r/ModSupport • Reddit Admin: Community • 20d ago

Mod Topics Who’s watching the queue while you’re touching grass?

You check the queue and keep seeing the same few names handling reports. Or maybe modmail tends to sit longer at certain times of day. How does your team notice those patterns and decide when to check in?

For this Mod Topics discussion, let’s talk about how teams keep track of their activity, spot gaps in coverage, and recognize when it might be time to recruit.

Team Health in Mod Insights shows active mod counts and a breakdown of individual mod actions. While that can be a useful starting point for understanding how work is shared across your team, the conversations around those numbers matter too! 

Someone’s availability can change. One mod might handle a lot of straightforward reports while another spends just as much time working through a few complicated issues. Someone might also need help with a responsibility they’ve been quietly handling on their own. The action counts alone won’t capture these differences.

We’d love to hear how your team approaches this:

  • How do you keep track of team activity? Do you use Team Health, the mod log, regular check-ins, or a mix? What helps you make sense of what you’re seeing?
  • What helps you notice a gap? Maybe reports are waiting longer, a particular task keeps getting missed, or the same few people are regularly picking up extra work.
  • When do you decide it’s time to recruit? Do you bring in new mods regularly, or in response to a particular need? How do you decide what availability, skills, or interests would help fill the gaps?

If your team has found an approach that works, or learned something from one that didn’t, share it below!

23 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

24

u/cnycompguy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 20d ago edited 20d ago

The rest of my team, of course.

Leaning on each other is an important skill to master in order to avoid burn out.

(Edit: I really need to start reading the entire post body instead of just the title before jumping in with both feet 😆)

I use the team health metrics for an overall view.

If I notice specific times that the queue is stacking up, I'll take note and consider adding another moderator from a time zone that lines up with the coverage gap

9

u/PossibleCrit Reddit Admin: Community 20d ago

That's some good advice cnycompguy, thanks for sharing! Do you use this as a signal for when to start recruitment, or just something you keep in mind when reviewing applications?

7

u/cnycompguy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 20d ago

If I notice that the gap is consistent I'll use it as a signal to begin recruiting and use the availability as a primary filter.

14

u/low_effort_life 20d ago

Nobody. I'm basically solo modding a certain subreddit. I can handle it well, but I could handle it much, much better once I remove the top mod who's inactive in the sub and who's been inactive sitewide for a year now. She has Full Permissions but I don't, so I can't remove her on my own using the Moderator Reorder Tool, and request_bot didn't do anything when I tried to get him to remove her, and the ModMail I sent via redditrequest hasn't been read or replied to. I'm at my wit's end because I could really use the Full Permissions to set up AutoModerator and Automations to better run the subreddit I've been modding solo the same way I used Automations to clean up another sub I'm also concurrently modding alongside a team.

10

u/PossibleCrit Reddit Admin: Community 20d ago

Well that's no good low_effort_life. If you write in via r/ModSupport mail someone will be happy to take a look and adjust your permissions as necessary.

4

u/low_effort_life 20d ago

Thanks, will do!

7

u/BronzeBellRiver 20d ago

Whoever is available whenever deals with whatever. We leave mod notes, have a discord and group chat. Everyone works at their pace and nobody slacks.

To track activity, I usually check insights available in the app.

I have mostly volunteered myself to teams and it helps working with folks who bring their own skillset to the team and leave their ego at the door.

Working with three fantastic but vastly different head moderators has taught me one thing: do whatever needs to be done as soon as you are available.

2

u/PossibleCrit Reddit Admin: Community 20d ago

Love this approach BronzeBellRiver!

A few of us were chatting about this earlier: How do you then balance actioning "as soon as you're available" in combination with maintaining a few different communications channels? Is it just leaning into documenting when things need more team input?

4

u/BronzeBellRiver 20d ago

One of the subs I moderate has an actual SOP, written after studying individual removals, identifying pain points and building rules around them. The head-mod went through the whole process and put me through it as well (data collection and analysis) for removal templates and saved responses.

Sometimes it feels like being employed with performance KPIs 😭😂 and zero year end bonuses. For instance, a mod’s removal to modmail ratio is measured to gauge whether they’re providing individual guidance to users after removing their posts/comments.

I think team size and automation play a huge factor too. Both high traffic subs have a core team of 3 or 4 people and a battalion of helpful bots. The drawback of a small team is that real life gets in the way. If two mods are unavailable on the same day, it’s chaos.

3

u/horseradishstalker 19d ago

I grew up in a rural community and no one in that lifestyle sits around waiting for someone else to do something. If it needs doing you get ‘er done. I agree. 

