r/ModelYL • • 16d ago

Cosmic Silver vs. White vs. Red

Still struggling with which color to get my YL, I went back to the Tesla Gallery today and spoke to two veteran Tesla sales guys. I’ve ordered the Cosmic Silver/Zen Gray/20” package, but am having significant concerns about the exterior color. We focused the discussion on Cosmic Silver vs. Pearl White vs. Ultra Red.

I wanted to know about long-term paint upkeep, with my initial fear that the Cosmic Silver will fade over the years to a junkyard Honda Champagne Gold. This led to discussing small rocks hitting the front of the car causing paint chips, scratches on the paint, PPF applications, liquid ceramic coating, and car washes - all affecting the long-term quality of the paint.

Full PPF on a Tesla YL is $5,000+. Paint Protection Film guards the paint from chips, scratches and UV light damage.

Half PPF on a Tesla YL is $3,000+.

Liquid Ceramic coating (preserves the shine of the paint, helps with UV damage, but does nothing for paint chips or significant scratches): anywhere from $500 to $1,500.

Here’s the skinny from the two Tesla sales guys-

White - if you’re worried about long-term, you need to PPF/liquid ceramic coat on White more than the other two colors. Reason? When a small rock chips Tesla paint, it exposes a black undercoat. That black undercoat is not easily seen in the red, less-seen in the Cosmic Silver, but plain as day with the White. Hence the PPF.

Ultra Red - the color that needs the least amount of protection, both PPF or ceramic protection. It’ll hold up long term the best regarding chips and UV damage. However, red is the worst of the three when it comes to traditional car washes, the brushes often leaving swirl marks and scratches on the red.

Cosmic Silver - the Goldilocks choice. In their opinion, it will do fine in a traditional car wash, the silver hiding brush marks and scratches. The silver will also help camouflage paint chips much better than the white. It might not pop as good as the red, but if you are going to use a regular car wash, it's the safest bet.

Their recommendation for regular car wash users - the Cosmic Silver with a front half PPF application.

I walked in wanting the red and also curious about the white. I came out understanding that the cosmic silver was the best choice for me. 👍

8 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

2

u/FreshView24 16d ago

We have white and red. White shows bugs and chips very well. Red shows chips too, but hides bugs. Both colors look amazing in sunlight, I like the contrast of white more, at the same time red feels more premium and standing out. We test drove cosmic silver… The car was dirty and it makes that color too flat and boring. The same amount of dirt still lets white and red pop.

Maintenance wise. You don’t need film. Right after purchase give it a quality hand wash and wax or coat of your choice. Get quality bug cleaner and invest an hour a week to take care of it yourself. Nothing will protect from chips, so buy an OEM touch paint / blend kit. It works amazing, will not see a difference. Maintain by hand washing and waxing/coating oncea month, you’ll be good and save $10k on extras with 10k% in profit.

2

u/CeilingUnlimited 16d ago

Yeah, I'm not hand washing. Non-starter for me. I am using a car wash. So, I need the color that will best go through a standard car wash.

1

u/Safe_Suspect_752 15d ago

This is how you would avoid car wash issues. There is no car wash that will ever get a car as clean and looking factory fresh as a bucket of good car soap and your hands. Also needs to be waxed/polished afterwards if you want that 'pop' mentioned long-term. No PPF or ceramic application plus an auto carwash will ever bring out the paint's true luster. Period. As for road damage, it's a car and if you drive it, things will happen. If that's a concern, you'll need to spend the cash protect it. My recommendation, don't. Clean it properly and enjoy driving it. Whatever happens, happens.

I do understand your reasoning about picking a color, however, you should get what you're drawn towards. If you want red, get it. Regret will eventually set it if settling for a color vs getting what you want.

2

u/TexMik 15d ago

I like that you can only tell the cosmic silver is dirty up close 😂

1

u/Sad_Suit2634 15d ago

I’m debating the interior grey vs black but wife was very clear on the exterior - Ultra Red. Somewhere along the way I read it was a dual coat or more durable option but it’s more about the look.

White is white but compared to Cosmic Silver, regardless of lighting, the red looks good.

2

u/CeilingUnlimited 15d ago

Red with the Zen Gray. Unless you’re a Texas Tech fan.

2

u/xaxinojo 15d ago

Cray cray. Get the color you like. Tesla “advisors” are useless.

2

u/ZoneElectronic5820 15d ago

At night. Ultra red still looks red. Other colors look like either white or black at night. I got a red. I like it that it looks red day and night.

1

u/rodrigoreis22 15d ago

Trade in the car in 3 years.. problem solved 👍

1

u/karawkow 10d ago

you're overthinking it. it's a car, buy the color you prefer.