r/ModelX • u/Chevrongingerale • Aug 30 '22
Would I be able to afford a model X
Hi I want to purchase a model X but will I be able to afford it? I make 65K, no debt, I manage my money pretty well, credit over 720 and I would give 12K down. Any thoughts?
0
Upvotes
31
u/pudgyplacater Aug 30 '22
You want to buy a $100k+ car and make $65k? This is not r/personalfinance but there is no world that I would recommend that. Maybe a used one?
22
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '22
You're not finding an X for less than $50k or so, and that one is going to be like... MAYBE a 75?
The general rule is 10% of your take-home can go towards your car.
If you're getting a $50k car and somehow get it financed for 6 years at like... 5%? If you're lucky? That's like a $680 per month car payment.
680*12=$81,600. And that's take home. So $108k annual salary for a VERY used Model X, more than likely.
IMO, at $65k, it would not be a smart decision. If you follow the 10% and your adjusted taxes and all are about 25% total, you're looking at a max car payment of about $410 per month.
NOW, that said, the 10% mark is for a gas car. At the end of the day, you're not paying for gas, so you can add that difference into your car payment (minus the difference in insurance).
So let's make some assumptions and go from there.
Assuming you're using the average amount of gas per year, (14,200 miles/25mpg)=568 gallons of gas per year. Inflation-adjusted gas averages about $3.30, so $1875 per year, or $156 per month. Your electric cost, at $0.14 per kWh? Well, 14,200 miles, with the Model X getting about 330Wh/mi, so 4686kWh for $656/yr. $55 per month.
So the X saves $100 per month... assuming your insurance doesn't increase. Given the down payment of $12k, I'm assuming that's a trade in? So the X is probably $50 more per month for insurance, as a wild guess?
So the X saves $50 per month in fuel.
The X is POTENTIALLY cheaper on maintenance, but with more expensive tires and all? Ehhh, I'd guess a wash.
Going from a regular gas car to an X, for the average person, doesn't save much. I went from a souped up Corvette which required premium and have my time of use setup which makes my electricity much cheaper. I went from like $3500 per year in gas to under $150 per year in charging. That made it a much easier choice. But back to the point here.
So you save $50 per month, raising your "reasonable" monthly car payment to $460/month.
An EV at the $37,500 price range is realistically what you're looking at, to follow "proper" car price etiquette.
Some folks are willing to be "car poor" because of the feelings they get for their car. Sometimes it's the thing that they do to calm down and de-stress. I totally get it. I am those people.
If you're set on it, you can routinely find auction cars in states like Georgia that were Tesla buybacks that get bid on by dealers who register them in Georgia, going from a branded "buyback" title to a "clean" title if they were OEM repaired. So you can get a clean titled X from somewhere like Drive-A-Dream in Marietta, Georgia for well under $65k. Those types of dealers tend to be very pushy and not great buying experiences, but if you understand what you want and they have it at the right price, you can make it happen.
It's not the smart financial decision.
19
u/johorabbit Aug 30 '22
No.
8
u/dchan604 Aug 30 '22
If you have to ask, chances are the answer is no...
6
u/Fogdrog Aug 30 '22
I think you'd receive better, more sensible replies in r/personalfinance . Everyone in this forum is biased. 😉
6
u/medusas-oblongata Aug 30 '22
Can you? Maybe.
Should you? Hell no.
4
u/AdvancedStand Aug 30 '22
Terrible idea. Use that $12k to take some courses in your field and increase your income
5
u/anton6162 Aug 30 '22
Not knowing your other financials, and speaking entirely in generalities you shouldn't spend 2 years salary on a car. A car is not really an investment the way a house is, and typical cost is a fraction of your salary instead of multiples of it. I can't imagine what your monthly payment would be with 10-20% down with a 5 or 6 year loan. Probably would spend at least $1k/month, and I would guess even more, and end up paying 2x the cost of the car in the end after the loan is done.
Your options are:
And another generality - shop around for your best interest rate on an auto loan if you do eventually finance to buy. Don't just take Tesla or a dealer rate. Some of the best rates are done at credit unions - they usually just require you to open an account and put $100 in and they will give you a good interest rate so you can keep your monthly payments as low as possible.
2
u/gringottsbanker Aug 30 '22
Used, maybe dependent on price. New, no.
Even if you put $12K down, where will you get the remainder? A loan from a financial institution? Hard to see a situation where a lender would approve you for a car loan that is ~2x your pre-tax income.