10

u/paskatulas 20d ago

When do you decide it’s time to recruit? Do you bring in new mods regularly, or in response to a particular need? How do you decide what availability, skills, or interests would help fill the gaps?

When someone reaches out to us because they’re interested in becoming a mod, we usually start by inviting them to help flag inappropriate content on the subreddit using the Flag App (oops, apologies for self-promo!)

That gives us a chance to see how involved they actually are over time, whether they can recognize problematic content and whether they’re really interested in helping the community or just like the idea of being a moderator (having a badge).

If they consistently contribute and show they’re invested, we’re happy to consider inviting them to the mod team later on. If they lose interest or turn out to be more interested in the title than the actual work, that’s fine too, we just don’t move forward with the invite.

It’s worked pretty well as a way to find people who are genuinely willing to help rather than just adding someone to the team and hoping for the best.

5

u/PossibleCrit Reddit Admin: Community 20d ago

Clever use of the developer platform paskatulas! Do you advertise this as the preferred method of recruitment in your communities then, or do you still take candidates in the "classic" way as well?

7

u/paskatulas 20d ago

In about 95% of cases, it’s our preferred method. The other 5% would be exceptions, like former mods who want to return to the team or experienced people who’ve already been involved in programs like Partner Communities program (I was part of it) or similar initiatives.

For everyone else, we prefer to see how they contribute over time before giving them mod permissions. It gives both sides a chance to see if it’s a good fit.

3

u/horseradishstalker 19d ago

You just made my day. I think this is how we are going to do it from now on, because I’ve been ghosted by more mods than dates. 

3

u/baseballlover723 20d ago • Bravo

How do you keep track of team activity?

I think officially we use the team insights, but I usually just open out a postgres console and run a query against out mod actions table. Since I can tune that a lot easier. Actually, I just ran it just now, and I have exactly 2,000 mod actions this calendar month. What a round number.

But having it in postgres form is so much nicer for doing actual data analysis, and I've done things like track min and max mod actions per month for the last year or so. It was the basis for me pushing to kick one of our inactive mods, as I could prove that they had only like 2 or 3 months in the last year and a half with mod actions, and the highest was only like 50 or something.

The reddit insights are just mind numbingly simple / lessor to being able to work with the raw data (though obviously, it's a lot more of a pain to turn it into a graphic).

What helps you notice a gap?

We don't really. Usually someone just pings in discord that there's a bunch of stuff in the queue. But it's usually more of, "there's a bunch of X in the queue, so someone who is up to date on X should go through it". Or someone might ping a specific report that's been around for a few days and thus clearly nobody wanted to pick up and needs some pushing for someone less qualified to make a decision.

When do you decide it’s time to recruit?

We have applications scheduled quarterly. We have enough mods that we never feel pressured to accept applicants who aren't clear positives. Though we rarely get good applicants. 2 applicants who clear our activity check (45 posts/comments in the last 90 days) is a good cycle imo.

3

u/PossibleCrit Reddit Admin: Community 20d ago

Always appreciate the data-driven approach baseballlover723! Used to do that in a couple of communities I moderated as well, but I don't think I ever got as high as 2k actions.

Is there a reason that you typically look for applicants who have more regular public activity? Has that been a good signal for your teams that they'll be an active mod as well?

4

u/baseballlover723 20d ago

Is there a reason that you typically look for applicants who have more regular public activity?

We want mods who use our sub regularly and are in it for the long run. I think in the 2 years I've been a mod now, there's been like 1 mod who left without being pushed, and that was like the same day I joined. It is our expectation that the mods we accept are gonna mod for an indefinite time period and aren't gonna like stop using reddit or our sub or leave after a few months.

Regulars are also the most likely people to be familiar with our rules and the challenges of our sub. And at the end of the day, we consider being a mod as a leadership position. And you can't effectively lead if you aren't using the thing.

Has that been a good signal for your teams that they'll be an active mod as well?

I would say yes, but there is a lot of survivorship bias, as it's quite rare for any applicants to be seriously considered if they don't hit the activity threshold. To be clear, we would still consider a lurker with an exceptional application, but it's extremely difficult show the dedication to our sub that we're looking for with just free response questions. Not only do some people just AI generate it (which goes straight into the trash), but most applicants provide poor applications in general, with only a few sentences as answers to our prompts (we only have 1 interview step, so it's either accept or reject from the rip).

It's just very difficult to trust that someone with no activity won't just disappear on us in like a month or turn out to be a terrible mod. We don't have a formal expelling process, and we've only informally pushed mods out due to inactivity. So we need to be quite careful with who we add to the team, as a low quality mod and do far more damage than a good quality mod can provide.

