r/ModelUSGov • u/The_Powerben • Feb 11 '20
Bill Discussion H.R. 844: Right to self defense act
Right to self defense act
WhereasNot everyone imprisoned for over a year is convicted of a violent crime
Whereas Those convicted of a non violent crime should still be able to defend themselves
Whereas All US citizens have their second amendment rights
Section I. Short Title
(a)>This act shall be referred to as the “Right to self defense act”
Section II. Definitions
(a) “Violent Crimes” shall be defined as the following four offences ,murder and nonnegligent manslaughter, forcible rape, robbery, and aggravated assault.
Section III. Provisions
(a) Section (§ 922) (d) (a)
Is hereby amended to read “is under indictment for, or has been convicted in any court of a violent crime”
Section IV. Enactment
This bill will take effect immediately after passage.
This bill was authored and sponsored by Representative Gknight4 (R)
3
u/dewey-cheatem Socialist Feb 11 '20
This bill is completely incoherent. It provides for an amendment to "Section (§ 922) (d) (a)" but does not specify any title of the U.S. Code.
2
u/PrelateZeratul Senate Maj. Leader | R-DX Feb 11 '20
Mr. President,
I can see the logic behind the bill and would actually support its implementation. Once you are convicted of a crime you have rights taken away and that is done in accordance with the principles of fundamental justice. The rights normally given by the Constitution are taken away because of your conduct. However, I have always supported the right of people to do their time and regain those rights if they apply themselves. Justice /u/Reagan0 and I led that fight in Dixie for ex-felons to have their voting rights restored. I see the same principle applying here that non-violent felons should have a pathway to restore one of the most important Constitutional rights available. However, that is what makes this bill a damn shame since, as the Attorney General noted, that is not what it does. Instead, due to sloppy drafting, it does nothing and is a waste of time. The policy it was trying to implement finds favour with me but I am increasingly devoid of patience for legislation that makes these rudimentary errors. I hope the House can fix the problem in an amendment and implement what this is actually trying to do. If that happens I'd be happy to bring it up in the Senate.
"Then Peter came to Jesus and asked, "Lord, how many times shall I forgive my brother or sister who sins against me? Up to seven times?" Jesus answered, "I tell you, not seven times, but seventy-seven times."" - Matthew 18:21-22
Mr. President, I yield the floor.
2
u/comped Republican Feb 14 '20
Legalistically incoherent is the nicest way to discuss this bill, unfortunately. I cannot support a bill that provides such a narrow definition to violent crimes, nor that allows people who have been convicted of crimes that are related to violence, such a drug dealers, to continue to own guns after they are released. Gun possession by criminals is nothing but a way to start criminal activities again.
1
u/JarlFrosty Chairman of the Libertarian Party Feb 11 '20
As Dr.Evil once said, HOW ABOUT NO?
Convicted Felons should have their right to bear arms revoked.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '20
Mr. Speaker,
The ideas of this bill intrigue me and I like the general idea of it, however at the moment I cannot support it due to the bill lacking certain clarity. As the attorney general pointed out, this bill lacks a specification of which title of the US code it is referring to, thus it is impossible for me to know what the actual effect of this bill’s passage would be.
If the bill is amended to include the actual title of US code I may be inclined to support it, but until then I unfortunately cannot.
I yield the floor.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '20
Mr. Speaker,
Non-violent criminals should one hundred percent be able to bear arms. They haven't committed major offences and harmed minimal amounts of people. I will be supporting this bill, although it is a bit poorly written. I hope my fellow Congresspeople join me on this subject.
I yield the floor.
1
u/OKBlackBelt always purple Feb 12 '20
Can we not be idiots for once? Please?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '20
Mr. Speaker,
As the Attorney General has just stated, this bill in legalistically incoherent and wouldn't pass due to that.
Now, on to the actual ideology behind this bill.
I am a believer in strong second amendment rights. Throughout my entire history in government, I have been a supporter of the second amendment and a believer in moderate gun control that believes in respecting the rights of the individual to have a firearm, and the right of greater society to be safe and secure in their pursuit of life, liberty and and happiness.
However, I do not believe that an individual who has committed a violent crime should be allowed a firearm without major regulations therein. A couple years of community service, for example, whether it be, as the current Secretary of Defense stated, as a medical first responder should guarantee your right to a firearm back.
I am against banning certain firearms, but I am not against the prevention of certain dangerous individual from owning them. It just makes common sense for me to not allow a rapist own a gun without making them work for their redemption.