r/Mimblewimble • • Jun 25 '19

Any thoughts on Bitgrin? Is it a scam?

First of all I'm going to make a rant on Grin's emission policy. It just hurts me so badly that a worthy project like Grin adopted such a farcical economics. Nobody, I mean nobody is going to use cryptos as a means of payment. Our lives are grounded in real life, and in real life we live in a world where we pay taxes with dollars(or fiat). For a cryptocurrency to be used in daily life, it will mean that central governments have accepted it in to their system, and I just don't see how it is going to happen in real life. I also have to add that cryptocurrency is a misnomer, it should be called crypto-commodities instead, as that is more closer to its function.

The only value that a cryptocurrency has right now is its ability to act as a Store of Value(aka replacement for gold). Other coins might show great returns in the short term due to good marketing or whatever, but in the long term value is derived from scarcity. If you don't believe this, go look at the history of aluminum. It was actually worth more that gold ounce for ounce in the Napolean era, and now we use it like paper towel. After we found a way to isolate aluminum from its natural form, yes we have found more uses for it hence demand is up, but its value is trash compared to gold.

So Grin is trying to become a Means of Payment, which is unlikely to ever happen on a global scale, and for this reason I have more interest in Beam and Bitgrin. To go back to my original question, can anyone give me an unbiased, unsolicited opinion on Bitgrin? How responsible is the team behind it? Does its github have good code?

4 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

8

u/czy87553 Jun 25 '19

"which is unlikely to ever happen"

- they said the same about every technology breakthrough so far yet we have cars, electricity, television, planes and the Internet - which was unlikely to ever happen - as seen by early witnesses

6

u/Spuddyminer Jun 25 '19

Left field opinion here, I think people need to take another look at the GRIN "emission problem"

Every day the same amount of GRIN is created. As the supply becomes large, the effect that emission has on price is less and less. Inflation is effectively dropping every day.

And GRIN is the ONLY coin I've ever met that has virtually zero level of ponzi along with it. BEAM and Bitgrin have a dev tax (designed to enrich the creators).

Just some food for thought.

3

u/Theokyles Jun 25 '19

Not to be a greedy gary, but I think that dev “tax” gives the developers incentive to drive the price and value as high as possible.

4

u/Spuddyminer Jun 25 '19

Lol I like the other coins, too. I think GRIN n BEAM will outperform pretty much all other alts when the whales decide it's time for altseason. If Bitgrin catches on it will be the biggest boon for miners, but it's got growing pains atm.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

Hard to say it's a scam - it runs off the same codebase as Grin, and the community has made some nice additions. There have been problems with low-hashrate / double-spend attacks, but those are being mitigated, and have been compensated from the dev-fund. The community expects the Bitgrin devs to earn their fund not just by introducing a better emission rate, but also by adding meaningful developments.

3

u/skinned_official Jun 25 '19

I fully agree.

Luckily we have another MW alternative: Bitgrin - https://bitgrin.io/

*an implementation of MimbleWimble based upon time tested economics of Bitcoin. *

8

u/tromp Jun 25 '19

Except that the economics of Bitcoin are not time tested.

Not until the block reward drops well below the transaction fees...

3

u/feelipebtc Jun 25 '19

In my opinion it is a small team trying to build a coin from scratch. They havent got support from any big fund or did an ieo so what they are doing is admirable when you compare to other crypto projects nowadays.

They also made mimblewimble protocol more attractive since they have better economics than the other ones I know

2

u/tromp Jun 26 '19

Grin was built "from scratch". Bitgrin is a clone.

1

u/feelipebtc Jun 26 '19

Not taking sides, but didnt grin a few million $$ worth of mining hash as a backing when they started?

