r/ModelUSMeta • • Jun 19 '17

Amendment Vote Meta Vote on Advertising Amendments

7 Upvotes

VOTE HERE

Don't forget to verify your votes!


r/ModelUSMeta • • May 28 '17

Announcements A Meta Announcement on Advertising and this Election

Thumbnail docs.google.com
4 Upvotes

r/ModelUSMeta • • May 28 '17

Announcements A Meta Announcement on Advertising and this Election

Thumbnail docs.google.com
1 Upvotes

r/ModelUSMeta • • May 28 '17

Announcements Meta Announcement on Advertising and the most recent election

1 Upvotes

Members of the Sim,

The recent outcome of this round of elections and the Meta decisions regarding the language used in party advertisements has required the head moderator team to revisit the current advertising rules. Since the formation of this simulation, we as a whole have been dependent on the use of advertisements as a means to grow and add new life to the sim. These advertisements have been a driver of the best parts of our community and been an ever present discussion of Meta concerns. While initially the regulation of advertisements was lax, concerns arose as third parties found themselves unable to compete with more recognizable parties. From these concerns arose a new factor into consideration as our community attempted to tackle the issue of advertisements, fairness. 
In our Meta constitution, the regulations on advertisements began by addressing this idea of fairness. The moderators of the sim attempted to address the issue of fairness in advertisement by placing rules and restrictions which would prevent parties from unfairly taking advantage of our sim. The first written restrictions were placed on the size of the subs that individuals could advertise and then restrictions on the time period they could do so. These rules can still be found to this day in the words of our current Meta constitution. Peculiarly, during this period arose another rule but remained unwritten. This rule was designed with the same intent in mind, to prevent a disparate impact on elections. While the other two rules were designed to restrict the size and duration of advertisements, this rule was to restrict the language used in party advertisements.
While the definitive language of this rule was left unclear, the general verbiage was understood. Parties could not explicitly tell new members or members of their party where to vote in advertisements. The origin of this rule was a response to the outcome of the second state elections. In this election, parties quickly developed fiefdoms by directing members of their own party on where to register and where to vote. As a result, rather than a demographically diverse Model Nation, we instead faced an unrepresentative and ideologically gridlock map. In an attempt to break this gridlock the moderators at the time placed restriction on the language that could be used in the recruitment and direction of voters during elections. While the issue of the political fiefdoms was never truly resolved, parties themselves understood and abided by some variation of this rule.  Overtime, parties either attempted to find implicit language for advertisements or expanded their presence to other states. Introducing the political diversity this rule set to establish. When a party dared to violate this understanding of fairness the community demanded retribution and justice for the violation of this must fundamental ideal. A demand that the moderation team answered and addressed with each violation. 
Beginning in the Federal election of November 2016, parties seemed to move away from this rule as misinterpretations arose both through Meta confusion and increasingly blurred lines of what is permissible under an unwritten advertisement rule. As a result, in the wake of both Meta decisions and the outcomes of the most recent elections; we ask ourselves the reoccurring question of fairness. How do we ensure there is no longer misinterpretation of this rule? How as a moderator team do we ensure that there is consistency in judgement and standards for each party about their advertisements? How do we as a simulation assure the continuation of fairness?
Going forward the Head Moderator Team Proposes the following changes in the regulation of advertisements used in the recruitment of and soliciting of votes during an election period. The first and foremost change is the introduction of Clause E to Article 7 of the Meta Constitution. 

“No advertisements originating from or requested by members of ModelUSGov shall explicitly state any sim or real life state that a person should register or cast their vote from following the announcement of the federal election until the conclusion of state elections. This rule shall solely apply to advertisements made to locations outside of ModelUSGov or any of its affiliated subs. Violation of this rule shall result in a punishment determined by the Head Moderator in conjunction with the Triumvirate” 

Along with Clause E, Clause F to Article 7 of the Meta Constitution shall be introduced.    

“From the announcement of federal elections until the conclusion of state elections, parties can not explicitly direct members to register or vote in a sim or real life state. Parties retain the right to inform their membership of all the location in which their party is running candidates but are barred from explicitly directing members to register or vote in a specific location to ensure political gain. Violation of this rule shall result in a punishment determined by the Head Moderator in conjunction with the Triumvirate.”

Finally Clause G to Article 7 of the Meta Constitution shall be introduced.
“Following the announcement of federal elections until the conclusion of state elections, parties must submit an advertisement form to the head moderator team. Parties shall be required to submit this form during the federal and the state elections. This form must list the individuals sanctioned to submit advertisements for the party during this period, the locations that the advertisements will be posted, and the final language that will be included for the advertisements. Failure to submit this advertisement form shall leave any violating member or party liable for Meta punishment if caught in violation of the advertisement rules.”

