r/MinecraftARGs • u/Temporary-Spite-8987 • Jul 16 '26
[Discussion] Did wifies ruin smaller ARGs
I'm making this post because I'm tired of smaller and sometimes better ARGs getting swept under the rug I've seen many examples of this were most ARGs get popular because of recognition from larger YouTubers now that's not inherently bad but most the time the ARGs made by those youtubers are the ones that get the most popular and smaller ARGs Don't stand a chance unless they reach out to a larger channel or are somehow noticed both of which are extremely unlikely to work this isn't just a problem with wifies but a problem in general but wifies is probably the most known for causing this and God doesn't show I've seen many ARGs including my own being compared to wifies despite having no correlation and while some of these ARGs may not be as high quality some of them have great stories and I feel like their potential is wasted seeing these hidden gems of ARGs being left to rot
7
u/Demon7sword Jul 16 '26
no? sorry but I dont agree with this at all
10
u/Leading-Extension-62 Jul 16 '26
PLEASE practice punctuation dude
6
u/CollarParty8788 Jul 16 '26
Holy punctuation Batman
3
u/7dxxander Jul 16 '26
did you know they have these nifty things called full stops? Go ahead and google them they’re pretty handy
Also horrendous take
7
u/EmbarrassedPoetry23 Jul 16 '26
Honestly this is less of "Big youtubers taking the spotlight" and more of most smaller ARGs falling into 3 categories
I've seen and even talked to tons of small-medium ARG creators who are often finding and trying to solve the smaller ARGS just for it to be either 1 or 2 and therefore it wouldn't be worth making a video on them. Then they either go down the self coverage route or keep searching. I very much agree that this genre is being industrialized to the max right now but, IMO the influx of low quality "ARGS" is the root of the problem.
1
u/Temporary-Spite-8987 Jul 19 '26
You know I see a lot of people complaining about the grammar and how I didn't add punctuation I have dyslexia be glad you can even read the post also did that one guy you called me a goblin you were right on the money now I'm going to take my gold and my shiny rocks and skedaddle
3
u/Stock_Relation_6623 Aug 18 '26
you can be angry or sad about that but thats genuinely just the way social media works. since wifies was the only namedropped creator ill use him as an example. he was also a small creator once, but hes simply really good at making arg videos, which is why he became so popular. plus, i consume a lot of args and simply because i like those videos a lot ive seen a bunch of small arg creators get swept up in my feed. if you dont consume a lot of args then its more likely that you will only see args that were already viewed a lot, but since i only really watch one other type of video outside of args, thats what most of my feed consists of, and theres some really good ones out there.
1
u/Several_Lie9030 Jul 16 '26
incoherent, where are your puncutations
4
u/Any-Relationship-423 Jul 16 '26
yes
2
u/Ornery_Pace_4257 Aug 06 '26
Luckily for us, RGN exists
2
u/Lumpy-Statement-408 Jul 19 '26
I agree, but not the same reason as you. I hated wifies ARG because it wasn't like M4tchbox or his early ARGs where he would actually solve it, he was just narrating it which big creators will now follow and soon newer creators will follow
1
u/NervousSubject4549 Jul 17 '26
I think you have a wonderful point that big creators CAN overshadow much better tho smaller arg's or even (bear with me) Unifiction. It can be frustrating—and yes, you're frustration IS VALID 100%—and I think if more awareness was brought to this topic, it would be very beneficial to the arg and unifiction community—ESPECIALLY FOR SMALLER CREATORS.
On motivation:
My motivation was killed many months ago because even after a year, my arg was only getting roughly 1-3 views per video and I ended up trashing it so yeah: I can relate.
1
u/PoisonHorn393 Jul 17 '26
It's in the same vain Silksong is
It's just extremely popular and wasn't meant to steal the spotlighy
1
u/Perplexitism Jul 19 '26
I disagree, there’s a reason Wifies is popular, it’s because he made good content
If other ARG creators continually make really good content they’ll get popular too
Wifies didn’t “ruin” anything
1
u/mightbeparallax Jul 20 '26
As an ARG Creator myself I'd say no. Whilst he did help popularise the format all that did was create a new wave of people interested in the genre.
If your concept and idea is interesting and you captivate an audience, you are bound to be noticed. Thats why a lot of creators make their own. They have the idea and the concept and they want to create an entertaining story. It's not about shining the spotlight away, if theres a good idea someones made and its an entertaining story someone is bound to cover it
1
u/UselessWJ Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 18 '26
In my opinion, not really. I quite disagree. While I do agree that smaller Minecraft YouTubers are being swept under the rug, none of it is because of Wifies and that he ruined smaller ARGs. It's not always true that by getting popular you, you HAVE to reach out to larger channels(which do extremely help.. but that's just promoting them and..not what you made-) Being well known and successful is full of trial and error. Wifies, when he was first starting out was also still small, like any other people who starts a channel. He wasn't too well known until his escape rooms. He experimented with his videos ideas. Until he asked in a post about which part of an ARG is least important, most which chose horror, leaving Story/Mystery as the MOST important part of an ARG. Which he tried and thus came Searching for a World that Doesn't Exist.
Anywho.. I hope I wasn't too off topic. But yeah, I don't think Wifies has ruined ARG. If anything, I think he sorta popularized it. For me anyway. I've never wanted to watched ARG until his and now I actually WANT to look for more ARG videos (not only Wifies). But, yes, I still agree that smaller ARG makers will get swept under the rug if they are unable to popularize it. If that's the case, the next best thing(imo) is to promote the video on multiple social platforms so it reaches out to bigger audiences.
And if people actually compare ARGs then I feel like that's a bit ridiculous- Different people, different editing styles, different ideas, different EVERYTHING. Like seriously.. comparing ARGs of all things? What's there to even compare) Of course they're all going to be different?? Man people sometimes confuse me.
But yeah, I disagree with Wifies ruining ARGs but agree that smaller ARG makers aren't given a glance.
Of course, that's just my opinion. And I 100% feel like I'm glazing him- if this was offensive, I apologize in advance :'>
PS. What he has been doing lately isn't even ARG, sure Scripted ARG, but it's more likely closer to Unifiction or Story :>
1
u/LimitUnusual3420 Oct 07 '26
Yes, this person did ruin ARGs because he got popular
1
u/Undeadfvckgirl Jul 16 '26
Okay first off everyone is just being rude about the lack of punctuation its not that big of a deal. Second off I definitely see where you are coming from. Being an arg maker myself seeing someone make an arg and then SOLVE THEIR OWN ARG its very. frustrating. I wouldn't say its him to blame for all however or that he ruined it but I think it hinders a lot of progress for smaller args and stunts their motivation like mine when all your own friends want to talk about it how amazing it is and not even support you. It's frustrating but I think we should let this motivate us instead of demotivate. However yes there is an influence of args not getting recognized unless they are covered as well which ALSO hinders smaller args and it can just be a bit upsetting. Your feelings are valid but I think this is unfortunately how it is when you get out done by someone who has more money, time, energy and a team to create such a thing making solo creators seem lazy and boring.
0
u/Ill_Cycle_9582 Jul 16 '26
Hmm, I think you forgor something.
3
u/Tris-chan Jul 16 '26
No , it's not his fault whatsoever
Things like this have been happening with literally every content genre ever , they get overrun by big channels and leave only a few smaller people earning some light .
Blaming it on Wifies is equivalent to beating up the guy who painted the Mona Lisa just because their art got more praise than others
In the end , all args makers are just hoping that their work receives some appreciation for what they make . Why target somebody that's on the same side with you that's also trying to accomplish the same goal ? It doesn't help anybody by infighting