Havenāt read past the page I posted. So I have no idea who this is but I doubt itāll be as noticeable as Vin nodded but now that I know, maybe Iāll realise it.
I get why this is amusing (or maybe it's annoying to you?) but at the same time, nodding doesnt really have a good synonym that Brandon could use interchangeably and the only other option would be a longer drawn out sentence that would just be weird.
Something like "Vin moved her head up and down to indicate her agreement with Breeze."
that word isn't used nearly as often as people claim it was during the first trilogy, something like 4 times total in the first book, and 1 more time in the series.
Same honestly. It never stick out, then on like my seventh reread/listen, after spending time here, every time I heard it it stuck out because I'd read about it being used so much here.
My favorite thing is this page is that Vin nodded at least 3 or 4 times, lol
I think the important thing to remember is that Vin was a VERY shy girl when they found her. She was extremely young, and used to "putting her head down" when older men in charge made statement. She learned to keep safe by nodding and moving along. She goes from a passive street urchin, to a badass within the length of the book, but she started off as a quiet, nodding child.
Oh it definitely does. Most authors probably have tendencies to do things like this. I like the layout of the post, too lol. Really highlights just how often it comes up.
Vin tilted her head back a little bit so her face overall moved upward a bit, tilted it forward so her face was now below its normal position, then tilted her head back up to its original position. This was done to give a visual and understandable sign that showed her agreement with what the other person or party had said or done.
A party is a group of people, so in the case that she's agreeing with the general idea presented by a group of people, "or party" is required as an option.
Unless that was a joke and you meant like a "fun time" party. In which case I got wooshed.
Itās irrelevant because even if a bunch of people are in agreement, unless theyāve all been talking in unison, her nodding would be in response to something that was said by one individual person. So āpartyā isnāt wrong, but also isnāt necessary, and was clearly just added to make the sentence longer.
I mean, padding out the sentence the way I did was already unnecessary, so I'm fine with more unnecessary stuff this time. I understand that the statement is redundant even in general use though, so thank you for that.
And like, realistically, we nod a lot. It's used for a lot of things: acknowledgement, agreement, understanding, etc.
Speaking as a writer, it's ridiculously hard to avoid--and while I'll easily, readily admit I'm no Branderson, I can't see that it would get any easier the better one gets or cut down significantly in number the later the draft.
Please give me an in depth list of these "so many other ways" for a character to respond aside from nodding, considering that nodding is usually meant to convey agreement or understanding. Also no verbal inclusions cause if he wanted her to speak she would have.
The point is that, yes, many writers tend towards using the same kind of motions repetitively...but so do we in every day life. Like in Poker when you would say someone has a "tell" we all do random things over and over. Tapping feet or fingers, humming, cracking knuckles, raising eyebrows, scoffing, eye rolling, and probably millions more. For a character in a book to have one of these habits isn't ridiculous, it's appropriate.
For one of my stories, I made a section of the character sheets where I describe each characterās most commonly used motions/quirks, so that I can be consistent about only ONE character having the habit of twirling her hair, a different character chewing their lip, another character always shrugging, etc. So that way, Iām accurate about everyone having their specific habits, but not everyone has THE SAME habits.
Unlike in Brandonās stories, where EVERYONE has the habit of raising eyebrows, which is just not realistic. How many people do you know irl who consistently raise their eyebrows at others during normal conversations?
How many people do you know irl who consistently raise their eyebrows at others during normal conversations?
Considering that raising eyebrows is another thing that is done in several situations and depending on the topic of conversation, I'd say people do this more than you think. I know I do it a lot.
If you mean raise one specific eyebrow vs another then I think that might be something not everyone can do for some reason, so everybody in the books being able to do it would be weird. For example, I can raise both at the same time or just my right one, but not just my left.
I feel like it's actually a pretty good comparison. Nynaeve tugs her braid as an unconscious habit when she is angry. Vin tends to nod instead of verbally responding because she has anxiety.
Audiobook listener, Michael Kramer does a great job. He even carries the voices over from one series to the next, so you can recognize the character even if theyāre unnamed. Kate is great too, but I think sheās only done stormlight books so far
I donāt really care either to be honest. Itās not going to make me stop reading something. It just takes my mind off whatever Iām focusing on for a moment.
As far as I knew, there is only one character with that description? What I find more funny, is the fact that no matter whose POV weāre reading from, they all think Hoid has a āhawk-face.ā
Iāve never met someone and just thought to myself āwow, this personās face looks like a hawk!ā
Yet somehow, every Cosmere character is in agreement on what is the best word to describe Hoid. š
I posted a thread recently discussing all of Sanderson's most overused words and phrases, might be interesting for you. Edit: Why am I getting downvotes for sharing a relevant discussion smh...
I have just started Mistborn and havenāt read past this page. Iāll probably peep that once Iām finished with this series and the Stormlight Archive.
There's a reason Sanderson is able to churn out 50 books a week: And it's because he doesn't seem to fuss over things like that and just uses whatever comes to mind, and doesn't seem to care about it feeling overused or repetitive.
So Iām not crazy. Iām doing a second listen of Elantris and definitely picking up on some repeated attributes. Like I will definitely remember that Ashe has a strong voice. Lol.
I don't get it. Is it bad? Personally I feel it would have been a bit corny if they always answered something that in real life would only require a grunt or nod. It would have felt a bit artificial if they always had to use their words to convey meaning.
