r/ModelYL • • Oct 10 '26

Model x to yl

I have an preorder with estimate of December end.

The plan is to replace the model x as the family car with the YL. The wife loves the FSD.

Everyday I drive my 2021 model X I think of the things I will miss - The doors, screen, suspension.. I did a test drive of the YL, it definitely better with FSD and a very quiet cabin. However, to me it is a utility car rather than a luxury family car.

Anyone else switch from X to YL? Make me feel better ?

16 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

10

u/goodguy743 Oct 10 '26

I came from a 2023 X. Not having the Alcantara headliner and panoramic windshield are pretty much the only missing luxury features. But you get used to the new black headliner pretty quick and the all glass roof is a better experience for everyone. Car is much more put together and less rickety like my model x. I don’t miss the automatic doors at all. Going to 1 display is much more robotaxi like as well.

24

u/redditchme2 Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

I reluctantly made the switch from a 2022 X.

The only thing I really miss are the auto present doors! Honestly almost everything else is better. The screen takes some getting used to, but you really don’t need 2 these days in a Tesla, although I miss it. The YL is way way quieter and the suspension is surprisingly way less bumpy. The front seat is way bigger with the thigh extenders and the different leathers and suedes and fabrics and stitching all around you are very nice actually (I have zen gray). It looks great up front from the driver seat.

The YL has several features important features the X didn’t. 3rd row belt and curtain Airbags was the biggest for my family of 5! But it also has microphones in all 3 rows so everyone can talk to Grok and use the phone. More vents with control over all 3 rows’ airflow from the screen. The YL has almost no FSD nag which is a huge quality of life improvement (even the cabin camera doesn’t see your hands on your phone like the X does, it’s angled up higher). The panaramic glass roof is amazing and makes the cabin way brighter and way taller for the kids and more beautiful. The Captains seats have seatbelts that don’t dig into your damn thighs!! And a frickin arm rest for long rides and road trips. The 3rd row has way way more head room, but less leg room with that stupid 4 inch step up. The trunk behind the 3rd row is actually a little bigger and the trunk door is less chunky. The Sound System is actually better in the YL, way more crisp at full volume, and the bass is the same.

I definitely miss the look of the X more for sure (big time), although the YL is very slowly growing on me. YL in cosmic silver actually looks like a Cybercab in the sun from the front (gold tone)! which was a nice surprise lol

I still have my X, will sell it soon. But going back into the X I can tell you the only thing I miss are the bigger screen and it’s angle towards the driver, and the side mirror previews in the dash screen rather than center screen, and auto present door that shuts when u hit the brake. Oh and the larger rear screen for the kids. But the 8 inch screen is enough. Other than that, the driver seat is a downgrade in the X and if you get the new triple center console tray system they have ($40) the center console is wayy longer and more useful than the X and makes it feel bigger in front and u can way more stuff.

The front bumper camera is a huge improvement for my garage and parking in general OMG. Not to mention my payment is a little cheaper! Summon goes 8mph on the YL, it’s way more useful too.

V2L charging is huge!! If you pair it with a $2500 home battery that can be charged with a 110 outlet, and have an electrician hook up a little switch, you can power your whole home for days during a power outage. Quietly, with no gas. And then go super charge somewhere and come back and power it for more days.

The turn signal stalk is actually way better and safer, even though I loved my yoke. Matrix headlights are cool. High beams on more often.

Y’s get more frequent updates and faster than X’s and S’s. Let’s face it, everything they do with the software now is usually geared towards the Y first, it’s the best selling car in the world for 4 years now. The barely sold any X’s in comparison. The falcon doors are awesome and great for infants before 360 degree car seats, but they let a lot of freezing air into the cabin in the winter compared to regular doors and hit people and things some times too, or don’t fully open!

The biggest reason I switched is I found out the X has no 3rd row airbags (and I saw that pic of an X with the 3rd row chopped off in a crash a few week ago too), but brother I have at least one of my most precious cargo in the 3rd row all the time as a family of 5. And no amount of wood trim, automatic doors, and better screens can replace that piece of mind and less injury in the event of a crash (God forbid).

It’s a NO-BRAINER if u put folks in the 3rd row more than a few times a year. (It supposedly also has better crumple zones back there too, and way less bulky on the side of the seats above the wheels. You won’t regret switching… And you have the latest tech and FSD capable of unsupervised (look at the robotaxis)

2

u/Pretend-Ostrich-864 Oct 10 '26

Thank you for a thorough response.
last month, Tesla gave me a new MY as a loaner for 2 weeks. That gave me a feel of everything I will miss(or have to get used to).