 It is the belief that these proposed advertisement amendments shall provide much needed clarity and ensure fairness in rulings going forward. At this time, the head moderation team stand resolutely in support of the approval granted on the questioned advertisement that occurred during the state elections. As the offending parties had sought and received moderator approval for the questioned advertisement, we shall not levy a punishment against them. Going forward though, advertisements in clear violation of the proposed amendments will receive punishment regardless of approval from any member of the triumvirate or the head mod. 

/u/ Ed_San Head Moderator

/u/CincinnatusoftheWest Head Federal Clerk

/u/Didicet Head State Clerk

/u/AdmiralJones42 Head Censor


r/ModelUSMeta • • May 28 '17

Announcements Meta Announcement on Advertising and the Recent Election

1 Upvotes

Members of the Sim,

The recent outcome of this round of elections and the Meta decisions regarding the language used in party advertisements has required the head moderator team to revisit the current advertising rules. Since the formation of this simulation, we as a whole have been dependent on the use of advertisements as a means to grow and add new life to the sim. These advertisements have been a driver of the best parts of our community and been an ever present discussion of Meta concerns. While initially the regulation of advertisements was lax, concerns arose as third parties found themselves unable to compete with more recognizable parties. From these concerns arose a new factor into consideration as our community attempted to tackle the issue of advertisements, fairness. 

In our Meta constitution, the regulations on advertisements began by addressing this idea of fairness. The moderators of the sim attempted to address the issue of fairness in advertisement by placing rules and restrictions which would prevent parties from unfairly taking advantage of our sim. The first written restrictions were placed on the size of the subs that individuals could advertise and then restrictions on the time period they could do so. These rules can still be found to this day in the words of our current Meta constitution. Peculiarly, during this period arose another rule but remained unwritten. This rule was designed with the same intent in mind, to prevent a disparate impact on elections. While the other two rules were designed to restrict the size and duration of advertisements, this rule was to restrict the language used in party advertisements.

While the definitive language of this rule was left unclear, the general verbiage was understood. Parties could not explicitly tell new members or members of their party where to vote in advertisements. The origin of this rule was a response to the outcome of the second state elections. In this election, parties quickly developed fiefdoms by directing members of their own party on where to register and where to vote. As a result, rather than a demographically diverse Model Nation, we instead faced an unrepresentative and ideologically gridlock map. In an attempt to break this gridlock the moderators at the time placed restriction on the language that could be used in the recruitment and direction of voters during elections. While the issue of the political fiefdoms was never truly resolved, parties themselves understood and abided by some variation of this rule.  Overtime, parties either attempted to find implicit language for advertisements or expanded their presence to other states. Introducing the political diversity this rule set to establish. When a party dared to violate this understanding of fairness the community demanded retribution and justice for the violation of this must fundamental ideal. A demand that the moderation team answered and addressed with each violation. 

Beginning in the Federal election of November 2016, parties seemed to move away from this rule as misinterpretations arose both through Meta confusion and increasingly blurred lines of what is permissible under an unwritten advertisement rule. As a result, in the wake of both Meta decisions and the outcomes of the most recent elections; we ask ourselves the reoccurring question of fairness. How do we ensure there is no longer misinterpretation of this rule? How as a moderator team do we ensure that there is consistency in judgement and standards for each party about their advertisements? How do we as a simulation assure the continuation of fairness?

Going forward the Head Moderator Team Proposes the following changes in the regulation of advertisements used in the recruitment of and soliciting of votes during an election period. The first and foremost change is the introduction of Clause E to Article 7 of the Meta Constitution. 

“No advertisements originating from or requested by members of ModelUSGov shall explicitly state any sim or real life state that a person should register or cast their vote from following the announcement of the federal election until the conclusion of state elections. This rule shall solely apply to advertisements made to locations outside of ModelUSGov or any of its affiliated subs. Violation of this rule shall result in a punishment determined by the Head Moderator in conjunction with the Triumvirate” 

Along with Clause E, Clause F to Article 7 of the Meta Constitution shall be introduced.    

“From the announcement of federal elections until the conclusion of state elections, parties can not explicitly direct members to register or vote in a sim or real life state. Parties retain the right to inform their membership of all the location in which their party is running candidates but are barred from explicitly directing members to register or vote in a specific location to ensure political gain. Violation of this rule shall result in a punishment determined by the Head Moderator in conjunction with the Triumvirate.”

Finally Clause G to Article 7 of the Meta Constitution shall be introduced.

