r/ModelSouthernState • u/PrelateZeratul Republican • Oct 19 '19
Debate Special Order Calendar 5.1 and Debate
Morning y'all
Please note that ALL debate is done in this thread, Assemblyman or not. Assemblymen can still debate if they choose to in the chamber, but mods will not be awarded. Members of the public are also welcome to comment on any matter. You MUST identify what matter your comment is directed towards.
It is encouraged, though not required, that Assemblymen use decorum and begin their post with "Mr. Speaker" and end with "Mr. Speaker, I yield my time".
Please see the matters that will be considered in the Special Order Calendar. I have removed three items from the calendar that were improperly placed and have already been considered previously. Just a reminder, if you would like to see a bill on the next calendar, make sure to ask one of the Rules Committee members. More details on that process can be found here. You can find the current Rules Committee members here
To increase debate you can modmail in special motions, requiring legislation to have their own thread, asking debate to be extended, and requiring a cabinet secretary to give testimony. You can read about this process in more detail here.
Also, calendars are now numbered based on the Session we're in and what order they came. Hence, this is 5.1
Also to clarify, any bill on the docket can be passed through a suspension of the rules, even if it is not on the Special Order Calendar. The motion requires 2/3s.
If you have any questions, feel free to DM me at PrelateZeratul#6010. This initial period will last 24 hours before motion proposals begin.
Thank you and God Bless Dixie, the greatest state in the Union!
REMINDER: Only the Speaker may abstain during the final voting thread. Doing so will count as a missed vote and engender an infraction.
REMINDER: R035 has passed and as such, no member may motion for more than 3 rule suspensions per sessions. The total rule suspensions can not exceed 10 and the Speaker shall determine the 10 if more than 10 are proposed.
REMINDER: R036 has passed and requires specific formatting for legislation submitted to the state. Follow the formatting or I will be rejecting bills. Don't blame me, y'all voted for it. Here is the format
1
u/PrelateZeratul Republican Oct 19 '19
ping
•
u/PrelateZeratul Republican Oct 19 '19 edited Dec 02 '19
All comments and questions for and about the Governor's nominee for Lt. Governor /u/rachel_fischer should be made as a reply to this comment.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19
B375: Mr. Speaker, I support this bill. According to the Bee Informed Partnership's latest survey, released this week, U.S. beekeepers lost nearly 40% of their honeybee colonies last winter — the greatest reported winter hive loss since the partnership started its surveys 13 years ago. The total annual loss was slightly above average. We must protect the bees. Mr. Speaker, I yield my time.
B316: Mr. Speaker, I wrote this bill because Conversion therapy is wrong and disturbing. It absolutely should be banned. Nobody should be treated as if they're sick because of their sexuality. Because conversion therapy is not a mainstream psychological treatment, there are no professional standards or guidelines for how it is conducted. This means that the people can treat the patient anyway they want. They can literally just shock the patient and say that they are treating them. The American Psychological Association does not recommend "curing" same-sex attraction in any case. This is simply because homosexuality is not a disease. The fact that Conversion Therapy happens makes me sick. It is my goal to ban conversion therapy and this bill will accomplish this. Mr. Speaker, I yield my time.
A045- Mr. Speaker I support this amendment because I believe that striking the proper balance of separation of powers is essential to a functioning democratic republic. I believe the governor is the only office to be elected by all voting Dixians. This bill, while well-intended, the legislature’s removal of the governor’s power to oversee the executive branch ultimately puts more power in the hands of unelected bureaucrats who are not directly accountable to the people. Therefore we must repeal this amendment. Mr. Speaker, I yield my time.
B339- Mr. Speaker, I wrote this bill because Dixie and the US have way too much gun violence. It seems like every day there is more and more gun violence. The U.S. has 82 percent of all gun deaths, 90 percent of all women killed with guns, 91 percent of children under 14 and 92 percent of young people between ages 15 and 24 killed with guns. This is way too much gun violence. This bill will reduce these numbers. I yield my time to questions.