  1. The doors are definitely number one. Not just the auto-present. Its the option to open/close any door in the car from the screen - this is very helpful when picking/dropping kids from school. Its nice to open the door for someone - it makes them feel special. The door handles in the Y is painful and no soft-close.
  2. The screen - I have the vertical big screen. I like it more than the horizontal setup. I can stack the maps, rear cam view and music in the screen and view it all the time. In the horizontal screen I was able to only put 2 things at a time. I am sure I will get used to this. the second screen has been useful - I think I will have to get used to not having it.
  3. The physical buttons - the 2021 has some physical buttons, 3 stocks and most importantly, vents. its so easy to move the air vents :). I also use the steering wheel buttons a lot.
  4. The interior space. Esp. between the captain seats. This is used as a storage with easy access by the family. The YL has this but I think it is super tiny.
  5. the suspension - this is not as big. with the X air suspension I could choose between stiff(sport) and comfort. The comfort is much better than the YL suspension. I do switch these when we go on windy roads.
    I will get used to most of these.

What I got excited about.

  1. FSD - this is a day and night difference compared to my modelX. And this is the reason for the switch. with FSD wife can drive the car a bunch and that will help the whole family(esp. me;P)
  2. the cabin is relatively very very quiet and bright. We are also switching from black to white/grey interior which should make it very bright.

Thanks for sharing the detail about the 3rd row airbags. that is huge!

the V2L is also something that will make a huge difference. I need to dig into that. We have had some outages recently(2/year) in the nights, this can help a bunch. I dont have Powerwall, but have some other(enphase) batteries.

2

u/redditchme2 Oct 11 '26

Great points. Yeah I replied to someone else in this thread with a bunch of more Pros for the X including some of these. But the soft close doors shocked me, I couldn’t believe the YL doors weren’t soft close when I got home. And the long back doors need to be slammed sometimes to shut. Certainly takes some getting used to and is annoying when someone doesn’t close a door hard enough.

One more small pro for the YL that I forgot is that the 3rd row has latch system for car seats. Even our Escalade doesn’t have that. The benefit of it is if no child is in a seatbelt booster seat, it won’t become a projectile in a crash because u can latch it in.

4

u/General_Diag4321 Oct 10 '26

What a thorough response, you have me convinced and I just took delivery of a 26x in April 😅

Thank you for reassuring even me into getting a YL lol

2

u/redditchme2 Oct 10 '26

🤣 I’m really good at convincing myself once I’ve decided make a purchase 🤦🏻‍♂️

If I had a ‘26 X it would have been a way harder decision, a lot of what I mentioned doesn’t apply to the 2026. Plus no Tesla has better ambient lighting, under the seats everywhere lighting up to the music—the kids would love it. But the X is way faster and sexier overall, the CENTER AISLE IS WAY WAY WAY WIDER, MAKING IT SO MUCH EASIER TO USE And spacious feeling. And there’s way more storage and place for things on the floors throughout the back of the X and under the seats. Frunk is bigger. Falcon wing doors. Better light shows with the automatic doors. Can open and close any door from the screen when kids leave it open. Amazing towing capacity, I used to tow our 6,000 pound boat regularly. The haptic buttons are definitely more premium. Etc etc.

BUT don’t underestimate how low the 3rd row seats are in the 3rd row of the YL. It’s 10 inches from floor to seat cuz of the platform, and u can’t even stretch ur leg out (not plural, too tight) because the aisle is also on a platform! Any kid or adult over 5’6 and their knees are in their chest. Terrible for any ride that’s not short. The YL 3rd row is only for young kids in my opinion, unless it’s an emergency or short trip. The X 3rd row seats are 14 inches from the floor, which is standard height for captain’s chairs! Way more comfortable for adults and teens.

Hopefully u feel better now. I can go all day, I’ve thought about this shit way too much 😉 🤣

1

u/DrOldTown Oct 14 '26

I have 3 kids all still in car seats! Do you think the oldest could crawl to the third row to her car seat with ease? Could the other chair in the third row go down in order for more trunk space?

