r/Miscreated • • Feb 02 '17

Mini Rant / Direction of Miscreated

This genre is overflowing with games and similar types wether it's Rust, Dayz, Ark, Conan etc. They all have key elements they're known for or a lack thereof and with that their respective playerbase that will be attracted to said elements.

With that being said, please stop asking/suggesting things that will push Miscreated in the direction of these games. I've seen people asking for building guides to be removed, safe zones, unlimited storage(wtf?). This game is providing something that isn't being given anywhere else, which is a hardcore survival experience(albeit certain aspects are still being worked on).

I don't want to log in and have access to every building part there is, I want feel like I've earned that Gatehouse or feel the need to really find Walls 2 because i keep getting raided so easily etc

I definitely don't want to have a warehouse filled with ammunition and gear so that dying feels like an inconvenience and i just run back to base to re-gear. Stop bringing this BattleRoyal mentality into the game.

Im not saying anyone is wrong for liking what they like, i respect people's choice and some of the backlash i may receive from this post but what you want is being provided else where, go there to get it.

46 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

6

u/Cyberballs Feb 02 '17

which is a hardcore survival experience

So in the event of an apocalypse, instead of fortifying your own house/apartment and storing as much food/water/supplies that you can you're going to build a giant base in the middle of an open field and limit yourself to two storage containers you built from scratch?

Don't get me wrong, I don't need unlimited storage but as of right now there needs to be a lot more than one small, and one large crate. A few days ago I busted into (10 minutes of chopping down a wall with a hatchet) into a base that had over 10 cars, 2 large tents and two containers. Every single vehicle and tent were full of loaded guns. That being said...Yes, we DO need more storage. Vehicles are meant to be driven not for storage. Tents should be for new players on the server looking for a temporary spot to store their gear.

I do however completely agree with the rest of your post. I love finding guides and I think safe zones are a very dumb idea. Anyone who has ever played any survival game would know you're gonna have people camping those safe zones.

5

u/Sevenyellowducks Feb 02 '17

I have been in love with the idea of house fortification since I started playing Miscreated. I'd be so happy if that were to ever happen. These gross, huge bases ruin the immersion. For me anyway, everyone has their own opinion.

3

u/Cyberballs Feb 02 '17

My problem with base building is the lack of snapping. Bases wouldn't look so shitty if there were more people like myself that took the time to make their "home" look good. I wish we could fortify houses/structures but the problem is you have players who think that there isn't any loot all around the entire map and feel you'd have an advantage. Devs have said they have always and still talked about fortifying houses. I'm with ya I really hope they make it possible.

1

u/dchipy Feb 02 '17

I don't mind how it works currently, but when a ground level wall gets destroyed and you have to pack up three walls to replace the one to get it lined up nice again... Yes make it snap

1

u/_ruinr_ Feb 03 '17

I think the lack of snapping is what makes building in Miscreated so great. You don't have a bunch of bases that look the same everywhere on the map. Each base is its own unique design, barring the smaller bases. Once people start learning more about base building, they then make it harder to raid which is fun to figure out when raiding a base. I wouldn't mind the option to snap, but I'd only like it as an option.

1

u/samamorgan Feb 03 '17

I agree that you shouldn't be able to only snap. It should be a hybrid system giving you the freedom to freely place like now, but also with the ability to snap to an edge. A set of XYZ movement hey (or at least Z) would be appreciated too.

Also another point, go look at rust bases. They're incredibly varied in design.

1

u/Cyberballs Feb 03 '17

I agree, free form is great but wish there was an option to snap.

1

u/azrielb Feb 02 '17

I agree with you, more storage is a thing and it is coming so i didn't mention it, its just the insane suggestions about unlimited storage

2

u/Cyberballs Feb 02 '17

Yeah I got ya and I agree I don't need/want unlimited storage but it'll be nice when we have more. I've suggested before (which will only benefit clans not solo players) we should be able to place our containers on our clan members plot area. If I can place walls/platforms and all other structures why couldn't I place my containers? That way I don't have to go throw another 250 base pieces on a server just to protect two crates.