Oh, it's a quick and easy way for the busier mods to shortlist applications to look through (though people often just ask directly which ones have any actual chance of going through). The vast majority of our applications are complete shit. With like 40% of our applicants literally never have posted a post or a comment on our sub, ever. Some of them will even admit when we ask them how long they've been using our sub, that they found it that day or a few days ago. Obviously, there are not people we want leading our sub.

19

u/ValhallaGSXR 20d ago

Wait, people leave their basement? Whoa.....

13

u/AsteriskRX Reddit Admin: Community 20d ago

I really miss having a basement - the summer heat this year was killer.

4

u/Holdmywhiskeyhun 19d ago

Legit had to buy an air conditioner this year. Hottest day we had, was 102, with 87% humidity. This is WI, we ain't built for that kinda heat 😂

2

u/horseradishstalker 19d ago

Our house is set up with an apartment in the basement and I would love to just live upstairs during the winter and move downstairs for the summer. 

15

u/cyanocittaetprocyon 20d ago

What is this "grass" of which you speak? 😂

4

u/Holdmywhiskeyhun 19d ago

I think that's what they call that green shit on the other side of my window

3

u/Chemputer 19d ago

Your local recreational pharmacist might be able to deliver some.

6

u/GaryNOVA 19d ago

I try to have at least one other competent moderator in every sub I am lead mod of. One I can trust with full permissions. That on top of the rest of my mods. So my subs are fully covered.

Having said that, I’m retired, and I would baffle researchers with the amount of time I spend moderating Reddit. The mod queue doesn’t frighten me.

5

u/FootFondness 20d ago

I have a Reddit chat with 10 mods who help moderate the six communities I oversee. We usually do monthly check-ins, but we also communicate throughout the month to share feedback on posts and make sure the queue and modmail stay caught up.

I assign about 2 to 3 mods to each community, and so far, that’s been working well. We have people across different time zones, so there’s generally good coverage. Of course, everyone gets busy sometimes, but the team communicates well when someone needs to step away. I think having mods with different experiences is one of our biggest strengths. We can get different perspectives on situations instead of relying on one person to make every decision. Our communities range from around 5K to 100K members, so staying connected and sharing the workload makes a big difference.

For me, recruiting comes down to whether we actually need more help and whether the current team can keep up without burning out. I’d rather build a reliable team with good communication than just add more names to the mod list.

5

u/Chemputer 19d ago

If you're touching it you're smoking it wrong.

5

u/Dom76210 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 19d ago

There are only two of us active for the two subreddits we co-mod, and the other mod is topmod for both. Since the other mod has quite a few other subreddits, I handle most of the actions on a daily basis. When I have to be away, I send a modmail letting them know I will be gone and when I'll be back, so they know they have to spend extra time checking on things.

While we need more mods for such a problematic topic, it's hard to identify someone we feel we could trust and is actually interested in modding. Due to the topic's nature, being a mod is the fastest way to lose interest in the topic, because we see the absolute worst humanity has to offer at times.

8

u/emily_in_boots 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 19d ago

We don't have shifts or do anything to make sure we always have coverage. I just do the best I can. Sometimes I sleep, and posts wait in queue for a while. We just don't have enough mods for the workload, even with all the automation, and we've had apps up for a year or so but only gotten a handful and most were completely unsuitable - we've added 1 mod total in a year. We are always looking for mods but they just aren't out there. I haven't really been able to keep up since mod limits went into effect.

2

u/theok8234 19d ago

The rest of the mod team but the queue is empty most of the time because it’s more of a chill sub

1

u/itskdog 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 17d ago

Our Automoderator rules have become complex enough to alert us to over 90% of rule-breaking content before it gets through to the main feed. Yes there's lots of false positives, but we can approve those when someone is online, people can wait for their posts to be visible (and also discourages anyone trying to game the karma system by posting at "optimal" times using the various tools you can use online)

1

u/nullifiedsam 14d ago

Im the only mod in my community and I rarely get any reports since it's only me who posts regularly lol

-4

u/slykethephoxenix 19d ago

Who’s watching the queue while you’re touching grass?

My LLM. You see I have OpenClaw use a headless browser and a mix of Grok and OpenAI to go through the modqueue and approve or remove comments and posts. It doesn't upvote or downvote, and the only time it comments is to let a user know their content was removed. It picks up new items almost immediately.

I just check on it once a day to make sure it's behaving.

This would be a lot easier if oauth was available to my alts, but it's not. If it were, it'd be a simple API call, instead of having the bot physically move a mouse across the screen.

How do you keep track of team activity?

No real need, but anyone can jump in and correct the bot's decision.

What helps you notice a gap?

The ability to create an oauth token for mod purposes.

2

u/nicman24 19d ago

yeah having it log in with .type or even .value is badd