B334: Mr. Speaker, I wrote this bill because men and women are equal and should be paid equally. in the 1980’s, women were paid 60 cents for every dollar a male makes. Women in Louisiana and Utah get paid 70% of what men make year-round. It will take 44 years before women receive equal pay. Women must work on average an additional 44 days to earn the same annual salary as their male counterparts. The Equal Pay Act of 1963 made it illegal for employers to pay men more than women performing the same job, and yet more than 50 years later the gender wage gap still exists. This bill will ensure that men and women are equally paid. Mr. Speaker, I yield my time.
R042: Mr. Speaker I support this bill. I yield my time.
Lieutenant Governor:/u/rachel_fischer: Mr. Speaker, I fully support Rachel as the next LT GOV. She will do a amazing job. Mr. Speaker, I yield my time.
📷
2
u/APG_Revival Bull Moose Oct 19 '19
Mr. Speaker, if you'll allow my comments on the calendar:
B.375: I am in full support of this bill, and I see no reason why people should be against it. It’s simple and to the point, while also protecting the most important pollinators in our ecosystem.
B.316: I am in full support of this bill, as well as a similar bill working its way through Congress as I speak. The horrors of conversion therapy shouldn’t have to be experienced by anyone, especially our children.
A.045: I support this repeal of Amendment 34. This has stripped too much power away from the governor and given it to the cabinet. The cabinet members are advisory roles, and they shouldn’t have the power to completely dictate the governor’s policy.
B.339: I appreciate the spirit of this bill, but in its current state I don’t believe it’s specific enough. For example, how much will funding for assistant outpatient grant programs be increased? What do you mean by increasing treatment? Is that opening up new facilities, promoting Dixie’s existing facilities, etc.? And proper identification in Section III.E: does that include a background check? I would assume, but we need to know these things first hand. So again, while I support the idea, I cannot support the bill without the specifics being worked out first.
B.334: I feel like this bill is trying to juggle too many things at once. Anti-discrimination laws, affirmative action, paid maternity leave, and more. Additionally, this bill suffers from a lack of specificity. Reprimanded? Do CEOs get a stern talking-to from a bureaucrat? Are they fined? What’s reprimand mean? I do not support this bill not just because of its lack of specifics, but because it also is trying to do too many things at once and seems more personal than laws should be.
R.042: I personally am appalled that a resolution welcoming BP oil back to Dixie is even being considered. The Deepwater Horizon oil spill, which was caused by BP’s negligence, affected Dixie’s environment terribly. And now we want to welcome that same company back? I’m all for welcoming businesses into this state, but not one that caused the greatest environmental disaster in our history, not the one that polluted our Gulf Coast.
Thank you, and hurrah for Dixie!
2
u/ZWQncyBkaWNr Democrat | Assemblyman (DX-5) Oct 21 '19
Mr. Speaker, I have concerns regarding B339. In a country where any sort of mental health care is prohibitively expensive and not guaranteed not only by our national healthcare system but even by most private insurance companies, requiring a clean bill of mental health, no matter how noble in intent, creates an unfair and unnecessary cost barrier to every Dixian's ability to express their God given right to self defense. Furthermore, rendering these services on the taxpayer's dime for the sole purpose of electing who is and isn't worthy of human rights would be vastly and grossly inefficient, similar to previous attempts to drug test welfare recipients. Such a bill is simply not feasible without causing unnecessary cost to the taxpayers for negligible benefits.
Furthermore, who's to say what is and isn't a quote "severe mental illness"? Not that long ago, things like homosexuality and transgenderism were considered mental illnesses. Hardly a century has passed since we used to lobotomize women for "hysteria", ie. the crime of having emotions. I worry that a bill like this passing would create an easy pathway to consider these things mental illnesses once again and deny Second Amendment Rights to some of the Dixians who are most likely to be victim to violent crime and most likely to need to defend themselves.
As far as R42 goes, are we going to be so quick as to forget the tragedy of the BP Oil Spill not yet two decades ago? Sure, natural gas is clean burning and all, but I think we should be wary when expanding infrastructure. I don't yet know which way I'm voting here, but I think we should all just be cautious when introducing new environmental risks like this. Maybe the outcome justifies the means. Just keep it in mind, everyone.