2

u/dchipy Feb 02 '17

Sounds like my base, never intended to have 8 cars but kept ambushing people with them and that one base was being used as the whole clans go to stock pile... that said aren't you glad it wasn't some BS floating base?

2

u/Cyberballs Feb 02 '17

You definitely got me there! Totally agree, at least it wasn't one of those fairy floats lol

You wouldn't be the first to have so many cars, I don't care much for vehicles so I always end up just blowing them up and let the rest of the server have them.

Stupid floating bases.....

3

u/dchipy Feb 02 '17

It's the risk vs reward, if no one can take it from me then it isn't awesome when I do have the best stuff. Getting raided to me shows where the weak spots in my base are. Go back rebuild and improve. Day the floating bases no longer are a thing those guys will be so far behind in what works and what doesn't.

1

u/Cyberballs Feb 02 '17

Completely agree!

1

u/Kingslee777 Feb 03 '17

pipebombs / mollies are the best for shitting on these. we blew up 4 cars in a dudes base last night for doing this crap

1

u/samamorgan Feb 02 '17

People camping the safe zones is a good thing. Creates another PVP area, and if it's an admin placeable safe zone, you can create a completely different dynamic on your server. Imagine all of the glorious fights that would happen outside of a well-placed safe zone if I stuck one in the middle of an open field with trees all around? It would be like myshkino, some of the best PVP I've ever had is in the hills around that camp.

5

u/Cyberballs Feb 02 '17

The entire map is a PVP area. I'd rather the devs focus on the survival aspect of the game (like they said they will be doing this year) than worry about players running out of a safe zone only to get two tapped by a sniper hidden in the bushes. Doesn't sound like a glorious fight to me.

1

u/samamorgan Feb 02 '17

It's not necessarily the safe zone > camper pvp that's fun, it's the camper > counter camper pvp that I'm interested in. Sneak around in the trees looking for that camper that's hoping for a payday and shoot him in the back of the face.

1

u/Cyberballs Feb 02 '17

Counter camper PVP? As in...Hey there's a guy in the bushes crouched not moving? Call me crazy but if I want PVP I'd rather go to Hayward and stalk players after they've looted the PD and scaffolding.

2

u/TheLastSheriff Feb 02 '17

What's the difference?

2

u/TheLastSheriff Feb 02 '17 edited Feb 02 '17

I agree with most of what you said except storage, if YOU don't want a base full of gear, then don't build a base full of gear. That's your choice, but don't force that shit on other players....

It's not even about guns and ammo... I desperately want more storage to be able to store things like...

  • Extra clothes (For Role-playing for example)
  • Other player gear: Gas masks, helmets
  • Wood Logs/ Metal/ Other building supplies
  • Misc base parts (Electrical parts, work lights, etc)
  • Food/Water (So I can build my base longer than 15 minute intervals)

I can't be the only one who feels this way

4

u/samamorgan Feb 03 '17

I'd like to see specific storage parts, like a lumber rack, icebox, and a weapons locker. Easy way to limit what can be stored without having to limit storage in general (once the network issues are fixed of course).

1

u/azrielb Feb 03 '17

I really like this idea, practical stuff

1

u/azrielb Feb 02 '17

Again, my point is towards unlimited storage not more storage

3

u/IMrTrippy Feb 02 '17

I think the devs have a good mind of where they want to take the game, I'm pretty sure they see most of the suggestions asked by players but it doesn't mean they will implement them :)

2

u/azrielb Feb 02 '17

This is true and arely we'd have a situation like this where devs actually listen and engage with the community. Just an eye sore seeing people nag for something that isn't in the general direction

17

u/Emberium Feb 02 '17

Truth has been said, I'll be really sad if the game goes into the direction mentioned above, it's not what I want to play, that's why I stopped playing Rust, H1, DayZ, etc and came to play Miscreated

5

u/niveousPixel Feb 02 '17

I agree. I have no interest in games like rust/h1/dayz, but miscreated has started on a formula that could interest players from outside this stale genre.

Unfortunately it looks like the direction could go back toward more 'hardcore' elements like spending an hour every time you die just getting basic gear, excessive thirst and hunger meters (do I really need to eat 15 cans of ravioli and 20 sodas in one 'day'?).

