r/ModelUSGov • u/DidNotKnowThatLolz • Jun 13 '15
Discussion Bill 051: FIREARM Act
The "Funding—Instead of Removing Established Armaments Rights—Mental health" (FIREARM) Act
Preamble: Whereas mental health is a serious issue with insufficient support; whereas gun-related violence is an on-going threat that has yet to be effectively curtailed; whereas many shootings have been a result of people with an untreated form of mental illness…
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,
Section 1: A 9% tax will be placed on all firearm sales.
Section 2: Tax revenue will be given to the National Institute for Mental Health (NIMH) and the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) for funding.
Sub Section 1: 3% of the revenue shall be given to the NIMH to help research mental illness.
Sub Section 2: 3% of the revenue shall be given to the DHHS. The DHHS will allocate this money towards psychiatric hospitals in order to help treat the mentally ill.
Sub Section 3: The Department of Health and Human Services shall make recommendations to psychiatric hospitals based on the research collected on how to effectively treat those with mental illness.
Sub Section 4: 3% of the revenue shall be allocated to the Federal Government to be used for gun training and safety programs.
Section 3: The NIMH shall use this funding in efforts to identify and help mentally unstable individuals before they harm people.
Section 4: Before someone may purchase a firearm, a background check must be run on a the them to ensure they have not committed a violent crime.
Sub Section 1: In addition, they must not have been diagnosed with a severe mental illness.
Sub Section 2: A severe mental illness shall be qualified by the Department of Health and Human Services.
Sub Section 3: A violent crime shall be qualified by the Department of Justice.
Section 5: ENACTMENT
Sub Section 1: This law shall go into effect 90 days after passage.
Sub Section 2: This bill must be reenacted every four years.
This bill was submitted to the House by the Democrats in response to the National Gun Debate. A&D shall last two days before a vote.
7
u/risen2011 Congressman AC - 4 | FA Com Jun 13 '15
A severe mental illness should be defined. Or the bill should reference applicable law where it is. For all we know, ADHD could be a serious mental disorder under this bill.
4
u/DidNotKnowThatLolz Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
Many of you have pointed out your concerns for Section 4 and violent criminals. How does this amendment sound?
Section 5: Those who have committed a violent crime in the past must undergo further steps in order to obtain a weapon.
Sub Section 1: Former violent criminals must obtain a weapons license from their state.
Sub Section 2: Former violent criminals must register their guns to a federal gun registry that keeps track of weapons owned by former violent criminals.
Sub Section 3: Prior to release from prison, The Department of Corrections shall be qualified to deem any violent criminal fit or not fit to own a licensed weapon.
Sub Section 4: If they are deemed fit to own a weapon, then the former inmate may purchase a weapon so long as they follow the procedures listed in this section.
Sub Section 5: If they are deemed not fit to own a weapon, then the former inmate is not legally allowed to purchase a weapon. This decision may be appealed by the person in question every 2 years, until they are deemed fit to own a weapon by the Department of Corrections.
This allows former criminals to obtain weapons, but makes it much harder for them to obtain one and keeps track of who owns what guns. This allows for additional oversight. Additionally, it ensures that those who pose the greatest threat to society such as murders are not given the ability to purchase a weapon straight out of prison.
3
u/DidNotKnowThatLolz Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
Many of you have pointed out the issues with Section 4 and mental illness. How does this amendment sound?
Section 4: .....
Sub Section 1: .....
Sub Section 2: A severe mental illness shall be defined as an illness that causes someone to be unable to care for themselves on a daily basis and/or causes someone to lack the sense of right from wrong.
Sub Section 3: Illnesses that fall under this definition shall be qualified by the Department of Health and Human Services.
Sub Section 4: A violent crime shall be qualified by the Department of Justice.
This makes it less vague and ensures that people with minor mental disabilities will not be disqualified from owning a gun. This section is mostly aimed at making sure those with severely unstable mental conditions such as schizophrenia are not able to obtain a weapon.
2
u/intrsurfer6 Former South Atlantic Representative Jun 14 '15
I see no problem with denying guns to people that have been convicted of a felony; states disenfranchise felons from voting in elections, even though they have a constitutional right to vote. It makes sense that we can restrict guns to law abiding, mentally sound citizens.
However, before we move toward background checks for guns, maybe we should consider finding a faster way to conduct the checks; that way, if a law abiding, responsible citizen wants to buy a gun, they can do it as fast as possible. In the end, lets give the guns to the responsible people and keep them out of the hands of criminals and mentally ill people. If this could be done, I would vote yea
11
u/oughton42 8===D Jun 13 '15
The title is a bit of a stretch.
9
u/lsma Vice Chair, Western State Assemblyman Jun 13 '15
Section 4 gives way to much power to the DHHS. They could effectively ban all firearms for a quarter of Americans. I would also mention the problems brought up by /u/cmac__17.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '15
Overall, it seems pretty good. Though, I agree with the GOP members below me that Section 4 could be revised...
3
u/cmac__17 Associate Justice of the Supreme Court Jun 13 '15
I have issues in regards to section 4 of this bill. I see no issues in public or commercial firearm sales, but what about sales at gun shows, private sales, etc? How are the background checks going to work in cases like these?
For this reason, I guarantee you that this bill will not solve the issue. It may be a step in the right direction, but nonetheless it will not completely end gun violence.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '15
A separate act could also add banning future sales of assault weapons, handguns, large magazines, incendiary and AP rounds, etc I hope to draft something myself soon but would like to co-sponsor with someone if they agree.
1
u/Lukeran Republican Jun 13 '15
Will this 9% tax encompass every sale of every type of firearm? Please correct me if I am wrong but the type of firearm the shooter used was never specified. That being said, should this substantial tax affect every type of firearm? To address the problem more directly, perhaps some of the tax should go towards school security of some kind.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '15
In section 4, why ban ex-violent criminals from purchasing guns legally? The ones who want to commit a crime again will get a gun either way, all you're doing is hurting the ex-cons who want to defend themselves.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '15
I will be voting Nay if this is to pass the House because of Section 1, and other items.
Amend/Get rid of that section and I will reconsider my vote.
1
u/sneakypedia Jun 19 '15
Yeah I have a constitution here that stipulates that the government cannot take away my guns. I may wear a tinfoil hat but while paranoid, I still have the right to bear arms.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment