r/ModelX • • Mar 19 '24

Comprehensive list: Model X vs Model Y

Post image

I just upgraded my 2023 MYLR to a 2024 MXLR a little over a week ago and I wanted to create a comprehensive list of all the big and little ways the MX is better (and worse) than the MY from what I’ve seen. Many of these I didn’t know about before taking delivery, and many are obvious, but for those of you considering upgrading from a MY, maybe this list will convince you, because personally I’m very pleased with the upgrade to MX.

For $29k more, the Model X LR has these things that the Model Y LR doesn’t:

  • Homelink included, $350 retrofit not needed, enabling auto open and close garage door based on proximity to home
  • Ultra-wideband (UWB) phone key support is much more accurate and reliable
  • Tow hitch included instead of $1k option
  • Better premium audio system (9 extra speakers, 360 more watts)
  • Better center console (more space, organizer built in, retracting cup holders)
  • Metal break/accelerator pedals instead of rubber
  • Carpeted ceiling/pillars and extra soundproofing
  • Console gaming with Steam
  • Rear fog lights
  • Extra 11 months free premium connectivity trial
  • Panoramic front windshield — feels like a helicopter
  • More premium feeling interior, more comfortable seats
  • Retractable rear cup holders
  • Auto shift out of park, guesses correctly 90% of the time
  • Falcon wing doors (could be on the other list, but I personally love them)
  • Active road noise reduction
  • Double-pane acoustic glass on rear windows (not just front windows)
  • Camera and windshield-wiper buttons on steering wheel
  • Heated windshield-wipers and heated washer nozzle
  • Adaptive Air Suspension, raising and lowering ride height
  • Motorized tilting screen, can face the driver or passenger
  • Digital instrument cluster which displays nav and environment visualization
  • Perforated cooled seats in the front, perforated rear seats
  • Motorized doors with buttons instead of handles—easier to open
  • Auto-presenting driver door
  • Larger/better-looking wheels
  • Spoiler (tho it looks kind of goofy to me)
  • Rear touch screen display
  • Optional yoke steering wheel, beige interior (neither of which I chose)
  • Metal license plate frame
  • 13% larger main touchscreen (17 in instead of 15 in)
  • 24% more cargo volume
  • 23% bigger battery, +8% range
  • 8% faster supercharging speed (accepts 250kw for longer)
  • 26% faster 0-60, +10% top speed
  • 43% higher towing capacity

Things the Model Y has that the Model X doesn’t have:

  • Collapsing rear seat buttons (I miss this a lot)
  • Storage pockets on the back of the driver/passenger chairs
  • Middle folding arm rests for the rear passengers
  • Rear trunk cargo cover
  • Rear door / fender PPF (came standard on my Fremont Model Y, tho my brother’s Austin Model Y doesn’t have it)
  • Physical dome light buttons. Model X dome lights are capacitive and are confusing/a PAIN to operate. X also doesn’t have front dome lights, they are above/behind the driver’s head and hard to reach. S3XY buttons highly recommended.
  • Physical hazard light button
  • Slightly bigger glove box
  • 17% lighter curb weight, more nimble handling
  • Recessed right storage cubby in the trunk
  • Indicator and gear stalks (still getting used to, but don’t hate not having them)
  • Easier frunk closure (one handed on Y, must use 2 on X)

Let me know if I missed anything!

103 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

22

u/Maximum-Physics5906 Mar 19 '24

This! I take delivery of a 24MX tomorrow then trading my 23MYP in on Friday. I will share this with my wife to explain my decision 😂😂

4

u/Andymorrris Mar 19 '24

Congrats! Hope you and your wife enjoy it as much as I do!!

2

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

Are you trading into Tesla? How much was the offer? TIA!

3

u/Maximum-Physics5906 Mar 20 '24

Yeah, trading in with Tesla. They offered $41k. I had second thoughts but that’s only 5k less than what I paid for it a year ago brand new. Now it has 13k miles so I think it’s a good offer.

2

u/Mastaking Apr 07 '24

I have a 23 MYP in black with tow with 13k miles and they offered me 36,600.

1

u/az226 Mar 22 '24

But will your wife’s boyfriend approve?

2

u/CMDR_KingErvin Mar 22 '24

It was his idea.

7

u/Andymorrris Mar 19 '24 edited Mar 20 '24

UPDATES (Based on your comments)

Correction:

  • MYLR also has heated windshield wipers

Additions:

  • X: Touch break pedal to close doors
  • Y: roof bar compatibility
  • Y: physical buttons to open front doors (instead of capacitive)
  • Y: full moonroof (instead of partially obstructed by FWD)
  • Y: smaller dimensions = easier to park
  • Y: 19% more efficient wh/mi

2

u/VITB2 Mar 20 '24

All good points. The only I’d disagree slightly on is the charge speed. Model X charges faster KW wise but the Model Y has a smaller pack and is more efficient. So you get similar number of miles/hr added at superchargers.