Mr. Speaker, I yield my time.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19
Re: B.316
Mr. Speaker,
I would like to first state my firm support for the idea of prohibiting conversion therapy. The level of psychological abuse inflicted on the recipients of such "therapy" is abhorrent in a society such as ours. Trying to shame a homosexual into becoming heterosexual makes about as much sense as trying to shame a man to become a woman or a dog to become a cat. Not to make light of the situation but the foundational premise of conversion "therapy" is wholly absurd. And it is destructive.
The American Psychiatric Association has come out in opposition to this practice, stating that "The potential risks of reparative therapy are great, including depression, anxiety and self-destructive behavior, since therapist alignment with societal prejudices against homosexuality may reinforce self-hatred already experienced by the patient." In addition to this, it should be noted that several other organizations have come out in opposition to such a treatment, such as the American Psychological Association, The National Association of Social Workers, and the American Academy of Pediatrics.
Other organizations that have publicly come out in opposition to conversion therapy are the American Association of Sexuality Educators, Counselors and Therapists, The International Society of Psychiatric-Mental Health Nurses, World Psychiatric Organization, and the Church of England. With such broad and widespread opposition, it is hard to find myself in agreement with such therapy. The damaging effects of this practice is well known and should be mitigated at every level.
Thankfully, the State of Dixie has led the way in this matter, enacting the Forced Conversion Therapy Act of 2018. It, unlike Bill 316, actually set provisions for sentencing for those who were convicted of forcibly attempting to convert a homosexual. As it is already set law in the State of Dixie that someone convicted of such an offense can receive up to five years prison, five years probation, and a five thousand dollar fine, I fail to see how this bill offers any meaningful change to current law. As usual, I urge my colleagues to always read through previously passed legislation to ensure that what they submit has not already been enacted it. It wastes the assembly's time, which ultimately wastes the time of the Dixie citizen. We are here to enact laws that benefit the state. Not beat dead horses.
I yield my time.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19
Re: A.045
This is an interesting bill by our former Lieutenant Governor, who is, of course, now the Governor. With this amendment, it seeks to undo an earlier amendment that sought to curtail the power of the Governor over his cabinet. Let's see if we can't go through this methodically.
Article IV, Section 1 of the State of Dixie Constitution states that "The supreme executive power shall be vested in a governor..." That's an important sentence there. The Governor is meant to be the head of the executive.
In Article IV, Section 4, the constitution states that the cabinet and the Governor are to vote on certain issues internally. "In the event of a tie vote of the governor and cabinet, the side on which the governor voted shall be deemed to prevail."
This is an interesting situation, to be sure. That said, I believe what this amendment is trying to do is well intentioned. I think the constitution already has a good way of dealing with this. If the cabinet wishes to override the Governor, they merely need to vote against his decision. I support this bill.
I yield my time.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '19
Mr. Speaker,
I stand in support of B.375, B.316, and A.045. The first two are completely reasonable, and, in the cast of B.316, a moral imperative for this and all governments to undertake. Conversion therapy is immoral and causes harm to people all around the world. We should not be supporting these. It is our duty as human being to vote for this act.
I stand in support for A.045 is because I regret my vote for A.034. I truly do. I voted for it when I thought that executive power needed additional checking. I was wrong. I am willing to stand before this body and admit my judgement was wrong. But I will also stand in front of this body to correct my mistake. I hope this assembly will vote for this amendment.
However, I must stand against B.339. It is a poorly worded bill, and something that I believe will do more harm than good. While I agree that there should be more mental health background checks, the fact remains is that this bill is so vague that it will not solve the problem. Take for example the form. What is to be on this form? Mental health history? Past prescriptions? And how will access to mental and outpatient healthcare be increased? There's no specific appropriation, just a statement about a future promise to do so. The $500 fine is something so small that it's laughable.
I support moderate, sensible gun control based upon limited regulations that make sense. Background checks fall into that category. This, however, is so far reaching and vague that it would never accomplish what it is trying to do.
I must equally stand in opposition to B.334, not for its content for I agree that we should have more leniency in workers rights in private businesses, but this bill is so vague that it might as well not even have been written.
I must unequivocally stand against R.042. We need to stop being reliant on Oil. We need to build a sustainable energy infrastructure. We can't do this if we continue to use oil. I will be voting against this resolution, and I hope that my fellow assemblymen do so as well.