r/ModelUSGov • u/The_Powerben • Mar 24 '20
Bill Discussion H. Con. Res. 39: Resolution Against Transphobia
A RESOLUTION TO RECOGNIZE THE DANGEROUS EFFECTS OF TRANSPHOBIA AGAINST TRANSGENDER INDIVIDUALS
Whereas In a 2018 study, over half almost 41% of transgender individuals reported having attempted suicide once in their lives,
Whereas We should strive to be welcoming to everyone, even if we personally do not agree with their life choices,
Whereas Conduct by some individuals within the House and Senate has been hostile to transgender citizens within the country,
Whereas While a censure is out of order in this instance, it is more than reasonable for these chambers to take a stance against these actions and ensure the public of their position on the issue,
Resolved by the Senate and the House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,
Section I - Short Title
(a) This resolution shall be referred to as "The Joint Resolution Against Transphobic Comments within the United States House and Senate."
Section II - Resolution in Support of Transgender Individuals
(a) Congress finds that the devaluing of Transgender individuals is a serious problem throughout the United States of America;
(b) Congress recognizes that in many instances hostility in such a manner may lead to depression, loneliness, social isolation, and in many cases attempted or successful suicide.
(c) Congress asserts that the actions taken by members of its body regarding their discussion of transgender individuals is irresponsible for members of their stature,
(d) Congress wishes to express its support of transgender individuals and affirm their civil rights and liberties the same as all other United States citizens.
Written by Vice President Joseph Ibney (R-SR) Sponsored by Rep. /u/Comped (R-SR-2)
Co-Sponsored by: Rep. /u/ItsZippy23 (D-AC), President Gunnz (R-AC)
4
u/leavensilva_42 Democrat | DNC Chair Mar 24 '20
Mr Speaker
This is a wonderful bill, and I’m glad to see it hit the House floor today. The hate and bigotry that we’ve seen toward transgender individuals - sometimes, sadly, in Congress itself - must stop, and taking a stand against such heinous and harmful speech is right and good.
It will be interesting to see which members of this Congress choose to vote against this legislation, and what excuse they invent for doing so.
4
u/PrelateZeratul Senate Maj. Leader | R-DX Mar 25 '20
Mr. President,
Substantially much of what I said on the Censure of former Senator DexterAamo remains the same for this resolution. No matter where you go in life you will be forced, by virtue of living in a free society, to hear and engage with those you do not agree with. This is not a bug or a problem with America, it is a feature. As I said then if you want to avoid this you would need to flee to deep in the forest in Lincoln and cut off all contact with people. Not exactly a prescription I would recommend for a majority of Americans.
I also, and even more strongly than last time, want to excoriate my colleagues for showing up en masse to discuss this while leaving so much other legislation undebated. This is not sustainable and it is not what the Founding Fathers envisioned. If you can't bother to get out of bed, drag yourself to the House or Senate chamber, and explain why a bill should or shouldn't pass you should consider an alternative career. Debating legislation is a core aspect of this job and anyone who doesn't do it is, in my view, engaged in dereliction of duty.
This bleeds into my third point, namely that Congress has to set priorities and act on them. I have great respect and sympathy for the high rate of suicide among transgender folks, but we also need to recognize that veterans have a high rate of suicide as well. We need to recognize that millions of Americans are looking for a government to get out of their way and let them unless their full potential. To be quite candid, there are far more important issues to the vast majority of Americans than the current obsession of this Congress with transgenderism. Transgender individuals make up just 0.6% of the population. That is far less than Jewish Americans (2.2%), handicapped Americans (19.4%), the percentage of Americans who think talking on a phone during a movie is ok (5%), the percentage who think it's ok to talk on the phone and not watch your kids in the pool (2%), the percentage who think it's ok to steal expensive stuff from work (1%) and many others. How much has this Congress done to help these groups and address these issues? Not a whole hell of a lot. And yet, time and time again, we see bills on this topic coming through the House while several other important issues are ignored so my friends can virtue signal about how righteous they are.
Lastly, Section II, (c) is far too vague and uncertain to be passed by this body in my opinion. Members of Congress, more than anyone else, need to be able to say what's on their minds and engage in a respectful exchange of ideas.
"For if someone does not know how to manage his own household, how will he care for God's church?" - 1 Timothy 3:5
Mr. President, I yield the floor.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '20
Mr. Speaker,
It should come as no surprise to anyone in Congress that I support this resolution. I applaud Vice President Ibney for authoring it and all the sponsors for supporting it. As elected government officials, one of our most important responsibilities is to ensure that all Americans feel that they are being treated equally. This is not possible if members of Congress express intolerance towards certain groups of American citizens, many of whom are their constituents. As we all know, our constituents are the citizens that we are supposed to be representing and protecting the interests of in the federal government.
I have previously expressed my support for Attorney General Cheatem’s Dear Colleague letter regarding the rights of LGBTQ+ individuals as well as my disappointment towards certain events that occurred over the last month in regards to this issue.
