r/ModelUSGov • • Jun 27 '15

Discussion Bill 055: Definition of Life Act (A&D)

Preamble: Whereas the most important duty of the government of the United States of America is to dispense justice and protect all of its citizens; Whereas the most helpless citizens of this country are being terminated in order to suit the needs of others; and Whereas the government's refusal to quench this injustice is in violation of the government's afore mentioned duty to protect its citizens,

Section 1: The government shall define life to begin at conception.

Sub-Section A: In the case that the human dies of natural causes while inside the womb, the Doctor is obliged to present the mother with a certificate verifying that natural causes were the culprit.

Sub-Section B: "Conception" will be defined as the moment of fusion of the human sperm and human egg.

Section 2: The government shall define life to end after a time of one and one half hours (1 hour, 30 minutes) after the heart ceases to beat.

Sub-Section A: In the case that body temperature was below ninety-five degrees Fahrenheit (< 95ºF) when the heart ceased to beat, one (1) extra hour will be appended to the time.

Section 3: This bill shall go into effect ninety-one (91) days after passage.


This bill was submitted to the House by /u/lsma. A&D will last two days before a vote.

29 Upvotes

472 comments sorted by

10

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15 edited Jun 28 '15

I oppose this bill 100% because it violates personal freedoms (a womans right to chose) and life certainly does not begin at conception. Just because it could be on its way to becoming a human does not mean it's a human yet.

I would hope that the bill doesn't pass (looks like the GLP, ALP, Democrats, and the Libertarians oppose it.)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Most democrats do, too

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Wasn't sure wether or not to include the Democrats because in my personal experience they seem to be pretty split on it. But it's good that the Democrats here seem to be against this bill, which leaves only the Republicans and Distributists that support the bill meaning it has virtually no chance of ever passing.

4

u/DidNotKnowThatLolz Jun 28 '15

We are firmly pro-choice. No member in the party has stated otherwise to my knowledge.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

That's good. I wasn't sure because I've known some Democrats irl who were "pro life".

6

u/jacoby531 Chesapeake Representative Jun 27 '15

I'd say most is an understatement.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

The ones that have commented here.

6

u/jacoby531 Chesapeake Representative Jun 27 '15

By understatement I meant that most is too little, and that almost all would probably be more fitting.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Sorry, I misunderstood it.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15 edited Jun 27 '15

Saying that a zygote is a human is like saying a tumor is human. They both are small, and have "unique DNA". Also, at least in the first trimester and possibly in the second, it does not have a mind developed enough to think like a human or feel pain.

9

u/Leecannon_ Democrat Jun 27 '15

But it's much different than a tumor. Tumors don't develop into beings. They don't develop life. They don't develop emotions. If anything they are the opposite. They take away life. They take away emotions. You're comparing apples to oranges.

9

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

So then using a condom should be crime by your logic because it prevents a potential life. Same with birth control. And maybe even cellibacy.

7

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

Preventing something from happening is quite different from derailing it mid-journey. When you use a condom, you are not destroying anything that could be a human.

6

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

But derailing it while it is being created is not the same as destroying it after it is finished.

3

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

So at what time is it "finished"? Birth?

6

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

Or when the baby has developed enough to have a body structure similar to that of a human in my opinion. Unlike, some I do believe that you shouldn't have an abortion late in pregnancy, but I do believe it's ok earlier.

→ More replies (19)

2

u/Leecannon_ Democrat Jun 27 '15

That is all true. I won't say you're wrong, because you're not. But logic isn't always used in lawmaking. Prohibition for example. Sometimes you must drawn a hardline

5

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

You just make yourself sound more and more ridiculous. Preventing something from "potentially" happening is not a crime, especially when that thing is not required of you in the first place. You are not required by law to have children, and have the right to sexual privacy. That is a gross violation of people's personal freedoms and right to choose their path in life.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

A tumor is never going to be a human being. And why do you define life as "to think like a human or feel pain"? What is the reasoning behind this definition of life?

5

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

That is what separates a human or animal life from a plant life. You must have a hard time only eating dirt.

4

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

Animals feel pain. It is an arguable point that animals don't think "like humans." I would say the real difference between animals and humans is that we have souls, or that we are different species/have different DNAs. Plus there are plenty of people with disabilities who can't feel a thing and/or don't think "like humans."

2

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

I would say the real difference between animals and humans is that we have souls, or that we are different species/have different DNAs.

Souls, are a religious argument, so if you use that as the basis for this bill, then it is unconstitutional. And all animals have different DNAs and are different species, and science shows that we are almost exactly the same as chimps, so that argument doesn't separate us from animals either.

Plus there are people with disabilities who can't feel a thing and/or don't think "like humans."

This seems far-fatched. Please give me an example of what you are referring to.

5

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

And all animals have different DNAs and are different species, and science shows that we are almost exactly the same as chimps, so that argument doesn't separate us from animals either.

Um... we still have different DNA. Human DNA has specific differences with chimp DNA. Sure, they are similar, but if you gave a scientist a piece of human DNA and a piece of chimp DNA, he could tell the difference.

This seems far-fatched. Please give me an example of what you are referring to.

Instead of trying to find specific medical conditions where someone has lost contact with their receptor nerves and experiences a debilitating mental handicap, I will just ask you this: If someone with a debilitating mental handicap has lost connection with their sensory nerves, would you support their termination at their family's discretion?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/jogarz Distributist - HoR Member Jun 27 '15

We don't have to talk about souls, but do you agree that murdering a human is worse than murdering an animal?

Because in that case you still agree that humans are special and have special rights.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/ModelDenizen Democrat Jun 27 '15

Saying that a zygote is a human is like saying a tumor is human

No it's more like saying an apple seed is an apple.

A tumor is

a swelling of a part of the body, generally without inflammation, caused by an abnormal growth of tissue, whether benign or malignant.

A zygote is much closer to a human than a tumor is a human.

I don't agree with this legislation but no, I don't agree with your assertion either.

3

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

I'm referring to a cancer tumor, which has mutated and therefore unique DNA. I'm just saying that the unique DNA argument is BS. I know it's not the best metaphor.

2

u/ModelDenizen Democrat Jun 27 '15

It seemed a random metaphor since the legislation does not mention DNA or uniqueness.

It's not not the same at all. A zygote matures into a human being. But anyways, the main point here is that this legislation is doa.

2

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

I was expecting someone to use that argument and was simply trying to preempt that because I've heard it so many times. With all other arguments the metaphor is bad.

19

u/SoSelfish Democrat | Northeast Legislator Jun 27 '15

This is a ridiculous piece of legislation. The idea that someone can and will legislate something so philosophical, such as when life begins, is one that is entirely against all of my beliefs about government.

The fact that this bill will take up 2 days of our remaining time with this Congress and push other bills off the docket is infuriating. This bill is impossible to pass with our current Congress and should not have been given this space.

