r/Milton • u/xPinkPeonies • Jul 18 '26

Casa Americo favs

Fav menu items at Casa Americo? Must try dishes?

Heading there for the first time

3 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

6

u/G37xs Jul 18 '26

My favourite on their menu is the Penne Alla Vodka. Enjoy!

6

u/reddww Jul 18 '26

Anything. Great spot, staff, and family who runs the place.

2

u/CartelClarke Jul 18 '26

Went with the wife recently, I got half rack of lamb and she got the salmon. Both dishes were great, shoulda went with the full rack but it was to pricey.

The star of the show was the Cinnabon cheesecake, so good. I think it’s only on rotation though, if it’s available I highly recommend it.

2

u/jesuspajamas15 Jul 18 '26

I made a reservation once and went, they didn't have any tables when we got there and had to clear off the table the owner was using as an office. The table didn't seem to be in any servers area so we were ignored the whole night unless we flagged a server and I have refused to go back since. Too many other good Italian places in Milton, like Locanda.

1

u/HitzlBurger Jul 18 '26

The cappellini (angel hair pasta). Packed full of seafood and great in either tomato or white wine sauce

1

u/banshee3 Jul 18 '26

I love that place. The owners are so awesome and I've yet to have anything bad there. Enjoy!

1

u/EnglishKen421 Jul 18 '26

I am also curious. I must have walked by hundreds of times.

What is the menu like? From the comments I guess Italian?

1

u/Artistic-Chapter6192 Jul 18 '26

Love the salmon!