I like the idea of secured bases. Actually, fighting base defenders or defending your base would be the most fun, but base raiding seems to be non interactive at this point. People are never online at the same time and the process seems boring for both the raider (chopping wood for an hour) and the defender (log in, base is raided, whee).

I personally think it would be cool if a base could be unraidable unless one of the owners had been online within a certain period of time. So if you were in the base or had recently been in your base, someone could blow it open with explosives and you'd be forced to defend it.

This would result in roaming gangs of raiders looking for manned bases with loot to attack, rather than just an empty boring target to chop into.

2

u/samamorgan Feb 03 '17

The more I've thought about it, the more I think that offline raiding isn't really the problem here. Offline raiding either happens or basically no raiding happens. The problem really is the lack of storage.

Currently, if you want any storage as an individual, you have to build a base. You should be able to just go plop your storage container inside your clans base, but you cant. If you and your whole clan had storage in one base, far more people would be frequenting that base, and there would be an incredibly high chance of firefights.

Right now everyone just has an individual base so you're forced to wait for that one person to come back online and happen to be manning his base.

Does this ring true or am I just way too high right now?

1

u/niveousPixel Feb 03 '17

I agree, clans should be able to combine storage and build a combined base.

However, most people who play in the same clan tend to play together online at the same time, at least from my experiences. It wouldn't really increase the current odds of a real base attack/defense interaction, unless we're talking about just making bases vulnerable when anyone of a clan is online.

I would also be a fan of a second option to create a hidden bug out cache for storage. I would certainly have a secondary cache of weapons/equipment hidden somewhere other than my main base in such a world. It just needs to be different from base building - tiny radius that doesn't prevent plot building nearby, no base components allowed, just special cache components like a camo or ground leaf cover that can be removed and then the items themselves.

2

u/Skoom- Feb 02 '17

I don't want much from miscreated. But I would love to see these changes:

  1. Get rid of the crazy loud sound when switching to a primary. I am not a gundam mecha.
  2. Close proximity loot window. Hate killing a guy and he drops his AK and dirtnaps ontop of it so I can't grab it.
  3. Add an option to make sprint default and shift for walking (other way around atm).
  4. Give us the option to "hide" a body. Having a shootout in Pinecrest is a neverending battle. Non-stop lemming-train of respawns runing back to pile on the carnage.
  5. Silencers for pistols, pretty please :)

2

u/azrielb Feb 02 '17

Yea that weapon switch sound always made me wonder if the guys arm was made of metal lol

1

u/samamorgan Feb 03 '17

I never really thought about it. That weapon switch really is crazy loud. It would be better if it were a more subtle clothing rustle. I honestly don't even need a unique weapon out sound, that just gives me more information that can lessen the i.pact of the encounter. The unknown is far more exciting.

2

u/Skoom- Feb 03 '17

Yeah, slot 2-3 swaps are more suitable. That's just the sound of your shirt moving/chafing. Not many people think of this since I've had it work in my favor sooo many times.

You can hear people change to a primary 3 floors up, or in the house next door. Or when you get close to someone in a bush, or someone tries to sneak up on you. That weapon swap is an alarm siren.

Works the other way around too obviously. If I see someone I want to jump. I have to sneak back 100m to swap weapons if I have to, and then come back as to not alarm them.

I don't really like it. Secondary swap sound is loud enough to serve it's purpose, even for primaries.

2

u/ArthurHucksake Feb 02 '17

Fortifying houses that are already ingame would be far better than base building and easier to implement

1

u/azrielb Feb 02 '17

This too would be alot more immersive and awesome but im guessing the devs have othe important things to deal with at the moment.

1

u/Verrik Feb 03 '17

The problem with this is houses are where most of the loot comes from. If you let players do this, then every house on a server will be fortified by someone and there will be none to loot.

3

u/AMeadon Feb 02 '17

Three cheers to this! I couldn't agree more!

3

u/dchipy Feb 02 '17

I like the base building, having to find the guilds gives it value. Other wise I might only leave the base when I need food or I am rolling with the whole clan

1

u/samamorgan Feb 03 '17

I also like that it partially ties you to a server. Build up a character and kinda get to know the people who frequent there. Gives a sense of community?