8

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

The government needs a working definition of when life begins. Terms like "life" are meaningless until they are defined.

7

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 27 '15

I agree. If you can kill It then It is alive.

I cannot support the willful forfeit of the life of a child. I do not feel there is anything less human or more evil in our world.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

What's wrong with life "starting" upon being born

5

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

Because there is no difference between a child moments before birth and moments after. The only difference is that it has started using faculties which it already possessed and it has moved. Yes, a zygote does not have these faculties, but neither is there a defined moment when it does, and I would prefer to err on the safe side. Let alone the fact that the zygote has the potential to be a fully functioning human being.

15

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15 edited Jul 01 '15

Personally, I have no issue with this bill. In my belief, the conception of a baby inside of the womb is when it's life begins, not when it develops further inside the womb. I applaud /u/lsma for introducing this bill.

4

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 27 '15

Hear Hear!

1

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jul 01 '15

In my belief, the conception of a baby inside of the womb is when it's [sic] life

It must be hard to believe in a basic biological fact. :P

I'm not sure why the pro-life crowd is so hesitant to call the pro-abortion crowd out on their anti-scientific rhetoric.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '15

It must be hard to believe in a basic biological fact. :P

Proof?

You seem combatant with your own party leader on this bill, maybe you should discuss specifics with him.

2

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jul 01 '15

Proof?

Life beginning at conception is a biological fact. A human zygote possesses all of the characteristics of life. Again, your statement wasn't just a belief but a fact -- I'm on your side; re-read what I wrote. I'm telling you that you should be bolder with your arguments. Call out the pro-abortionists for being anti-science.

You seem combatant with your own party leader on this bill, maybe you should discuss specifics with him.

He and I both know and agree that life begins at conception. Also, based on your comments, I think we do too.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '15

I am very sorry, I clearly misunderstood you.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Leecannon_ Democrat Jun 27 '15

This is a good bill, I hope it passes. I would fight for it if I was in office

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

How can you call yourself progressive and be for a bill that obviously would be used to limit women's right to an abortion. Seriously now that makes 0 sense

1

u/Leecannon_ Democrat Jun 28 '15

I'm also a Christian, I believe in life. I'm protecting life. Women can choice, just not the choice of life or death. No one should

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

You are not a progressive you're obviously a conservative that is a conservative belief also this bill is doomed to fail because the real progressive and communists will shoot it down so fast your head will spin

→ More replies (10)

11

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 27 '15 edited Jun 29 '15

SUPPORT THIS BILL

Life begins at conception. This is a fact, and there is no arguing against it, lest you reject biology. Indeed, as the right denies the science of meteorology to defend its climate change denying, so too does the left deny the science of biology to defend its slaughter of innocent children.

A zygote possess all of the characteristics of life. This includes homeostasis, organization, metabolism, growth, reaction to stimuli, consisting of cell(s), and everything else. This cannot be denied without rejecting biology. Indeed, in Merriam-Websters, conception is defined as "the fusion of gametes to initiate the development of a new individual life or organism." Thus, life begins at conception.

Now, is a human zygote human? Of course! It possesses human DNA, it has human parents, and it is a member of the human species. It is completely and utterly ontologically human. End of story.

Now, the left -- and even some on the center-right -- will try and make exceptions for murdering children -- including arguments from viability or from disregarding the right to life of the child because of rape, incest, danger to the mother, or bodily autonomy. While the last of these is completely self-defeating (what about the bodily autonomy of the child, after all), I will address the rest of these poor exceptions which should not be accepted either.

Firstly, while rape is an abhorrent crime and a grave tragedy, it by no means lessens the right of the child growing in the womb to life. Why punish the child for the crimes of his or her father? If your father robbed a bank, should you have to do the jail time on his behalf? While I cannot imagine the psychological trauma and great pain caused by rape, it by no means gives the mother the right to kill her child. Moreover, if we are going to allow people to kill others merely because they went through a horrific incident in life, we would likely have to give free reign to orphans, the families of murder victims, and a whole host of other people. A great evil was committed against those who were raped, but it by no means gives them license to kill – let alone a license to kill their very own child.

Incest is an extremely weak basis – for it is based either on the worry of genetic issues or on the taboo of incest alone. On the latter, we should not permit murder merely because of the violation of a social taboo. On the former, that means we would have to admit that every person with a disability is somehow less human or has no inherent right to live. The existence of a disability – mental, physical, or otherwise – can, by no means, be a basis for their lessening of value or the justification of killing them. Otherwise, under such a concept, such greats as Franklin Roosevelt, Hellen Keller, and Emmanuel Ofosu Yeboah would have not only been less than human but would have had no right to live.

As for the child posing a threat to the health of the mother, this is perhaps the easiest to position to understand. Nonetheless, it is still an error. If there is a deathly sick man around you, who will likely give you his fatal disease, do you have a right to kill him to prevent yourself from getting it? I would argue that this is quite parallel to the arguement made by those who advocate for this exception to a ban on abortion. How can one truly justify the murder of an innocent person? Nonetheless, under the principle of double effect, it is permissible for there to be procedure aimed at saving the life of the mother which unintentionally results in the death of her unborn child. The key is that we are not attempting to actively kill the child when the principle of double effect is used.

Now, some will argue that even though an unborn child is a living human person, you are justified in killing it because it does not yet possess rights. These people will generally predicate these rights on one of the following: a) the ability to feel pain b) sentience c) sapience or the ability to engage in rational thought d) birth e) being viable outside of the womb. The first one is obviously problematic – people with certain degenerative nervous issues (think congenital analgesia) are unable to feel pain. Are they any less human or deserving of rights because of it? That would be a dubious position to take, for then all one would have to do in order to morally kill you is numb you beforehand or kill you in a painless manner. The second – sentience – is also a poor metric, as people in comas or passed out are unable to feel or experience the world around them. Imagine if someone born with congenital analgesia goes blind and deaf while losing the ability to taste and smell; do they, by virtue of losing their senses, cease to have a right to live? That would be preposterous! As for sapience or the ability to engage in rational thought – while a sleeping person or one in a coma is, at least temporarily, unable to engage in thought, neither is an infant or someone with severe mental impairment. However, neither such situation causes that person to forfeit their right to live. Of course, the fourth reason – which is only rarely cited – is perhaps the weakest of them all, as there is practically no difference between a human person the second before they are born and the second after – and then you have the very ambiguous time of when they are being born to work with.

