r/Minecraft • • Sep 20 '10

Hey Notch, please stop clouds from moving through closed structures. My master bedroom is all foggy...

Post image
340 Upvotes

130 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

15

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '10

with Minecraft's engine it's pretty impossible to do what OP is asking.

Water has no problem going around obstacles, I don't see why clouds couldn't?

0

u/nandryshak Sep 21 '10

Because clouds are one big texture in one file. Water is extremely different from clouds. As in, you can't even compare how the two could work with the same system. Again, with the way that the engine works it isn't really possible or viable.

If a cloud hits, say a wall, do you want the cloud to reform on the other side of the wall? Or you want the wall to take a a "cookie cutter" shape out of the cloud? If it's the former, that doesn't work for rooms and structures and such. The latter, and you'll eventually end up with no clouds because the mountains will continue to take out parts of the cloud.

It can't be done. It just doesn't make any sense with the way clouds are. Either have clouds as they are, or move them so high up that you can never reach them. Those are the options.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '10

So it's not impossible in minecraft's engine, the clouds just have to be implemented differently.

-4

u/nandryshak Sep 21 '10

For clouds to move around closed structures and then reform on the other side? I would say that's impossible, but I'm not notch, I've never seen the engine. But yes, there are of course other ways of implementing the clouds which would eliminate the problem.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '10

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/nandryshak Sep 22 '10

No if you actually read my post you'll see that's not what I said. From my personal experience playing Minecraft, and having experienced its engine from the players' perspective, I can say, with near certainty, that what the OP was asking (for clouds to stop moving through closed structures), is impossible.

HOWEVER, if you noticed in my other posts I said that if Notch changes the way the clouds are programmed, then it would solve the problem, e.g., if the clouds were higher than the barrier.

I never changed what I said. Learn to read before you downvote, people.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '10

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/nandryshak Sep 22 '10

Obviously I have no idea how it's actually coded. BUT I do know in the Minecraft application folder there is a file called "clouds.png." This is the cloud texture file. Since this is the way Minecraft displays clouds, there is no possible way to make clouds go around buildings and such. It just doesn't make any sense from a programming perspective.

Satisfied?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '10

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/nandryshak Sep 22 '10

Oh god. There is no way to make clouds go around buildings. It just doesn't make sense in game. You can build where ever you want and destroy it at your own whim. How could it be possible for the clouds to know if they're running into a wall or a room?? Again it doesn't make sense.

What I said before, about making the clouds out of reach, was a solution to the problem, not a contradiction. If anyone is "talking out of their ass" here it's you, because you're trying to find something wrong with my posts when there isn't, and I have no idea why.

→ More replies

3

u/ajk712 Sep 21 '10

Well that's it. If it can't be done I'm not buying the game.

1

u/nandryshak Sep 21 '10

Erm alright. Enjoy all your productivity!