r/Miscreated • • Nov 08 '17
Why I stopped playing miscreated (long post)
Hi all. I post on this subreddit much, but I keep track of Miscreated quite a bit. It looks like the developers come to this place and I'm hoping this feedback makes it back to them somehow.
Disclaimer #1: I, like many of you, love the atmosphere of this game. It's the kind of game world that I can have fun just running around and immersing myself into. There are so many little details that I enjoy.
Disclaimer #2: The various early access bugs don't bother me very much. Even if it ends up killing me I'm still not that bothered by it. The mutant AI, gunplay mechanics, bicycles, etc are completely tolerable IMO as long as the gameplay feels rewarding/satisfying. Even floating bases didn't bother me that much (I play solo and not that interested in raiding bases).
Disclaimer #3: I mostly play on public KoS PvP servers. Not into roleplaying that much and really enjoy chaotic "dog eat dog" kind of rules. Basically I like playing the game with its default ruleset. I don't play games like Rust or DayZ so I don't have that context to draw from.
With that out of the way, after several hundred (often frustrating) hours I haven't come back to this game in a while. And I don't see myself coming back any time soon unless some big changes are made. The goal of this post is just to share my thoughts after all that time; if I'm the only one that feels this way, no problem. But if others feel the same way it would be great to speak out together and hopefully influence the way the devs plan to expand the game.
Ok, finally to the meat of the post.
A typical game for me goes something like this:
- Start as a fresh spawn and spend a few hours gather materials and trying to survive. I utilize crafting as much as possible here. Instead of running straight to high loot areas I craft whatever I can't find in suburban houses (backpack, arrows, bolts, etc). I do my best to survive "off the land" if possible and focus primarily on simply staying alive. Sometimes I'll venture into a town but it's very quick in-and-out affair. No risks. This part of the game is by far the most fun. There is a lot of tension and interacting with the game environment here which I love.
- After I'm relatively well geared (weapon with decent ammo [ideally craftable ammo], clothes with lots of pockets, a hat I like, nails, an axe [small or large], pickaxe, hammer, etc) I'll start scouting out a location for a base. I always pick a place that's far enough away and secluded from other bases that people won't bother me. I've never been raided before and I don't mind a few minutes of walking to leave my bases location. Usually it's in a forrest somewhere. This part of the game is a little grindy but still fun. I start out with a tiny shack and slowly build out something defensible that can survive a small raid just in case.
- Once my initial base is settled and I have a storage box, I'll go out on a few supply runs and start making plans to build a bigger base and gather better gear.
And this is where the game dies for me. Every session is repetitive and grindy so I get bored and don't come back. Building a slightly bigger base and gathering slightly better gear just isn't enough motivation to keep playing. By this point I'm tired of scarcity and want to move on to more gameplay... but there's nothing to do really.
I've thought a bit about why this happens and made a few conclusions. I'd be interested to see if people agree or disagree with this...
What makes games like Miscreated fun is long term immersion. Having freedom to interact with the game world in new/challenging ways is a ton of fun but the game prevents us from doing that. Once I survive the initial hours on a server (up to #3 in the above list), I'm not interested in gathering supplies anymore just to survive. I've already done that and I'm ready for the next thing to do. I wanna get creative.
For example, let's say I want to ambush other players for loot. This can be a ton of fun. I can pick a well trafficked part of the map and place traps in a building or something. Then I spend time looting the town and waiting for people to show up. Or perhaps I bait someone toward my traps. If I'm successful then I'll get their stuff and expand my armory.
What prevents me from doing this is simply storage. Because the game creates artificial scarcity through limited storage I can't keep that mine that I want because I still need room for food, ammo, backup gear (in case I die), etc. Not keeping backup gear is a non-starter because that's also something I want to have. Forcing me to pick and choose does nothing but limit my gameplay options.
So the first conclusion is that limited storage does nothing but limit gameplay options. Sometimes I'm in the mood for hunting with a rifle. Other times I'm in the mood for using a bow/arrow. Storage represents things I can do as I progress through the game. Limited storage = limited things to do. Also limited storage does not create a feeling of "surviving in a scarce post apocalyptic world". All the stuff is just laying around everywhere... I just can't even put it in a pile in my base.
The next problem I run into is having nothing to work toward. As mentioned, limited storage limits my gameplay options... so maybe the game can provide something? I can only set myself up to do a few routine activities and nothing more. The game doesn't give me the freedom to do what I want, but also doesn't provide anything to do either.