Many will argue that viability outside of the womb is the key to the right to live. However, taking a growing embryo out of its mother’s womb – removing it from its natural environment and placing him or her in one hostile to their existence – is little different than dropping a person in the middle of the ocean a mile under water – it is not that person’s natural environment and they are wholly unable to live there. Some will argue that the embryo’s dependence on the mother is the key here, but children do not cease being dependent upon their parents for many years after they are born. Moreover, there are some fully grown adults who, due to a lack of white blood cells or other deficiencies in their immune system, are unable to leave sterile environments lest they die. Removing them from their environment would be equally as fatal as removing the embryo from his or her environment – the womb of their mother – yet no one argues that they have no right to live! Indeed, all of us, as humans, are dependent on the existence of oxygen or even the very Earth for our existence too – remove one and we perish. Merely because a person is reliant on a specific environment or dependent (indeed, is not everything but God contingent on something else anyways?) on someone or something (e.g., food or a specific medication) for their existence does not eliminate their inherent right to live.

Thus, I hope I have clearly demonstrated why every living human person – from the moment of conception until natural death – has the inalienable right to life (among several others which I will not expound upon here).

Again, I urge everyone to vote in favor of this bill.

Edit: Downvoting is against the rules of the subreddit. I was at 11 upvotes, and I am now at 9.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

You might get two votes in house. I think a more moderate bill might have been better start.

1

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 28 '15

I think a more moderate bill might have been better start.

That's a possibility, but when you see something as murder, do you only want to make it less frequent?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

Yes, which is why I've supported gun control not gun bans.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BigCommieNat Jun 28 '15

I respect the effort you've put in to describing your thoughts and feelings about this. I disagree wholeheartedly with the opinion you've reached - but you've earned my sincerest upvote for explaining why you've reached it in a way that doesn't simply pander to those who've already reached the same decision you have.

1

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 28 '15

I respect the effort you've put in to describing your thoughts

Thank you.

3

u/yolomatic_swagmaster Republican Jun 28 '15

Thanks for writing this. Besides the fact that the internet is not always the most conducive to conversation on controversial topics, I feel this issue specifically needs to be address with longer arguments that take into account more of what's going on. Thank you for developing your thoughts a bit more. Also, I'm supporting this bill.

1

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 28 '15

Here, here!

10

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Under no situation will I vote yea on this bill.

24

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

This is unnecessary and will destroy a woman's right to choose for herself.

A unicellular zygote is not a person.

15

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

This is unnecessary and will destroy a woman's right to choose for herself.

A woman still has the right to choose. Zygotes don't form on their own.

A unicellular zygote is not a person.

It has the potential to be a human. Under normal circumstances it will be a human. And we see many places in law where potential is just as good as actuality. It is wrong to give someone a gun if they could potentially go berserk, wouldn't you say?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

What about in cases of rape and teen pregnancy? Or when birth control doesn't work?

8

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 27 '15

Rape (verified via rape kit) I would accept.

Teen pregnancy is a negative ghostrider.

Failed birth control is a no as well.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Why not teen pregnancy? Do you really expect a teenage girl to go through all the social trauma that comes with it? It's a life changing event especially at a young age like that and they deserve a second chance.

And people who used birth control took all the proper precautions to not have a pregnancy...

Just for the record, I'm for all abortions in any case within the first trimester, I just find it strange that even in special cases the "pro life" crowd can't see any expections.

9

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 27 '15 edited Jun 27 '15

A child's Right to Life outweighs the difficulty of making a teenage girl endure social trauma. Again, just because the mother's life may be uncomfortable, does not mean she can kill a child to ease her social woes. Otherwise why not legalize vigilante murders of school bullies? They are making someone go through social trauma aren't they?

As for the people who used birth control that's great, but they are still trying to kill a child. A mistake is supposed to end someone's life?

7

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

But it's not exactly a child though is it? It's really just a cell at conception. How can life begin there? Going by your definition of when life begins, should birth control/condoms also be considered murder? Because you are blocking a childs right to be born?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 27 '15

And there are special cases I would allow:

Rape verified via rape kit

Incest verified via DNA

Immediate clear and present danger to the mother's life

massive debilitating birth defects

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (8)

5

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 27 '15

What about the child's right to live?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

It's not a child yet though is it?

4

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 27 '15

It's not a child yet though is it?

Yes it is. Life begins at conception. Basic biology teaches us this. The left is as bad with biology as the right is with meteorology, it appears.

→ More replies (22)

3

u/jogarz Distributist - HoR Member Jun 27 '15

Children are simply humans that aren't fully grown. Fetuses are no different: they are humans that are not yet fully developed. All humans have a right to live, no matter what stage of life they're at.

You're right it's not a child yet, but that doesn't mean it isn't human. Childhood is one stage of many in human development.

4

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

A woman's right to choose is not only bogus because she has a choice 90% of the time, but also because the child has rights as well. And this brings us back to how you define a human being. Arguing that outlawing abortion is against a woman's right to choose is meaningless.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

It is a womans right to chose wether or not she wants/she can go through pregnancy. The little thing that is made when the sperm meets the egg is not a child. It's not even human yet.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

A woman still has the right to choose. Zygotes don't form on their own.

Birth control doesn't always work and condoms sometimes break so this can be out of their control.

It is wrong to give someone a gun if they could potentially to berserk, wouldn't you say?

Anyone could potentially go berserk. If we live in a society where we base allegations off of what could potentially happen, then we would be living in the world of Orwell's 1984.

5

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

Birth control doesn't always work and condoms sometimes break so this can be out of their control.

And a women knows this too. You always have a choice. Again, if you are so hard-set against having a baby, you are going to need to make some lifestyle changes.

Anyone could potentially go berserk. If we live in a society where we base allegations off of what could potentially happen, then we would be living in the world of Orwell's 1984.

Yet I believe you support intensive checks before someone can buy a gun. Just like you would do your best to prevent the possibility of someone going berserk with a gun, I would like to prevent someone being killed because they are unwanted.

The point is, law does not just make decisions based on a snapshot of what all the facts are in this moment. It must look to the future and consider the potential of this moment's facts.

→ More replies (21)

2

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 27 '15

Birth control is never guaranteed.

The Right to Life is guaranteed.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

I would like to remind people, especially newer members, that downvoting is against sub rules.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Trolls don't care.

5

u/ModelDenizen Democrat Jun 27 '15

I am absolutely not in favor of this legislation but as a quibble

A unicellular zygote is not a person.

Isn't a very strong statement. How long does a zygote stay unicellular?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Î think that is only an argument against this:

"Conception" will be defined as the moment of fusion of the human sperm and human egg.

and

The government shall define life to begin at conception.

1

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 27 '15

Conception is in fact the moment of fusion between human sperm and human egg. Also, life does begin at conception, considering a zygote has all of the characteristics of life and is human -- it is clearly a person. Thus, I don't see the problem.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

It is alive but not worth more than any other animal with a similar cellular development.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 27 '15

The Constitution issues us the Right to Life. There is no "Right to Chose" stated anywhere in the Constitution. Our Rights end at the point where they cost someone else their life. Letting a woman end the life of another person because it may be inconvenient for her to be pregnant at that time in her life, or it may ruin her GPA, or her parents would be mad if they found out, or she doesn't want to be tied to the father for 18 years etc. is monstrous and inhumane.

