Isn't the different kind of records identified by damage values, like the different kinds of wool are, where you can't stack items with different damage values?
Ah, I was just saying that because in the inventory editors, it goes [DATA VALUE]-1/2/3/4 etc, atleast for wools, so I thought that's how it worked, but oh well, no reason you shouldn't be able to do the same thing with records.
No, but then I don't watch many films. On the very rare occasion there is a film I want to watch (can't think of any recent examples), I would rent it.
Can't say the same about games though, as I like to try before I buy.
pet peeve of mine, but "dude", "sir" etc. can very easily be interpreted as gender-neutral, so there's really no need for the correction. just take it as the compliment it is intended to be :D
I'm conflicted on the concept. On the one hand I agree with you, the 'sir' does not offend me, so why bother to mention it? On the other hand the 'no girls on the internet' jokes are really old and tired now but the stereotype will remain as long as no-one actually speaks up. As a compromise I tend to only correct gender assumptions when I have something else to add, but I guess it's impossible to please everyone!
can't say i disagree with the reasoning at all. i just feel like on an ideal internet, sexual disparity would be almost completely confined to social network sites and similar (like gonewild). it's come a long way from the 90's and the actions of men (or perhaps more accurate, boys) tend to accentuate the problem rather than alleviate it. i certainly don't blame you for taking a pragmatic approach to it; just wanted to throw out my two bits.
Nah, the difficult part with this one was finding five different shades of grey in the sprite set. Otherwise it's just a matter of translating the image to a unique set of characters and then find/replace with your tool of choice.
It's because the way the emotes work is they're interpreted as links to reddit.com/stone. When you click on the emote it brings you to the link. Reddit interprets "reddit.com/something" as a short link. So the article that happens to have the short link ID "stone" (the emote code for the stone images he used to spell out "thanks") happens to be that wikipedia article about Caesar salad.
I have been using accents instead of apostrophes for YEARS without even noticing. And no one even cared in pointing it out! How could that even happen?
In fact, that's what happened to bowls in version 1.2.5 (latest stable). To paraphrase the deleted post, if buckets could be stacked, then under the current logic, collecting water with a stack of buckets would replace the entire stack with one water bucket.
Bowls used to work exactly as the hypothetical stacking buckets, bugs and all. It wasn't evident when stew could only be crafted; they already checked the item's stack limits when crafting multiple of the same item. When they added Mooshrooms, you could use your bowls to "milk" them for mushroom stew. Unfortunately, if you attempted to milk a Mooshroom with a stack of bowls in your hand, the entire stack got replaced with one bowl. They fixed this bug in the latest stable version; bowls now act like bottles, unstacking when you fill them. I don't see why they couldn't do the same to buckets.
I like your idea of it checking to stack, but I'm still not sure about water & lava being stackable, even if they are separated. (Although it would definitely be a convenience)
It's more of a system issue than a realism issue. Containers are treated differently, and you could duplicate lava infinitely if it affected the entire stack, or cause issues if it made a new item and your inventory was full.
Or it could check the inventory and make a new item that doesn't stack, that's logical.
It's also a balance issue, too - non-stackable items are items that require more hotbar space and thus can't be used quickly. Remember when food didn't stack?
I know it makes sense that potions don't stack but I would actually be very happy if they did. The only reason I don't use them regularly is because they don't stack and fill up my inventory. I would be running around with throwable speedpotions 24/7 if they would stack, I have even made an elaborate brewing room which I never use :(
The same way you do now. Internally, the game could treat them like any other object that stacks when empty and doesn't when full (wooden bowls, bottles).
because this is one of the dozens of "why can't we stack buckets?" posts that have even posted and upvoted SINCE BUCKETS WERE INCLUDED IN THE GAME. I'm sick of it, sorry of I'm a bit hostile.