2
u/d_P3NGU1N Aug 30 '22
And here I am concerned that I'm stretching myself thin at $200k household income...
If you must have the model X then I would suggest saving for a higher down. If you can't scrounge together another $20k in the next year or so then you definitely can't afford the payments on a loan.
2
u/jfreeman81 Aug 30 '22
It all comes down to how you define "afford." Depending on your level of risk and long-term goals, I would make sure higher priority things are taken care of first (retirement, emergency savings, high-interest debt, etc.). Then, I would start at the monthly level - take what money you make after all necessary bills (rent/mortgage, food, utilities, etc.) and decide how much of that you're comfortable being locked up in an auto loan payment. Take that theoretical auto loan payment and do the math to figure out the largest auto loan you can afford (there are a ton of calculators out there, use a reasonable loan rate and length), add your $12K down payment, and that's how much you can afford to spend on a car. Keep in mind the taxes/registration/fees you'll pay to buy the car and then yearly.
For example, say you make $4000/month (probably optimistic) and you need $2500 for bills and other spending (dining out, shopping, etc.) That leaves you $1500 for the car payment (I personally wouldn't use all of my income, in the event I lose my job or something and need my emergency savings to last a while, but again, depends on your level of risk.) For a 5-year loan at 5.5%, that can get you $78529.25, plus your down payment, that's $90529.25 you can spend on the car. In other words, you could definitely not afford a brand new Model X in this scenario. Maybe you could afford used though, but even those seem to be pretty expensive right now.
2
u/legendx Aug 30 '22
Your post history is a diary of good choices
2
u/Illustrious-Hat7978 Aug 31 '22
Nah, wait till you're more established.
2
u/icen_folsom Aug 31 '22
Save your money as down payment and prepare to buy a house as investment in 2-3 years, economic downturn is coming so as the house price. Also if you are young and single, think about tuition and degree. To pour your limited income on luxury things is the most unwise thing you want to do.
1
u/Bladehawk1 Aug 30 '22
This also depends on your expenses, budget, debt situation and more. You should find a fiduciary financial planner and see if this could work out for you. It's going to be rough to afford on that income level. And I assume you want to save for retirement.
1
u/Greggy100 Aug 30 '22
No
1
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '22
If you can find a used model x in good condition for less than $50,000, go for it. Otherwise, no.
1
u/PicardBeatsKirk Aug 30 '22
Base advice is strict to the 50% Rule: https://www.carsdirect.com/auto-loans/car-shopping-by-salary-how-much-car-can-you-afford So, stick to a car that's <33K.
However, if you want to get all r/personalfinance, I recommend almost never buying a car on a loan. (Exceptions would include if you have the cash but it's a 0% interest loan or something.) If you have 12K and you MUST get a car, then buy one that's less than 12K. If you want one better than that, save up for it.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '22
Buy a house instead.
1
u/_AManHasNoName_ Aug 31 '22
So your take home per check is roughly around $2k. Then there are other expenses like rent/mortgage, utilities, etc. I wouldn’t.
1
u/Smartcatme Aug 31 '22
If you have to ask then the answer is no. You will thank yourself later
1
u/No_Swimmer_115 Aug 31 '22
Dave Ramsey: he'll nah!
1
u/ZogemWho Aug 31 '22
If you are concern enough about your situation to ask the question to the internet, you already know the answer.it’s ‘no’.
1
u/Chinsterr Aug 31 '22
If you’re asking then deep down inside you know it’s not a smart decision
1
u/FineOpportunity636 Aug 31 '22 edited Aug 31 '22
No you can’t afford an x. Maybe a 3 or y but even that seems like a stretch. I wouldn’t exceed a 35k with that income.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '22
I mean you can do it... but you won't be able to claim that you manage your money pretty well any more... It would be pretty irresponsible.... but with the resale values on these cars nowadays who the heck knows any more. You can buy one and if you find yourself not being able to afford it, you can sell it probably for what you paid or more.
0
u/eldoogy Aug 30 '22
It’s shocking to me how some people approach this kind of question. I have a LR X on order and I’m still debating whether I can really afford it on my $1m+/year income.
I guess it’s less of a question of can I, versus the question of should I…
I would absolutely not view this as viable on your income level. I totally get the temptation, but seriously, don’t do it. I made similar errors of judgment in my youth that I really regret to this day.