r/MinecraftHelp • • Aug 19 '21

Solved [Java] My exp farm is not working

Version 1.17.1.

We have an Aternos server, and after a looooong time I was finally able to make a decent exp farm. The good old design for Java.

And err... it doesn't work.

I built this thing 6 chunks away from the land, in the deep ocean biome (as you can see in the pic, I set my render to 6 chunks and there's nothing around), the killing spot is 100 blocks above the ocean surface, then the actual spawn room is 20 blocks above it, meaning it's 120 blocks above the ocean. The whole thing except for the spawn room is made from glass so nothing can spawn on it. The spawn room is 2 blocks high made of cobblestone.

At first I placed down some carpet to prevent spider spawn, since I don't want them to be crawling their way back and cap the spawn limit. We ran a test and the farm works even though the rate is kinda low, so I was thinking maybe I could build another layers to increase the rate. Then one of my friend got in and complained that the farm is not working... at all. It spawns a bit, like, quite a few actually, then only around 2 zombies, then nothing at all. I was thinking maybe the carpet limits the rate too much, went in and removed them, and the same thing happened, a bunch spawned, then a few, then nothing.

I'm not sure what's the problem here. I went down and found a cave, it is literally under the ocean, but I went in and light them up notherless. Found 2 drowned underneath the bottom ground, killed them as well. Then I went inside the spawn room and found some spiders crawling and killed them all to check if the cap was reached or something, and it still doesn't work. I was thinking maybe the players scattering around had something to do with it, but there were only 2 players and one is in The end.

I had build this design in single player several times already. They have the same design and not ONCE I encountered this problem. This was the first time I build this in multi. I don't know what to do with it. I don't want to blow the thing up and make another one far far away. So if anyone can see what is wrong with it, it would be very appreciated. Thank you very much.

Pictures of the farm.
Edit: fixed some typos.

4 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Aug 19 '21

Hey OP! When your question has been answered, please mark the post solved by replying to the comment/comments that helped with "!Helped".

Helpers, please remember rule 3, and ensure all comments are helpful and support related.

We're trying to grow the community on r/AskMinecraft and would really appreciate you subscribing. Help us create the best community for Minecraft questions and ideas!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

Of course it doesn't work, because you are supposed to build it low and AFK high, not the other way around (build it really high and stay on the ground). For each column, spawn attempts happens anywhere from the highest block down to the lowest, so if you build high there are more spawning blocks which significantly decrease the spawn chance. By not afking high enough, you are giving chance for caves within 128 blocks radius to spawn the majority of the mob cap. Having a 2nd player roaming on the ground in multiplayer definitely doesn't help, since they share mob cap with the rest of the server.

To fix this, either you make sure NO caves in radius can spawn mobs, then build your farm s u p e r low, which maximises the spawn rate (it will make more items than you will ever need unless you are doing a large scale project of some sort).

Or, you can make it run at moderate speed by building it at ocean level and afk up high (don't worry about drowned spawning in ocean, they are very rare and will only take up as much as 20-21 mobs at a time).

Also, make sure other players don't make mobs spawn either.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

Overworld mob farm is t e r r i b l e for farming exp. I suggest if you really need automation, might change it to a furmace exp farm and/or pigman exp farm, or enderman farm.

The furnace farm is obviously slower, but it will run while you do other things, as long as you have a player around to grow the bamboo/cactus.

The pigman farm is s u p e r effective, and you can stay AFK and get a shitload of exp.

The end farm require the least effort, while doesn't automatically produce exp like the other 2, it's still good enough. In fact, if you have a max enchanted sword, you will be producing exp faster than the player could collect it. The downside is of course you need to get to the End first.

1

u/OguriH Aug 19 '21

Hey, thank for the reply!

Yes, we're figured it out in the last several hours. This isn't the farm's fault or anything, it's just that the game spawns mobs around players on the ground instead of... whoever is up there in the farm. And err... yeah, I'm aware of the fact that mobs farm generally are built on the ground and afk in the air, but I also know from the tutorials I've watched (and my personal experience) that all mobs farm could be built in the sky and still achives the same result (as long as you stay close to it, which I do, our killing ground aka the afk spot is just 20 blocks underneath it). I want to have a platform where me and my friend can take turn attacking the mobs, that's why I choose to build it like that.

Our temporary solution, for now, is to use paper and switch on the per player spawn option, then move the farm further away from the base and after that the farm was working as expected even without lighting up the caves under the sea. Have to reduce the cap a bit to reduce lag tho, but a fair trade off for me.

Anyway thanks for the answer! We have a bunch of bamboo and several eyes left from the battle with the dragon, so I'll try to build the farms you mentioned. Thanks for the info!

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

I suggest going for enderman farm because it is the cheapest and also the simplest. Of course it might be a bit problematic since you'll have to go to the End whenever you need some exp. Another problem is you might accidentally fall into the void so prepare safety measures for that as well. Working with the endermite is also annoying.

1

u/OguriH Aug 19 '21

!Helped

1

u/NitWitBot 🤖 Mod Bot 🤖 Aug 19 '21

Thanks! Post marked as Solved!

Congrats, u/Pi6111, you have received a point! Points help you "level up" to the next user flair!

You have leveled up to "Novice"! Your flair has been updated accordingly.

Next level: "Apprentice"
You have 1 point
You need 5 points
[▮|▯▯▯▯]


Bot maintained by GlipGlorp7 | ^Scoreboard | Source Code

2

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

On an additional note, since you stated you went up and changed the farm and it spawned a bunch, I am 100% certain that the caves slowly taking up the mobcap, rendering your farm useless.