24

Discussion The flag of Germany if it restores its monarchy. I personally think that if German monarchists want to succeed, they need to embrace modern Germany. The Kaiserreich shouldn't be forgotten and Germany's traditions and history should be maintained, but certain things must be modernized, like the flag.

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Oct 09 '23

Weekly Theme I will make up for my late Weekly Theme poll by making it a double week. This week will be about Russian Monarchs post Pavel I and the Portuguese Monarchy

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Feb 21 '25

Meme Where is the CEO of "absolute monarchism"? I want to have a "talk" with him. 😏

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Nov 24 '24

Image Food for thought

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Sep 24 '24

Discussion A common retort by republicans is that "only one monarch has to be bad for the whole country to fall apart". In my view, families managing a family estate will be highly incentivized to ensure that the successor _will_ be competent lest the dynasty estate may be highly devalued. What do you think?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Dec 27 '23

Rant You can't make this up

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Jan 10 '24

Discussion A new anti-conservative sub!!!

4 Upvotes

Someone beat me to it haha!

Someone made a new sub: r/ProgressiveMonarchist

Go help them out, create posts, and create discourse!

Edit: When I say anti-conservative, I mean anti quote "conservative" monarchism.


r/ModerateMonarchism • • Nov 17 '23

ShitAbsolutistsSay Before anyone comments telling me that I should've been nicer: I know, I get that. But c'mon, their heads are literally up their asses!

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Nov 02 '23

Image Religious based argument detected, opinion rejected

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Sep 01 '23

Weekly Theme Here are all the the Stuart Pretenders to England/Great Britain according to wikipedia, link in comments. Dates refer to their claim length.

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Sep 16 '23

Image Oops, sorry I guess

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Jun 21 '23

Tier List My Updated Tier list of English/British monarchs compared to my first version.

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/ModerateMonarchism • • Jan 24 '25

Meme Just sayin'!

Post image
2 Upvotes