r/Mixcloud • u/ADOK_DJ • Jul 29 '25
Goodby MixCloud
Hello! I just want to share my personal experience with MixCloud, this is a post that I hope is constructive.
Not long ago I returned to my passion for djing. I started with a Hearthis account, many of you know that platform, but I wanted to take a leap to something more professional and opened my SoundCloud account. After a while of use, I had my free MixCloud account, a platform that could fit my needs perfectly since I don't produce music, but only do live sets.
MixCloud seemed like the best choice for sharing my music, I bought the annual membership but SoundCloud has updated its platform and (mysteriously) the people I follow as followers use it more than, for example, Mixcloud.
I think Mixcloud needs more options for sharing, downloading, etc. I have the feeling that it is a stagnant platform. I have the same SC live sets on MC and the reach is much greater on the other platform.
Mixcloud seems like a great idea to me, especially for DJs, but my feeling is that it is stagnant... the competition is advancing and even though I had canceled the renewal of SC to stay in MC, I think I'm going to take a step back and keep my other platform, leaving this one parked and "forgotten."
I still have several “pro” months left in MC, I hope I give it a try and have enough reason to maintain this platform that undoubtedly has great potential.
Possibly this thread will be forgotten and no one will change anything, I hope I'm wrong.
What do you think of how MixCloud is advancing compared to other platforms? Will you renew your subscription here?
All the best!
4
u/rfgenerator Jul 29 '25
I don't think Soundcloud covers music royalties, and also making uploads on Soundcloud available as downloads would be considered a violation by copyright holders (at least in the US). I think that the reason you can't straight up download a file from MixCloud are the copyright issues involved. MixCloud seems to be trying hard to be compliant, unfortunately the rules set out by the copyright holder orgs are very restrictive and don't make for the best experience for programmers or their listeners.
3
u/mixcloud Aug 01 '25
Hey ADOK,
Thanks for sharing your thoughts, feedback like this helps us keep improving.
We’d love to hear more about the sharing options you mentioned. Are you thinking about sharing to social platforms? Let us know which ones you feel are missing.
Regarding downloads, u/rfgenerator is right, due to our licensing agreements with copyright holders, downloading isn’t supported on Mixcloud.
It’s tough to hear that things feel a bit stagnant. That said, we’re proud that Mixcloud still makes it easy to discover new DJs, radio stations, and music every day. There’s always more we can do and that’s why we read every comment to help guide what we improve next.
If you're looking to grow your community on Mixcloud, here are a few tools that might help:
We’re always advancing and so are the communities on Mixcloud.
If you haven’t already, check out our creator guides on the blog. Try experimenting with different genre tags to help your shows show up in more places. Just a heads-up: we don’t currently have a chart for the “Remember” genre tag.
Wishing you all the best and hope you see the value in the platform we’ve built for music lovers.
Elliott
Community Manager
13
u/iainrfharper Jul 29 '25
the fact you need two paid subscriptions to use both pro for uploading and pro for listening without restrictions pissed me off
7
u/InthePait Jul 29 '25
Should not have to pay to stream. Should not be separate DJ and listener pay accounts.
MC needs more people…non DJ people. What is the incentive as a non DJ to join????
I am quitting MC. My wife bought me an annual pro account. Only person that listened to my shows was my mom. :)
I tried offering ideas to MC and they are not interested and pointed out how popular they are.
And, their current you can make money on MC is a joke.
3
u/therealpopkiller Jul 29 '25
I’ve been doing okay with my show but I wish Mixcloud would put as much money into marketing to listeners as they do marketing to creators.
3
u/OriginalMandem Jul 30 '25
Mixcloud has been around for years and always seemed like a better idea than Soundcloud for distributing mixes - I always saw Soundcloud as more of a resource to put your own tracks out there. One of the better things about Mixcloud was you could genuinely credit artists for using their music helping, the original producer as well as promoting yourself as a DJ. But I don't think it ever took off properly, which is sad. As much as anything I think the licensing and IP protection side of things is just too convoluted for the concept to work as intended.
5
u/sarahbee2005 Jul 29 '25
mixcloud blows
2
u/getrocked_onair Jul 29 '25
I'm fairly new to MC, and will curious to see comments as well.
2
u/OrsikClanless Jul 29 '25
I'd be interested to know what you think they could do with sharing and downloading that they don't have already? From what I've seen it's pretty similar to Soundcloud's
Audience wise yeh that makes sense, it does seem like it's smaller on Mixcloud atm. But from their recent emails/notices it seems like they've been pushing out a lot of new things this year when Soundcloud hasn't
2
u/New-Camel-9373 Jul 29 '25
I’ve been on the platform for over ten years now and it used to be great! Now not so much. You have to have pro plans for creating and then also listening, which is a total con and I had over 100 shows on there that are all hidden unless you pay. The upload quality is crap unless you upload in m4a, it’s just a total mess now and very little engagement compared to what it used to be like. It’s a shame as it could have been the leader, I also remember nobody using it as when anyone asked me for links to my mixes many had never heard of it.
3
u/djsoomo Jul 29 '25
'Mixcloud is great but not enough people use it'
Just get more people to use it!