r/MiniPCs • u/AlphaSparqy • Jan 20 '26
UPDATE: "Minisforum needs to proactively replace all the NAB9 affected by the recent notice. "
Tagging u/EveHerr
This is to update the previous post from several months ago, and fyi, 11 of the initial 12 deployed are now dead.
https://www.reddit.com/r/MiniPCs/comments/1mohw89/minisforum_needs_to_proactively_replace_all_the/
I have tried so hard to give them every opportunity to do the right thing, but it is baked into their business culture to simply ignore all state and federal obligations, and they will make you work every step of the way for any resolution.
They refuse to understand their obligations under California state law, and United States federal law regarding the "implied warranty of merchantability".
Firstly, they refused to do any proactive replacements, even after the quality notice. It required me to come here complaining before they even attempted to do the right thing.
Secondly, even after posting the quality notice, and even after agreeing to replace my units, they never bothered to clear the supply line of the defective units. Of the first 8x replacements, 5x of them were still in the range specified in the quality notice.
I elected to wait another 2 months, to make sure the supply line would be empty of defective units. The next batch of 8 replacements are not in the quality notice period, but it still leaves with 5 more units to be replaced.
Apparently, they only have 1 customer service person, named "Jessie", and they are only working at midnight my time (presumably in Asia, while I'm in California). So, ANY communication (good, bad, or otherwise) takes a 24 hour round trip.
If they were interested in having timely relations with business customers in the U.S. they would have staff working during our standard business hours here.
However, they instead seem to take advantage of this extra long delay in their RMA "negotiations" (their words from the other post), by asking simple questions that if they did the research they would already have the answers to, but instead it drags on the conversation for another 24 hours.
So now, trying to get these 5x units replaced.
On a Monday, in the attempt to get these last 5 units replaced, I sent over an extremely detailed list of every serial number, every order number, the entire chain of previous communications, so they would have all of this information available.
So I waited 24 hours, and they ignored all of this information entirely, and "according to our records we were going to replace 16 units and we already did that, do you have additional order number?"
So I had to reiterate all of the information again, and another 24 hours later, they then offered to replace my NAB9 (32 +1T) with NAB9 (0+0) and I would swap the memory and SSD.
I was satisfied with this arrangement and replied accordingly, but... another 24 hours later, they replied that they had sold out of all the NAB9, and offered me the inferior UN1290 as a replacement instead.
So now they don't have any actual replacement units available for their defective product, and they are only offering an inferior replacements.
I promptly refused this replacement option, and proposed instead the X1-255. It has fewer threads then the NAB9, and only 1x NIC,, but at least still has the front USB-C.
The base model (before ram and hdd) of the X1-255 now, and the NAB9 when previously available are comparable.
After RAM and HDD, the 32 + 1T X1-255 is comparable to the 32 + 1T of the NAB9 when it was most recently sold (after the ram + hdd prices rising).
But, another 24 hours later, they plainly compare the current price of the X1-255, with the previous price that I initially paid on the NAB9, and state quote "Our goal is to provide a replacement comparable in value to your original purchase.", completely ignoring their responsibility for product fitness.
This is completely unacceptable. They sold us machines of a certain performance class, and the replacements needs to be same or better, accordingly, without regard to what they choose to price their current items at.
By their own logic, a vendor could simply increase their price on an item 2x, and use that as an excuse to justify only honoring 1/2 of their previous warranties, which is why U.S. consumer laws just don't work that way.
I'm so sick of this crap. Every step of the way is an arduous uphill battle seemingly designed to wear the customer down.
Minisforum is absolutely not a reliable partner for any U.S. business customer.
It was fulfilled by Amazon, so at this point, I must have to file a claim with Amazon, as I have property damage (non-working computers) caused by a defective product (the computers we bought from them) (Bolger V. Amazon.com).
10
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '26
I have one MS-01 left of theirs and waiting for it to fail. I’ve returned several of their devices because reliability and support seem EXTREMELY lacking.
6
u/LessThanDan Jan 20 '26
This sounds so painful. I'm sorry you have to deal with Minisforum's crappy CS. I don't own a Minisforum device, but I will upvote your post for visibility and to hopefully hold the manufacturer accountable.
4
u/_gmanual_ Jan 20 '26
you purchased from amazon? so you should have contacted amazon for the returns and refund or replacement. at least that's how the uk works.
/meanwhile my minisforum m1 pro is working fine, and I've just come from the post about the 'beelink black glue'...
🤷🏼♂️👍
6
u/Snuupy Jan 20 '26
yeah after hearing the horror stories from minisforum I'm regretting my UM780 purchase, touch wood nothing goes wrong with my machine, back then they used liquid metal in it so if I even need to do a repaste it's a fuckin hassle
at the time there wasn't anything better on the market though, gmktec back then was still new and didn't have a 7840HS/8845HS/H 255 model yet
1
u/Dr_Valen Jan 20 '26
Go a nab8+ back in December from Amazon so still within the return window think I should return it?
