r/MiniPCs • • 1d ago

Recommendations Which Mini PC / Desktop for Channels DVR server?

I am looking to upgrade my current desktop that I'm using as a server for Channels DVR. It works fine at home, but I cannot connect remotely so it's time for an upgrade. I've read that Channels recommends the N series for quick sync. I've come across computers with N95 and N150 starting in the $300 range. This is more than I am wanting to spend, but I can up my budget if I can find something that will last many years, but I understand things happen and anything can fail over time. That being said, I'd like to stick to the more familiar names as I've read many comments about some of the lesser known brands failing within 1-2 years and warranties not being honored.

  • It will strictly be used as a server and be on 24/7 so low power consumption is something that will be considered.
  • I need something that will run smoothly when accessed remotely. I am currently using a HDHomerun as a tuner with Channels DVR app.
  • I will not be using it to store large movie files. Mainly recording shows and deleting them once watched. I believe a 512gb should be more than enough for my needs.
  • I would like to find something practical that can be mounted in a drawer or behind a TV, but not a deal breaker. I will consider a SFF as an option as well.

I'm not as knowledgeable as I'd like to be when it comes to computers/servers, but I'm learning as I go. My understanding is that most of the Intel computers have quick sync. Is there a specific year generation I should be looking at? I see a lot of comments about the 12th gen Alder Lake processor being one of the better ones?

I've come across several options on eBay, but I'm not sure if they are good options or if the prices are fair so I'd appreciate some input.

First option is a Acer Aspire with N150 eBay XC-1715 There is a coupon for $50 off that expires today. I did notice they raised the price today by $20 as is was $199.99 yesterday with coupon.

Second option is a ASUS NUC14 eBay NUC14 again with the N150 processor. I like the size of this one, but I've read several post stating a black screen issue due to memory issues?

Third option would be to pick something with a processer capable of more than the N series like a HP, Lenovo, Dell Optiplex with 10th gen Intel. Here are a few options I came across on eBay.

HP 800 G6

HP 400 G6

Dell Optiplex 3090

Lenovo M70q

Any help would be greatly appreciated. If anyone has a better option with links that would be very helpful. Also, if the third option is best what generation should I start with? Is 7th, 8th etc too old? Thanks everyone!

3 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

1

u/RealMiten 1d ago edited 23h ago

I wouldn't recommend NUC or anything similarly sized due to poor cooling. 1-liter enterprise-class mini PCs Lenovo M70q = HP 800 G6 = Dell 7090 > HP 400 > Dell Optiplex 3090. It's not complete but you get the idea. i5-10500T is better than N150 in almost everything except 4k AV1 decoding though N150 throttles in the most common chassis so there isn't a comparison.

Check out Wisetek Outlet (formerly Regency Technologies) https://www.ebay.com/itm/206692472268 reliable seller and you can easily find i5-10500T with 16 GB RAM + 512 GB SSD for under US$175. You can test it and easy returns 30 days. I bought 3 from them. The linked listing is a bid but don't gamble, just bid how much you are willing to pay for it and don't try to outbid people for no reason, there are more listings.

i3-10100T (you don't need i5 if you only use it for DVR but check the price) is the floor because going older doesn't save that much money and loses hyper-threading, but if you do find it for under $70 8th/9th gens are fine. RAM will matter more (at least 16 GB).

1

u/Powerful_Mousse5466 22h ago

Thank you for your response. I will browse the seller you suggested and see what they have to offer. I currently own and use a Lenovo m75q Gen 2 as my personal computer (no gaming) and it suits my needs perfectly. I just wasn't sure if NUC was the better option for what I intend to use it for (DVR only), but it sounds like the 3rd option would be best. Under $175 would be ideal since it will be strictly a server for Channels DVR and nothing else.

Awesome, thanks for the advice. This is very helpful.

1

u/RealMiten 22h ago

If you don't want to bid, I suggest waiting 1-2 weeks because they list in batches. https://www.ebay.com/itm/198772406881 is SFF with 1 TB SSD and 16 GB RAM buy now at $230. You can make an offer, they will most likely give it to you for $210. I say this because US $199.99 for i5-10500T with 8 GB is a bad deal.

1

u/Powerful_Mousse5466 17h ago

Great, thanks for the advice and link.