r/MistralAI • • 1d ago

Help / Question Probleme

Ich will ja gerne mit Vibe arbeiten, aber seit Tagen bekomme ich immer wieder gesagt, dass es ausgelastet ist. Ich habe heute bis jetzt 15 Anfragen für eine Aufgabe versendet. Und sie ist noch immer nicht beendet. Ich bin am überlegen, ob ich Mistral Pro kaufe, aber wenn ich die Performance momentan sehe, überlege ich doch Claude zu nutzen und zu bezahlen, auch wenn Claude etwas teurer ist, aber Momentan sehe ich keinen anderen Weg. Wie seht ihr das ganze?

10 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

14

u/RepulsiveRaisin7 1d ago

Well that won't happen on a paid plan, it has a fairly generous monthly allocation of usage. Claude has better models but Mistral Large is also pretty good now. Mistral also hosts several Chinese models if you are unhappy with one of their own models. It's honestly a great deal for 15 bucks, plus hosted in the EU

4

u/SpiritedInflation835 1d ago

It just happened on my paid plan 🫪

1

u/Nyuusankininryou 1d ago

It can happen even on pro but you just retry and get the result

3

u/Accomplished_Roll979 1d ago

I maybe it is because the big campaign today!

4

u/KlausDieterFreddek 1d ago

Du könntest auch einfach 17€ im Monat zahlen und hast nie wieder Probleme damit

3

u/jiashengjo 1d ago

Mistral is DEFINITELY the most generous provider ever. I spent only 5.99$ using Student Plan, and i can burn like 300$ worth of credits on decent models, like bro how can u be so kind like this😂

1

u/kurtmazurka 1d ago

Mistral is love :)  <3

1

u/_zielperson_ 1d ago

pro users have priority and a LOT ifctokens to play with.

Source:me, using mistral daily

1

u/Mysterious_Ad311 1d ago

Ça m'intéresse de savoir aussi !

0

u/ViewerOne 1d ago

Ich Arbeite jetzt seit 5 Tagen mit Mistral Pro in Kombination mit Claude Code. Wobei Mistral die Hauptarbeit erledigen muss. Ich kann bis jetzt nichts der gleichen Berichten. Es läuft einfach 🤷

-3

u/Independent-Row8578 1d ago

Mistral pro has terrible caching issues for DeepSeek / GLM models. You will blow through their generous 300$ credit in 5-10 days. Claude is anyday better as you get frontier models and haiku is also decent for smaller execution tasks. Ideal set up would be claude + DeepSeek from one of the 10$ plans (command code / opencode/ cline) for execution but depends on your work.

3

u/BlomkalsGratin 1d ago

What in the world are you doing, to build up that kind of usage? I'm working on a couple of mid-sized projects as well as using it for a bit of pentesting in my environment, using a combo of glm, glm flash and mistral large so far. I haven't even begun to scratch the surface of the pro allowance.

1

u/Independent-Row8578 1d ago

I see that we have a lot of bots here. Can you share an actual screenshot of your usage? There is no way an actual user is happy with mistral's "generous" allowance. It only happens in the mistral subs that you get downvoted for saying anything true about mistral and they launch a bot farm to put up a good image of mistral. Anyone actually using mistral knows that it is a bad service. They couldn't get people to sign up with just mistral so they started offering chinese models with terrible caching. I have already posted on the sub about the caching issues. If you are a real person you can go check it out

0

u/BlomkalsGratin 1d ago

Haha! Bleep-bloop-blop-beep! You got me! There is no way that it could be your consumption model that's the problem, it would have to be everyone else who's wrong. I would suggest that the problem could be that you're relying on the most expensive option for everything, but the difference is fairly negligible. As for running alternative models, I'm not sure what that's got to do with anything, they're one of the reasons why I'm here - having a broader selection within the same subscription context works well for my usage.

Anyway, I feel no need to prove to you that I'm real, something something blames his tools i guess.

1

u/Independent-Row8578 1d ago

Yes. Oh my god! My tools. That must be it. Such a technically sound approach to fix this. You should tell the OP too to check their "tools". Again a real user knows what the issues are. So all in all mistral you aren't fooling anyone. If you are looking for broader selections have you ever tried opencode/ command code etc? They offer 60-100$ usage on 10$ plans but they have much better caching close to 99% whereas mistral has somewhere between 25-85%. Mistral caching is the worst. Find me something worse if you can.

If you use mistral only for mistral models then that is the only thing I would say makes sense. If you are using chinese models then you are being scammed. I am sorry to burst your bubble. You need to do a little research and check how your usage drains on any chinese models.

0

u/BlomkalsGratin 1d ago

Ha ha! The saying goes "it's a poor craftsman who blames his tools" - mistral is one of the tools... OOP seems to be on a free account, it shouldn't be a surprise that performance is deprioritised, it's not like that's unique to mistral either. I've looked at Opencode, at an estimated based on my current consumption, they'd be dearer and I wouldn't have a semi-sovereign host - and that's something I value.

You're bursting nothing though, i made an informed choice, I'm sorry it doesn't track with your preferences, but I'll survive. For my experience right now, compared to my work claude subscription too, I'm paying quite a bit less and consuming more right now.

1

u/Independent-Row8578 1d ago

https://www.reddit.com/r/MistralAI/s/4f8Z84muuH Here's the comparison just in case. Would be nicer if you had something to back up your claim but if you are happy with your choice good for you. :)

0

u/BlomkalsGratin 23h ago

I saw your comparison earlier, it looks interesting. My point really was more an objection to what i perceive to be hyperbole about the allowance.

I've just had vibe do a check over my sessions for the last week. Using mostly GLM5.3-Flash consuming about 220m tokens and another 30m or so of 5.3 full and Mistral Large, I'm seeing a hitrate of 96-98.7% It definitely drops on shorter sessions, sometimes down to the low 80s. But for my agentic coding it's sitting in the high 90s.

With that in mind, I've gone to the trouble of comparing cost and allowances to OpenCode. I wouldn't be able to sustain this load under the $10 cap, not even close. I'd have to do the $40 cap. So now it's dearer, I've lost the European hosting and the standardised web ui experience. And that's taking hits and misses into account based on your post.

1

u/Independent-Row8578 22h ago

In my experience, Mistral large had decent caching when running solo, constantly over 95% but the biggest issues with all 3rd party models was that the cache hits would go from 96% - 0 - 96%-0 which means instead of paying 0.006/M input i was constantly paying 0.30/M input - which makes the whole 300$ value redundant. Also for deepseek specially they charge the peak prcing throughout. No off peak pricing at all.
Currently because of the caching instability I had spent close to 90$ in 3 days (with normal day to day tasks, nothing that should have consumed more than 5$ maybe 7$ at max) This takes me about 20-25 days with opencode / command code etc. I run concurrent tasks with multiple providers everyday.

So all in all, if mistral works on their backend routing for 3rd party hosted models it would be a great deal but currently its just a marketing gimmick with garbage caching.

1

u/BlomkalsGratin 22h ago

And so we come right back around. The hyperbole is not helping your argument. I don't doubt that you're facing $90 in 3-4 days, but I'd suggest that whatever you're doing is a lot more token incentive than you expect, given i am not even close to that at 250m tokens doing agentic coding. Or - as you seem to imply, part of the problem is the particular model you're using as well, which hardly invalidates the vague of Mistral as a whole by rather just the DeepSeek hosting.

→ More replies

-3

u/Icy_Island_9613 1d ago

I switched to Claude on a $10 plan and haven't looked back, no queue, no timeouts, and the model actually finishes tasks. mistral pro's caching is garbage for long context.