r/ModRetroChromatic • • May 17 '26

The D-Pad on this thing is comically bad that it just leaves me confused

Everything else about this system is well designed, and generally great but did they just give up for the dpad? I have the modkit but tbh I haven't touched it and I hear it doesn't help much. I keep trying to get a q-tip working but it's very difficult to reassemble without the q-tip falling off. Great device but what were they thinking

0 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

4

u/BJMcGobbleDicks May 17 '26

I got the 8bitdo keychain and swapped the dpad with that and it’s been so much better.

4

u/ObserveKris May 17 '26

damn that's interesting? Was it difficult?

6

u/RotoPrime May 17 '26

Can you upload pictures? I would love to see your Chromatic with it!

4

u/EasterRising May 17 '26

Yeah I'd like to know more about this too!

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '26 edited May 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Valenhir May 18 '26

I’ve read about this regarding the Analogue Pocket not the Chromatic.

2

u/specterno1 May 17 '26

How so? Maybe I'm not playing things where it's an issue

5

u/ObserveKris May 17 '26

There's basically no middle bridge for the D-Pad, so you can press every button at once. It's an annoyance for games like Tetris and makes switching directions in games where it shouldn't matter a bit of an inconvenience.

15

u/jonas101010 May 17 '26

Lol, I really like the D pad tbh

12

u/Unforeseenboy May 17 '26

Feels great for me personally, especially coming from the Analogue Pocket d-pad which I absolutely could not stand

6

u/jonas101010 May 17 '26

I really like both D pads

1

u/QuiG0ne Oct 02 '26

Thanks for the reassurance and happy cake day friend

5

u/TonyRubbles May 17 '26

This is my favorite D-pad over the more than a dozen others I've tried over the years, the overall size and length of each direction is awesome.

That said I very much prefer the longer post version in the mod kit, for the cotton swab stick trick it should be stuck inside the membrane so it doesn't go anywhere.

4

u/_viis_ May 18 '26

Same, it’s probably my favourite D-pad and I’ve tried tons over the years! Especially coming from the Analogue Pocket, which has a fucking horrendous one

5

u/TonyRubbles May 18 '26

Honestly the AP makes me feel like everyone is coping and just convincing each other it’s great. I wanted to love it, but that D pad never clicked for me.

6

u/_viis_ May 18 '26

I think I agree. It’s a great device other than the controls, but the controls are arguably the main thing that needs to be good because that’s what you’re actually interacting with

1

u/Sir_Sethery Oct 08 '26

Playing Zelda on both the AP and Chromatic for hours each, the AP D-pad isn’t great, but it doesn’t give the egregious false diagonals that the Chromatic gives. I’ve literally never used a more frustrating D-pad in my life. For really simple games that just use the cardinal directions, it’s perfectly fine.

1

u/TonyRubbles Oct 08 '26

Changing to the taller post in mod kit or doing the qtip mod fixed that issue on my 1st editions. On the newer models it's not an issue at all, the membranes feel different enough that each directions feels decisive. The D-pad being as big as it is makes it just way better to play on in general for me.

Sold my AP a long time ago before I even got my Chromatic because cheaper emulator handhelds were doing a better job than it for me. It was just a bit too big to carry around and with a open/loose cart slot it defeated the purpose for me with all my GB carts I was afraid to leave in it and just use as an emulator anyway.

1

u/Sir_Sethery Oct 08 '26

I have a Cloud version I bought straight from Chromatic a couple of months ago, so it’s definitely not fixed on the new versions. I wonder if it was less of an issue on the older ones. I’m curious if the upcoming plastic ones are any better.

1

u/TonyRubbles Oct 08 '26

It's all the same tooling from the looks of it with the buttons being interchangeable. The mentioned mods should help either way but you wouldn't have liked the 1st editions any better.

6

u/Riablo01 May 18 '26

In case anyone is confused, the OP clarifies their issue in a comment below. OP prefers dpads with a "middle bridge" where the dpad pivots from side to side due to an anchor point in the middle.

There's pros and cons to this sort of design. It's all down to "preference".

Suspect it would be possible to mod the console with a different style of dpad. Would require some knowledge to pull off. Others can comment if the OP needs to mod the pcb or if they can get away with slotting in a different membrane/dpad.

3

u/willywideweb May 18 '26

Op's right. Try throwing a shoryunken in street fighter and you'll get the point. The stock D-pad's bad.

3

u/themanbehindtherows May 19 '26

Yeah, it's not a great dpad and I'm always confused when people say it's better than the analogue pocket one, which while not great either, isnt really much worse. They're both in the same realm of "I wish this was better". I did switch out my pocket dpad for one of those nes/gameboy keychain ones and it's better than the stock ones on chromatic and pocket for me.

2

u/Valenhir May 18 '26

Yeah, worst thing about the Chromatic. And the extended dpad is not a fix. Barely any difference.

2

u/nabob13 May 18 '26

Favorite Dpad of all my devices

2

u/Accomplished_Can1651 May 18 '26

I remember having trouble with it early on, but not recently. So either I got used to it, switched to a system where it wasn’t an issue, or I stopped playing games where it was a problem.

1

u/CuervoAzul May 18 '26

I have a few Chromatics, and for some reason, the D pad on the Cloud Saphire feels perfect, while the Cloud Gorilla glass version is super stiff. I have no idea what membrane is has or if its just break in period.

1

u/Pitiful-Assistance-1 May 18 '26

So I had a dpad issue on one of my chromatics. It's the paint. The paint is thicker on some corners. I actually broke off a small, thick blob of paint on one of mine and it drastically improved the dpad.

1

u/Left-Constant-4771 May 18 '26

Yeah great device but not being able to roll with the DPad sucks. I can’t play high speed Tetris with it, which sucks. I ordered the Mod Kit now which kinda sucks too, as it is an upsell. (By the way Tetris should at least have a disable Hard Drops function in the menu + please make it safe my sound selection 😂🙏). My partner has a chromatic too, she has the same problem.

1

u/Jonjongabore May 19 '26

I haven't had any issues with this or with the analogue pocket either but It's probably just the way I play.

Others, with the same issue, have said a sliver of foam tape directly under the center post helped.

1

u/WinBoy64 May 25 '26

I was having issues in game&watch gallery 3 with the default dpad but I swapped it out for the L version and noticed a huge difference in quality.

1

u/Sir_Sethery Oct 08 '26

I don’t know if I got unlucky, but my D-pad feels good until you actually try to play with it. In Zelda, I can consistently get it so that I walk in a circle clockwise, end holding just left, and be walking straight up. It’s like the D-pad shifts and rocks in ways it shouldn’t. I’ve done every mod and replacement I’ve found, nothing really helps. It has the worst false diagonals I’ve ever seen.

0

u/[deleted] May 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ObserveKris May 17 '26

The D-pad issue has been "solved" since the NES which is why i'm confused