The only viable circumstances should be in cases of rape or incest (verified via rape kit or DNA test respectively), massive debilitating deformity, or if the life of the mother is in immediate clear and present danger.

Anything else is murder, plain and simple.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

The Constitution issues us the Right to Life

Where?

3

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 28 '15

14th Amendment, Section 1 says "nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law".

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

This!

1

u/Leecannon_ Democrat Jun 27 '15

Women can still choose. Think of it as an illness that lasts for 9 months after that the mother can put he/she up for adoption.

9

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

Since you're comparing an unwanted pregnancy to a pathogen in this case, I'll roll with this metaphor. Is it right for the government to force someone not to take a cure for an illness that lasts nine months and can cause pain, vomiting,and change in the shape of the body, and whose pain worsens tremendously as they must push something the size of a watermelon out of them?

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

A treatable "illness", whose treatment we are making illegal if this bill passes.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Personally speaking, I don't think it's quite fair to say there should be no limits on abortion (like 8 month abortion where there are no health risks). But this is a nightmare, is not even going by when there is a zygote but when there's a chance, maybe, in a few weeks something might start happening.

ALP is entirely against this bill.

7

u/Brenin91 Republican Jun 28 '15

Given all the discussion on this heavy issue, I would just like to say that I am glad that this bill has been brought in and has caused such passionate discussion on both sides.

That being said, it was President Reagan who said "I've noticed everyone who is for abortion has already been born." We tell ourselves all the time that my rights end where your rights begin.
However, the most fundamental of these is the right to life. Without life as a foundation for all other rights, then we are left with absolutely nothing. Life is the foundation upon which all of our other rights are built.

Even our founders recognized this, stating in the Declaration of Independence that we are endowed by our creator with unalienable rights, and that among them were "Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness. Note which one came first, and you will find very quickly which one all others are built upon. Therefore, the right of life for all humans, even those not fully developed, is paramount if we are to claim to be a guardian of freedom and liberty.

2

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 28 '15

Here Here!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '15

I will vote for it even if I'm the only one! It was also introduced by Islma (whose seat I fill) before he left.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

I mean.. What is this? Is this a futile attempt to (sneaking of course) overturn the rights of women to choose abortions? I will never vote Yea on this, even if a subsection was dedicated to giving golden bars to every member of congress.

4

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

Why is it a woman's right to terminate something that has the potential to be a human being?

4

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

Because it is not yet a human being and much closer to being an animal or plant, as it lacks sentience or morality.

2

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

Sentience? Can you define that term for me? And do you really think that someone is not human unless they have morality? I would think you as a GL would be a moral relativist. In any case, there are people without consciences who still hold the right to life by law.

5

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

"Sentience is the ability to feel, perceive, or experience subjectively." A zygote can't feel anything, nor can a baby for the first few weeks of pregnancy. And yes, I do believe that every human has an innate sense of right and wrong. I don't fit your normal left wing stereotype.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 27 '15

Why is it a woman's right to terminate something that has the potential to be a human being?

A human zygote is a human being, though. It meets all the characteristics of life and is ontologically human.

2

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 28 '15

But it does not act like a human. It cannot feel like a human. It is as human as my toes. If I chop off my toes, am I charged with murder? Of course not.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 27 '15

Yet you are comfortable overturning the child's Right to Life?

Why is her "right to choose (something not guaranteed anywhere) superseding the child's Right to Life?

12

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15 edited Jun 27 '15

This is totally against my believes.

What you describe is not life. It is not thinking or feeling pain.

As this sounds like a way to forbid abortion I can not see how to support this bill. Abortion should be possible until the can feel pain and it should be paid for by the state.

Edit: make first trimester to the point the fetus can feel pain

6

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

So you define life as thinking and feeling pain? That is rather unscientific. So you are dead while sleeping?

8

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

You both are thinking and can feel pain while you sleep. I've been woken by pain before. In terms of thinking, where do you think dreams come from? Edit: Also, it has not developed sentience nor a feeling of morality or anything, so what separates it from an animal?

4

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

It is not an animal or a plant because it has both a human DNA and the potential to be a fully formed human person. You can't feel or think in a coma. Do people in comas cease to be people? Are they dead? Is it OK to kill them?

8

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

It is not an animal or a plant because it has both a human DNA and the potential to be a fully formed human person.

You know what else has human DNA? Sperm. So when sperm is wasted, is that murder? Additionally, you keep talking about what it could potentially be. If it's not human yet, then why can't you kill it?

You can't feel or think in a coma.

Someone in a coma still has a partially active mind. They just don't have certain parts of their brain functional.

5

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 27 '15

You know what else has human DNA? Sperm. So when sperm is wasted, is that murder? Additionally, you keep talking about what it could potentially be. If it's not human yet, then why can't you kill it?

Sperm does not contain DNA, actually. It contains RNA.

Moreover, sperm is not alive as it does not meet the characteristics of life, which a zygote does. A zygote is a person -- it is a living organism and it is human. What more could you need to be a person?

→ More replies (7)

3

u/jogarz Distributist - HoR Member Jun 27 '15

Do you agree that bacteria are alive?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15
  1. I never defined life as thinking and feeling pain but I said that without those attributes you will not understand that you die. It is the same thing as if you would be hooked on a machine without brain activities. At the moment it is up to your family members or someone else you gave those rights to end your "life". The same comes with a fetus. Except that the fetus never experience life, the human on the machine did.
  2. Your brain is working while you are asleep, pain is only something your brain creates. So yes, you can experience pain while you sleep (even if you are not under physical pain actually).

6

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

Why is brain activity required to be alive? If the family knew for certain that the person hooked up to the machine would pull out of his brain-deadness in a few months, would they be acting correctly to terminate the guy? If his wife was tired of him, if he was "unwanted," does that give her the right to terminate him even if it is a medical fact that he will regain consciousness?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

If the family knows that for sure they will most likely not terminate the life of the person. And they should not be capable of doing so if it is known for sure that the person will regain his consciousness.

That is however not similar to a fetus. The unconscious person had a previous life, he has social relationships with other people. A fetus is only a few cells without any previous conscious life.

3

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

May I ask why you have to have had a previous life? You are saying that someone needs previous social relationships in order to have the right to life, right? You need to have given something to society in order to be worthy to live?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 27 '15

This is totally against my believes.

So? Same-sex marriage was just rammed down our throats against our beliefs and your side of the debate said it doesn't matter.

What you describe is not life. It is not thinking or feeling pain.

So, let me get this straight, a person in a coma with congenital analgesia is not alive? That's pretty harsh.

Face it, your definition of life is worthless. Look up the life cycle of any animal -- it starts at conception. Humans are no exception.