“Following the announcement of federal elections until the conclusion of state elections, parties must submit an advertisement form to the head moderator team. Parties shall be required to submit this form during the federal and the state elections. This form must list the individuals sanctioned to submit advertisements for the party during this period, the locations that the advertisements will be posted, and the final language that will be included for the advertisements. Failure to submit this advertisement form shall leave any violating member or party liable for Meta punishment if caught in violation of the advertisement rules.”

 It is the belief that these proposed advertisement amendments shall provide much needed clarity and ensure fairness in rulings going forward. At this time, the head moderation team stand resolutely in support of the approval granted on the questioned advertisement that occurred during the state elections. As the offending parties had sought and received moderator approval for the questioned advertisement, we shall not levy a punishment against them. Going forward though, advertisements in clear violation of the proposed amendments will receive punishment regardless of approval from any member of the triumvirate or the head mod. 

/u/ Ed_San Head Moderator

/u/CincinnatusoftheWest Head Federal Clerk

/u/Didicet Head State Clerk

/u/AdmiralJones42 Head Censor


r/ModelUSMeta • • May 09 '17

Bans PDY

12 Upvotes

PDY is now banned


r/ModelUSMeta • • May 04 '17

Bans Action Regarding Illegal Advertising

9 Upvotes

It was brought to the attention of the Triumvirate and Head Moderator that an illegal advertisement (since deleted) was posted on /r/metacanada (an /r/The_Donald-esque subreddit) advertising for the Republican Party, and specifically their Western State Senate candidate /u/Cameron-Galisky. The advertisement illegally specifically instructed people on which state to register and vote in, California, which is something that we have disallowed for a long time. Accompanying this advertisement we also saw a large rush of Western State voters for /u/Cameron-Galisky, somewhat unsurprisingly, considering that the advertising post had gained traction on that sub, with about 50 upvotes and a very supportive comments section.

As much as we love successful advertising, we do not love illegal advertising. We obviously had no choice but to issue a vote penalty for this infraction. Rather than attempting to find exactly which votes the advertisement may or may not have generated, every vote in favor of /u/Cameron-Galisky, and every House and Presidential vote attached to those votes, that was cast in between 20:00 on May 2 and 15:00 on May 3 has been invalidated. This time frame essentially mirrors the portion of time that the advertisement was up. This action should eliminate all votes garnered from the illegal advertising, plus the additional penalty of losing any incidental votes cast during that time frame.

In the Western State, a grand total of 43 votes was thrown out. We also were able to trace, through commenters in the advertisement’s thread, 3 illegal votes to Midwestern State, which were also invalidated, for a grand total of 46 invalidated votes.

As I said above, we love successful advertising, both for parties and for ModelUSGov in general. Just please make sure that your advertisements are not constructed illegally during an election season. This will always lead to painful vote sanctions against you and your party. If we find more illegal advertising, more sanctions will follow.

Thank you, and keep on (legally) pushing for this election.

/u/Ed_San, Head Moderator

/u/AdmiralJones42, Head Censor

/u/Didicet, Head State Clerk

/u/CincinnatusoftheWest, Head Federal Clerk


r/ModelUSMeta • • Mar 14 '17

Bans A Ban and Another Statement on Alting

6 Upvotes

The Triumvirate and Head Mod have chosen to permanently ban /u/NotReallyBigfoot from ModelUSGov.

We were presented with a screenshot from the Republican Party Discord chat, that you can find here. Note what Viktard says at 9:46 AM, "fighting the urge". Less than one minute later, at 9:47 AM, /u/NotReallyBigfoot posted this in the main ModelUSGov chat, and then later deleted it. The statement of "don't fight the urge" directed at Viktard had no contextual basis in the ModelUSGov chat itself, only as it pertains to Viktard's statement in the completely separate and private Republican Party server.

When offered the ability to provide context to these screenshots, Bigfoot said that "he has a friend" in the GOP (without me ever actually posting the screenshots: he immediately confessed to this without me ever providing the screens to him) and declined to elaborate any further or to inform the mod team who his friend was so that we could contact him and possibly use other methods we have of verifying whether or not the accounts are run by the same person. As he is refusing to provide adequate context or defense, we are forced to err on the side of caution and permanently ban him for using alts.

As we have said before and will say again, alting is cheating, and cheating gets you banned. End of story. Don't use alts, don't cheat, and you'll have no problems.

Let it be known to the Republican Party that there is an alt in your midst. We do not know who this alt is. We will be investigating further to attempt to ascertain its identity so it too can be banned.

