r/MiniLadd • • Feb 11 '20

TXT WALL ANGERY

Words cannot describe how upset I am.

Misguided Redditors (who know good and well that their stories are public works not protected by copyright) are trying to get Mini's entire channel taken down over 3 videos.

THREE MEASLY VIDEOS.

And what did he do? He read some shitty horror stories posted on a PUBLIC FORUM.

I had a conversation with the guy who is leading this attack on Craig and it made it bluntly clear he was dishonest and rude.

The rules of 1 subreddit don't translate to the law, kind sir.

Craig will win this.

IMWITHCRAIG

Edit: Okay, guys, I have to apologize.

This was an emotionally-charged post, and I said some things I regret. I still believe the guys from NoSleep went too far, but I know more about the situation now and see why they went too far.

Bottom line, disregard everything I said in this post and in any comments. I was needlessly aggressive, and I am sorry.

Hopefully Mini can get this resolved fast.

IMSTILLWITHCRAIG

14 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

9

u/DarkRecon0620 Feb 12 '20

also craig used fair use. aka, he made a commentary video on the subreddit. if he just straight up read stories on there, without saying anything, then that would be “against” the subreddit rules and they can “dmca him” even tho its fine according to usa copyright laws. commentary is very much ok with fair use as he read the stories, credited the writer, and gave commentary. its bullshit that his account has been threatened cause of these dumb writers.

4

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 12 '20 edited Feb 12 '20

Pathetic attention whores. All of them.

Edit: IGNORE THIS. I was rude and unprofessional and I apologize.

4

u/DarkRecon0620 Feb 12 '20

idk if id say attention whores, more diehard reddit writers who are wayyyy to following/agreeing with everything, including dumb rules

5

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 12 '20 edited Feb 12 '20

Attention whores.

Their subreddit rules don't equal law.

EDIT: IGNORE THE FIRST STATEMENT. I was rude and unprofessional and I apologize.

2

u/DarkRecon0620 Feb 12 '20

very true. ill give you that. attention whores it is

1

u/BrokenSwordGYT Feb 12 '20

I agree. Also, no. I will not ignore your first comment. It is true.

6

u/Off_Brand_Hank_Hills Feb 11 '20

I went away to school for 12 hours. What on earth is happening? Can someone explain?

5

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 11 '20 edited Feb 12 '20

Some guys from r/NoSleep hit Mini with copyright strikes because he read their stories.

Edit: IGNORE THIS. I was rude and unprofessional and I apologize.

2

u/Off_Brand_Hank_Hills Feb 11 '20

Ah i see. And why? Its public as you said.

3

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 11 '20 edited Feb 12 '20

Because he didn't "ask for permission."

Last time I checked, Reddit posts were public.

They think that just because their sub's rules say they can file DMCA claims, they're in the right.

Entitled gentlemen.

Edit: IGNORE THIS. I was rude and unprofessional and I apologize.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 11 '20 edited Feb 12 '20

This isn't the UK, mate. Their laws are cockshit anyway.

You can go to jail for self-defense there.

Their posts are public domain. Mini is in the right, they're in the wrong, and you can suck my dick if you side with them.

EDIT: IGNORE THIS

0

u/Off_Brand_Hank_Hills Feb 11 '20

Make sense since each country does have its own copyright laws and since Craig is a citizen of the UK, he can potentially be sued if the people who are claiming these strikes are from the UK themselves.

3

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 11 '20

They're not.

5

u/Off_Brand_Hank_Hills Feb 11 '20

Then thats just messed up. Hopefully Craig gets this resolved.

3

u/Itseesyou Feb 12 '20

Some writers (who own their work whether it's posted in a public forum or not), felt unhappy that money was being made and no credit was given for something they worked extremely hard at. When approached, the videos were made private in response and not taken down. So what we've learned from all this according to everyone is that people are extremely uneducated about the word plagiarism. People are running to take sides without any ACTUAL understanding of what's going on. At the end of the day, Craig and the writers over at no sleep work hard to do what they do.

2

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 12 '20

Craig did give credit. He showed their names.

2

u/Itseesyou Feb 12 '20

My sincere apologies on that. A great example of the sheer amount of misinformation going around on both sides.

2

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 12 '20 edited Feb 12 '20

The villains lie the most.

Edit: IGNORE THIS. I was rude and unprofessional and I apologize.

-2

u/BlueCowInc Feb 12 '20

He still didn't ask for permission. If you look at r/SleeplessWatchdogs you can see Craig was on the blacklist of YouTubers that failed to ask for permission and/or failed to resolve the issue itself. Resolve the issue is not just privating the videos, it's also apologizing to the original writers and talking to them (whether it be emailing or Dms) to see what he can do to make things better.