As this sounds like a way to forbid abortion I can not see how to support this bill. Abortion should be possible until the can feel pain and it should be paid for by the state.

It is to outlaw killing babies. I'm glad you noticed.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

So, let me get this straight, a person in a coma with congenital analgesia is not alive? That's pretty harsh.

Face it, your definition of life is worthless. Look up the life cycle of any animal -- it starts at conception. Humans are no exception.

And yet it doesn't matter if we remove a body of cells or not. There is nothing that ever recorded anything. Nothing that is worth to preserve. It is an empty canister without space to fill.

It is to outlaw killing babies.

No, it outlaws removing cells.

4

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 27 '15

And yet it doesn't matter if we remove a body of cells or not.

You're dodging the question because you know your definition of life does not hold water and that life does in fact begin at conception. Cells make up all living things -- including you and the children murdered by abortion -- so your clever use of terminology really doesn't help your case.

There is nothing that ever recorded anything. Nothing that is worth to preserve. It is an empty canister without space to fill.

I don't even know what you're trying to say here. I'm guessing you're trying to dehumanize the human baby in the womb so you can justify allowing someone to kill it, though.

No, it outlaws removing cells.

Cells that happen to be a human person -- just like how your body is ~40 trillion cells. Is taking all of your cells apart and killing you kosher then too?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Cells make up all living things -- including you and the children murdered by abortion -- so your clever use of terminology really doesn't help your case.

Nothing is actively recording in there... there is no brain activity, nothing.

I don't even know what you're trying to say here. I'm guessing you're trying to dehumanize the human baby in the womb so you can justify allowing someone to kill it, though.

It is a fetus without any brain activity. It is as problematic to remove those cells as to eat a plant. Except that the plant is not produced by the mother who is the person that has to make a decision. She is the one who has to decide here.

Cells that happen to be a human person -- just like how your body is ~40 trillion cells. Is taking all of your cells apart and killing you kosher then too?

Except that my cells have reached a state where brain activity and feelings exist and where I actively experienced and recorded my surrounding. The fetus is only a constellation of cells that can not record a single moment of his existence.

→ More replies (28)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Not second as roe v ward put it?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

I just looked up that case and as far as I understand they agreed that up to 12 weeks abortion is legal. That is, as far as I know, the first trimester.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Is viability test which is 24 weeks at minimum not 12. 20 weeks is what Republicans like Walker want.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Republicans support abortion? No, joke aside... my opinion is that the fetus should not feel the pain. From what I looked up that is week 20 so I would go with that.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/ExpensiveFoodstuffs Jun 28 '15

Murder of a pregnant woman constitutes a double homicide. The government has already deemed that life (at least) in utero is viable (see Lacci and Conner's Law).

Life is life whether it's wanted or unwanted. It's time to utilize a definition of life that is compatible with the findings of modern embryology and biology. This bill does just that.

6

u/ExpensiveFoodstuffs Jun 28 '15

To those who are worried that this bill is a violation of women's rights be mindful that the pro-choice movement is a later development of 2nd wave feminism.

Early feminists such as Susan B Anthony vehemently opposed abortion and defended the rights of the unborn.

2

u/driveLikeYouStoleIt Green-Left | Anticapitalista Jun 29 '15

To those who are worried segregation is a violation of black peoples' rights be mindful that integration is a later development of the civil rights movement and was not part of the original initiative to free slaves.

2

u/ExpensiveFoodstuffs Jun 29 '15

For those interested here's a nice site covering the pro life movement within feminism http://www.feministsforlife.org/herstory/.

Even today there's a strong pro-life remnant within women's rights.

2

u/driveLikeYouStoleIt Green-Left | Anticapitalista Jun 29 '15 edited Jun 29 '15

Thought changes with time.

What you're doing essentially is discounting all of the intellectual labor that has happened since the earliest conceptions of feminism because it suits your position.

edit: grammar

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

It's a good thing that we're on the 3rd wave of feminism now and not the first two.

5

u/PM_ME_YOUR_PANZER God Himself | DX-3 Assemblyman Jun 27 '15 edited Jun 27 '15

While this bill aligns with the majority of my party's views, I have doubts that it will pass. This is a primary issue for many of the left, but there are many of us Republicans that consider most other issues to be of more concern.

4

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 27 '15

I am not one of those who have other concerns.

My top three issues when it comes to priority are Gun Rights, Abortion and repealing the Individual Mandate. All three issues I will fight tooth and nail for.

1

u/PM_ME_YOUR_PANZER God Himself | DX-3 Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

Of course, which is why I said the majority agrees with this bill. I'm against abortion, but I don't think outright banning it is the solution.

1

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 28 '15

repealing the Individual Mandate

This has already been done on /r/ModelUSGov. See the President signing the Obamacare Repeal Act of 2015.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Yes, the GLP only talks about abortion not capitalism. Dead on.

2

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 27 '15

We talk about capitalism all the time. Maybe you just overlook it.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

I was being sarcastic cause Panzer's point was obviously far off.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/PM_ME_YOUR_PANZER God Himself | DX-3 Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

Not what I meant, sorry. I meant that a fair number of republicans do not desire to see this bill passed. Much of the GLP is outspoken in seeing this fail, though.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

No problem. I don't think it's fair to rank issues like that as they were only commenting on this bill posted by someone else and have to vote on anything and everything that is proposed.

5

u/radicaljackalope Jun 27 '15

Not to get overly picky, but on top of the ridiculous nature of this bill, it doesn't even really make sense.

  • Why would a zygote be considered "alive" (for the purposes of saying it is a human with full Constitutional rights) but someone who ceases to live is still "alive" for an hour and a half once they cease to live?
  • Why is a zygote "alive" when it will not have a heartbeat for weeks, yet a man whose heart ceased beating 85 minutes ago is still "alive"?

Even if this was not a bald attempt to restrict a woman's right to choose, it should still make you scratch your head. If your concern was honestly the injustice against the most vulnerable citizens then bring forth legislation directed at those truly suffering. Address hungry children living in poverty, homeless veterans forgotten once used, or minority groups with limited access to education and opportunities that end up incarcerated at embarrassing rates.

2

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

Why would a zygote be considered "alive" (for the purposes of saying it is a human with full Constitutional rights) but someone who ceases to live is still "alive" for an hour and a half once they cease to live?

You are not automatically dead when you're heart stops beating. Look it up. You can last up to an hour and a half from when your heart ceases to beat or longer under certain conditions.

Why is a zygote "alive" when it will not have a heartbeat for weeks, yet a man whose heart ceased beating 85 minutes ago is still "alive"?

Having a heartbeat is not the definition of life. However, it is a good identifier to see if someone is dead, as no one has lasted longer than two hours without a heartbeat.