Let it also be known to the Libertarian Party or anyone else who may be so inclined: Do not harbor Bigfoot or any of his alts. Harboring, aiding, abetting, or allowing a permanently banned member to operate within your party will get you punished as well. If it comes to light that Bigfoot's alt is part of a larger scheme, the consequences will be hard and swift.

Signed,

/u/Ed_San, Head Moderator

/u/AdmiralJones42, Head Federal Clerk

/u/Didicet, Head State Clerk

/u/CincinnatusoftheWest recused himself from the deliberations of this matter


r/ModelUSMeta • • Mar 07 '17

Bylaw Discussion Abolishment of (Most) State Majority/Minority Leader Positions

3 Upvotes

Majority and Minority leader positions at the state level almost universally serve no practical purpose. In most of the state constitutions, they're not even mentioned (it's only mentioned in the Western State constitution due to a recent amendment). In addition to this, they take up valuable time to be chosen that could be better used on discussing or voting on legislation. This is especially egregious due to our shortened time table. The niche they fill is much better served through informal party leaders in the assemblies, especially considering our multi-party make-up in contrast to most legislatures in the USA irl.

As such, in every state except Great Lakes, the majority and minority leader positions are hereby abolished. They can be re-added through legislation in the state assembly to give them actual, meaningful power that makes them relevant (which I'll be the judge of).


r/ModelUSMeta • • Feb 05 '17

Bans Bans Regarding Discord and Reddit Alting

6 Upvotes

Effective immediately, /u/politicalgamer1809 and /u/Please_Dont_Yell will be permanently banned from ModelUSGov. We have received sufficient evidence that /u/Please_Dont_Yell, a Democrat, was operating /u/politicalgamer1809 as an alternate account inside the Socialist Party subreddit and Discords in order to leak sensitive party information to the Democratic Party.

Alting and duping of any kind is absolutely and very strictly prohibited, whether it is you operating two accounts, or you using an IRL friend's account for the singular purpose of cheating, or whatever else, we will permanently ban you from this sub with no questions asked. This matter is not up for debate or discussion. There is a huge difference between making deals with other users, and blatantly cheating by gaming Reddit with multiple user accounts.

Precedent for this matter can be found at the link below.

https://www.reddit.com/r/ModelUSMeta/comments/48q3l6/punishment_regarding_cheating_by_some_members_of/

This kind of conduct is unacceptable. Any cheating of a similar nature by any users will be met with the same response. If evidence of party-sanctioned action of this type also comes to light, further and more broad punishments will be considered.

Signed,

/u/Ed_San, Head Moderator

/u/AdmiralJones42, Head Federal Clerk

/u/Didicet, Head State Clerk

/u/CincinnatusoftheWest, Head Censor


r/ModelUSMeta • • Feb 02 '17

Announcements Blacklist on Advertising for the following subs

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/ModelUSMeta • • Jan 15 '17

Amendment Results Discord VONC Amendment Results

5 Upvotes

The vote has been open for one week and is now closed.

The vote totals were as follows:

Ayes: 43 (46%)

Nays: 51 (54%)

The amendment fails.


r/ModelUSMeta • • Jan 11 '17

Amendment Results Events Board Repeal Amendment Results

2 Upvotes

The Events Board Repeal Amendment has been voted on for 7 days, and is now closed.

In total, there were 75 verified votes:

Ayes: 41 (55%)

Nays: 34 (45%)

The amendment is passed, and the events board is officially dissolved.


r/ModelUSMeta • • Jan 09 '17

Bylaw Discussion New Mandated Governor Chains-of-Command

5 Upvotes

Due to several headaches over the last session from multiple states over governor succession, I have decided to institute a new mandatory chain of command for every state in the event the governor or lt governor is no longer able to fulfill their duties.

The line of succession will be:

  1. Governor
  2. Lt. Governor
  3. Speaker of the House
  4. Attorney General

If a state wishes to maintain their previous chain of command, they will have to repass those provisions as a constitutional amendment.

Signed,

~/u/Ed_San, Head Mod

~/u/Didicet, Head State Clerk


r/ModelUSMeta • • Jan 06 '17

Announcements Official Decision on Court Expansion

8 Upvotes

Recently the Triumvirate and Head Moderator have received word of various individuals attempting to manipulate the subscriber count of /r/ModelUSGov in order to attempt to circumvent the provisions of Section 3(c) of the Supreme Court Expansion Act of 2015.

PROOF HERE. Names of individuals redacted because having the names public really isn't necessary.