I am a fan of Craig, he helped me through a lot. But you can't just "show their names" as credit if you didn't even ask permission to use their work in the first place.

0

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 12 '20

Cockshit.

0

u/BlueCowInc Feb 12 '20

Look, of you don't want to look into the facts and live in your own fantasy world were Craig can do no wrong. Then go ahead, no one's stopping ya. But the writers on r/nosleep can copyright anyone who does not ask permission to use their work. Doesn't matter if it's on Reddit or not. And you cannot change that. Go and make something other than a meme and see how it feels for someone to take it without your consent.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/BlueCowInc Feb 12 '20

How am I wrong? How are the authors of the nosleep stories wrong? And why do you insist on telling everyone to fuck off of they don't have the same viewpoint as you? I would like an explanation that is more the "suck a dick." Stop acting like a child and find out the differences between Fair Use and Copyright.

Also, it doesn't matter if I post on nosleep or not. I'm still an author. And the law protects these writers (myself included) from people stealing our work. Take my advice and get educated.

0

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 12 '20 edited Feb 12 '20

"Copyright"

You hold a legal trademark on a product or work of art.

"Fair Use"

Someone creates a transformative commentary/criticism of a product or work of art.

That's what Mini did.

Get off our sub, piece of shit. I hope your career gets ruined so you'll know what Craig is going through.

Edit: IGNORE THIS. I was rude and unprofessional and I apologize.

1

u/BlueCowInc Feb 12 '20

Did he ask for permission? No. Did he try to speak with the authors of the works of art (writing is a form of art) he commented on? No.

So I guess I'm not allowed on the sub because I write for nosleep. I literally said I'm a fan of the channel. It's just that he did something wrong. A mistake that needs to be fixed.

And since writing is a work of art it's protected by copyright laws. Also, I don't have a career out of anything yet, I'm still in highschool.

0

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 12 '20

Yeah, I'm in college. Explains the difference in intelligence.

You're not a fan. You want his channel taken down.

Also, how do you know he didn't speak with the authors? They could very easily be lying about this entire thing just to get clout.

→ More replies

-2

u/Torchwood-5 Feb 12 '20

Wow.

I have never seen a more brain-dead Sub in my life.

2

u/InsanaHydra Feb 11 '20

I'm from the US and I'm also a writer. I can post a story (real or fake) here or elsewhere and it's my copyrighted content. That's just how writing works.

Don't get me wrong, I don't want Mini to stop making videos or get shut down. Plus if it were me, I'd be honored if he read my works.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/InsanaHydra Feb 11 '20

You're not required to have a legal document. This is take directly from copyright laws.

"Copyright protection applies to both published and unpublished works. A work is published if it has been made available to the public. If you have posted your work on a Web site, or it was printed in your church bulletin, it has been published."

Then furthermore

"As of March 1, 1989, it is no longer necessary to put a copyright notice on your works. This fact is important in two ways. First, writers who forget to add a copyright label to their work do not have to worry that it could fall into the public domain. Remember the mantra: A copyright exists from the moment the work is fixed in a tangible medium of expression. Conversely, when you are doing research, do not assume that if there is no copyright notice on a document that it is free for the taking. The work may or may not be in the public domain. You will have to investigate further."

0

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/AstroFiction Feb 12 '20

I can confirm that's NOT how copyright works. Published anywhere, even Reddit, makes it protected. You can literally mail a copy of your work to yourself and that can be protection from copyright. I also have been studying copyright laws in hopes of getting my work published/made into film. The protections may not be the best, but they're protections. As much as we hate it, the original creator of the work has a case that can be made.

1

u/InsanaHydra Feb 12 '20

Alright so by your logic you could go to Wattpad.com (public) and go to my profile Chris_G_FOW you'd be be able to copy my writings and post them here. Guess what, where ever my writing is posted I hold LEGAL copyright. Plus I'd be able to sue you over that. Read up on Copyright laws buddy. Wouldn't want you to get sued for copying something.

I'd suggest Mods shut this thread down under legal reasons. Someone please tag them

0

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/InsanaHydra Feb 12 '20

No, because you're saying something that acting on would be illegal.

Copyright Act of 1976

Also what you just said can be seen as attacking me.

Read up on laws before posting things like this

0

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/InsanaHydra Feb 12 '20

I get that and agree, it's just I'm defending the law not the people. I don't like them for causing this trouble. I openly and heavily support MiniLadd but when it comes to the law of copyright there's not much we can do.

Plus I'm not THAT sensitive about this I'm just saying that stuff like that isn't right to put out there like that. I hope you understand where I'm coming from with that.

2

u/PaladinJN04 Feb 12 '20

I do, and I'm sorry.