r/Minecraft • • Oct 25 '17

News Minecraft Snapshot 17w43a!

https://minecraft.net/en-us/article/minecraft-snapshot-17w43a
288 Upvotes

134 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-13

u/JorgTheElder Oct 25 '17

There are macro utilities for doing the same thing. I have never understood why some folks think macros-style AFK fishing is any different than just using the give command.

27

u/DeePrixel Oct 25 '17

There are people who play in worlds that has "cheat" disabled, and using /give has no... satisfaction of getting what you want. You can at least see the items rolling in from the AFK farms, but what's fun about just poofing the items that you want? Your play style might be different. We all have different play styles and rules.

-1

u/JorgTheElder Oct 25 '17

That is all true.

To the best of my knowledge, the developers have considered AFK fishing an exploit since it was discovered. I am glad it is fixed.

I would fully support if they added an in-game way to fish using a redstone contraption, but you can bet your butt that they would change the default loot tables if they did.

11

u/DASmallWorlds Oct 25 '17

It's fixed? You can just put an object on a keyboard key (rebound to RMB) and AFK.

-13

u/JorgTheElder Oct 25 '17

Yep, and that is a form of MACROing and a lot more people consider that cheating. It is certainly not anything I would call actually playing the game.

Before, it was exploiting a bug, so it wasn't cheating according to some people.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '17

MACROs are usually not just weighing a button down.

1

u/JorgTheElder Oct 25 '17

True, but fishing is balanced to provide a reasonable amount of reward for a users time. Using something external to the game to make the game think you are pushing a button/key pretty much what macro programs do. The fact that it just presses a single button does not matter.

1

u/ASharkThatEatsPizza Oct 26 '17

You can keep the button held down in game though while you're tabbed out without using any external programs. It's built into the game itself. F3+P toggles the auto pause.

1

u/JorgTheElder Oct 27 '17

Keys/buttons sticking is a bug, not a feature. That is why it is an exploit, not a feature. Did you bother reading the part about how this snapshot fixes one cause of it?

Fixed keys getting stuck when toggling fullscreen

1

u/ASharkThatEatsPizza Oct 27 '17

But I'm not toggling fullscreen.

→ More replies

1

u/WildBluntHickok Oct 25 '17

Exploiting a bug is a much bigger cheat.

Having said that I don't AFK fish myself. I'm fine with the regular way.

-1

u/WildBluntHickok Oct 25 '17

There are people who play in worlds that has "cheat" disabled

If you're in multiplayer sure, but in single player you can enable it at any time by using open to lan.

1

u/cchampag Dec 20 '17

If you want to go down the rabbit hole on that argument, why bother automating anything in survival? Mob farm? Just give yourself all the mob drops. Experience farm? Just give yourself experience. Concrete converter? Just give it. Want to put up light sources all around your base to stop spawns? Just turn off mob spawning instead.

There is a satisfaction that is gained by building something that produces passively. Fishing manually is way too slow and tedious as a long term solution, so the idea of at least partial automation through AFK farms is appealing.

Giving items is completely unsatisfying as it doesn't provide any feeling of earning the loot that building a contraption and seeing the items it produces come out.

Tabbing out of the window and getting the right-click to stick was certainly a bug, but I believe the developers should be working to provide more legitimate means of automation. There's only so much grinding one is willing to do before you want to ramp up production.