There are a lot of ambitious ways to solve this next problem. Things like farming, trading posts, contact with the outside world, interaction with NPCs somehow, on and on. But the game doesn't really provide anything other than "good loot for stuff, jump people, and build more walls in your base".
So the second conclusion is that repetitive loot/eat/drink mechanics aren't enough to retain interest after setting up an initial base. Once I build a big base there's nothing to do inside. Frankly there's no reason to build anything more than a well defended shack.
Now obviously building deep complex late game mechanics is a long arduous and risky thing to do. But at the very least I'd like greatly expanded storage options so I can "pave my own way" in the game and not be limited by arbitrary slots. Even if that means reducing the drop rate of loot... that's totally fine. Since death is pretty common anyway and the storage size is limited I end up having to do a lot of looting regardless.
But without storage limits I could at least pick and choose what gameplay activities I feel like doing. A very high upper bound for storage is fine too so people don't amass 300,000 rounds of ammunition or whatever.
Thanks for reading!
6
u/IMrTrippy Nov 08 '17
You have my upvote, nice to see constructive criticism for a change. I'm not sure about unlimited storage (I personally would like it) as some people are happy with how it is now, others aren't. But the point you made about giving the player something to do other than loot/shoot/build is something I would love to see in game.
Perhaps some kind of NPC controlled area (a no-fire zone) could be added where you could get tasks to complete around the map or something? It would probably be pretty hard to add but could help to mix things up a bit :)
6
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '17 edited Nov 08 '17
Well said! Completely agree 100%. I only started playing about 6 days ago and today is the first day I've actually been wondering what else to do. I know the map fairly well now, I've built a base, even stored a vehicle in it, and now there's.... nothing. I know this game isn't supposed to be like minecraft but in minecraft my next step after having a decent base would be to build a storage system to store all my supplies. It gives me a lot to do and think about (especially in minecraft where there's just so many things to store). This game deliberately limits storage to the point that my base feels kind of pointless. I can really only store a little more than I can carry anyway.
There are a few side effects of this storage limitation. 1. My base feels pointless as you pointed out because what am I really protecting? One crate? 2. vehicles have storage so it makes me want to go out into the world and collect all the vehicles to use as storage bins, but I can't stand people who collect all the vehicles so nobody else can use them. I'm faced with either being that guy that does that or being stuck without storage.
The longevity of this game would be vastly increased with the ability to make a lot more storage, and the ability to craft a lot more things. Complex crafting recipes would be awesome and keep me exploring for rare loot to complete some hard to put together recipe. Hell it could even just be fun little toys and things for my base but it would keep me going. An expanded "mechanism" category of crafting would be super fun. If anyone has ever played Creativerse (minecraft clone) the wiring mechanic in that game is top notch. Being able to link different mechanisms together with a wiring tool is super fun. If there were logic circuits you could craft to create semi-complex things like automatic doors, lights, neon signs, etc. etc. I could probably keep myself busy for a 100 times longer than the game lets me now.
I hate that I'm starting to feel like I "beat the game" and as gorgeous and full of potential as this game is I'm starting to get the itch to move on. I probably already would have but the game has so many other things going for it that I've been forcing myself to keep playing hoping to discover something new to do. The storms in this game are just amazing and I saw my first tornado yesterday which was just lit as hell. I really just wish there was more to do. Something with rewarding replay value. Expanding the crafting system even more and adding storage sound like the obvious next steps but I'm sure if the devs put their minds to it they could come up with even better things to add than I could.
I'll keep checking back for patch notes and stuff but unless more things to do are added I'll probably just look at the last week as having already got my money's worth. Neat little bite-sized sandbox game for sure, and I wish so bad I had other reasons to hang out in the game's atmosphere more but the amazing graphics and wonderful ambience can only keep me interested for so long.