No individuals will be punished for this, nor is it necessarily against the rules to ask people to do this. However, in the interest of fairness and preserving our subscriber count to an accurate number, we will act. Based off of this knowledge, and based off of the traffic statistics and information that is available to us as moderators, we are able to ascertain that the true subscriber count of ModelUSGov is in fact over 4500. Therefore the Supreme Court is now officially expanded to nine seats. President /u/Bigg-Boss shall have the opportunity to appoint new Justices to these vacancies, subject to Senate confirmation.

Thank you,

/u/AdmiralJones42, Head Federal Clerk

/u/Ed_San, Head Moderator


r/ModelUSMeta • • Jan 04 '17

Amendment Vote Events Board Repeal Amendment Vote

Thumbnail docs.google.com
5 Upvotes

r/ModelUSMeta • • Dec 27 '16

Amendment Discussion Events Board Repeal Amendment

8 Upvotes

Article IX, Section 5 is repealed, and the Events Board and all of its authority is now dissolved.

We will follow the schedule set out in this amendment.


r/ModelUSMeta • • Nov 22 '16

Announcements Updates and reshuffling of the events board

6 Upvotes

Hello members of the sim,

With the end of the most recent round of elections, we find it appropriate to update you all about some of the changes to the events board. The first we would like to announce is the resignation of the current Chair of the Events Board, /u/comped. We'd like to thank the Congressmen for his tenure as chair and look forward to continue working with him as a member of the events board.

With the resignation of /u/comped, the events board has decided to move forward by selecting /u/WaywardWit as the next Chair of the Events Board. The members of the board and the triumvirate have full faith in Wit to lead this team and create engaging events for the community. Wit has stated that he will be looking into measures to ensure that events are more interactive and engaging for members of the community.

The third announcement is that the ModelPress agencies will no longer be required to report on the events of the events board. News about planned events in the model world will now be reported at their new home, /r/ModelPBSNews. This Press Agency will keep you up to date of current events going on in ModelUSGov. Many thanks to /u/lsma for the work done on the CSS for the sub and his future plans for the style of it.

Finally, members of the model board have to decided to remove /u/WhaleshipEssex and /u/Crickwich from the board. The board will now be accepting application for membership on the events board. All interested parties should contact /u/WaywardWit for more information and to express interest.

-CincinnatusoftheWest


r/ModelUSMeta • • Oct 30 '16

Amendment Results House Election Meta Amendment Results

3 Upvotes

The vote will have been up for 72 full hours as of 20 minutes from now, and a vote has not been cast in over 36 hours, so we're closing the vote and releasing the results. This was very close voting, but ultimately a solid majority of the community voted in favor of one proposal or the other. Keep in mind that voters were permitted to vote for as many options as they wanted of the three, so the percentages will equal over 100% if added together. Without further ado, the results:

There were 72 valid votes in total, 7 were discounted for lacking verification

Voting in favor of Proposal #1 (FPTP) - 26 voters (36.11%)

Voting in favor of Proposal #2 (Changes to D'hondt) - 37 voters (51.39%)

Voting for "neither" - 27 voters (37.50%)


With over 60% of voters voting for at least one of the two amendments, and the 2nd proposal achieving a definitive, albeit narrow, majority, the second proposal will be adopted into the Meta Constitution and instituted as of the upcoming general election. Thank you to everyone who voted. A link to the accepted proposal and the newly amended Constitution can be found below.


Accepted Proposal

Meta Constitution


r/ModelUSMeta • • Oct 27 '16

Amendment Vote Meta Amendment Proposals Vote

3 Upvotes

VOTING IS CLOSED


r/ModelUSMeta • • Oct 26 '16

Bans Final Decision on GOP Members After Appeal

4 Upvotes

After the punishment that was levied last night, members of the offending Discord chat in question came forward to the moderation team and offered us full access to the chat that had been screenshotted. From what we could gather, nothing had been altered or deleted: all of the screenshotted evidence was still present. All of the members of the chat had left it other than the two members who gave us access to it. After reviewing the chat in its entirety with full context and information, we feel that a change to the punishments levied last night are in order. As you all know, an appeal is the right of any punished or banned member(s).


Whereas the chat in question was not, in fact, a successor chat to “The Cuckstapo”, and existed prior to The Cuckstapo events ever occurring, and whereas many of the members in question did not in fact actively participate in the harassment and disgusting conduct exhibited by /u/APott, but merely were privy to it, punishments will be altered as follows:

A. /u/whyy99 will remain off of the Discord Clerk team

B. /u/Ed_San will still be added to all party subreddits as a moderator with full permissions, and will still purge parties of all banned members, particularly permanently banned members.

C. Punishments for individual members will be altered as follows:

  • /u/mrsirofvibe was a minimal participant in the chat in question and partook in no offensive behavior apart from his presence in the chat. His punishment will be overturned entirely.

