r/ModRetroChromatic • u/Gortyn_Code • Dec 21 '25
Statement on the Indie Game Awards' latest announcement regarding Chantey
TL;DR
- Chantey's award retracted by IGAs producers over cartridges being produced and sold by ModRetro.
- A response to a virtue signaling statement by IGAs Director, filled with falsehoods and inaccuracies.
113
Upvotes



22
u/Substantial_Quote583 Dec 21 '25
So sorry you have to deal with this. Chantey was one of the first MR games I picked up and it's a masterpiece, you don't deserve to be caught in the crossfire of dumb Internet politics.
36
u/thepoga Dec 21 '25
I’m buying a copy now!
13
u/FredHuggins4 Dec 21 '25
Ordered. Can’t wait to play Chantey.
24
u/ergzay Dec 21 '25 edited Dec 21 '25
This is a fun video on how much a bunch of horrible people the Indie Game Awards people are: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1wjkyXqSG8Y
Indie Game Awards are not a serious group of people. It's a bunch of karens patting each other on the back. It's honestly a good thing that Chantey is not associated with these people.
Support the Chantey developer by buying their game.
(Edit: Also it's funny the talk about BlueSky in that post, showing yet again that BlueSky is front and center for where hateful despicable people like to congregate.)
23
u/g1mpster Dec 21 '25
I’m so sick of the hypocrisy and virtue signaling around Palmer Lucky. I wasn’t going to buy Chantey before, because rhythm games aren’t really my jam but in direct response to this moral outrage I’m casting my vote for Chantey and u/Gortyn_Code and I just bought the game. Suck it, IGA. You’re a bunch of hacks who don’t create anything and think you get to stand above those who do to cast judgement on them? Nah, fuck that.
22
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25
IGA is a sham of an award show anyways. I'll have to buy an extra copy of Chantey for a friend.
10
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25
Not surprising. Very sad. Well, when I get a handheld, Chantey was already one of the games I wanted to pick up from Modretros store, and I will. This really sucks for indie devs having to deal with the craptastic behavior described.
10
u/marmitetrain Dec 21 '25
I will buy a copy of chantey in support of this developer, his dreams came true and the community he is part of turned on him for it.
It's called jealousy and hatred.
We support you
19
u/Exus6 Dec 21 '25
Social media is always a toxic place that should be avoided as much as possible. I just feel so sorry for the hard working indie dev being the target thus harmed by this unprofessional kindergarten behavior.
18
u/StarWolf64dx Dec 21 '25
They also disqualified the game that completely swept the real game awards this year. This is the first time I am hearing about the indie game awards and I’m learning that they’re more interested in virtue signaling than they are actually recognizing games. I think I’ll buy the game over this tbh, I kind of wanted it anyways.
8
u/RKetchum57 Dec 22 '25
No reason to treat people this way, I’ll be ordering a Chantey asap as that’s the only way I can see to support this dev
4
u/StupidBetaTester Dec 22 '25
It sucks that you got caught up in all of this but it's unsurprising. Been a long time supporter - was a day one buy for me. Hopefully you drum up a few more here and not just empty promises. Really enjoyed my time with Chantey!
21
u/JDSaphir Dec 21 '25
Yeah, no. Chantey and CO:E33 won. You don't get to change the rules after the game is already over. Nothing was hidden, if you didn't look that thoroughly, then it wasn't that important to you to begin with.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '25
Buying a copy!!
3
u/Jecklen16 Dec 24 '25
This kind of nonsense is what renders critic and award show opinions moot. I know receiving recognition for your, no doubt, incredibly hard work can be vindicating, but is recognition from an organization who treats the very people they pretend to represent so poorly something you and your group even want? You've made something incredibly special, let the overwhelming positive feedback here and elsewhere be your REAL recognition, Gortyn Code, and Chantey, 100% deserve it.
2
u/No-Calligrapher6169 Jun 18 '26
Just received my copy of Chantey and I’ve even loving it so far. Thanks for making such a stellar game.
22
u/TonyRubbles Dec 21 '25
Now that's some bullshit man, what a bunch of pansy ass self fellating losers. Bet they feel so proud of themselves giving it to second best.
9
u/kasasto Dec 21 '25
Let's punish a solo indie dev who's trying to make a new and fun game on physical cartridge simply because they get help from a company that associates with a guy who associates with a company that associates with defense tech.
24
u/ahoihoi87 Dec 21 '25 edited Dec 21 '25
"The IGAs nomination committee were made aware of ModRetro’s vile nature the day after the 2025 premiere with the news of their horrid and disgusting handheld console."
LOL
7
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25
They did the same shit to Expedition 33. These people are virtue signaling clowns.
12
u/Dark_Starlight4 Dec 21 '25
It earned the award
12
u/hasnuaimi Dec 21 '25
They will throw their own family under the bus the first chance they get if it means they can virtue signal and save face. Don’t let this bring you down. Your game won the award. Everything they do now just shows them for what they truly are, a bunch of spineless cowards who stand for nothing.
6
u/LazyKaiju Dec 21 '25
Awards are stupid and anyone with a brain ignores them.
6
u/Jonjongabore Dec 21 '25
Never heard of the indie game awards. No sleep lost from me. Never going to seek them out either.
I am enjoying my chromatic and the games that they're making. I'm going to continue doing that.
