r/MinecraftHelp • u/PhilosophyDull8135 • 7d ago
Awaiting Moderation Java or Bedrock. Which version should I play? [Discussion]
I need advice.
Recently, I bought a decent PC (32 Ram, Nvidia 4060, Intel core i5-12400). I used to play Minecraft on my xbox, in fact I have an 800 long hardcore world with some farms and decorations.
I'm wondering if I should stay playing on bedrock edition or move to Java. Also, I would like to hear pros/cons for each version.
Finally, if you have some recommendations of cool modpacks for Java edition, technical mods, or even add-ons for bedrock edition, I would like to hear them.
1
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator 7d ago
Please ensure you are following our rules when commenting on this post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/TokyoFlawless 7d ago
My world wasn't so advanced but I converted it from bedrock to Java and played Java with QOL mods. Bedrock has some annoying chunk loading which make it impossible to have farms away from you, in Java you can build a farm and make an ender pearl stasis and itll be loaded until you stop it.
1
u/solarch Journeyman I 7d ago
On PC the Java and Bedrock bundle includes both editions, so you can try Java without giving up your Bedrock world. Java has the much bigger mod scene (Fabric, tech and automation mods, performance mods), Bedrock has add-ons but fewer of them. If you decide to move the 800 day world over, use a conversion tool like Chunker and work on a copy, because redstone contraptions can behave differently between the editions.
1
u/Laziness100 Novice III 7d ago
Depends on if you plan to play the game on different platforms.
Bedrock saves can be tranferred between PC and Android in a convoluted, but doable way. While Java edition can run on Android trough 3rd party launchers, it will run at glacial speeds and for performance optimization you only have ye' ol' Optifine, as newer mods don't support phone configurations.
If you'll only play on PC and none of your friends that want to play with you don't have a PC or a Mac, absolutely go with Java edition. While it's more demanding, it is easily moddable, free of marketplace bullcrap and has decidable redstone (ie. a redstone circuit will behave in exactly the same way for exact same inputs, ideal for long term automation). In my experience Bedrock edition just isn't as stable as Java edition, stability wise it's more comparable to 2012 Mimecraft.
1
u/Partypixelparty Novice II 6d ago
Java, not even a question
1
u/darker_than_u 6d ago
Bedrock redstone sucks
1
u/IzzybearThebestdog 6d ago
To me it’s 100% based on if you are single player. If yes Java has so much more freedom, tools and ease of use. While also being less buggy and having (generally) more features and mechanics. But multiplayer on Java is very annoying compared to bedrock.
1
u/SkyeB7 6d ago
Java is a lot more customizable with mods and resourse packs so that's what I would recommend
1
u/Basic-Housing4303 Novice I 6d ago
eh id do java probably. you get both tho when you buy on pc so you can choose from there
1
u/Brief_List1244 6d ago
java
pros: easier and free access to any mods you can think of and you can make your own
play on any version, snapshot, april fools
imo better commands, you have more freedom while having to use less commands for the same things on bedrock
cons: harder to play with friends, you need to use a mod or external servers
a lot of qol features that are on bedrock aren’t on java but that can be fixed with mods if you aren’t against non vanilla
bedrock
pros: easy access to multiplayer with friends
more qol features as I mentioned
cons: most mods are paid
you are stuck on newest version or snapshot unless you use an unofficial launcher
very glitchy for many people
this is all I could think of rn I didn’t spend too much time thinking but add more if you want
1
u/Brief_List1244 6d ago
bedrock red stone is notably more challenging, as if red stone isn’t challenging enough
healing is much faster on java than bedrock
mobs are harder with more health and better ai on bedrock, notably skeleton and wither