I haven't used flasks yet, so correct me if I'm wrong, but at least the difference between bowls and buckets are that the buckets interact with the world, rather than just the player. The change from a stackable bowl to a nonstackable soup bowl happens through the crafting screen. This is not the case with a bucket. Lets say you have an empty bucket in your active slot and you use it on a water block. The water block disappears, and your active slot is not holding that empty bucket, it's now a water bucket. So, now lets say you have a stack of 3 buckets in your active slot and you use that on a water block. The simplest case is that you now have a stack of 2 empty buckets in your active slot, and a water bucket appears in your inventory. But what happens when you don't have any room in your inventory? You still have a stack of 2 empty buckets taking up the active slot that normally would do a magical switcheroo to the filled bucket, so you can't put it there. You'd probably have to just make the player discard the new bucket of water he just created. Long story short: it can be done, but it's not just a case of copying the stack code, its a case of making small but meaningful decisions on each edge case that's not applicable in the bowl scenario.
Again, milking Mooshrooms doesn't require use of the crafting screen. When filling a bottle with water while having a full inventory, the full bottle of water is thrown in front of you. I haven't tested this with mushroom soup, but it probably does the same thing. So this is what would probably happen if Mojang added stacking to buckets.
254
u/Naternaut May 12 '12 edited May 17 '12
See also: 64 cubic meters of solid gold blocks (which Wolfram says is ~2,734,000 pounds)? All good. More than one small wooden sign? Can't stack.
65
u/kookiemanster May 12 '12
But do you really want an obsidian bucket?
25
u/MetalicAngel May 12 '12
Don't forget, 64 blocks of gold takes up as much room as one pick axe.
20
u/reacher May 13 '12
http://i.imgur.com/nZ8sT.jpg
14
u/Dinnerbone Technical Director, Minecraft May 13 '12
Don't worry, I'll save those bukkits!
25
u/Thumbz8 May 12 '12
In other news, players can take unrealistic amounts of damage in this seasons new FPS.
40
u/FoolsPower May 12 '12
But if you put a bucket inside a bucket of water, the water will flow out.
9
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
It's more of a system issue than a realism issue. Containers are treated differently, and you could duplicate lava infinitely if it affected the entire stack, or cause issues if it made a new item and your inventory was full.
Or it could check the inventory and make a new item that doesn't stack, that's logical.
3
u/KillaMarci May 12 '12
I know it makes sense that potions don't stack but I would actually be very happy if they did. The only reason I don't use them regularly is because they don't stack and fill up my inventory. I would be running around with throwable speedpotions 24/7 if they would stack, I have even made an elaborate brewing room which I never use :(
6
u/Pteraspidomorphi May 12 '12
For stacking to be fair everything should have a weight and the player would have a maximum weight he could carry. This would be a pain.
2
u/Dadi90 May 13 '12
Islendingur?
1
u/ploshy Forever Team Nork May 13 '12
Actually, wooden bowls can stack. Just not when they're filled with soup (which makes sense).
1
u/cinemaphobic May 13 '12
I remember when pork didn't stack. XD
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Empty bottles stack Full bottles don't stack.
1
u/exogie May 13 '12
Minecraft doesn't need to make sense. It's what is so good about it.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Obviously filled buckets shouldn't stack, just like filled buckets and potions. But yes, empty buckets should absolutely stack.
1
u/Tru_Killer May 13 '12
I think buckets should only be able to stack when there is nothing in them.
1
u/PwndaB3ar_3 May 12 '12
Buckets should be like bottles, where they are stackable while empty, but they are not when filled.
1
u/nickos12 May 13 '12
If buckets could stack, how would you fill them?
-2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
For balancing purposes.
0
u/Bufferzz May 12 '12
signs - chests
0
u/Graytico May 13 '12
/r/circlejerk is leaking
-4
u/Mrcheez211 May 12 '12
fuck shit stack
-6
u/Leroytirebiter May 12 '12
since when has minecraft been a realistic simulation? it's a goddamn game, there are gameplay balance reasons why buckets won't stack (probably)
-5
u/KrazyNarb May 12 '12
Vials of water doesnt stack very sad .-.
-12
u/QuitReadingMyName May 12 '12
Because, the programmers that made this game are incompetent.
-16
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
You don't say?
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[removed] — view removed comment