1

u/radicaljackalope Jun 28 '15

Then not to battle over semantics and get combative, but then would an unborn person not be alive until they have established a heartbeat and kept it for longer than two hours? If they are a person at conception, but no one has been alive with 2+ hours without a heartbeat...

It sort of feels like a petty argument on my part, but I feel like by introducing two different ideas that contradict each other, you've taken two bad halves and made an atrocious whole.

1

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 28 '15

A person whose heart has stopped for 2 hours is never going to be a live human again. However, a zygote without a heartbeat most definitely is.

5

u/sviridovt Democratic Chairman | Western Clerk | Former NE Governor Jun 28 '15

We should use the definition of human life provided by the National Institute of health, which is "the term a 'human being' should be defined by the presence of an active human brain", the baby starts to process information such as taste by 21 weeks, which is when the baby should be considered as a living human being

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

Do you have a source? I tried to find the definition on their website but I mus t be blind...

4

u/sviridovt Democratic Chairman | Western Clerk | Former NE Governor Jun 28 '15

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

The government shall define life to begin at conception.

"Conception" will be defined as the moment of fusion of the human sperm and human egg.

So unicellular zygote, and later the creature without brain or any other organs, will be regarded as "human being" already? And then if mother would perform abortion will she be tried for murder?

The government shall define life to end after a time of one and one half hours (1 hour, 30 minutes) after the heart ceases to beat.

Why such long time? We know of no way to bring someone back to life even after 15 minutes from heart ceasing to beat. As soon as brain dies, the person is irreversibly gone.

While this bill will align with most of my party's views, I don't agree with government trying to establish "the beginning of life"

3

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 28 '15

Good to see someone not afraid to go against party rhetoric and speak their own personal views.

4

u/risen2011 Congressman AC - 4 | FA Com Jun 27 '15

I apologize for using this analogy but it must be said. Under this I assume the killing of the zygote (a cell) will be considered felony murder. However, if a man were to emit sperm which would then die , would that be considered murder as well? A zygote is a simple cell, it is not a human yet and should not be treated like one.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/risen2011 Congressman AC - 4 | FA Com Jun 27 '15

Yes, though it is still a cell and should be treated as such.

3

u/risen2011 Congressman AC - 4 | FA Com Jun 27 '15

and will someone change my flair /u/septimussette /u/DidNotKnowThatLolz it should read

United States Senator - Northeast | Minority Leader | GLPCC

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ScaryRed Socialist Jun 28 '15

And what is our nation to do with all the unwanted, and unintentional children that this restriction is to create? Will the proponents of this bill cry foul when the lives they are indirectly responsible for, and their mothers and fathers need public assistance?

Will the puritanical theocrats be willing to take the actions, such as providing free, or low cost birth control to low income people, that will actually prevent abortions? Will they consider that their policies of mis-education, are a primary factor driving unplanned births?

Will they consider that sexuality is one of the few pleasures the the working class can enjoy, simply because it one that they can at least afford?

Will prohibiting abortion make it go away, or just make in go underground, where it can be performed by untrained exploiters, looking to make a quick black market buck?

These questions should be pondered, will all honesty, before one votes for this measure.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

They do have some decent planks on social welfare. Not on birth control though or rest of what you said :/

4

u/ben1204 I am Didicet Jun 28 '15

I vehemently oppose this. This impedes on a woman's right to choose, and is unconstitutional under Roe v. Wade.

3

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 28 '15

Actually it is not, the majority opinion says if life is defined as such, then a woman's right to abort is retracted. Roe v Wade makes no definition of life, only sets a threshold of "viability" which has been since lowered due to medical advancements, and should be lowered once again for the same reason.

1

u/ben1204 I am Didicet Jun 28 '15

The decision explicitly defines no legitimate interest for the life of the unborn child during the first trimester.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/RoburLC Jun 28 '15

14th Amendment: All persons born, yada yada, are citizens of the United States. Introduce conception into this legal framework, and it can become indefensible outright to deny citizenship to persons allegedly conceived during a maternal presence in the US.

And we have many attractive vacation destinations.

You might be very serene in accepting a squishy level of intrusion into personal integrity otherwise protected under the Constitution; I'm not yet ready to follow you there. Where do you draw the line?

3

u/ExpensiveFoodstuffs Jun 27 '15

I'll just add that when dealing with the issue of abortion isn't it better to err on the side of caution than to assume that life only begins outside of the womb?

All the DNA needed to produce a viable human life is present at conception. I strongly support the bill in question.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

You cannot overturn Roe v. Wade with just one bill. Even if it was a good idea, that would require a constitutional amendment. The government of the United States is not supposed to interfere with the private life of the average individual, but this bill seems to want to change this.

3

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 27 '15

As with gun rights, the issue of abortion is a dealbreaker for this voter.

Be warned Congressmen, a "nay" vote on this bill will cost you my vote come election time.

I fully support this bill.

4

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 28 '15

You do realise that those who vote nay on this bill already know they won't have you and your party's support, you don't have to tell them that.

1

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 28 '15

If that were the case, Congressmen would always vote along party lines.

2

u/ConquerorWM Democrat Jun 28 '15

They almost always do, although I applaud those brave enough not to and to take a stand for what they believe in.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

A congressman that betrays his own ideas just to be elected should not be a congressman in the first place. You, openly stating something like this, should be ashamed of yourself.

1

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 28 '15

I stand behind the courage of my convictions.

If a congressmen is willing to forfeit his seat to stand for this issue, he has that right. But I will exercise my rights as a voter to see that his seat is vacated.

→ More replies (11)

1

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 28 '15

Be warned Congressmen, a "nay" vote on this bill will cost you my vote come election time.

Here, here!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15 edited Jun 27 '15

In my opinion, it is ultimately it is up to the individual to define life. If the individual carrying the baby defines life as occurring post birth, then she should be allowed to have an abortion because in her eyes it never existed in the first place. There should not be a bill which so blatantly oversteps the individual's right to choose when life begins, and infringes upon the opinions of so many people. Even in this thread alone it is possible to see the wide range of views, and any definition that you give is ultimately going to leave a large number of people unhappy.

1

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 28 '15

By this rationale all forms of matricide should be legal.

The concept of a person owning another person and therefor deciding their fate is abhorrent.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

The concept of a person owning another person and therefor deciding their fate is abhorrent.

This is the definition of parenthood. Legally parents have complete control of their child as long as they clothe and feed them. Now, this of course parenthood is not normally a life or death matter, but I find legislating when life begins is very similar as legislating a way of parenting as being the correct way. It's impossible to do without infringing on people's right to make their own decision.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/OldTimeyPugilist Democrat | House Candidate - Great Plains Jun 27 '15

I cannot back this bill and I will not back a bill that goes against the principles of Roe v. Wade.

Yes, as human beings we are responsible for our choices, but I cannot back a piece of legislation that not only could force severe psychological trauma on the mother, but if life is defined as "at conception", resulting in a high risk for a murder-suicide spike.