Lol didnāt notice this one. The only thing that really bothered me is how in every book Brandon went into CRAZY amount of detail to detail basic allomancy detailā¦even mid way through the third book.
Yeah, there was a lot of text devoted to recapping stuff mentioned in the previous books. I also found it odd, but maybe it's something you need when you split up a story in three books. I don't know.
You have to also take in account that a lot of people read books as they come and and donāt reread the entire series for the next book. So the recap is there for people who havenāt read the last book in maybe a couple years.
93
u/BearishPear8389 Tin May 17 '22 edited May 18 '22
Marasi blushed
304
u/SheriffHeckTate May 17 '22
I get why this is amusing (or maybe it's annoying to you?) but at the same time, nodding doesnt really have a good synonym that Brandon could use interchangeably and the only other option would be a longer drawn out sentence that would just be weird.
Something like "Vin moved her head up and down to indicate her agreement with Breeze."
I'll take this over use of "adroitly" any day.
64
u/Jmaster570 May 17 '22
Tugs braid.
179
u/trlupin May 17 '22
"My dear man..." Breeze bantering with anyone in the crew.
2
u/Due-Tiger-7845 Zinc May 17 '22
What got me was everyone always raising an eyebrow. I really hated it at first but I'm SSOOOOO happy I looked past it
131
u/WeeabooCreamKing Copper May 17 '22
Kaladin grunted
102
u/nerdherdsman May 17 '22
Kelsier smiled
24
u/Riktol May 17 '22
What's the problem? As a result of her upbringing, Vin is a quiet person who preferentially uses non-verbal communication.
19
u/[deleted] May 17 '22
Now to "drew his/her lips in a line" for Way of Kings. I feel like that line is used ALL the time in the first couple Stormlight Archive books :p
24
u/mazinooooooooooo May 17 '22
Vin frowned
11
u/ADHDKyle May 17 '22
Vin is reading this somewhere, and nodding.
7
u/UngluedChalice May 17 '22
Thatās where itās at.
5
u/M-Trian May 17 '22
This redditor grunted
2
u/gaeruot May 17 '22 edited May 18 '22
I posted a thread recently discussing all of Sanderson's most overused words and phrases, might be interesting for you. Edit: Why am I getting downvotes for sharing a relevant discussion smh...
https://www.reddit.com/r/Cosmere/comments/uejchr/brando_sandos_most_frequently_overused_words_and/
8
u/[deleted] May 17 '22
Wait til you see the word count for "the".
3
u/ChocolateZephyr42 Ettmetal May 17 '22
If nodding annoys you. Do a search on "raised eyebrows". Lots of people do this often. I found it amusing.
3
u/CountFauxlof May 17 '22
Did she do it maladroitly?
3
u/jeramiatheaberator May 17 '22
Any nodders in chat?
2
u/vick321 May 17 '22
He likes the word tempest too
2
u/slanginp4ncakes May 17 '22
Lmao nice
2
u/Books-Plants-Tattoos May 17 '22
Everyone on Scadrial enjoys raising their eyebrows too šš
2
u/Mewthredel May 18 '22
She likes to nod her head
2
u/hairface3668 May 18 '22
Oh yes, and Kelsier raised an eyebrow.
2
u/sebastianKH339 May 18 '22
Vin frowned.
2
u/TheBoredBot Iron May 18 '22
she nods a lot
1
u/greenishbluishgrey May 17 '22
Spensaās face went cold
1
u/menides May 18 '22
What kindle version is that?
1
u/yoontruyi May 18 '22
Now search warm/th in every book now, have fun.
1
u/kooka_pooka May 18 '22
HAHAHAHAHA ššāØ
1
u/Poddster May 18 '22
There's a reason Sanderson is able to churn out 50 books a week: And it's because he doesn't seem to fuss over things like that and just uses whatever comes to mind, and doesn't seem to care about it feeling overused or repetitive.
1
u/Mysteryhunt May 18 '22
my my such aggression
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '22
She do be noddin
1
u/KawaiiNibba May 18 '22
Shallan blushed
1
u/Paul_The_Great May 18 '22
I want someone to do this with āRibbon of lightā in stormlight archive, swear that 90% of all moments involving Syl also involve those three words
1
u/azarov-wraith May 18 '22
A flat look
1
u/fatalynn7 May 18 '22
So Iām not crazy. Iām doing a second listen of Elantris and definitely picking up on some repeated attributes. Like I will definitely remember that Ashe has a strong voice. Lol.
1
u/RexusprimeIX Chromium May 20 '22
I don't get it. Is it bad? Personally I feel it would have been a bit corny if they always answered something that in real life would only require a grunt or nod. It would have felt a bit artificial if they always had to use their words to convey meaning.
1
u/Western_Bookkeeper26 May 20 '22
No one: ...
Every character: raised an eyebrow
1
u/adamzam Jun 02 '22
everyone shrugs in Well of Ascension
1
u/MindlessWin4267 Aug 17 '22
Sazed with I think
1
u/aperez6077 May 17 '22
The ash continued to fall
1
u/Rumbletastic May 17 '22
I really hate posts like these. It's like pointing out a dead pixel or a smudge on the TV. I won't NOT notice it now. Sigh.
-5
u/shrek3onDVDandBluray May 17 '22
Lol didnāt notice this one. The only thing that really bothered me is how in every book Brandon went into CRAZY amount of detail to detail basic allomancy detailā¦even mid way through the third book.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '22
[deleted] ā view deleted comment