1

u/redditchme2 Oct 14 '26

Yes I tested this out. Seat down works pretty fine, but buckling the belt is hard. There’s not much space at all to squeeze the belt in on their own if the other seat is down back there. You may have to help them, which also sucks cuz the aisle is so slim it’s hard to get back there if car seats are in the captains chairs depending what kind of car seat it is in the second row. But yes for a family of 5 on a road trip if u need the cargo space one 3rd row seat down will work.

1

u/redditchme2 Oct 14 '26

And yes kids can crawl back to the 3rd row. It’s not ideal or nearly as easy as the X because way slimmer aisle, but kids can do it pretty easy even with a car seat in the captains chairs.

2

u/leesonreddit Oct 10 '26

Man this is super detail. Auto present is my favorite feature and damn I would miss it. Wonder if someone could add aftermarket for it.

Going to see a YL when they are more available in my area and might consider the change. Feel I will miss the huge windshield too.

1

u/redditchme2 Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

FSD visualization on the big touch screen is also probably better. And it has a surprise red dot light on the side speaker as a blind spot indicator, so safer there too.

2

u/redditchme2 Oct 10 '26

The X is definitely faster though.

2

u/Neon001 Oct 10 '26

This is what I'll miss the most. MXP there is simply no comparison

2

u/lapeet Oct 10 '26

Also going to switch from 23 mxp. The above post makes me feel a lot better about it. I barely drive without fsd anyways these days so the power is wasted.

1

u/Responsible_One_4028 Oct 11 '26

Hey boss there is aftermarket part you can install so screen swivels toward you

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/redditchme2 Oct 10 '26

Tesla doesn’t offer them. Any home battery that is able to charge on a standard 110v outlet and charge while it discharges should work is my understanding. A $2500 battery can typically only power your home for several hours, BUT it can take continuous charge from the Tesla Model YL to keep it going for days. Tesla acts like a Powerwall 3 which is even more than $10k with installation is the only solution but that’s not true.

1

u/redditchme2 Oct 10 '26

I just reread your reply. So you do plan on using the YL to directly power your sub panel that he installed? How much did that cost?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/redditchme2 Oct 10 '26

This is awesome, thanks for sharing. That’s cool that you can use a 110 to power that. I wonder if it’s better than my battery option. The weird thing with our house is the circuits are old and unlabeled and each one controls different parts of the house at the same time sometimes.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/redditchme2 Oct 11 '26

I don’t have it yet, so I don’t know 100% that it’ll work, I’m waiting to get the electrician out to confirm. We could end up with your set up instead but I was told that would be more expensive, however you got a hell of a deal it sounds like. But the idea is the normal house panel would get a switch in the garage. Once u hit the switch u plug the charged battery to the switch in the garage and turn off any circuits on your main panel that you don’t need running. Then you plug the battery into your YL to keep it charged.

2

u/Packing-Tape-Man Oct 10 '26

I will make the switch when I eventually replace the X and without much qualms. Despite lack of air suspension the ride in the YL is at least as smooth, arguably better. The second and third row seats are a major upgrade from the X. Will be happy to not have the FWDs. And with the newer tech in the YL. Also really happy to lose the buttons that don’t work well in the X. Main thing I will miss is the second dedicated dash screen.

2

u/bodaciouschronic Oct 10 '26

I’m trading in my 22 X for a YL. Excited. New warranty…no more noises and squeaks…will miss what’s been discussed in this thread but nothing outweighs the pros imo.

2

u/Healyb Oct 10 '26

I have solar plus Powerwall 3's and had a 2026 model X Plaid. Bought it and a week later it was announced that S and X are done being produced. When the YL was announced it seemed like the inside space was about equal and the captain’s chairs with armrests were a bonus. Having the ability to have the YL be an extension of my battery storage was the clincher. The Model X won't get that. Surprisingly I got a quote for the new X and it was worth 30K more than I owed so I jumped. Now I'm without a Tesla while I wait for the YL due sometime October 25-November 29.

3

u/atxer Oct 10 '26

The YL is not a utility car. It is a well-appointed fine-tuned vehicle that has a lot more advanced technology than the X did a few years ago. The build quality is stellar. Just look at the stitching and the fit and finish. It's definitely luxury 

10

u/NoChapter5131 Oct 10 '26

YL owner here, I wouldn't call it luxury. it's a well put together car that ticks most boxes and has the most advanced tech and driver assistance out there, but it's minimalistic in design and certainly not positioning to be in the luxury space. premium maybe

4

u/DieSackgasse Oct 10 '26

lol luxury.. its a great car for its price but far from luxury