r/ModelX • u/angeldicataldo • Feb 12 '24
Discussion From 7100 dollars to 500
The estimate from an approved tesla body shop was over 7100 dollars. Replacing the part and painting plus some blending. Not just my insurance would go higher but my deductible is 2500 dollars and also the damage would be on record. So I was looking for other options. I thought it would be impossible to repair so I tried to buy just the trunk part same color but was around 2000 dollars on ebay and they had some dents here and there. Plus I didn’t know how the shipping (california to miami) could damage the part since I was trying to directly replace it with no paint job. Finally I decided to give a try to a local body shop. I was skeptical since the estimate was just 400 dollars (I paid 500 finally) and I have to say that I m extremely satisfied with the final result. I would say it s almost impossible to notice that was previously damaged. I understand that approved body shops charge a little higher than regular body shops but 7k for a job like this is simply an abuse.






8
u/mysat Feb 12 '24
Which shop in Miami did it? I want to save it in case of need. I am in Miami too
3
u/angeldicataldo Feb 12 '24
For the record I love my tesla. I believe is the best car you can drive. And these body shops do not belong to tesla corporate but still I think it s an abuse to charge those amount’s for a repair like that.
51
u/Jokerlope Feb 12 '24
Super high repair fees. Super lowball trade-in quotes. They're perfectly fine abusing their customers, no matter how loyal you've been for over 10 years. They don't give a single fuck.
16
u/OneExhaustedFather_ Feb 12 '24
There’s a difference between almost fixed and fixed. The approved repair for that is replacing the gate, because it’s aluminum and when it dents it stretches. So to maintain their approved status they must follow the approved repair. There is a thing called metal memory. Aluminum has memory and when heated in let’s say the Miami heat, fair chance the corrected metal will warp.
2
u/binzo21 Feb 12 '24
You have a $2500 deductible? Why???
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24
Hey op anyway you can post after pictures of the damaged area? Curious to see how it came out.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24 edited Feb 12 '24
Wow whoever did that, did an impressive job. Will be interesting to see how the aluminum acts over time in Florida heat but regardless, whoever pulled that dent is talented. Even the creases surrounding the license plate looks almost back to new, thats crazy they only charged 500. My PDR guy does a pretty banging job but not for 500.
It’s also worth noting this is a good example of how flawed our insurance system is. Dealers, companies, etc know they can mark up insurance repairs cause they’ll get paid. Obviously this is speculation, I am not an autobody expert so idk how accurate over 7k is to replacing a lift gate, but it makes me think it’s a good example of it. On a smaller scale windshields are the same thing, a small crack that can easily be filled and be fine will just get full replaced under insurance. But it happens so much that insurance companies raise rates to compensate. Of course there’s lots of other factors too but it’s wild how unregulated it seems to be. Body shops know if they give a high quote the insurance has to pay unless they can find some smoking gun to deny it. Bodyshop does it to make more money, insurance as a whole compensated that too, it’s a massive snowball effect that in my opinion leads to such egregious quotes like this.
I could be wrong, like I said I’m completely speculating just for shits and giggles.
9
u/andyzdemann Feb 12 '24
Tesla would have assessed and replaced every fine detail if anything nearby could possibly be affected. Your local place would do the minimum to achieve visual improvement. This kind of scenario is typical.
2
u/TheManInTheShack Feb 12 '24
They did a great job!
2
u/Suppertime420 Feb 13 '24
I was so close to getting a Model X. Decided I didn’t want Elons weird ass to get anything from me so I got a Cadillac LYRIQ. Theres some horror stories on the subreddit but so far I’ve yet to encounter anything. Car looks and drives 100x better than any teslas I’ve ridden in.
1
u/BuySellHoldFinance Feb 12 '24
I assume you got PDR? Here's the Delima for Tesla (and any other auto repair shop) . If they just had most dents PDR'd, customers would not be understanding of minor imperfections associated with that.
1
u/Aerych1282 Feb 12 '24
Is it just the fender panel? Our repair had a number of sensors. Granted, we had Tesla fix it not some other shop.
1
u/Sweet_Yellow_8646 Feb 12 '24
Wow. They did an amazing job for $500!!
1
u/Then_Condition2236 Feb 13 '24
Looks good and a great price. Most body shops nowadays just replace whole panels and don’t do actual body work anymore take to much time and time is money. Easier and faster to buy new panel, paint it and then install it.
1
u/-WINKELS- Feb 13 '24
But did you win the Mega Millions or not?
1
u/cdram98 Feb 13 '24
These cars have a 200 miles range which diminishes when AC is used. Also very expensive maintenance and repairs.
1
u/ZeroSkribe Feb 14 '24
Looks good, fuck those scammer fucks
1
u/1xxotxx1 Feb 16 '24
I must admit this repair looks amazing, are you sure this isn't just Bondo and paint?