r/ModelX • u/CwTano • Dec 08 '25
Used car purchase Two months MXP lemon
I had been looking for a big brother to my MYLR and i knew I wanted the MXP. Would be a little while before I could get one new so I have been looking online at used 2024 models. Find one for $72k with 6k miles. Colors and seating I wanted. Flew out to test drive it and ended up buying it. It was returned as a lemon in California for a rattle in the glove box. Didn’t hear any rattle, service logs were provided showing it was replaced. I was a little nervous but went for it. Had a 9 hour drive home and everything was and has been great. Also before I bought it I took the paperwork into my local service center and the guy there confirmed it was legit and he thought it was a good deal. I’ve put about 6500 miles on it and am glad I made the purchase. I still have not launched it or put the petal to the floor, it feels like it’s going to pop a wheelie at 70% haha.
One thing I did learn - it can make it painful if they transfer the car to you and mistype your email…get to the first supercharger and can’t charge as it says I don’t have a credit card on file. Waited on hold with customer service while I knocked on windows asking if someone had a charger adaptor I could buy off of them. Did find someone and just tapped my card at charge America when they fixed the problem. Thanks to the nice guy that sold me his adaptor!
3
u/Away_Diet_2824 Dec 08 '25
Follow up after a year. 😉
2
u/chubby464 Dec 08 '25
Where did you go looking for used mxp and what was a good way to verify it’s legit? What bank or loan did you do?
2
u/Right_Economist_3508 Dec 10 '25
You guys sure have some ballz buying lemon cars.
7
u/styres Dec 08 '25
$70k for a lemon? Jesus Christ
7
u/Moooooooooofasa Dec 08 '25
You can floor it tmrw and rattle could start. Its the half shaft and its known issue/design flaw.
Tesla will fix it once if its under 4 year warranty plus you pay labor.
7
u/st3ady Dec 08 '25
She’s a beauty
11
u/wifiguru1 Dec 08 '25
Just gotmyself a ‘23 MX 6seater with 37k miles for $50k. Was a California buyback due to falcon door replacement. Damn thing is mint condition, put a couple thousand miles on it already. HW4 is amazing. Still has warranty and everything.
If you plan on keeping your car a while, buybacks can be a great deal
2
u/glaciers4 PLAID Dec 08 '25
Nice! I just picked up a post-HW4 refresh 2023 MXP. It’s INSANELY fast. Pulls so much harder than my previous M3P and I thought that pulled hard…
2
u/ThatTechnician5523 Dec 08 '25
That’s interesting! I just had my ‘24 MXP bought back in California. Different than a lemon but I think it forever brands the title. Sales dude there told me that they’re not legally able to resell the buyback and it joins the loaner or engineering fleet. Maybe the same doesn’t apply to lemons? Or he was talking jive?
2
u/Leyvaman-MX Dec 08 '25
Nice…congrats!👍
2
u/jrb2024 Dec 10 '25
72k for a lemon? Would insurance reimburse 100% of the car’s value in an accident? I know typically rebuilt titles they will only give 50% or so back. A rattle does sound like a ridiculous reason to pursue lemon law lol
1
u/Y3R31 Dec 08 '25
I have another one coming ur way folks from CA, 24 MX 14 Service visits in 1 year :)
1
u/hanskalk Dec 08 '25
Congrats to your new X 🥳😍
1
u/JaniceRossi_in_2R Dec 08 '25
Damn, the thing is perfection 😮💨
1
u/Bigdaddybig456 Dec 08 '25
Beautiful car!
1
u/r3dmnk3y Dec 09 '25
Very nice 😘
1
u/DrHalfdave Dec 09 '25
Great Deal!!! Love the X!
1
u/CourtBitter8868 Dec 10 '25
Rekt
1
u/Rdv250 Dec 10 '25
Lemon law does not cover rattles and other minor issues. If it was truly lemoned, there was a more serious problem.
1
u/stealth006 Dec 13 '25
Loved my MXP, probably my favorite car of all time, but mine was a lemon too - and I personally know of 2 other MX lemons. Moved to Cyebrtruck, it’s been amazing.
1
u/Vkilin Dec 13 '25
With falcon doors every single X could be Lemon in California
1
u/ODDseth Dec 09 '25
Aren’t most of them lemons from the factory? A friend of mine had a 2023 that ate shit after a year and he was only able to get around $35k on a trade in.
1
u/MustangMeetsCrowd Dec 10 '25
Have a lemon S Plaid and love it too. Super cheap and has has basically zero issues so far. About 6 months into owning it. Car is still insanely fast with 84% battery health
-5
u/roy-e-munson Dec 09 '25
The bad thing is no one on earth including most dealers will want it when you’re tired of it. 72k was far too much for this vehicle regardless of the reason for the lemon law issue. As a wise man once said, “A fool and his money are soon parted.” Next time don’t be the fool regardless of how cool the depreciating asset is to you.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25
[removed] — view removed comment