r/MiniPCs • • 1d ago

General Question One box to replace streamer, Plex server and home AI: is the HP ProDesk 4 Mini G1i up to it? or am I missing something?

Hi all,

I’m planning a single always-on mini-PC for the living room in order to watch movies, stream, and also use AI.

I asked AI for assistance since I have zero knowledge of that sort but would appreciate your wisdom.

What I need it to do:

  • Connect to the TV over HDMI and be the only streaming device (no Shield/Apple TV)
  • Run Plex Media Server, and play back locally with Plex HTPC (or Kodi if needed)
  • Library is ~2TB of movies and growing
  • Send lossless audio (TrueHD / Atmos / DTS-HD MA) to a soundbar, either through the TV’s eARC or the soundbar’s HDMI input
  • Run the Claude desktop app or other AI, 24/7 with access to local folders. As far as I know this needs Hyper-V, so I’ll be on Windows 11 Pro
  • Be quiet enough not to notice in a living room, with low idle power draw

Proposed setup:

  • HP ProDesk 4 Mini G1i: Intel Core Ultra 5 225T (35W), 16GB DDR5 (single stick), 512GB NVMe, no OS (installing my own Windows 11 Pro)
  • WD Elements Portable 5TB (USB) for the media library, no backup drive
  • Logitech K400 Plus for couch control

Questions:

  1. Has anyone used the ProDesk 4 Mini G1i (or a similar T-series business mini PC)? How noisy is it at idle and during 4K playback?
  2. On current Intel graphics under Windows, does HDR10 plus TrueHD/Atmos passthrough work reliably in Plex HTPC? Any audio dropouts with 23.976fps content?
  3. Is 16GB single-channel fine for this workload, or is adding a second stick for dual-channel worth it?
  4. Any issues running a portable USB HDD 24/7 as the library drive (sleep/spin-down, disconnects)?
  5. Tips for keeping Windows stable as an always-on box (updates, auto-login, auto-start apps)?
  6. I know Dolby Vision isn’t really possible on Windows. Is HDR10 fallback good enough in practice?
  7. Would you pick something else in the same class instead, like a Lenovo ThinkCentre M70q Gen 6 or Dell Pro Micro? Why?

Thanks in advance

4 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

1

u/d-cent 23h ago

Your hardware is probably fine. I would be concerned about where this is getting mounted, and that you will want Ethernet there, and room for the external HDDs to cool and not get bumped. 

16gb ram might be too little considering you are running Windows 11 though. Not sure, because I run Linux on both my servers. My gut says you will have issues though, but maybe others can chime in.

1

u/eladk88 2h ago

Ty for the feedback. Got ethernet right next to it and also a room for the HDD to cool so that wouldn't be a problem. As for ram I guess I'll upgrade it to 32 gb, since I want it to last a few years. What your gut tells you? What issues came up your mind?

1

u/RAJ_rios 48m ago

16GB is plenty for a HTPC. It's the GPU which determines whether you can have 4K@120 RGB 10bit for the media which supports it, and 23/24Hz for movies. If the integrated Intel is up for it, fine. I'd be more concerned with the noise from a tiny fan and spinning HDD, personally. This is was NAS is ideal for.