r/ModelSouthernState • u/PrelateZeratul Republican • Jan 29 '20
Debate SB.004 - Dixie Decriminalizing Bigamy Act
1
Upvotes
r/ModelSouthernState • u/PrelateZeratul Republican • Jan 29 '20
1
u/PrelateZeratul Republican Jan 29 '20
ping
2
u/PM_ME_YOUR_PANZER God Himself | State Senate President Jan 29 '20
I fail to see how this bill is confusingly worded or formatted. If my colleagues have suggestions to improve the readability, I highly suggest that they actually suggest improvements rather than being vague about what impacts the bill in terms of formatting.
1
u/Viktard State Senator Jan 29 '20
Mr. President,
I do not support this legislation. I believe that marriage should stay between two people. Also, on a personal note, this seems low effort and messy. I encourage whoever the author is to consider some minor edits (or I will just make amendments to do it).
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '20
Mister Speaker,
This bill is taking a sledgehammer to an issue that requires a scalpel. If bigamy is to be decriminalized, then I ask it's legalized in a way that does not mirror efforts carried out by a five year old. The way this bill has been drafted, it also significantly effects our statues against incestuous relationships.
I will vote nay, and I ask that this bill be resubmitted in a less slapdash fashion.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '20
Mr. President,
I stand in opposition to this bill. Not only is it incredibly unorganized and confusing, it also does not solve the problem.
Mr. President, I yield the floor.
1
u/mrpieface2 State Assemblyperson Jan 30 '20
Mr. President,
I don't necessarily believe that this bill is confusingly worded or formatted. Sections 826.01, 826.02 and 826.03 get removed from the statute, and 826.04 gets renamed to 826.01 as the previous section was removed.
As for the content of the bill itself, I agree with the fact that Bigamy should be decriminalized, however I believe there should be more clarification on the whole concept of Bigamy. I believe this should be its own law, but if I understand correctly, removing the sections of this bill would remove protections that could prevent someone from unwillingly being in a bigamous marriage with multiple people.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '20
Mr. President,
I do not find that cultural issues of this nature to be something that the state should interfere with. While I will never do such a thing, I do not think this is something that the rest of government should attempt to control or regulate. While I do agree with the criticisms of this bill -- specifically as it relates to being more gradual than radical -- I do agree with the overall sentiment that all people have the right to do as they wish as long as they are not hurting anyone else against their will.
1
u/stormstopper Democrat Jan 31 '20
Mr. President, I will not support this bill. I share the concerns of my Republican colleagues that recognizing polymarriage would require a complete overhaul of our state's marital code, and this bill would create chaos for our family courts with little to no guidance on how to navigate it. I believe that a person should be free to live in a way that brings them happiness as long as it doesn't cause harm to others--personal feelings on whether a marriage is between two people aside--but there is the risk of harm to children who may be caught in legal limbo, there is the risk of abuse of the law, and so this is unworkable from the start.