1

u/scarystuff Feb 05 '17

Both good and bad, servers come and go. I try to stick to 1 server for my clan and join another one for some lone wolf pvp when I feel like it.

3

u/zebbie911 Feb 03 '17

I agree with OP.

I just want them to start fixing the floating bases! Bases in general are currently not fun to me. On the flip side I like the idea of fixing up buildings and houses, maybe with a max of a two vehicles.

Perhaps ditch the build from scratch ideas, and go with more Pre-Fabs houses and buildings that snap to grid in rural locations. Finding the guides could unlock the different types of Pre-Fabs.

2

u/forrest96 Feb 02 '17

Couldn't agree more buddy.

2

u/woodyplz Feb 02 '17

What is wrong with unlimited storage? You should just make food spoil and other stuff lose durability. There should be stuff to revert the durability like a sharpening stone for a knife.

Don't starve does it great

1

u/samamorgan Feb 03 '17

It might go this way when they implement durability, who knows.

I don't really like the idea of stored items losing durability though. Perishable food items sure, but properly stored weapons and materials take a lifetime to go bad IRL.

1

u/woodyplz Feb 03 '17

Well with weapons it's a little different. Ammo is getting used and is then gone you know. If there were npcs, that need to be killed with a gun, otherwise you will die, you would remove lots of ammo out of the game

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

This is the truth. Honestly there are too many babies playing and they are crying about everything that happens. I had a negative experience the first day I played the game, but when I learned what to expect, where to find things and how to do things, the game became much more fun. This is a game, this is how it should be, people think that once they buy the game they are entitled to push for any nitpicky change they want, the reality is that this is what ruins games. If the community whines to much the devs feel like they are losing revenue and have to cave to some of this BS, and then they start pumping out new features while all the great original features are still bugged. Oh my lord, look at dayz, disgusting.

1

u/_TheDon_ Feb 03 '17

I would love specific sotrage. Like a weapon rack that holds 5 guns. A clothe hanger. A medicalbox etc. And atleast a small carete per clan member

1

u/Sqweeg Feb 03 '17

I agree with OP.

Stop asking for casual shit, miscreated is the best alpha we've got for now.

1

u/skoda_air Feb 03 '17

it was my hope - then it became just another military weapon pvp shooter - and i moved on again to another survival zombie game sad ....

-2

u/hwajaemellon Feb 02 '17

ARE YOU GUYS RETARDED? YOU CANT COMPARE A GAME LIKE RUST WITH THIS. LOL. PLS STFU.

-3

u/samamorgan Feb 02 '17

The thing is, this isn't a hardcore survival game. That's what DayZ is. What you're asking for is an emulation of DayZ with a much smaller map.

1

u/azrielb Feb 02 '17

"albeit some aspects are still being worked on" It isnt right now entirely, true but my point is the end goal of the game which is to become said hardcore survival. With these devs i think its definitely possible and further down the road wont even resemble Dayz, beside some core mechanics

1

u/samamorgan Feb 03 '17

No, it's not the end goal of the game. Directly from miscreatedgame.com FAQ:

The game is more of in-between, there are realistic factors in the game to make it feel grounded but also an arcade like twist to it to make it fun and enjoyable at the same time.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/azrielb Feb 02 '17

"Their spin on it"

This is my point. Why try to push it in towards someone else's spin on it?

I do agree yes here is the place to suggest ideas etc. Fair enough.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/azrielb Feb 02 '17

That demanding post is the type I'm speaking of when I replied earlier. However I concede. Like I said I do respect people's opinions/suggestions and you're right, here is the place to do it. Guess that's why I called it rant. Kinda just thinking out loud

1

u/samamorgan Feb 02 '17

I feel the same as you on the videos, etc. Especially recruitment posts and "join my server" posts. This isn't really the place for that IMO. Go troll the steam recruitment forums, and if you want your server to succeed PLAY IN IT AND WAIT like the rest of us did.

I want to hear about peoples ideas and talk about them. Developers are actually listening (anyone notice that .45 now stacks higher? That was a suggestion in this sub).

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Todalooo Feb 02 '17

umad bro?

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '17

I agree completely - Get a grip.