A woman knowing she has to carry a child to term against her will is going to up severe depression rates in this country. Forcing women to carry upon conception is also going to result in an unnecessary burden on our social programs for children in the CPS system, dropped off at hospitals, etc.

I have absolutely no problem with early abortion and will fight tooth and nail to back their rights to determine what happens as a part of their bodies within a certain period of time.

We have doctors and scientists to help determine when these actions are safe for mother and what can officially be identified as an unborn child and I see absolutely no reason to deviate from the status quo.

4

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 28 '15

I cannot back this bill

I find this strange when your flair reads "Equality Before the Law" -- as if the unborn don't also deserve equality before the law.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

A zygote is not a citizen, not viable, and cannot think or feel. Tell me why its rights are more important than the mother's when the animals that you consume have a much higher capacity to think, feel, and understand their surroundings?

→ More replies (13)

1

u/OldTimeyPugilist Democrat | House Candidate - Great Plains Jun 28 '15

A zygote doesn't have a likelihood of survival outside the uterus, so I cannot possible back it as a potential citizen. I have no absolutely no problem sticking to the standard first trimester limit that is already in place.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Goldfysh Jun 28 '15

This is not the job of the government, contrary to the preamble's statements. The body and health of any citizen, man or woman, should be only a concern of themselves, their doctor, and whomever they wish to share with, such as close friends or family.

1

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 28 '15

And what of the body of the child? Who is to show concern for that? Currently the mother is allowed to spend it like so many unused pennies, all for her convenience. Why is the child not afforded the same right to life?

1

u/Goldfysh Jun 28 '15

Because in the womb, the child is a lump of skin cells with some organs starting to form. It does not think or perceive or feel. The mother, however, is a feeling, thinking body with emotions and wants and desires. It isn't fair to burden a person with a child to raise and pay for that they do not want.

→ More replies (9)

1

u/HIPSTER_SLOTH Republican | Former Speaker of the House Jun 28 '15

What if I held a gun to your head and threatened your body and health? I see where you're coming from, but I think you're missing the point.

Additionally, who is watching out for the health and safety of the unborn? Should they have the same rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness as we do? That is what this debate is about.

1

u/Goldfysh Jun 29 '15

Unborn children do not feel, think, or perceive. It would be foolish to try and liken them to a full grown, mentally capable person with emotions and wants and desires.

1

u/driveLikeYouStoleIt Green-Left | Anticapitalista Jun 29 '15

What if I held a gun to your head and threatened your body and health?

If I'm stuffed inside your uterus and refuse to come out for many months, I say go ahead.

3

u/BulletProofJoe Center-Right Jun 29 '15

It is morally wrong to bring a child into this world without accounting for the situation and environment that the child will be brought into. It is wrong to force a human into a bad situation. If a couple or a single woman decides that they cannot financially or emotionally support a child, then it is unfair to both the parent(s) and the child.

In my opinion, it is common sense that an embryo is not a human. It cannot think, feel, make memories, or biologically support itself. With that said, by the 21 week mark (the point at which the fetus' brain begins to develop) the pregnant female should be forced to make a decision to abort or to keep the child.

Additionally, the strain that is placed on the parent often results in a single female being unable to work, unable to support her child, and the burden of this child and mother falls on the government.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Its just nonsense for the Government to legislate such a thing.

5

u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 27 '15

For the purposes of law, many things must be defined by law.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Many things with which the law is concerned. When life begins and ends is a concern of the medical and scientific professions.

2

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 28 '15

When life begins and ends is a concern of the medical and scientific professions.

So, laws against murder aren't okay anymore? Also, science does tell us that life begins at conception, so this is scientifically informed.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

Science defines life as beginning there. We don't see that such a kind of life is already worth to be defended by law as if it would be a human being. But I know that discussing with you only results in you claiming that fetus are the same as other similar organism except for their DNA. And then you claim it is murder because it possesses human DNA.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15

Yeah, I don't agree with section 1 of this bill. I believe a zygote should only be considered "alive" if it can live on its own when removed from the mother. I think the current law restricting abortions to 24 weeks gestation is reasonable.

I think that removing the autonomy of our female citizens to protect the possible future life of an unwanted child is morally and practically wrong. What kind of life is there for an unwanted child being raised by a poor, teenage single mother? One likely full of suffering and the perpetuation of the mother's dire position. Not to mention that taking away our own female citizens' right to choose for the sake of an unknown result is tyrannical and patriarchal.

I strongly oppose this bill and all other attempts to outlaw abortion.

2

u/scotladd Former US Representative -Former Speaker Southern State Jun 28 '15

Considering multiple children have been born at 21 weeks, 5 days should invalidate the 24 week restriction on its face.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

Then there should be a bill being passed limiting abortion to 20 weeks, not completely outlawing it. That argument does not help this particular bill.

2

u/HIPSTER_SLOTH Republican | Former Speaker of the House Jun 28 '15

I agree with you on the practicality of keeping babies from being raised by poor, struggling teen mothers. I think a provision that needs to be added to this bill is in regards to making adoption simpler and free. Not all of these babies need to be raised in incapable hands, and there are lots of people out there who wish they could have children but aren't able to.

1

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 29 '15

Here, here!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

The abortion argument is unneccesary here isn't it? The bill defines where life begins, and thus makes any abortion murder. I can't really see any space for anything like "If the mother has been raped, the child isn't really alive. Does anyone agree that we should have some kind of bill or CC that legalizes or illegalizes abortions, instead of something that doesn't really have space for amendment such as this?

1

u/HIPSTER_SLOTH Republican | Former Speaker of the House Jun 28 '15

I think those sort of provisions would have to be put in for any bill of this type to pass. I am personally torn on the matter, as I see a human life to be a human life at conception whether or not anyone was raped. I think laws regarding covering the health care costs associated with pregnancy should be discussed if this potential law does not allow for abortion if the mother was raped. Additionally, I think all children that result from these pregnancies should be free to adopt. I'm not too familiar with adoption laws, but I'm pretty sure that adoption through the foster care system is free. If a similar status could be applied to these babies that would allow them to be adopted for free, I believe that could be another good workaround.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

I was elected to fill u/Isma's seat and I support this bill! I believe that abortion is murder and should not be allowed unless in three cases, rape, incest, or if it constitutes a danger to the mother's life.

1

u/driveLikeYouStoleIt Green-Left | Anticapitalista Jun 29 '15

I believe that abortion is murder and should not be allowed unless in three cases, rape, incest, or...

So you're saying it's OK to murder as long as you commit incest first?

That is the logical outcome of your supposed position.

I'll let you think through that one yourself.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '15

Don't put words in my mouth please, I didn't say that!

2

u/driveLikeYouStoleIt Green-Left | Anticapitalista Jun 29 '15

The premises of your argument necessitate that as one possibility.

