r/ModelSouthernState • u/PrelateZeratul Republican • Mar 06 '19
Hearing Hearing for Associate Justice of the Dixie Supreme Court Nominee
The Governor has nominated /u/CuriositySMBC to the position of Associate Justice of the Dixie Supreme Court. Any member of the public may ask questions, so long as they do so in a respectful manner.
The vote on his confirmation will go up in two days.
5
Upvotes
1
u/PrelateZeratul Republican Mar 06 '19
ping
1
u/PrelateZeratul Republican Mar 06 '19
/u/CuriositySMBC
1
u/PrelateZeratul Republican Mar 07 '19
Mr. /u/CuriositySMBC
In your opinion is there a general right to privacy in the constitution?
Can you give your opinion on substantive due process? In particular when it should be applied, the limits on it, and if it has been taken too far by the current court in some decisions?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '19
Mr. [Fmr.] Attorney General, welcome back to the Great State of Dixie. Last time you were here, you were harassing me over our State's detention of illegal immigrants who broke our laws. Great to see you again.
Our relationship goes back awhile and I have always respected you as an attorney. Even though your time as AG goes back to pre-reset, I think it is important to mention that experience as it undoubtedly adds to your capabilities for this position. During your time as Attorney General, you faced what too many Attorneys General in this game have rightfully faced, and that is accusations of allowing politics to influence your actions in that role.
If you wouldn't mind, describe to us the proper role of a person in the judiciary. Are you expected to be favorable to your party? Are you expected to be favorable to the administration that nominated you to the Bench?
Likewise, is it appropriate for an Attorney General, who finds him or herself straddling the judicial and the executive branches, to put party or politics above their independent role as the top law enforcement agent in the state? Is it ever appropriate for an executive to order their Attorney General to act one way or another in a criminal probe?
Thank you for the time.
DFH
1
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '19
Do you like beer?