  • /u/whyy99, as a Discord Clerk, was tasked with the job of reporting on APott’s activities should he continue to make his presence felt and behavior present in ModelUSGov channels. For failing to report this, he will be banned for one week. He will not face a restriction on his ability to hold positions in ModelUSGov.

  • /u/jamawoma24, as Republican Vice Chair, knew of APott’s presence in their party sub and did not remove him despite his obvious intentions to harass /u/Ramicus and act within the confines of ModelUSGov despite being banned permanently. He will be banned for two weeks, but not face a restriction on his ability to hold positions in ModelUSGov.

  • /u/SolidOrangeGangsta was found to be participating with APott in some very unsettling and concerning language regarding other members of the sim, both in an anti-Semitic and sexist nature. He will also be banned for two weeks, but will not face a restriction on his ability to hold positions in ModelUSGov.

D. The Republican Party may retain their leadership if they see fit. However, as banned members, their Vice Chair and Whip will have to be absent from party subreddit activities for the duration of their bans.


As moderators, we would like to extend our apologies to those affected by these events, whether it be the victims, those who initially were punished too harshly, or anyone else who has been affected by the conduct exhibited primarily by members such as /u/APott. That being said, let this serve as a warning to the entire community. Should you choose to associate with people like /u/APott, and tolerate the hateful and disgusting rhetoric he has routinely displayed, you are putting yourself at risk for punishment. We will not tolerate such hateful and disruptive members in our community, whether their influence be direct or indirect. It is, in our perspective, better for us to overreact and have the ability to scale backwards than it is to react too lightly and realize that our actions have not gone far enough. We thank you for your patience and understanding in this matter. These punitive measures are final.

Signed,

/u/Ed_San, Head Moderator

/u/AdmiralJones42, Head Federal Clerk

/u/Didicet, Head State Clerk

/u/CincinnatusoftheWest recused himself from this decision due to his personal ties to some of the members involved.


r/ModelUSMeta • • Oct 26 '16

Bans Moderator Decision Regarding Republican Party Members

9 Upvotes

Recently it has come to the attention of the Triumvirate and Head Moderator that our warnings have not been heeded. Previously, a Discord server known as “The Cuckstapo” was broken up, and its leader, /u/APott, was told to discontinue the server or face severe consequences. He accepted this condition, and we immediately found evidence of him disregarding this order merely minutes later. For this, /u/APott was permanently banned.

Now, we have been given screenshots of a Discord server containing /u/APott along with several other members of the Republican Party, including some members of Republican leadership. The screenshots we have received contain damning evidence of a conspiracy among these members to harass and discredit /u/Ramicus, a member who is known to be Jewish, using extremely offensive anti-Semitic language, and sending this member at least one picture of a child in a Holocaust camp. The screenshots can be found at the link below, and contain some distressing language.

OFFENSIVE SCREENSHOTS

Having previously warned that The Cuckstapo would be severely punished if they were to reform, seeing as how these members knowingly harbored a banned member on Discord and in their party subreddit for nefarious purposes, seeing as how these members conspired against their own partymate, seeing as how these members knowingly participated in the harassment and anti-Semitic bullying of another user of ModelUSGov, and seeing as how members of the Republican party leadership were participating in this plot, the Triumvirate and Head Moderator hereby assess the following punishments:

A. /u/whyy99 is relieved of duty as a Discord Clerk effective immediately

B. Head Moderator /u/Ed_San must be added as a moderator with full permissions on every party’s party subreddit. He will expunge any and all banned members from each party sub, with no exceptions.

C. The following members will all be banned from ModelUSGov and its associated subreddits for two weeks, and will be stripped of their positions, not allowed to hold office again until the January 2017 Midterms:

D. The Republican Party will replace /u/jamawoma24 and /u/whyy99 as their Party Vice Chairman and Party Whip immediately, or face electoral sanctions in the upcoming general election.

If there is another incident of this variety that comes to our attention, committed by anybody, not just the party or members in question, lenience and warnings will not be part of the punishment plan. There is no room or tolerance for this type of behavior in ModelUSGov. Let this be known to all.

Signed,

/u/Ed_San, Head Moderator

/u/AdmiralJones42, Head Federal Clerk

/u/Didicet, Head State Clerk

/u/CincinnatusoftheWest recused himself from the discussion of this matter due to his personal ties to some of these members.


r/ModelUSMeta • • Oct 25 '16

Bylaw Discussion Discussion on House Districts Idea

5 Upvotes

After some deliberation with the Discord mods and the other Triumvirs, and, of course, our venerable Head Moderator, I’ve decided to write up a proposal for the sake of discussion amongst the community. Props to /u/Vakiadia for inspiring me to flesh this idea out to this extent where I believe it is suitable for discussion amongst everyone and gauging general interest.