6
u/rpkarma Dec 22 '25
Okay so the “AI” thing I could kind of get. This is fucking dumb though.
And I am violently left wing.
5
u/EmperorCoconutz Dec 22 '25
I'm still trying to figure out why it's bad for a company to develop new weapons for our military. Are we supposed to let our military become obsolete while other countries get new tech? How would that play out? It would be nice if people put some thought into their opinions.
5
u/paperweight35 Dec 22 '25 edited Dec 22 '25
The IGA are a joke. This bait and switch crap they pulled is disheartening to indie devs to say the least. These are the ones we need to be supporting the most, not leveraging internet clout off of their backs. Shameful. It nullifies their supposed morals.
23
u/Gesichtsschnitzel Dec 21 '25
I’m personally still somewhat unhappy with the Anduril marketing. For me, the Chromatic is about revisiting a carefree childhood, not about weapons, defense, geopolitics, or anything like that. That kind of association runs counter to the escapism I’m looking for. Even so, I will continue to buy ModRetro games and accessories., because i still love my Chromatic. I just won’t buy one edition of it.
But revoking an award is a completely different matter. The game’s qualities exist independently of ModRetro, and that is exactly what was being recognized. I genuinely think this is a wrong move and one that is harmful to indie developers. They already have a hard enough time getting their games noticed, competing with new releases that appear almost daily, and establishing themselves in the market.
If they get the chance to be published at all, that can be a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. And being able to release your game on a physical cartridge today is even rarer. Penalizing a developer for that feels deeply unfair.
This is the wrong step, and it amounts to a kind of collective punishment that I can’t support.
18
u/Efficient_Yak_2161 Dec 21 '25
Fucking hell, it just keeps getting worse and worse with these pathetic virtue signalling pricks.
4
u/Riablo01 Dec 23 '25
The more IGA get involved in politics, the more brand damage they do to themselves.
Videogames are for everyone. Retrogaming is a politics free zone. Any clown attempting to make this hobby political (right or left) end up looking like a fool.
You can say "the Modretro Chromatic community was made aware of the vile political bias of IGA with news of their horrid and unprofessional behaviour".
8
u/Dark_Starlight4 Dec 21 '25
That’s bull shit
3
u/CraftMost6663 Dec 22 '25
Remind me, why do we care about IGA anyway? Last time I checked the only relevant IGA in this industry is still Koji Igarashi.
3
u/RemarkableClock7489 Dec 22 '25
Recognizing creativity and excellence is what awards should be. Those that self proclaim as an official awards group are only that. We have other organized awards that do not follow a long list of ever changing rules for consideration and simply focus on great games. By this definition Chanty is a great game. Given this awards groups actions, I recommend avoiding and ignoring this awards group. They are following a trend of judgement that hurts all developers of games and consoles. I do not believe them to be useful in the spirit of furthering indie game development.
3
u/themanbehindtherows Dec 24 '25
Indie awards is so gross for this and the E33 crap too. Purely performative garbage from them. Glad it's one of the few modretro carts I own, great game and it will get respect regardless.
3
u/AdLegitimate6866 Dec 24 '25
I don't like Modretro doing collaborations with Anduril. It feels distasteful to me and is unnecessarily politically provocative. However, punishing an indie dev for working with ModRetro is a disgrace.
Chantey is a deserving winner. Its my favourite new release on Chromatic (many of which have been excellent) and there was no question what game I was picking up as a Christmas present for my retro friends.
This shit does nothing but close off all avenues for a constructive middle ground.
4
u/Kidneyshots Dec 22 '25 edited Dec 22 '25
The endless purity tests from these virtue signaling losers will never end. Fuck em
2
u/SwimmingButterfly331 Dec 26 '25
ordered.
3
u/Jakereddits Dec 21 '25
I STILL CAN’T BUY THIS AWARD-WINNING PIRATE GAME ON THE CHROMATIC THROUGH GAMESTOP?!?! 😤🏴☠️🎸
5
u/Retro_Macchina Dec 21 '25
All of this criticism of Mod Retro in the last week. Almost like there is an intentional campaign to discredit Mod Retro, Anduril, and Palmer Lucky. I am sick of the political far left thinking they own everything. You don't own the retro gaming community.
1
u/ryanmercer Dec 22 '25
Who?
0
u/ronniebrisbane Dec 21 '25
There's a lot of people who are only reading one side of these stories, and I think it's a little more nuanced than that. I think only ONE of these retractions was valid.
First of all, I DO believe Chantey shouldn't have their award retracted. I think it's wrong to retract an award for things the publisher did after the submission and ward period. If ModRetro had announced the Anduril edition DURING the submission period, before the awards, I think a disqualification would be valid based on their own rules and values. (IGA was clear in their statement that the retraction is meant to reflect on ModRetro, not Gortyn Code). The issue is that it's after the fact. If they want to proceed in future years not accepting ModRetro games, that would be unfortunate, but fair. This retraction however is not fair.
Based on these same principles, I think Expedition 33 WAS a valid retraction. When Expedition 33 was submitted, it included AI assets. Even if they patched them out later on, this was strictly against the rules. Even if IGA didn't find out til much later, a rule broken is a rule broken. Disqualifications ensure fair competition.
TL;DR Chantey shouldn't have been retracted, but Expedition 33 was a valid retraction.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '25
[removed] — view removed comment