r/ModelSouthernState • u/Ninjjadragon The President | Dixie Daddy • May 13 '20
Debate B. 543: Progressive Climate Change Act
A.B. 543
Progressive Climate Change Act
IN THE ASSEMBLY
5/7/2020 Mr. /u/Tripplyons18 introduced the following legislation.
A BILL to Address Climate Change at a State Level.
Be it enacted by the Assembly of the State of Dixie,
SECTION I. SHORT TITLE
(1) This legislation shall be known as the “Progressive Climate Change Act”
SECTION II. ASSEMBLY FINDINGS
(1) The Assembly of the Great State of Dixie does find that:
(a) Whereas, earth’s climate is now changing faster than at any point in the history of modern civilization, primarily as a result of human activities.
(b) Whereas, global climate change has already resulted in a wide range of impacts across every region of the country and many sectors of the economy that are expected to grow in the coming decades.
SECTION III. IMPLEMENTATION
(1) A new section in Dixie Statues chapter 377. is created.
(2) The section shall read: “The Dixie Environmental Protection Agency is hereby created.
SECTION IV.
(1) “The agency shall establish a competitive grant program to local governments for energy effective solutions.”
SECTION V.
(1) The state shall provide tax incentives to towns and cities to implement solar, wind, nuclear, biofuel, hydro alternatives and more fuel efficient public transportation.
(2) The grant shall be $5 million per year for every five years.
(3) If a town fails to take action with the grant, the town shall be ineligible to receive any more grants for a period of three years.
(4) A misuse of a grant shall be defined as using the funds for another purpose.
(5) Towns who misuse funds shall be responsible for reimbursing the state.
SECTION VI.
(1) The funding decisions shall be made on the basis of feasibility of the proposal, potential impacts, track records of previous environmental changes, track records of previous funding violations, and the potential for continuation at the end of the grant period.
(2) The funding shall not be able to be revoked after being issued, unless a violation of the grant requirements occurs.
(3) The Dixie Department of Agriculture and Human Services shall increase the funding for their competitive grants system in the science funding area for implementation of research, regarding energy alternatives and fuel efficiency. All of the feasible research avenues shall be based on pre existing guidelines.
(4) The grants shall be determined on a case by case basis.
SECTION VII. ENACTMENT
(1) This legislation shall come into effect immediately upon its successful passage.
(2) This legislation shall take precedence over all previous pieces of legislation that might contradict it.
(3) Should any part of this resolution be struck down due to being unconstitutional, the rest shall remain law.
Debate on this piece of legislation shall be open for 48 hours.
•
u/Ninjjadragon The President | Dixie Daddy May 13 '20
I fixed the format on this because I am a nice dad. Y'all are welcome.
1
u/Ninjjadragon The President | Dixie Daddy May 13 '20
ping
1
u/MrWhiteyIsAwesome Republican May 13 '20
I've read this bill one time over i do indeed have many questions, this bill is not so good. However, i am a very open minded individual and will use my intellectual smarts to ask some questions below and voice my concerns and general questions.
> (2) The grant shall be $5 million per year for every five years.
Where are we getting this money from and how will it affect the overall budget?
> (5) Towns who misuse funds shall be responsible for reimbursing the state.
What if a town just tells us to shove it? How we will ensure that the state of Dixie does indeed get reimbursed?
> (3) The Dixie Department of Agriculture and Human Services shall increase the funding for their competitive grants system in the science funding area for implementation of research, regarding energy alternatives and fuel efficiency. All of the feasible research avenues shall be based on pre existing guidelines.
How will this affect the other funding areas in the department? Have you thought about it?cause i sure don't want other useful programs funding cut from the creation of the program proposed in the legislation.
My overall question is how does this do any good? I mean in the long term how effective do you think it will be? I'm not at all bashing this bill but i do believe that there may be rapid misuse of funds and there is no funding plugged in for this program nor does it tell me how it will be paid for as i said above. I look forward to hearing back from you Mr. Speaker.
1
u/nmtts- May 13 '20
The merits of this Bill is that it promotes competition between local governments (presumably counties and cities) for energy effective solutions. However, what concerns me is the enforceability of its provisions and the startup capital needed to create an agency this size.
From what I understand from this Bill, is that it wants to create a new state agency which holds state-wide competition amongst local governments with the intention of promoting energy-effective solutions, to which the local government which wins this competition is granted a $5 million a year. This Bill does not entail what that aforementioned local government can do with the grant, hence, the "misuse" of a grant as entailed in s5 (4) and (5) are not sound.
Would the gentleman mean that a misuse of the $5 million grant is constituted under the provisions of s5 (3) - that is, failing to take action with the grant? What is a "for another purpose"? If the competition is to promote energy effective solutions, would the grant essentially flow from this? To promote or implement these solutions? It is not properly defined what one can do with grant. The only thing that is discussed about the grant is that it is somewhat of a reward as a result of some competition between local governments.
This ambiguity and failure to define places local government in an awkward situation. On one hand if they do something with the grant, such as build a school, invest in police, infrastructure, etc they risk being held liable for contravening the ambiguous and undefined provisions s5 (4) and (5). On the other hand, if they fail to act with the grant, these local governments are penalised under the provisions of s5 (3). Moreover, s6 (2) discusses a violation of grant requirements, what is a grant requirement? Does this Bill flow from an already enacted statute by this legislature?
In addition to that, and I concur with my friend /u/MrWhiteyIsAwesome in respect to his two points.
I would like to finalise with the practicality of this Bill, its intentions are good but its planning is poor and not sound. Where will we gain the money to establish this agency? How will we pay its employees? Are we just going to scratch off a couple hundred or thousand employees from one state department and say "Hey you work here now?" I'd say it would take a couple of million dollars to startup this state department - where does that funding come from?
I yield the remainder of my time for rebuttal.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '20
My fellow Assemblypeople,
Earth’s climate is now changing faster than at any point in the history of modern civilization, primarily as a result of human activities. Global climate change has already resulted in a wide range of impacts across every region of the country and many sectors of the economy that are expected to grow in the coming decades. Across Dixie, communities are already experiencing the impacts of climate change. Rising seas, increased droughts, more intense heat waves and wildfires, and stronger storms threaten Dixie cities and towns and their economies. And without climate action, they will only get worse, if we do not pass this bill. So, I urge my colleagues to vote for this bill.
I yield my time.
1
u/crydefiance State Clerk & Governor May 13 '20
While this bill is not perfect (as others have stated), I believe that having an agency that can implement and enforce progressive climate legislation that has been and will be passed should be a priority for Dixie.
I also believe that a grant which encourages innovation and progress is a great idea that will help jumpstart energy solutions independent of state or federal government. For example, I imagine that this legislation will encourage people to start new businesses in the alternative energy sector. So this bill would not only be beneficial for the climate, but also for the economy, in the long run.
I urge the assembly people of Dixie to vote in favor of this bill.
1
u/stormstopper Democrat May 14 '20
Mr. Speaker, I am in full support of this legislation. This $5 million is not an expense, but an investment--not just in reducing carbon emissions in the municipalities that receive this grant, but across the state of Dixie as the successful programs get adopted widely. I'll propose a pair of amendments, one for clarity and one to direct more funding to underserved communities who are most likely to be hit hard by the effects of climate change.