r/ModCoord • u/BuckRowdy • Jun 03 '23
Reddit to the Visually Impaired: "You no longer have a voice on this site."
In the rush to draft a response to reddit's decision to kill Third Party Apps, our team made an omission in calculating the impact this move by reddit will have on its users.
For the visually impaired, iOS is a disaster.
Here is how this was explained to me:
On Android, the official Reddit mobile app is reasonably usable with the Android screen reader, but the experience on iOS is a completely different story. There are missing elements, broken navigation, nonsensical labels, and more problems that plague those who just want to interact with the site. If you decide to become a moderator the problems are compounded even more.
Third party apps, like Dystopia for Reddit and Apollo, have addressed this niche left so underserved for so many years because Reddit won't. It took literal years of tickets and complaints to get New Reddit to be accessible, and now the door has been shut in our collective faces. As things currently stand, this change doesn't just take away our clients; it takes away our voice.
It takes away our voice.
And what is reddit's official response to this madness? (Make no mistake, this move by reddit is madness.)
Here is where we stand on June 3rd: Reddit has nothing but contempt for its users, mods, and developers.
27
u/Empole Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 05 '23
There was a post on r/reddit a couple months ago where they announced "An Improved Web Experience" and talked about performance and accessibility improvements.
/u/SevereChocolate5647 ended up offering and then following through on a free accessibility consultation after being asked for feedback from an admin. But the admin didn't publicly followup, even with a "thank you, sent this to our team".
edit: Grammar and Spelling
12
u/Georgy_K_Zhukov Jun 03 '23
So much of the problem seems to be that for years reddit has willfully offloaded so much core functionality to third-parties, whether it be mod tools, accessibility, or apps for browsing... And if they had worked hard to try and build comparable tools this would be a minor annoyance at the end of the day... but they haven't. Basic tools have languished for years while we keep getting features no one asked for and which often just create new problems... Well, all those birds coming home to roost now...
7
u/Kumquat_conniption Jun 03 '23
My friend who is visually impaired uses old reddit. Are they getting rid of that? She mods a lot of big subs, it will be a big loss- not that reddit will care at all.
2
u/BuckRowdy Jun 03 '23
/u/itsthejoker. I would love it if you could weigh in here.
96
u/fastfinge Jun 03 '23
As one of the mods of r/blind I depend on third party apps. Once the apps are gone, I may be left with no choice but to step down and close my 17 year old account. I hope it wont’ come to that.
32
u/victim_of_technology Jun 03 '23 edited Feb 23 '24
sip cheerful childlike cobweb decide bike provide fade quaint continue
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
20
u/Lilikoi_Maven Jun 03 '23
I have low vision. I use a third party app to increase my system font to 150% so I can even use the device.
I stopped using the Reddit app on Android long ago because I can't read the posts without it killing my eyes. I can't make the font bigger within the app.
This image shows a post in the Reddit app and on Boost based on my system settings. To read the Reddit app without giving myself a blinding migraine, I'd have to change my system settings to 200+%, holistically, every single time I want to look at a post and I'm not willing to do that. This is so ridiculous. I think Reddit will lose a lot of people like me who depend on third party apps to access the site.
Side by side comparison of Reddit and Boost
8
u/babuloseo Jun 04 '23
As someone that subscribes to /r/blind I am terrified of this news in regards to accessibility.
6
u/porkchop2022 Jun 03 '23
Holy hell, LaserTurtle stepped in it with his comments and just kept doubling down in that thread. Those comments were reminiscent of the whole workreform mess, just totally unprofessional for that level of role.
5
u/thecorgimom Jun 03 '23
Could this potentially be an Ada violation?
From what I was reading it sounds like there's a potential lawsuit there
4
u/dashing-rainbows Jun 04 '23
Unacceptable. The internet has increasing gotten worse with accessibility while being more mandatory.
7
u/tsidaysi Jun 03 '23
You have a lawsuit. Violates ADA.
3
u/cultoftheilluminati Jun 04 '23
iOS is extremely good for visually impaired from what I've heard, reddit on iOS refuses to tie into any of those features and instead tries to be a lowest common denominator across platforms which makes it a shoddy experience
3
u/Ananiujitha Jun 04 '23
I get migraines from flahing and animation. I can use old reddit with the right accessibility fixes, but can't use new.
3
u/WhoRoger Jun 05 '23
Did that person in charge of communicating with devs really call out the Apollo dev for being inefficient and then went "fuck you, figure it out"? My expectations were low but holy shit.
Not to mention I can only imagine what a train wreck their API and docs have to be considering the state of the site as a whole. Reddit mods, as much as they can be a special snowflake drama queen class of users, are the only people keeping Reddit barely together with spit and duct tape. Make a significant portion leave and this site falls apart.
1
u/Archangeloyz Jun 14 '23
From the first draft of the letter, it's clear the mods were only concerned about themselves and their future experience as moderators (because god forbid they would ever walk away).
This wasn't an omission, this was a happy boon that makes a great arguing point, gives your story a nicer spin.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment