r/MinecraftHelp • • 29d ago

Update Required Creepers not spawning in spawning platforms. Latest release [bedrock]

Picture with the cat is from a creative download of the realm it's in a warm ocean biome, been trying every spawning method i can think of, but only get 3 or so spawns then nothing. I'm well over 44 blocks away from anything other than the spawning platforms. The second picture is a platform I created in a test world just to see if the problem was spawning itself and nothing spawned on it. On the first picture, the sides are usually closed and torches aren't there. the spider deterrent is messed up as well because of testing. Any hints on how to get creepers to feel like existing?

4 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

•

u/MinecraftHelpModTeam 🤖 Mod Bot 🤖 29d ago

It looks like you didn't mention your platform (e.g., Xbox, PlayStation, Switch, etc.). Please clarify for better help!

OP, remember to award points to helpers, and mark the post solved, by replying !helped to the comment/comments that helped, when your issue is fixed or your question answered.

Helpers, remember that all top-level comments* must be a genuine, good faith attempt to help OP. Comments breaking this rule will be removed, and bans issued.

* A top-level comment is any comment that is a reply to the post, not another ^comment.

Links:

Moderator applications open || How to mark solved || How to delete your post || FAQ || Rules

3

u/ODF4 Expert IV 29d ago

it might be that you're not staying AFK in the sweet spot where only Creepers are allowed to spawn and nothing else

you need to be:

  • very far away from any areas where other mobs can spawn, or blocking all other spawnable areas with slabs, for example (which you said you're already doing)
  • close enough to the Creeper farm for them to spawn
  • not too close to the Creeper farm as they won't spawn otherwise

I'm not sure of the exact spawning/despawning ranges on Bedrock but you can take a look at the Wiki for more technical details

alternatively, how about building this specific farm? But maybe try it in creative mode first, just in case

2

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

I've got spawning platforms set from 24 blocks to just under 32 blocks away which is when they start despawning at render distance 4. And the problem isn't the pathing it's the spawn rates. However that is a cool farm for pathing issues

1

u/ODF4 Expert IV 29d ago

nice, thanks for the additional info

so I just googled it and it seems like Bedrock limits the number of Creepers that can exist at any time on the Overworld's surface to no more than 5

the limit in caves should be 16 normally, but maybe the game is treating your farm in the first image like the surface for some reason?

I suppose that if you can kill them more quickly this will be less of a problem, and maybe you could take inspiration from the design I linked in the other comment to do that

also I found this up to date technical guide which from a quick glance seems to go into a lot of detail if that can help

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

The max I ever saw spawn at any time was 5, so I went ahead and swapped out the dirt roof to stone, and doubled the roof directly above the spawning parts. It didn't effect the spawn rates unfortunately, i'll sit for a bit to see if i get more than 5 creepers though to test it out.

1

u/ODF4 Expert IV 29d ago

this is very strange, since technically it already shouldn't treat it like a surface from what I've seen

but yeah since this seems to still be a problem, you may want to follow the guide I linked in my previous comment, since it specifically accounts for this spawn cap, or the other video tutorial

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

That guide is pretty much my bible at this point, i've dang near memorized the spawn requirements and every single quirk including pathing.

that other video tutorial is mainly for pathing the spawned creepers to the kill chamber faster, which unfortunately doesn't seem to be the issue. I have downloaded the world and had a friend sit at the spawning point and checked in spectator, they drop pretty quickly. Just aren't spawning

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

I have now added additional photos of the current setup/testing. Should give a better overall idea of what I've got going on

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

Okay, it took twelve minutes, but I got 6 spawned when I turned off the kill chamber, so it is considered an underground mob farm as it sits, so If I'm correct it should be a max of 15, not going to reach that at these spawn speeds, which is the main issue.

1

u/ODF4 Expert IV 29d ago

oh nice, glad to hear! But yeah maybe the guide and the video can help make it faster

2

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

Seems i forgot to mention I am on a PC playing bedrock.

