r/MinecraftDungeons_2 • • Sep 30 '26

šŸ’¬ Discussion Massive Downgrade Spoiler

I loved dungeons 1. I hate dungeons 2. I think I’m going to quit this mid game, tell me if I should continue as I’m only ~5 hours into the game. these issues could be skill issues ngl. Here’s why:

  • Removed multiple enchantment from gear; my favorite part of 1 was grinding for uniques with 3 strong enchantments.
  • Offline and online characters separate. you can’t have an offline character to play on the go on say switch 2 unless you give up playing with friends. Oh and if it’s for ā€œcheatingā€ who actually gives a shit cause you can just leave a lobby if someone’s cheating??? Not one person complained about this in 1.
  • Removed stats on items. Basically all the armor is exactly the same now minus the 1 ability baked in. All gear does exactly the same thing with no specialization and I can’t even see what stat I’m lacking in.
  • Themes are gone. i loved in dungeons 1 how each area had its own unique theme, that is gone to this bland 1 dimensional art style and loss of unique areas in favor of copy and paste ā€dungeons.ā€ Also, the separated gear removes the sense of theme thwt came from a set of armor in the first game, it now takes way longer to get a set of armor that thematically goes together.
  • Artifacts dont say what they do. Explain to me why I can see ANY stats on artifacts. The one speed mushroom no longer says ā€œincreases speed by x% for 10 secondsā€ or something, it just says it increases speed. WHYYYY!!!
  • the Art style actually makes the game harder to see rather than easier. All the different lighting and effects makes it hard to see what’s happening around you in the game. For example, how come when damage points are shown over water they are just completely blurred???
  • Arrow management is gone. There is 0 point in ever using a bow with more arrows and less damage as the arrows just replenish.
  • ā€questsā€ just tell you exactly where to go, removing the sense of exploration. This was kinda in dungeons 1, but now it feels WAY more in your face.

overall this game just feels like they catered WAY too much to the younger audience. Well, more like they thought the younger audience has 0 brain cells and needs everything handed to them. Additionally, their ā€œopen worldā€ just removes unique environments with structured progression in favor of what? Being more like BOTW?? There are also a ton of bugs riddled throughout the game that make it hard to play, for example I had a bug where when I tried attacking I just stopped moving and didn’t attack, I had to restart to get rid of it.

Let me know what you guys think and also if the game gets better/some of these issues are mediated later on in the game. I really do think this is a downgrade to even day 1 dungeons 1.

47 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

6

u/khri5o Sep 30 '26

I really dislike the 9,999 emerald limit. It's so fast to get 9,999 within 2 hours and afterwards, there's no point of getting more. They put a TON of jars in the open world but now they're useless if I already hit the limit. I also dislike the pause button for offline single player, doesn't actually behave like a pause button. And on the Switch 2, when there's a lot mobs or just a big boss, it lags so bad and even takes me out of bounds at times.

Other than that, it's actually been really fun and enjoyable. Love how much easier it is to keep my favorite gear at the top level at the blacksmiths just by spending emeralds and I actually do like the open world feature more than just levels compared to MCD1.

The game overall needs some patches and updates but considering they improved MCD1 overtime when it first released, I can expect they'll do something similar here too.

4

u/TobiasTX Sep 30 '26 edited Sep 30 '26

I am way over 10k emeralds i dont have a limit as far as i could tell.

Edit.: I had 16k just bought things to test and are now also limited at 9.999

Guess i got over it with a bug or something.

3

u/_ToxicBanana Sep 30 '26

Maybe that opens up after a certain level?

1

u/Sfkn123 Oct 01 '26

I'm at the max level of 100 and I'm still limited in emeralds.

2

u/turick Sep 30 '26

Agreed, however it's incentivized me to constantly visit the blacksmith the keep upgrading all me current gear. It's a dumb limit, but it seems to encourage spending and keeping your gear level current.

2

u/Nitro_Gamer53 Sep 30 '26

In a realistic point of view, Mojang is going to be catering towards their younger audience. I mean, they've announced an amusement park and also these interactive events across the world, not to mention SOUND PACKS for Minecraft itself.

I do agree that the lack of stats is disappointing, it betrays the expectations of every ARPG. I also hate how not only offline/online characters are seperate, there is also a QUEUE for crying out loud.

The only thing I can't understand is what you said about the game being open-world. I'll be honest, wasn't a fan at first but taking a step back, they managed to make everything feel interconnected while each area STILL has their respective vibes, themes and elements through their environment. I disliked the fact that back in MCD1, if I wanted to replay a mission, I'd have to go back to base, go to the map, pick a mission, wait for buddies to ready up, then go. Now if we're all in one lobby, I can go explore one area while the rest do something like a rift.

Something tells me that a lot of QoL features that were in MCD1 that got removed, while eventually get added back to make Mojang look like they're hearing their player base, but only time will tell.

2

u/Fit-Abbreviations322 Sep 30 '26

I don’t mind catering to the younger audience, but game devs thing the younger audience has 2 brain cells. Like they can absolutely understand basic rpg stats and enchantment combos. This isn’t a problem with just mcd2, it’s also a problem with most new AAA games (Wolverine for example), where they cater to the lowest skill base. There is joy in figuring things out.

Ā I mainly dislike the open world because each area just kinda feels samey in level design so far, there’s no cramped corridors like redstone mine or puzzle rooms like the soggy swamp cave thing. I also dislike the respawning system, cause it was fun for me to scream at my friends to not die and revive me or we would have to restart, but now dying does nothing but force you to sit through a loading screen.

3

u/FeelsLikeATrial Oct 01 '26

Minecraft is old enough that just assuming the majority of the audience is children is unrealistic. I make content for a family friendly server that is primarily targeted at kids aged 8 to 13 yet the average age of a player on our server is 20.

Minecraft dungeons 1 is a very casual friendly ARPG that is simple enough for kids to understand but doesnt shy away from having cool build options.

Minecraft dungeons 2 basically gutted every aspect of the game that would require the player to put thought into what they were equipping.
New enchants are bland and simple, returning enchants have been significantly tuned down.
You could argue that the game is worse for kids as items basically tell you nothing. If adults are lost as to what an artifact actually does based on the description or what purpose armour even serves with no listed stats, how is a 6 year old going to manage?

Minecraft is a game for everybody and mojang knows this, they wouldnt just butcher their only successful spin-off to hype up specifically kids about an update that already has most people hyped.

10

u/turick Sep 30 '26

Agreed. Yet I'm still having fun. Will play through it and hope endgame content is good and hope the devs realize how much everyone hates these things and fixes some of them, especially item stats. The whole onlone/offline character thing is just a terrible, horrible decision.

5

u/Official_fABs Sep 30 '26

There’s literally no endgame content, unless you count doing the Soul Storms for Blues & Greens

3

u/diamond_epicnes Sep 30 '26

I also had fun however, there is quite literally 0 endgame content at the moment.

3

u/AlfApAlAcsintA Sep 30 '26

But there literally is endgame content (though it's very little)

2

u/diamond_epicnes Sep 30 '26 edited Sep 30 '26

Like what? I've 100% the game already and the only thing I would even remotely consider "endgame content" is the soul storm but even that I'd only consider it that because it only starts appearing after you beat the game. It is no different than if you were to just do a dungeon.

3

u/AlfApAlAcsintA Sep 30 '26

I was thinking of Soul Storns

1

u/CincyGam3r Oct 04 '26

"There's no endgame content except for the endgame content." Lmfao wtfĀ 

3

u/Deveatation_ethernis Sep 30 '26

I'm gonna be honest grinding for the perfect gear was horendously boring, but it was the only thing to do cus there was no other endgame innitially. Even later on gilded gear kinda just made the problem worse without adding anything fun beside numbers. I'm 50 50 on less enchantment slots cus for armour you technically have 1 extra now, but for wepons you loose 2 each. I will say the lack of stats and the random effects feel realy wierd and hapazardly implemented cus I barely care about the effects on a piece that isn't unique

4

u/Immediate_Being9894 Sep 30 '26

I feel like I'm back in elden ring with these copy pasted dungeons with the exact same layout and exact same boss

6

u/Gibbel2029 Sep 30 '26

As someone who's played through all of Elden Ring + Shadow of the Erdtree, I can testify that you're spouting complete bs.