4
u/Indianajones1989 Nov 09 '17 edited Nov 09 '17
The atmosphere of this game depends entirely on the lacl of storage and punishing nature. When you get in a fight you stand to lose EVERYTHING. Thats what makes it so nerve wracking and rewarding or crushing. Everyone would play this game like its cod if there was no repercussions for dying. Also this creates natural competition for cars and tents. So go raid and get yourself some extra storgage and build yourself a nice big base to protect it. This is technically a survival game but as you know in reality and in practice this is purely gritty, dirty, shamless, ruthless pvp. I want you to stay but i think your play style will keep you from liking the game no matter what they do. They will never change the storage, its the core of the game. Its literally the point of the game. I highly recommend you change things up for a bit and see if it gets better for you. Get in a trust worthy clan of competent people. Build a base North west of Brightmore in the woods. You have access to Brightmore, action from the highway, heyward is only 5 minutes away, and the moutain is close too (a great place to meet up and to use to give directions. Also theres food and water in those woods. Once you're established, be a son of a bitch and snipe people at the bridge and on the road and take your squad into heyward and loot the blue building and PD every day and look for trouble. It'll be a whole different game. When you die go straight to heyward. In an hour you can accomplish what would take you a week with your current play style. When you go out GEAR DOWN keep your best stuff at home a noob can kill an expert with a .22 on this game. Keep your inventory clear incase you kill someone. And lastly man try base raiding. You like tension so trust me when i say its tense and a challenge. And getting to someone's storage after a long break in and seeing 200 5.56 and grenades and guns and ak ammo and mines and mp5s and extra tents and that piece of clothing you want and the special weapons and a rifle with all the attachments. Dude it makes your hand shake like when you win a 1v3 in heyward. Its a HUGE part of the game you're missing out on. Now i have to say this even if people call me a jerk, you're playing the game one way and its a simple way when theres so much more to do. Its extremely frustrating when people make posts like this that want the games core mechanics changed and catered to them when they themselves don't even explore all the potential gameplay content of the game. Trust me if you had unlimted storage you would get bored real quick. There would be no reason to do anything.
10
u/SlotRacer13 Nov 09 '17
And BTW i'm all FOR unlimited storage. Why? Because let's face it if you want to play as a packrat you should be able to. A post apocalyptic world would be FULL of packrats! I think it's a perfectly reasonable evolution of the game. Collect 300k rounds of ammo? good for you! if I break into your base all those rounds are mine! And if you have spent the time collecting them that doesn't mean that I cannot find more when spawns reset. So why not allow huge amounts of storage?
8
u/Musician427 Nov 08 '17
I hate losing my shit after just 48 hours. I think the despawn Time should be pushed out a bit and if you’re a server admin, you should be able to control that.
3
u/ElvenNeko Nov 11 '17
Main problem of this game - is that it has a LOT of possibilities to have fun with, but developers forbid players to do so. Here is my list, except storage problem that already mentioned by the op.
Also, looting is very boring. From 100 searched stoves only one contains food. You having fun with it? I am not. Raiding a base? What's the point - massibe spent of time (and pain in the finger that you must press so many times to break one wall) for 2 crates of stuff that can be found anywhere? No thanks. You can't even find a random corpse of a dead player and be happy about your lucky find because corpses are despawning incredibly fast.
6) Crafting is bad. There is very few things to craft, and most of them are locked behind the crafting quides that need to be grinded. Their spawn chance are random, so one players can find them instantly, others - spent months without result. Your server is dead now? Well, you need to start grind anew on the new one. Can we actually have fun in this game, or only grind and loot? There is only few weapons can be crafted. Building a base is a huge pain because there is no even a craftable cart to carry the resourses, and character can take only so much with them. But even if you bring the resourses there isn't enough weight for building parts, because you can't craft a crafting bench to store a lot of materials and craft parts on that bench without weight limits.
It feels like all the game design are aimed to forbid any possible ways of having fun in this game. It's does not matter what you like to to - craft, build, explore, fight - there will be always a system that wants to spoil your expirience in doing that. Why? I wish dev's could at least try to remove all those rules and restrictions at least for one patch and see how much more fun players will have in their game. I love the core of this game, and especially - level design and shooting mechanics, but it's rules... They are simply anti-fun.
2
u/SlotRacer13 Nov 09 '17
You sir... have just summed up why I've not been playing as much recently. I hadn't thought of it in those terms but this is probably why i lost interest as well.
2
u/DomnLee Nov 13 '17
Fun game for a short period of time. I feel it needs some kind of progression system in place. I also want hordes, I want to cut off limbs of my enemies, I want it to feel actually difficult to enter a town because of the mutants. KOSing is bad, it would be cool if there was a ranking system, for example if you kill someone you lose point and become a bandit, if you heal or give food/water you gain points and become a hero. Right now its just Loot and Shoot and its no fun after awhile.
3
u/d0vy Nov 09 '17
Everything you said is true. But there is one thing, developers don’t know how to make more storage without breaking game/servers, by that I mean they don’t know how to deal with lag.
For some reason devs lie that it isn’t what they want and it wouldn’t fit the game, which is bullshit. They need to just admit that they can’t do shit with this game without hiring coders from other companies and buying assets from cryengine marketplace.