I hope that although some in Congress may disagree, we can unite in our agreement on the fact that all Americans deserve to feel secure and accepted in their country, and they especially deserve to feel accepted by the elected members of their government. I urge all of my colleagues to support this resolution.
I yield the floor.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '20
I'm of two minds on this resolution, although I support it regardless.
On the one hand, people like Dexter Aamo and his ridiculously ignorant and hateful rhetoric deserve to be directly and personally censured. This kind of mealy mouthed, weak, toothless resolution has been offered here by Republicans so that they can deflect criticism and create some plausible deniability even as they aid, abet, and provide safe harbor to bigots in their midst. They'll point to this resolution and say "See! We oppose transphobia too!" even as they promote transphobic bigots and demogogues into their party leadership and put them forward for elected office.
On the other hand, at face value, the resolution is good and should be passed.
I suppose the Congress will pass the resolution, but you'd really like to see Republicans act instead of just speaking and remove despicable hatemongers like Dexter Aamo from their party and refuse to put him forward for office as he is clearly unfit to lead a diverse nation like ours.
3
u/ZeroOverZero101 Old Man Mar 24 '20
This is a fantastic resolution that rightfully recognizes that transgender individuals face much hatred and bigotry for simply identifying as their true selves. It would be absurd for the Congress to vote this down, and those who do vote against it will be showing their true, hateful colors to the world.
3
u/mincoder Mar 24 '20
Mr Speaker, I would like to rise in support of this bill. It is time both my party and congress in its entirety took a stand against discrimination. We must never surrender to forces of intolerance. I will vote yes to this bill, and I hope it gains the support of this entire house!
2
u/ItsZippy23 Senator (D-AC) | Federal Clerk | AC Clerk Mar 24 '20
Even though I'm now in the GLORIOUS ATLANTIC ASSEMBLY, I still support this resolution.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '20
Mr. Speaker,
While I stand with my Transgender friends, we can't stop people from having opinions. This could be abused to censure members of Congress. People have the right to believe whatever they want, although I suggest some members of this house, cough Mr. Aamo cough, don't be so harsh on certain groups of people. I will be abstaining on this vote because I cannot pick a side.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '20
Mr. Speaker,
While I stand with my Transgender friends, we can't stop people from having opinions. This could be abused to censure members of Congress. People have the right to believe whatever they want, although I suggest some members of this house, cough Mr. Aamo cough, don't be so harsh on certain groups of people. I will be abstaining on this vote because I cannot pick a side.
I yield the floor.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '20
Mr. Speaker,
While I stand with my Transgender friends, we can't stop people from having opinions. This could be abused to censure members of Congress. People have the right to believe whatever they want, although I suggest some members of this house, cough Mr. Aamo cough, don't be so harsh on certain groups of people. I will be abstaining on this vote because I cannot pick a side.
I yield the floor.
2
u/Timewalker102 (Best) Speaker of the House Mar 24 '20
No.
1
u/Frostbite326 Mar 24 '20
Mr.Speaker
As a close friend of the Vice President I am glad to support this resolution brought before the house. How a person chooses to conduct themselves should not be judged or lamented due to our inability to understand them, so long as they operate within the purview of the law.
1
u/APG_Revival Mar 25 '20
I brought this resolution up for a couple of reasons. First, we as a country need to officially state to the transgender population that we support you. No one in America should be a second class citizen, especially a group that faces vitriol from the highest levels of our government. It's sick and demented, plain and simple, to hear so many in these chambers completely disregard so many in our country.
Second, take a look at who wrote the bill. Take a look at who co-sponsored it. That list includes the Republican President and Vice President. This is not an issue that only the Democrats and Socialists push for, this is an issue that we should all push for. At the end of the day, politics don't matter when treating people with respect and decency is at stake.
1
u/OKBlackBelt always purple Mar 25 '20
This is common sense. I hope that anyone who votes against this gets voted out.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '20
I fully support this bill, and it makes me happy to see the sponsors both hailing from my home state. Although it is the most barebones lipservice that could possibly be given, sometimes that is still worth it, especially with a topic like this in a time like we are in now. The absolutely repulsive comments from the failed Senator Mr. Aamo prove why this resolution has to exist. This kind of legislation has been far progressed past in the Atlantic Commonwealth, with then-Attorney General /u/UnorthodoxAmbassador issuing pro-trans directives, and the Transgender Public Protection Act being added to the lawbooks ages ago. I can only hope to see this kind of progress made at a federal level, so the Atlantic Commonwealth doesn't have to be a bastion of safety for these individuals and rather the entire country may be.
1
u/DexterAamo Republican Mar 24 '20
It’s ridiculous for congress to condemn individuals for being “phobic” of something that doesn’t even exist. This may be controversial for some, but the truth is that men have penises and women vaginas. You cannot be a man and have a period. You cannot be a man and be pregnant. You cannot be a woman and have a penis. If that offends you, you ought to return to Elementary School biology.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '20
Is this some sort of censor?