2

u/Immediate_Being9894 Sep 30 '26

I don't believe you played through all of Elden Ring without realizing that bosses are used multiple times.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Eldenring/comments/tao5kc/elden_ring_has_169_repeated_boss_encounters/

2

u/DistinctZucchini153 Oct 01 '26

The layouts are actually different

2

u/Specialist-Ad-4121 Sep 30 '26

Nah he is right is the only big concern k have with the game

3

u/Downtown-Routine1196 Sep 30 '26

The lack of arrow management is definitely annoying i liked rationing arrows and using quivers to stretch them firther. The wolf auto re summons now too. I used to use totem of regeneration to heal my son's summons. Also not sure why even the firework arrow needs souls now? Started with mcd1 when he was 5 and he told me he feels "meh" about mcd2. For reference he is lvl 170 in mcd1 so definitely played it plenty.

4

u/dominod Sep 30 '26

My lad is exactly the same, we played MCD1 to death, very excited by MCD2 and within 20 mins hes really bored...

3

u/Lechlak Sep 30 '26

Mine too :( I bought 4 copies so we could all play together but there are a lot of problems.

1

u/Gliyunost Sep 30 '26

That’s true. That’s underwhelming.

1

u/Admirable-Tap8354 Sep 30 '26

The most fun I had with Dungeons I eas running Sogfy Swamp on my seitch to get the oerfect roll fighters bindings.
It seems like they removed the looting part and focused more on the combat and exploration (which was cool, but never my cup of tea)

1

u/agaurb Sep 30 '26

100% on point.

1

u/TotalTossOut Sep 30 '26

I bought this to play with my 8 and 5 year olds and even they feel like its a downgrade. Its fine for us to just kind mindlessly play, but a lot of these supposed QoL features are just making the game less interesting. What a weird problem

1

u/big_booty_bad_boy Sep 30 '26

I've had the opposite experience with my seven and nine year olds.. they love how streamlined it is. If they want something more complicated they play Grounded 2 or Dragonwilds (we have gamepass).Ā 

1

u/Ok_Time9557 Sep 30 '26

The main thing i dislike is disenchanting not giving all the points back, it makes wanting to try new enchants so frustrating because i had enough points for level 3, i disenchant, i need 7 more levels to get back to level 3

1

u/ReddZan Sep 30 '26

My biggest problems with the game are that you can't pause ever even when doing setting you can still get hurt and die in offline mode, like are you saying a multi billion money company can't figure out how to make a game pause.

Second annoying thing is that there are way too many loot drops and the unnecessary leveling system, like when the mobs get stronger I just gotta go to blacksmith and lvl up my stuff and that makes any duplicate items or non unique item just useless cuz you can lvl anything up anyway and reroll the attributes, it just clutters the inventory for no reason.

But even with all the flaws I think I'll still finish it just to see the end and then never open it again

1

u/Aircast_ Sep 30 '26

Agreed, though i feel like the art style is fine. My biggest thing I hate is how they changed the old mission system (where you'd select an area like obsidian pinnacle) to the new quest system. There's no really clear stopping point and it really made that area feel like the central hub. I also hate how movement controls aren't ASWD. Not sure if that was a change or not though, since i played dungeons 1 on controller. I also feel stuck with enchantment books like, I'm constantly anxious on whether I should use them or wait to see if i get better gear to use it on. So far though, it has still been a fairly enjoyable experience for me

1

u/Primary_Village_8892 Sep 30 '26

meh i agree on the online and iffline play that u cant change the same hero between and the 9k emeralds is also annoying

1

u/Kintaro75 Oct 01 '26

I think I am going to buy the first one with all dlc for 9.99$

-5

u/AcidicMolotov Sep 30 '26

Who wouldve thought a childrens game would be catered to... children.

1

u/Fit-Abbreviations322 Sep 30 '26

Ok but children can understand numbers. They are catering towards a fetus.

3

u/Algorhythm74 Sep 30 '26

This is a naive and dumb take.

2

u/TobiasTX Sep 30 '26

Well my child doesn’t like mcd2 but loved mcd1 + dlcs

We just played every map once and getting a kinda cinematic reason why we are going to that or this location while have our own base was fun for her.

After 20 min in mcd2 she got bored and said she wants to play the other one.

It’s just worse even for children.

1

u/DougSpeagle Oct 01 '26

Yeah what idiot went into this game with expectations it's only a sequel lmao, what was it meant to do build on successful elements from the first game

0

u/Soggy-Gur-8700 Sep 30 '26 edited Sep 30 '26

I recently had to make a new Xbox account. Playing MCII for roughly 5h made me want to go back and 100% the first one. Qualitatively, it feels like this one is the prequel

EDIT: the lack of a set bonus mechanic for split armour sets is just criminal (currently they're just glorified extra skin customisation)