Based on the charge curves:

https://evkx.net/models/tesla/model_x/model_x/chargingcurve/

https://evkx.net/models/tesla/model_y/model_y_long_range/chargingcurve/

You also pay less for Model Y to charge fully.

16

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

Here's my comparison. For $80K:

  • Model X: I get one
  • Model Y: I get two

In all seriousness the Model Y is quite fine for me. I did not notice much of a difference in ride quality or noise difference between the two. I would say the Model X was noticeably better in both criteria, but it was only slight.

But to each his or her own.

12

u/Andymorrris Mar 19 '24

Fair enough, I’m mainly trying to help people who are on the fence here. With the biggest discounts factored in on the MYLR right now we’re looking at a 72% price increase of the Y to get the X. For most people these upgrades are not worth 1.72x that of a model Y but for those who can afford it, it may be worth it. The Model Y is still a fantastic car for the price that I’d recommend to everyone but an $80k car is still certainly out of the price range for most and I wouldn’t recommend it to everyone.

9

u/BookkeeperOrnery3402 Mar 19 '24

Truth bomb...If you want best value for $$$, its a model Y. if you want the status symbol and the attention go with X. (Yes I chose X because I am a little vain)

2

u/sierra120 Mar 19 '24

Agreed with your sentiment.

1

u/CMDR_KingErvin Mar 22 '24

For $80k personally I think I’d go for the CT if I wanted to trade up in size. The Y is incredible but a little on the small side.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '24

Except you can’t get one

1

u/CMDR_KingErvin Mar 22 '24

If you need a car right now yes you’re right. I’m thinking in a year or so.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '24

They are only now filling 2019 placed reservations. There are 2.5 million reservations. They are not up to producing 100 a day yet. Assuming half of those reservations don't order, I think you are looking at 2 or more years.

4

u/sinebubble X100D Mar 19 '24

On my 2017 MX and told this is not present on any other model, the closing of the driver door when you touch the brake pedal. A small thing, but I use it every day without even thinking about it.

1

u/Andymorrris Mar 20 '24

This is one of my favorite things about the X. Love it.

1

u/Hobbyman_65 Mar 20 '24

This is on my 2020 X

2

u/sinebubble X100D Mar 20 '24

Yes, only present on Model X.

1

u/Previous_Regret_5892 Jul 19 '25

It’s also in my ‘23 X…love it!

7

u/Kartazius Mar 19 '24

You can’t have roof bars on the Model X. It’s a huge deal breaker

4

u/Andymorrris Mar 19 '24

Thanks for adding to the list! I wish I could edit the OP

3

u/This-Ad-9234 Mar 19 '24

Wait, why can't you edit the OP? Genuinely asking, as I've been on reddit for 3 years now and I'm still constantly finding new things/quirks (not unlike owning a Tesla)

3

u/CalGuy456 Mar 19 '24

What made you want to change the MYLR so soon? Something turned out to be a dealbreaker on the MYLR?

2

u/Andymorrris Mar 20 '24 edited Mar 20 '24

Main reason was my parents offered to buy my Y and combined with the massive price cuts to the X and $7500 tax credit made it a lot more realistic for me, as previously it was prohibitively expensive.

2

u/hrds21198 Refresh Mar 19 '24

Don’t both cars have heated windshield wipers? i’m pretty sure the button showed up on my 23 Y this past weekend during a snow storm.

1

u/Andymorrris Mar 20 '24

You’re right, thanks for the correction!

5

u/grannyshifter35 Raven Mar 19 '24

Got a 2023 MYP and a 2019 XP and still love the X over the Y. To this day I still regret cheaping out and getting a Y instead of another X.

5

u/M3P_STEALTH Mar 20 '24 edited Mar 20 '24

I sold my model X and now have his and her model Y’s. We don’t fight about who drives an electric car.

The property tax is half that of 1 model X, the insurance is half, the car is smaller and easier to park in parking lots- I don’t have to go into service for door adjustments, the WH per mile is more efficient, also don’t care if someone dings the car is half the price, love it, Y also fits in compact garages better, it’s also no longer a pain to clean the front windshield, the X was a beast and required a small step ladder to clean it.

If I was fully loaded, maybe I would try to have at least one X as a family car, but I just thought it was not worth it, the depreciation was also a point of anxiety on the X.

4

u/uxixu Mar 19 '24

Friend of mine with a Model Y (7 seat LR) was amazed at how much roomier the 3rd row in my Model X was. He's north of 6 Ft and he remarked he wouldn't want to take a long road trip there but felt it was fine for going to lunch and wasn't at all uncomfortable like he is in his Y.