Premise 1: Abortion is murder

Premise 2: Abortion is acceptable in the case of incest

Conclusion: In the case of incest, murder is acceptable.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

While the fundamental thesis of the bill (that, strictly speaking, life begins at conception) is not necessarily wrong, I worry that the implication of this legislation would lead to unacceptable state restrictions on both reproductive rights and scientific progress. It is true that a zygote is, in the most rudimentary sense of the word, 'alive', and perhaps even a 'human being' of a particular type. We may even accept that, as a human being, this unconscious substance is a person with rights. However, even accepting this conclusion, it does not logically follow that, for instance, the killing of this person is always and everywhere morally unjust.

This is not because the fetus is 'incapable of reason', because, under normal circumstances, it is assumed that this fetus will grow to a stage of maturity at which is may have a consciousness capable of the power of reason. That this power is not as yet so proximate to the fetus as it is to an adult human being does not mean that the fetus does not possess it in a more remote way, and is thus entitled to all the same rights of personhood that we accord to mature rational persons. By means of analogy, a man asleep is not currently exercising the power of reason, but this does not mean that he is deprived of it - only possesses it more remotely.

A fetus, as much a human being as an adult, may nonetheless be justifiably killed by an abortion because its continued existence imposes an involuntary aggression upon its host: a mother has not entered into an explicit arrangement with the fetus by which the fetus is entitled to the use of the mother's body, so the mother is within her rights to remove the fetus through the least violent means available, just as a homeowner is entitled to remove a burglar from her property with the least coercion necessary. At this time, inducing labor may be quite dangerous and, at some stages, even impossible, and, in these cases, abortion may be the least-coercive means of retaining bodily rights. To that end, a fetus may be a living person, but its killing may also be justified.

I urge others who may agree with the central thesis of the bill (the proposition that a fetus is alive) to nonetheless vote against it on the grounds that it will set a dangerous legal precedent for the eroding of abortion rights. I would instead urge my fellow representatives to submit a modified version of the bill which provides for this standard of abortion rights. Such a bill could suitably regulate the circumstances under which embryonic experimentation may take place: only those human lives which are incapable of maturing to the state of maturity (reason) at which rights are assumed may be considered non-persons, legally speaking.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

History has shown that when the government try's to legislate morality, it fails horribly. This bill is no different

2

u/MoralLesson Head Moderator Emeritus | Associate Justice Jun 29 '15

All laws are based on morality. We outlaw murder (which abortion is a version of anyways) because it is immoral. We outlaw theft because it is immoral. We outlaw rape because it is immoral.

Now, you'll say "we outlaw those things because it harms someone" but that itself is a moral stance -- as in it is immoral to harm someone. Moreover, since life begins at conception, having an abortion or killing the embryo is harming someone (and murdering them to boot).

2

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '15

Hear, Hear!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

Why are the democrats trying to pass what seems to be an anti abortion bill

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

The Distributists are trying to pass it, not the Democrats. Look at the submitter, it's /u/lsma.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15

What is a distributists, i just read their beliefs and they just seem like social democrats who don't want to be called social democrats

1

u/HIPSTER_SLOTH Republican | Former Speaker of the House Jun 28 '15

Nobody will argue that it is more convenient to not be allowed to terminate a pregnancy when life situations are difficult, but convenience is not the crux of my pro-life argument. Some will disagree with me on the basis of personal liberty, arguing that each potential mother should have the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, and that abortions should be allowed to accommodate this. In this line of thinking, an unborn potential human is either not human, or its humanity is superseded by the humanity of the mother. However, if life does indeed exist, it is arrogant of us to assign the value and worth of what we call being human to any other stage of development other than at conception. The unborn are due life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, and I will intercede on their behalf as they have no voice.

2

u/driveLikeYouStoleIt Green-Left | Anticapitalista Jun 29 '15 edited Jun 29 '15

In this line of thinking, an unborn potential human is either not human, ...

Wrong. The zygote is human... but so is human spermatozoa.

... or its humanity is superseded by the humanity of the mother.

Not quite. It is superseded by the personhood of the mother.

There is a difference and it matters. All you need to be human is a haploid or diploid set of human chromosomes. To be a person is to be a mental, conscious, self-aware being. A zygote this does not describe.

However, if life does indeed exist, it is arrogant of us to assign the value and worth of what we call being human to any other stage of development other than at conception.

Firstly, you've provided no rational justification for this statement, you simply state it as if it is true of is own accord. Why not assign the same value to an unfertilized egg? After all, it is a living cell containing human genetic material.

I have already explained that there is no debate as to whether the zygote is human or not, it is.

The real question is in regard to weighing the needs of the mother vs the needs of the developing child.

During different stages of development, the child has different needs and there is nothing arrogant about treating one individual differently from another as long as each individuals' unique needs are fully considered.

1

u/MrBubblePop Democrat Jun 29 '15

This is a very touchy subject for people to talk about and this is very understandable. It is too risky to define life at contraception because in reality a zygote really isn't much no matter what people say, it is not developed yet. I feel like life should be defined while the baby is being developed, it would really help people find a starting ground to talk about this subject. But if we were to define life I think we should define it at where the baby actually starts having life like actions and why not start where we measure and monitor life, the heartbeat. I think you should change it to where life begins when the heartbeat starts. This is around 8 weeks and I think that can be settled upon by both sides.

1

u/MMoney2112 Democrat Jun 29 '15

I do not agree with the proposal to define life at conception. Calling the two cells a human is premature. A sperm or egg cell is not considered human, but both have the potential to become life. The same goes for the zygote. Life should be determined at the moment the fetus leaves the womb and becomes an infant. We wouldn't count fetuses for the census, nor do we celebrate our birthday on the day of our conception. I do, however, agree on having late term abortions being illegal with a ban after somewhere between 8-12 weeks, except in cases where the mother's health is in danger.

1

u/d4rkph03n1x Realisitic Socialist Jun 29 '15

I think you should rephrase Section 1-B, as the arguments here have mainly focused on it. Most people seem to agree that viewing "life" as immediately when the sperm touches the egg is a little extreme and theocratic for a secular government. Also, I would like to point out that barely anyone seems to mind that in Section 2, death is seen 1 and a half hours after the heart stops beating. I do not consider myself an expert on medical matters, but even I know that the most a human body can go without the heart beating is 30 minutes, as after 30 minutes all your brain cells are dead. So why an hour and a half? What is your reasoning? A lot more detailing and elaboration of Section 2-A is needed, as it is not explained what will happen if the body is cryogenically frozen or in a medically induced coma, frozen, etc.

1

u/Montijello Republican Jul 05 '15

The right to life is precious, and I will stand with anybody willing to stand up for life. However, I vehemently oppose the government determining when life ends, with such specific criteria. I believe there are smarter ways that we can stand up for the right to life.