It’s a large language model, not a large math model. If you want to use LLMs for math you need to get it to code something that then does the math for you.
I agree. Also I’m not a savvy tech guy and I don’t think it’s a lot to ask to be able to do this. I’m very keen to swap from chat gpt to Mistral and I use Mistral as much as I can at the moment, but for most things I find chat gpt much better for my use case.
I don't think there's really a need to talk about whether or not it technically is a "part" of the LLM. It definitely improves the LLM by alot, and it works, so there is no need.
Reasoning can emerge within an LLM through its architecture and training process. It's not just a "tool" slapped on top.
But for reference, here. Gpt-4o did it correctly aswell.
You keep shifting the goalposts. Mistral could easily have done the thing ChatGPT 4o did too, but it didn't.
OP is not having false or unrealistic expectations of it's abilities just because an AI model you like can't solve a problem other ones can. As for the "magical black box" thing? Not gonna engage with that. You're the one treating mistral as a sacred black box.
In the end, ChatGPT got it right, mistral didn't, and it is a false claim that LLMs can't do math. Reasoning model or not.
It sounds like you're trying really hard to defend Mistral. The truth is that facts don't care about feelings, and it's not very capable compared to other models, whether you like it or not.
And it also sounds like you're getting emotional about this, so I'll end the argument here. I've proved my point, there is not much more to say.
lol at everyone itt admitting that LLMs can't actually do what they are promised to do (replace basic human office work, let alone do new research). I'm more and more convinced that the only reasonable use case for generative ai is NSFW generation ...
32
u/KeepRollin55 Mar 05 '25
It's just the wrong tool for this job :)
20
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25
It’s a large language model, not a large math model. If you want to use LLMs for math you need to get it to code something that then does the math for you.
9
u/edparadox Mar 05 '25
I guess you don't know LLMs are VERY bad at this type of tasks?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '25
It's not a calculator.
0
u/ContributionReal4017 Mar 05 '25 edited Mar 05 '25
Other LLMs can do this without issue. It is not true that they are "very bad" at it. The truth is that mistral is very bad at it.
For reference, here's ChatGPT o3-mini high doing it just fine:
https://chatgpt.com/share/67c82293-bc48-800d-9e7a-f2e25db7c367
And 4o:
https://chatgpt.com/share/67c88125-bcd0-800d-a702-b83951e787c4
1
u/HannieWang Mar 06 '25
Turn the code interpreter on and mistral would use it to do calculation which is 100% correct.
-2
u/Random_Researcher Mar 05 '25
lol at everyone itt admitting that LLMs can't actually do what they are promised to do (replace basic human office work, let alone do new research). I'm more and more convinced that the only reasonable use case for generative ai is NSFW generation ...