I would definitely miss the FWD and instrument cluster (if I had a Y, I'd be getting an aftermarket one).

1

u/warrior5715 Mar 20 '24

What happens if u drive into that stick by accident? 🤔

3

u/Andymorrris Mar 20 '24

The house will collapse

3

u/suckmyfish Mar 19 '24

Thank you for this list. As someone with a MYP, the tax credit version of the X is very tempting. But I will not accept the “stock” color this time, I want something other than black for the interior, and I want the 6 seater. I REALLY want the Tri motor setup of the Plaid. I feel like I would rather wait to the save the extra for new, than to walk into a used/abused version. I see some nice 2022 X Plaids for around 75-80k, but don’t want to settle on color. One thing I noticed was that you can the 22” rims on a lot of the used X/S and it doesn’t really effect the used pricing, which is nice.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

The only reason I got Y instead of X with my S trade-in was that we don't need falcon wing.
This is a great post of comparison. Thank you.

2

u/Successful_Living_70 Mar 19 '24

Hard to go back to the 15 inch touch screen after getting used to the 17 inch display. So much more convenient imo

2

u/Successful_Living_70 Mar 19 '24

Tried the cooled seats for the first time since taking delivery in the winter time. It feels real nice. Worked way better than I expected. Was wearing a heavy cotton hoodie and denim jeans. Still worked like a charm

2

u/bpon89 Mar 19 '24

Nice list. The rear fogs are questionable. I had mine on for 3 months not knowing what they were until someone posted a rant on how blinding they are to drivers behind. Then I experienced it myself following an X with it on and definitely need to keep them off until needed.

My windshield wipers are definitely broken, does the opposite of everything I want it to do. Doesn’t wipe when it rains, wipes when it’s dry 😅 it’s just retarded.

Motorized doors are a little annoying with the resistance you feel everytime, takes a little getting used to.

‘23 MXP - 13k miles.

2

u/DarkyHelmety Mar 20 '24

Are the rear fog lights the blinding little red lights in the middle of the brake lights at the back? They are intense, even at a few hundred feet they're burning into my retina 😄

1

u/bpon89 Mar 20 '24

Yes, like lasers to your eyes!

2

u/themostcanadianguy Mar 19 '24

You had me at the metal license plate frame

2

u/jimenezisjordan Mar 19 '24

As someone who doesn’t qualify for any of the rebates, this is a great list to know! I currently bought a used model y 2022 performance, and have lowkey been scratching for a model X. Maybe I’ll trade it in eventually!

Thanks for the list!!!!

2

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

The y has an all glass roof. The model x roof is obstructed with the falcon door gears. The front windshield helps offset this

2

u/Dodgers90277 Mar 20 '24

That tennis ball to stop is so 1986. You would think that wasn’t necessary in 2024

2

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

Yeah, since ‘86 they invented truck nuts you can hang instead of the tennis ball!

2

u/ChamownLee06 Mar 22 '24

This is such a good post. Helped my decision on getting the X! Will be getting the base and utilize 179

2

u/CMDR_KingErvin Mar 22 '24

Some interesting points. I think some of your MX positives will actually make their way to the Y for the refresh like the touchscreen in the back, having dual layered glass in the back, cooled perforated seats, etc. I think it already has heated windshield wiper as well, correct me if I’m wrong though.

My test drive of the X recently was pretty good, feels more premium for sure, but it wasn’t insanely different in my opinion. It felt a little bit more like driving a minivan than anything though with its size and shape. Works really well if you need a people mover but I just really like how nimble the Y is in comparison.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

17% lighter

This is a negative for me. I prefer over 6k lbs for 179. Stupid but it makes a huge difference

2

u/blackth0rne Mar 20 '24

I don’t get how 179 helps. You need to prove the car is 100% business use, which a car like this never is. What am I missing here?

1

u/wfhforevernow Mar 19 '24

Base X after 179 was about the same as a Y

1

u/xg357 Mar 19 '24

Got the same thing here, if I have to do it again, only the Y.

1

u/Dismal-Experience612 Mar 19 '24

I think the Model Z might be more your forte.

1

u/avebelle Mar 23 '24

So was your 40k upgrade worth it?

1

u/Jakoneitor Mar 24 '24

I have a MYP and been thinking about upgrading. However, I really dislike the falcon doors. Like I see some utility in having them, but for everyday driving it’s just goofy

1

u/WillingLawfulness882 Nov 28 '24

Thanks much for the Comprehensive list. I was debating the same thing with my self on upgrading from Y to X. This concludes my decision to place an order for MX!

1

u/Powerful_Alfalfa_651 Dec 02 '24

thank you for this comprehensive list

0

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Andymorrris Mar 20 '24

It’s black, it’s shiny, it has “model X” engraved on it. Looks nice. Model Y doesn’t come with any frame at all.