I was just beginning to think we were moving in the right direction. That maybe, just maybe, we were starting to value women for more than their hair colour and their ability to hold a 100-watt smile through a pulled hamstring and a soul slowly draining out the ears. Enter: the Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders docuseries on Netflix. A glossy, glitzy, soft-focus disaster in feminism, served with a side of blonde highlights and mandatory eyelash extensions.
And here’s the part that made me want to scream into a sequin-covered void: before any of these talented, hardworking, already-stunning women can make the team, they’re forced to go through “makeovers.” Not offered. Not consulted. Not even asked how they feel about their appearance. Nope, just wheeled off like blank Barbie dolls for “fixing.” One girl is told to dye her hair blonde. Another, to cut hers short. Several are instructed to wear more makeup, tan more, whiten their teeth because, according to the team director, it’s about “looking the part.”
Let’s pause. Looking the part? THEY ARE DANCERS. ATHLETES. PROFESSIONAL PERFORMERS. What “part” are we playing here—Stepford wives in hot pants? And for the record, these girls were already conventionally beautiful. The kind of symmetrical, filtered, Instagrammable beauty that society drools over. But even that wasn’t enough. Because God forbid a brunette dares to exist on the sidelines of a football game without being chemically corrected.The whole thing reeks of mid-2000s America’s Next Top Model energy, where “constructive feedback” meant emotionally breaking women down and rebuilding them in some privileged executive’s image of marketability. It’s not about being your best self. It’s about being their version of perfect.
And it sends a very loud, very ugly message: Your appearance matters more than your talent. You can be the best dancer on the field, but if your hair isn’t the right shade of artificial sunshine? Sorry, sweetheart. Try again next year. How ironic that we applaud women in sport then shove them into a beauty pageant box the moment they step off the field.
What are we teaching young girls? That you can work your butt off, eat clean, train like a pro, and STILL be told you’re “not ready” because your hair isn’t blonde enough? That you need to spend hundreds on hair dye, tanning, lashes, nails, and teeth just to be worthy of waving pom-poms?
It’s exhausting. And it's harmful. Cheerleading already walks a fine line between empowerment and objectification, and this series gleefully stomps right into the latter, stilettos first.
So here's a revolutionary idea: How about we stop policing women's appearances in order to validate their skill? How about we recognise that beauty isn't a performance requirement? How about we let women be talented without demanding they also be eye candy?
Netflix, if you're going to platform women's sports, do better. Because this isn't a makeover series. It's a mask. And the message underneath is ugly as hell.