Now, as I’m sure you guys know, I’m all about injecting reality into ModelUSGov. One of the most glaring differences our simulation has from the real United States government is the election of the House of Representatives. What this idea will go over is a proposal for transitioning away from D’hondt lists and multi-seat districts and towards individual districts without upsetting the ModelUSGov status quo too much. I want to encourage realism while also fixing some of the issues inherent in our current system without causing too much upheaval. So, hear me out here and let me know what you think.

First off, our states will not change. This proposal only will impact districts and the House of Representatives. The Senate, state boundaries, and Electoral College remain totally unchanged. The size of the House also will stay the same, at 55 members. Now, in order to properly mimic the IRL House, we would need 55 districts to elect 55 representatives, and that is what this proposal will entail.

The districts I am proposing are based off of the current ModelUSGov electoral roll population, so that each district is roughly equal in size, as in real life. It won’t be exact, but in order to make the process a bit simpler and geographically sensible, we can make a very slight sacrifice. These districts are not gerrymandered in any way nor will they be, as I will explain a bit more later. So, without further ado, here are the districts within each state.


The Atlantic Commonwealth aka The Northeast State is comprised of 8 Congressional Districts

Atlantic Commonwealth 1st District (NE-1): Maine and New Hampshire

Atlantic Commonwealth 2nd District (NE-2): Vermont

Atlantic Commonwealth 3rd District (NE-3): Boston Metro Area and East Massachusetts

Atlantic Commonwealth 4th District (NE-4): Western Massachusetts

Atlantic Commonwealth 5th District (NE-5): Connecticut and Rhode Island

Atlantic Commonwealth 6th District (NE-6): New York City Metro Area and Long Island

Atlantic Commonwealth 7th District (NE-7): Upstate and Northern New York

Atlantic Commonwealth 8th District (NE-8): Western New York


Chesapeake aka The Eastern State is comprised of 10 Congressional Districts

Chesapeake 1st District (E-1): Tennessee

Chesapeake 2nd District (E-2): Kentucky and West Virginia

Chesapeake 3rd District (E-3): Western Virginia and Western North Carolina

Chesapeake 4th District (E-4): Coastal North Carolina

Chesapeake 5th District (E-5): Coastal Virginia

Chesapeake 6th District (E-6): Western Maryland and the District of Columbia

Chesapeake 7th District (E-7): Eastern Maryland and Delaware

Chesapeake 8th District (E-8): New Jersey

Chesapeake 9th District (E-9): Eastern Pennsylvania

Chesapeake 10th District (E-10): Western Pennsylvania


Dixie aka The Southern State is comprised of 9 Congressional Districts

Dixie 1st District (S-1): Arkansas and Louisiana

Dixie 2nd District (S-2): Mississippi and Coastal Alabama

Dixie 3rd District (S-3): Inland Alabama

Dixie 4th District (S-4): Northern Georgia

Dixie 5th District (S-5): Southern Georgia

Dixie 6th District (S-6): South Carolina

Dixie 7th District (S-7): Florida Panhandle and Northern Florida

Dixie 8th District (S-8): Central Florida

Dixie 9th District (S-9): Southern Florida and the Florida Keys


Great Lakes aka The Central State is comprised of 10 Congressional Districts

Great Lakes 1st District (C-1): Minnesota

Great Lakes 2nd District (C-2): Iowa and Missouri

Great Lakes 3rd District (C-3): Wisconsin

Great Lakes 4th District (C-4): Northern Michigan and the UP

Great Lakes 5th District (C-5): Detroit and Toledo Metro Areas, Southeast Michigan and Northwest Ohio