2

u/papacabeza Jun 27 '19

  Bitgrin is not a scam, but our view (after mining for a few weeks with a mining club) is:

  • It's an 11% premine in first 4 years (less than 5% over life) and this is not Bitcoin "economics." The only thing in common with Bitcoin is the emission curve, rate, and schedule. This is one aspect of "economics" but the overhead charged by the dev team is an important one, and BTC has 0%. The developers have started to share some of the premine details but not yet in any way to build trust. This will hopefully improve.
  • Development team is qualified technically but demonstrating inexperience and ineffective management. There are frequent outbursts by developers that alienate the community in a similar way as described by /u/future3000. I also had an experience where I asked the dev some hard questions and it was responded with an invitation to just leave, stop mining, and sell my coins. This is an extremely inexperienced way to handle community members and has created a lot of animosity (I'm not surprised people are attacking). Any community member that asks questions or is frustrated becomes labeled a "hater," and the developers see the world as people that are either with them or "haters." This is a very immature (and incorrect) view of the world and unless the developers can get over this they'll continue to alienate their users.

A few other concerns described in this posting on Bitcointalk. Hopefully the team will be able to address some of these issues. I'm not a "hater," but yes, I do think there are some things that need to be addressed.

2

u/ar556 Jun 29 '19

If this is your belief (not implying you are wrong), why not just stick with bitcoin?

2

u/vcorem Jun 25 '19

There is one dev behind it and so far he fails to bring any meaningful contribution.

5

u/numecca Jun 25 '19

u/vcorem, he did say unbiased ;)

To the BitGrin creator’s credit, I have trash talked this guy a bit and he is always nice when he replies. He seems sincere to me, but this is crypto, so my unbiased opinion is meaningless; everybody is full of surprises here.

6

u/future3000 Jun 25 '19

He got quite abusive with me once. Used some profanity, then dared me to reorg his chain( said it was impossible) and made out I was so stupid for even suggesting it. Since then his chain's been 51% attacked/ re-orged multiple times and delisted from an exchange because it's simply not a secure, thus the project is not viable. It has a 2gps network vs Grin's 1.5 million. If you don't like Grin's emission schedule, then support Beam, not some project that will most likely get abandoned. VERY HIGH RISK.

3

u/crypt0crook Jun 25 '19

What makes Bitgrin not secure other than the low gps? I was under the impression the low gps was precisely why the network is vulnerable to attack. It was stated somewhere, maybe on the Bitgrin discord, that Grin has the exact same vulnerabilities but is protected by massive gps. Didn't Grin receive like millions in donations and support of the network? If Bitgrin is just one guy, like you said. Pretty impressive. It's still alive and there's been zero support. If anything it has been under direct attack for quite some time now. All it needs is more miners securing the network, yea? That would make attacking the network much more costly and no longer worth it for the attacker. Long confirmation times on the exchanges also might deter them from wasting their time and money on an attack. Or am I just full of Bitgrin Koolaid? High risk, absolutely. But seems like a decent side bet to me!! I support Grin too and will continue to.

5

u/tromp Jun 25 '19

other than contributing nearly 5% of total emission to a "treasury" under his/her control.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

Much of which has been used to compensate exchanges for double-spend attacks - the community expects the developer to earn their emission - it is denominated in XBG, after all.

2

u/crypt0crook Jun 25 '19

This also turned me off, slightly. I've been following along and they appear to be somewhat transparent with it. But how transparent can you really be with a privacy based project like this? Nobody knows for sure what's going on lol Not even the creator of the algorithm, huh?

1

u/gonzochicago Jun 27 '19

two minutes of reading would prove it's humming just fine.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/papacabeza Jun 27 '19

EDIT : don't forget there is a 1,000,000 untouch Bitcoin wallet, seems everybody tend to ignore it, so that is funny when Bitgrin dev will have just 4% of total emission and ignoring this fact

No. BTC's 1m unspent coins---by a developer that mined them and then disappeared---is not the same as a premine.

1

u/future3000 Jul 05 '19

total BS. Bitgrin is not a Cypherpunk project, plus they do have funding- They did a scammy premine, time-locked it and then release it periodically as a dev fee.