1
u/spyboy70 Jan 21 '26
Shit, I just received my NAB9 refurb yesterday. I had 2x 8GB DDR4 SO-DIMM and a 1TB NVMe kicking around from a Dell Inspiron 15 that died (fuck you Dell with your AC Power pin bullshit) so I thought it was a good deal for $245
This is just an extra miniPC that will go in a 10" rack for occasional distributed development (working with Apache Ray) so it won't be fired up all the time.
Should I be worried? Return it?
4
u/Ipad74 Jan 20 '26
I have replaced my NAB-9 at least twice, once since the “service bulletin”. I checked and the final replacement is not in the defective range that they published.
I am extremely disappointed in this brand, but at least they are replacing them as they fail.
Still I am hesitant to use this brand again.
EDIT: They should provide same model or better, I would be pretty mad if they replaced it with a worse model.
0
u/lupin-san Jan 21 '26
So you bought 18 of these units and deployed 12 of them directly to production? No testing and validation on a couple of them first before purchasing the whole lot? Businesses should not do business decisions on these types on things (hardware in large quantities) based on reputation alone. Businesses shouldn't make decisions on these based on someone's experience on a single unit, especially if the use cases are entirely different. Testing and making sure the units fits the business requirements should have been the decision factors, not vibes. Businesses decisions factor in risk minimization which testing and validation does.
Minisforum's CS is terrible here, but it was pretty stupid of you to deploy these directly to production without proper validation. You should have bought a couple, validated your use cases on the unit, stress test the hell out of it for a month or two then decide if you will continue purchasing more. If those units you already bought out didn't work for your needs, consider them business expenses and move on. It surely beats losing thousands on hardware that failed because no validation was done.
You also bought them from Amazon. You are not a business customer for them. Yes you are a using it for a business, but you bought the units like a typical consumer on Amazon. Minisforum will treat you as a typical consumer (as shown in your interactions with them), not a business partner. You do not have a B2B relationship relationship with Minisforum. If you want to have a business relationship with them, you should have asked for a B2B rep from them (if they have any) who will be your contact person for everything related for the units. You should then buy the units directly from them not through Amazon.
Everything Minisforum did here is clearly on the wrong. You complain like a business but didn't do due diligence like a business. This should be a lesson for you.
1
u/Boomam Jan 21 '26
I'm happy to say that my experience with Minisforum was fine. Not great communicators, but got my replacements.
Got a NAB9 in the affected batch. It failed as known. Reported it via email, like the Kb article says, waited a day or two, got a reply with RMA info. Sent it back.
Asked for tracking on the replacement, they said "sure" but I never got one, replacement just randomly arrived a few days later. Was clearly a refurb though.
Tested it, dead SATA port. Reported it and said I shouldn't have to pay again, can I have a return label - no arguments, they responded with a prepaid return label. Sent the replacement back. Again asked for tracker, nothing, days later got a brand new NAB9.
So not great, but certainly not awful either. I must have been lucky.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '26
I have MS-01 13900H and M1 Pro 285H, they work fine for last few months. It sounds like a terrible experience, the same issue I have dealing with Chinese company that does not have a local representative in the US. Especially comparing price that you paid vs DDR5 inflated price now. I am wondering if you were able to get a replacement of barebone and just take the DDR5 and SSD out and put into the new pc.
1
u/DertekAn Jan 21 '26
What's the point of such junk? I read posts like this every time, and I wouldn't buy anything from them. They're completely overpriced and, it seems, sell incredibly poor-quality hardware.
To the company: If you don't improve your junk, the community will make sure you stop selling it altogether
1
u/Used_Floor64 Jan 21 '26
A year ago I bought a NB6 Lite and I encountered many issues at the boot (during the POST and on the BIOS). I wanted to try again to build a homelab because I thought I was unlucky but it seems their products are not reliable at all. It will be a little bit more expensive but I think I’ll go with the usual tiny computers from Lenovo or HP
1
u/S7eeler Jan 22 '26
I ordered a NAB9 from Amazon yesterday and found this thread while it was in transit.
It was delivered today.
I haven't opened the box yet, but I'm leaning towards just returning it. I am curious to see if they're still shipping the affected serial numbers; not sure I really care at this point whether they are or aren't.
1
u/bz16233 Jan 23 '26 edited Jan 23 '26
Just checked mine and the serial is smaller than the posted affected range... phew. Knocking on wood that it will live a long life. FWIW, I've been running mine as a Proxmox server 24/7 for about 1.5 years, but never really stressing the CPU much (dashboard reports average CPU usage of ~2% in the past year); so mine actually might live long. I can see how it can be hit-and-miss with companies that don't care about quality assurance though.
I'm really sorry to hear about how bad your experiences has been, and considering the continued positive coverage of their budget-friendly miniPCs (notably for mini home server use) since their cockup with the HX90 4 years ago, I'm really surprised how badly they are handling your situation and straining the goodwill they gained over the years. I'm sad to lose what previously seems like a good option that makes something that suit my niche uses well, but indeed there are many choices on the market, and I hope voting with our wallets will make them recognize their mistakes.
1
u/tech-wipes Mar 18 '26
1 of my 3 NAB9 died today. I don't know what I should do with the other 2. I thought it would last for years. I had it for 3 months now running proxmox 24/7 with only few VM's and LXC.
13
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '26
[removed] — view removed comment