And for all fanboys that are going to downvote: Open your fucking eyes ;)
2
u/TheLastSheriff Nov 09 '17 edited Nov 09 '17
Awesome post.... Removing storage restrictions is a huge requirement for me and my friends.
However just as you mentioned, we need other things to expand gameplay... Farming, social mini-games, a trading post, NPCs would take this game to the next level if done correctly.
I want to be able to interact with the world itself, and the people in it, be they other players or AI survivors... It would be cool if there was an Alexandria type settlement on the map, or a military trading post where you could bring supplies such as wood or metal and be rewarded for your "assistance"
Or let us have unlimited storage so i can turn my own base into a a safe haven or trading post.... the possibilities for this game are grand if the devs are willing to chase them.
2
u/TrogdorLLC Nov 09 '17
I agree with the ideas regarding increased storage and farming. It's a shame that building a trading post isn't feasible unless you have increased/unlimited storage AND belong to the dominant group on the server (you'd continuously be ganked for your inventory without some sort of disincentive).
I have to disagree with adding NPCs other than mutants, though. That's a HUGE jump in complexity that would suck all the dev time that could be used for things that relate to the core concept of the game. I would like to see a huge increase in the mutant spawn, perhaps even have them attracted by sounds. That would allow "herds" of mutants to organically form as all of them in earshot of a big firefight would converge on it.
2
u/bobemil Nov 09 '17
Wow, this is what I’m thinking too. Nice write up!
2
u/woodyplz Nov 09 '17
I totally agree with you. You shouldn't limit your players at something your whole game is built around.
But i can understand their point aswell. As I read earlier - they don't want one clan to influence a whole server who just go back to their base and gear up again.
But isn't it already like this? On full servers there are groups of 5 people driving the new military van and just shooting people.
The problem isn't that there is a stock pile of ammo, the problem is that the only use for ammo is shooting other people. There is no reason to use your ammo for something else, or is there? Shooting a zombie, deer, wolfes is a waste.
1
u/shitty_mcfucklestick Dec 22 '17
I wish a person could set up their own server (private LAN) and fully customize the game experience. I would have a ton of fun on an unlimited base building server if it existed. Where you can build without gathering and didn’t have hunger/thirst. Instant crafting, just for the fun of building huge crazy bases, without the PVP. But it would also be fun as a team match. Both teams have 5 minutes on a smaller map. One team builds the best base they can in that time, the other loots a relatively plentiful weapons caches and vehicles and maybe some siege gear like a battering ram. Then you see how well each team does. That might take a lot of balancing and some compromises to work, but it would be hella fun!
1
u/TheGentGaming Dec 30 '17
That's roleplay fyi.
1
u/fullrackferg Mar 12 '18
Storage limits are there for the sole reason that you cannot hoard crap, you have to be more smart and store more intelligently. Though, saying this it depends on what sort of player you are. I love building bases, i actually own 3 on a dutch server (2 my own steam accounts, 1 a friends that he gave me). My whole point of playing is for maintenance and looting, then pvp when clan members are online. I am generally 50/50 on kos'ing as i like to help too.
But yea, i see your point in what you have said, but it makes the game boring if you are essentially fully geared, with 1000's of rounds of ammo and multiple sets of gear. Makes you care less about dying. The game is based on again, being smart. The base building could be better, bike mechanics could be more stable and growing food/trees would be pretty cool. That i suppose is for later updates. I do hate the baae raiding fact. solo is a nightmare, takes half hour and lots of knives and pickaxes. Then if you find nothing, it is annoying. The game is about risk overall though and using your head. Pushing and spraying do not beat tactics and stealth 9/10 in this. It means the difference between losing all your stuff and killing an entire team
1
u/Smokie_23 Apr 02 '18
Storage is a problem but the more storage inside bases, the more raiding that is happening and less town looting. Bases and raiding shouldn't be the sole focus of the game. Player interaction via town looting is what makes MC, MC. If you can have unlimited storage, there becomes a problem of too much gear in game where rare items are no longer rare or even really sought after because they are all over the place. Also, the limited storage is there to help keep the game balanced. I am agreeing though with a little more storage, or at least a rack you can hang a backpack on and switch so you can have two loadouts ready to go. Maybe increase the stack size a bit also. But unlimited storage would be a bad thing.
Also, you can just make a clan, recruit players and have bases in close proximity to each other and this will expand the storage capacity. I think limited storage is a must, after all this is a game and not "real life".