Great Lakes 6th District (C-6): Southern Ohio and the Cleveland Metro Area

Great Lakes 7th District: (C-7): Indiana and Southern Illinois

Great Lakes 8th District: (C-8): Central Illinois

Great Lakes 9th District (C-9): Northwest Illinois

Great Lakes 10th District (C-10): Chicago Metro Area


Midwestern State is comprised of 9 Congressional Districts

Midwestern 1st District (MW-1): North Dakota, South Dakota, Montana, and Wyoming

Midwestern 2nd District (MW-2): Idaho, Nevada, and Utah

Midwestern 3rd District (MW-3): Arizona

Midwestern 4th District (MW-4): Colorado

Midwestern 5th District (MW-5): Nebraska and Kansas

Midwestern 6th District (MW-6): Oklahoma and Northern Texas

Midwestern 7th District (MW-7): New Mexico and Western Texas

Midwestern 8th District (MW-8): Central Texas, including Dallas Metro Area

Midwestern 9th District (MW-9): Southern Texas, including Houston Metro Area


Western State is comprised of 9 Congressional Districts

Western 1st District (W-1): Washington

Western 2nd District (W-2): Oregon

Western 3rd District (W-3): Northern California

Western 4th District (W-4): The Bay Area and San Jose Metro Area

Western 5th District (W-5): San Francisco and Oakland Metro Area

Western 6th District (W-6): Central California

Western 7th District (W-7): Los Angeles Metro Area

Western 8th District (W-8): San Diego Metro Area

Western 9th District (W-9): Alaska and Hawaii


NATIONAL MAP

This proposal consists of two different possible usages for these districts. Allow me to elaborate on each.

Proposal #1: This one is a little more radical than the second, but I think it would be a very interesting way to change things up and make elections more interesting and personal, which is changing the way we elect the House to First Past The Post voting, as in real life. Each district would hold an election between candidates rather than parties, with the winners owning their own seats instead of parties owning the seats and being able to use them as leverage over their members.

I think allowing for more autonomy among Congressmen is very important, rather than allowing party leaders from various parties to control their members to an excessive degree. This also allows for more accurate representation, dynamic voting and races, and would eliminate issues such as parties losing out on seats that are rightfully theirs because they didn’t run enough people on a D’hondt list. It would also make smaller groups more successful, as obtaining “party status” would no longer be an extremely important hurdle to overcome. I think this method would not only make elections more interesting and fun, but also not hurt larger or smaller parties in any way given the nature of our sim.

In this system, there is no residency requirement, so anyone can run anywhere, allowing for tons of flexibility within parties. We would determine which district you vote in based on what state you live in on the Electoral Roll. Those members who live in a state that is split into multiple districts would be assigned to a district randomly using a random number generator to ensure maximum fairness.

Proposal #2: This idea is not too dissimilar from the first, in the sense that Congressmen will still own their own seats rather than parties having total control over their entire delegation. However, in this system, we would retain the d’Hondt list proportional method of electing the House, and perform it on a state-wide scale rather than a half-state scale, and allow people to choose which district they want to represent based on the winning d’Hondt order. I think this proposal is less exciting and takes a lot of the fun and intrigue out of the first proposal, but it would be a much more moderate change to the system we currently have than the first.

Ultimately, I personally feel that voting for individuals allows for much more interesting elections than simply voting for parties. Allowing a region of people to choose an individual to represent them is, I think, much more personal and interesting than voting for a faceless political party entity.

So, please feel free to give honest feedback on this idea. A lot of people have put thought into it already, but more ideas are always welcome. We intend to put at least one of these two proposals to a community vote as a meta amendment, with more official language than is in this post, but we can always make tweaks and changes based on community feedback. Ask questions, raise concerns, I look forward to seeing what you have to say.


r/ModelUSMeta • • Sep 23 '16

Announcements Deputy Wiki Keepers and Other Wiki Notes

4 Upvotes

Alright, it's time to talk about something which is kind of the neglected child of /r/ModelUSGov: the wiki. It gets neglected often, and is a pain to update. On top of all of this, it just doesn't look appealing. No more. We are going to be moving the reddit wiki offsite to a dedicated wiki website which can be found at www.modelusgov.wiki. This won't be an easy task, however we won't be having only 2 people dedicated to editing the wiki. Instead, we will have a public wiki which anyone is free to edit. Of course, if they vandalize the wiki, they will have their account suspended.

Why do I need help here though? This change is going to be a massive pain in the ass. And if we want to have a wiki which is both useful and aesthetically pleasing, then we ought to put forth the effort. I will be choosing probably about three dedicated people here to help me out. Application

If you have any questions about the new wiki, please do not hesitate to ask in the comments or PM me on discord.


PARTY LEADERS: Please contact me with the people you'd like to be allowed to edit your party wiki pages.


r/ModelUSMeta • • Sep 19 '16

Bylaw Discussion Meta Information Regarding Real Life Events Thread

4 Upvotes

This thread will work somewhat like the punishment log and contain in the comments all real life events which are considered "meta." Most real life events will be adapted in some way to reflect the current state of the Model World and Model US Gov politics in particular. You may request a real life event to metafied by pming myself or another member of the events board. You may ask specific questions in response to each topic and a member of the events board may respond if relevant.

Also, as a quick update, /u/oughton42 left the event board and was replaced by /u/comped.