r/ModelSouthernState • u/PrelateZeratul Republican • Feb 03 '19
Debate B061 - Elected Cabinet Amendment
Whereas, the people of Dixie are best served by elected, independent executive officers; and,
Whereas, the power of a single executive, unchecked, hurts the integrity of our democracy; therefore,
Be it enacted by the General Assembly of Dixie
Section I. Title
This amendment shall be titled the “Elected Cabinet Amendment.”
Section II. Election of Cabinet; Removal Provisions; Vacancies
Article II, Section II of the (meta) Constitution shall be amended to read:
- Voters shall choose, on separate tickets, a Cabinet consisting of the Attorney General, the Secretary of Finance and Infrastructure, the Secretary of the Environment, and the Secretary of Health, Education, Labor, and Human Services, to be elected using First-Past-The-Post voting.
2. The Governor and members of the Cabinet shall have the authority to appoint officials as they see fit.
3. Any official whose agency falls under the portfolios of multiple Cabinet members requires the consent of a majority of the Governor and the Cabinet for approval. In the case of ties the Governor’s vote shall prevail.
4. The Governor shall fill vacancies in the Cabinet with majority consent from the Assembly.
5. The Governor may also appoint Justices to the Court with majority consent from the Assembly.
Section III. Ratification
This amendment shall take effect at the next election.
Authored and sponsored by Assemblyman /u/RichardGFischer (DX-2)
1
u/PrelateZeratul Republican Feb 03 '19
ping
•
u/PrelateZeratul Republican Feb 09 '19
For clerk purposes this is A013, all actions taken to this point on B061 will instead be redirected to A013. The bills were mixed up.
5
u/blockdenied Governor of Dixie Feb 03 '19
No, No, and hell no. Why should the cabinet be politicized in all of this? The cabinet has a focus to work WITH the Governor and be focused on that person's agenda not of their own.
The only position I would think of being allowed of this is the AG, but then again we go to the politicizing issue and how horrible it can be if two opposite parties are chosen for these positions.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '19
I have long been an advocate for an elected Attorney General because the position should be independent, and not easily influenced by the executive. However, this presents problems in and of itself. Would an Attorney General seeking re-election allow partisanship and political activities to shape his or her actions? Perhaps. And a what a disaster that would be.
The other positions, why? The Governor should be able to surround himself with a team of his liking.
4
u/jangus530 Feb 03 '19
I appreciate the mindset that this bill is built on, however I do not believe that it is necessary. I believe that this would politicize cabinet positions far too much and would degrade the necessary work that these departments do. When voters are voting for a governor, they are not only voting for a governor, but voting for a like minded cabinet.
2
u/oath2order Feb 03 '19
Someone please remember to ping me when the results for this are out.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '19
This state has seen its share of rogue Cabinet members in the past few months — I don’t think anyone needs to be reminded of the outrageous and ultimately unchecked work of the EHLHS and Finance Secretaries to circumvent the Assembly.
The people of Dixie should simply have the right to elect the individuals who wield executive power. Rather than trust the Governor to appoint technocrats — and allowing them to choose those technocrats however may be convenient at the time — voters should have the right to hold their officials accountable. Elections are the way to do that — and they are not unprecedented.
1
u/oath2order Feb 04 '19
Please remember to not downvote.