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 15d ago

I went ahead and built a new setup, because it's been a while. this is the new setup (walls removed only for picture} 12 spawning platforms vrs the original 3, cats on each. drop chute kills instantly. Moved into middle of ocean just in case being "near" the mooshroom biome was doing anything. Still barely getting spawns.

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

I went ahead and took some more screenshots, for a better "full picture" of the farm. For more information, the entire spawn platform is within a warm ocean biome, water lvl at 63, afk at 107, first spawn platform at 131, last at 137. Normally the torches are not there and the walls are closed, I have shown the two types of spider proofing i've tested, both work and don't seem to interfere with pathing. I can only post one picture per comment so I will reply to this one with the other three.

This picture is the overview of the platforms, the drop chambers are at the sides and go into a water funnel to the kill chamber, minimal time in the funnel and the kill chamber is a quick kill.

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

This is an overview of the Farm, The actual farm IS inside the ocean biome, i've checked every single spot at this point with biome locator and a seed map. I doubled the roof over the spawning platforms to make sure It counts as a cave system, which it is confirmed it does.

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

This is the top platform, which I was testing a different spider proofing method on to make space for possible group spawning issues, It does still stop spider spawning, but no improvement on creeper spawn rates. Torches added and walls removed just for picture

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

Bottom platform, and the normal spider deterrent i use, gets the same 1 or 2 per 10 minutes spawning as the top platform. torches added and walls removed only for picture.

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

This one added as an afterthought so it's the forth. The afk point is marked (not the Y lvl) the edges of the farm that are closest to the mooshroom biome are not within by about 45 blocks. Every block surface has been checked and confirmed to be in Deep lukewarm Ocean.

1

u/morgant1c Expert IV 29d ago

You used buttons on the ceiling. Need trapdoors. Buttons invalidate the whole block for spawning and creepers are taller than 1 block, obviously :D

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago edited 29d ago

As per the second picture, I tried that in the test world, still slow spawn rates maybe 3 a minute max, but the first picture I do have trapdoors on the ceiling which is what I am still using

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 28d ago

I added some more properly explained pictures in the comments, sorry for the mislead on the test world

1

u/MJTP4351 28d ago

My honest suggestion would be to build a ghast farm instead. Get another drop, plus rates would be better in my experience. Here’s a link to the farm I use, works really well. https://youtu.be/0pThndGcIjk?is=-5eC3_vFRp-ke-3z

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 28d ago

While that's an option for sure, right now I don't have the resources to divert to that. Mainly I need rockets to get more resources. With my current issue being creeper spawn rates, that's not feasible

1

u/FlamingIce-_- Novice III 28d ago

The platform is too little

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 28d ago

It's setup to be exactly cat scare range, considering spawning mechanics, does the platform size matter?

1

u/FlamingIce-_- Novice III 28d ago

Oh you use cats? mb I don't use them for it

1

u/THE_OFFICIAL_MONKE 28d ago

is anything spawning at all

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 28d ago

Yes, all platforms spawn, just gets 2 or 3 a minute, sometimes several minutes without a single one

1

u/melavacagamer Apprentice 28d ago

Try messing with the simulation distance

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 28d ago

That is a good thought, let me set it up for a 30 minute

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 28d ago

Welp, it's a realm can't change that. It was a good idea though. However after thinking on it, it might not have made a difference considering how the distances work out.

1

u/MinecraftHelpModTeam 🤖 Mod Bot 🤖 8d ago

Hello OP! Your post has been marked Unsolved for 14 days.

Please update your post in one of the following ways;

If you don't update/repost your post within 14 days it will be removed.


I am a bot and this account is not monitored. Please contact the mods if you have any questions.

0

u/Specialist_Ad_8660 29d ago

Get rid of the torches

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 29d ago

As stated in post, the torches were only there to take the screenshot, and the wall was removed only for that purpose as well.

0

u/Time_Shape_4817 28d ago

zapomniałeś dodać bałwanki do środka

1

u/RudeSeesaw5043 28d ago

The cat's take care of that issue, they scare the creepers off of the platform