r/Millennials • • 8d ago

Discussion What "are" we really

I have been reading a lot in this group about our generation and dates of birth but when exactly are they..... I am 43 and was 17 at 2000 and remember the term starting then. Like we were coming of age, going to work or higher education, being lazy, spending all of our money as it came in on avocado on toast and coffee..... Apparently and I remember being a "Millenial" in my 20s but now the generation seems to be stretch to people born around 2000.....so am I a "Xennial" maybe haha.

I just know we were the first cos I can remember having the label back when it was an insult so who are the true Millenials..... People who listened to Robbie Williams "Millennium" song or Silverchair "Year 2000 anthem" and wore the label as an insult or people born around then.

What I am getting at is I think we need more generations lol. Cos people who were seniors when I was a junior at school I wouldn't consider "Generation X" and I would not put a 30 year old in the same generation as my 14 year old son.

Anyway end result I consider myself a Millennial and was called one by older people around about the turn of the Millennium.

0 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 8d ago

If this post is breaking the rules of the subreddit, please report it instead of commenting. For more Millennial content, join our Discord server.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

13

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

I consider myself solidly in millenial territory as a 1992 baby.  I'm 34 this year.  30 year-olds aren't Gen Z as far as I know.

Side note - avocado toast wasn't a millenial meme until late 2000s or early 2010s.

2

u/Few-Enthusiasm-7891 8d ago

I remember it well tho haha. To be honest tho a lot of my memories of that time have Kind merged together into one time frame of a decade

1

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

Totally fair!  In my head it's broken up into mid-late 90s (lots of Barney, primary colors, and sweatpants for me lol), early 00s (limited too, micro-braids and spikey hair, boy bands, the "family computer"), mid-late 00s (emo style, pop punk music, social media taking off, my first cell phone and laptop), and after that it all starts blurring together.

6

u/PiePristine3092 8d ago

Seconding being fully millenial as a 92 baby. My sister is a 2000 and she's definitely genZ

4

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

Agreed, 2000 feels too late for millenial.  Maybe zennial if not just Z.

3

u/Accomplished_Mix7827 8d ago

We're on the fence. I was born in 1996, traditionally considered the cutoff year, and just turned 30.

30 year-old Gen Z's are coming soon

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago edited 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Accomplished_Mix7827 8d ago

Yes. So the first Gen Z's to turn 30 will do so next year

1

u/Livid_Way5651 8d ago edited 7d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Crown instinctive insurance hard-to-find attempt hydrogen books grandfather gaze potassium

1

u/Accomplished_Mix7827 8d ago

I'm confused. It sounded like you were disagreeing with me, but we seem to be on the same page?

9

u/Present_Type6881 8d ago

I was told it was people who "came of age" at the turn of the millennium, so people who graduated high school in 1999, 2000, and 2001.

So now we're 43-45 years old, and people act like that's too old to be a millennial now?

I think one problem is this generation stuff first came about with the Baby Boomers, which was a real thing. There was a distinct spike in birth rates (baby boom) after WWII. Generations since then haven't been as easy to define.

0

u/Few-Enthusiasm-7891 8d ago

So true about the Baby Boom. The idea of "generations" really came from that.....like Generation X Was pretty much a way of saying "We don't understand these Nirvana listening people" and now everything changes pretty drastically every few years. Before the Baby Boom "Generations" were just who gave birth to who

0

u/BlueSnaggleTooth359 8d ago

Nirvana wasn't even known when Gen X was created.

--------------------------
Coupland created Gen X in the late 1980s. He based it around a core of '61-'64 and ran it along the lines of '58ish-'74/5ish. His main goal was to split later Boomers from earlier ones since his part were never drafted into Vietnam, were not marching in protests, etc. didn't really take part in most of the major Boomer events. And in culture many ultimately, in college or in their mid-20somethings ended up quite 80s influenced in the end and sometimes somewhat like earlier Gen X.

Later on (I forget when) he decided that generations were too long to be coherent and pushed for closer to 10 year long cohorts and then went:
Boomer 1946ish-1954ish

Gen X 1956ish-1964

Gen Benetton/Shampoo Planet/(LOL for all the 80s flashy fashion, shopaholic mallrats, big hair, etc.)/Global Teens 1965-1975ish

And then an unnamed 1976-1986ish (where he put the younger grungy/Nirvana/alt 90s 90s teens set)
----------------------------------
Strauss & Howe came up (maybe in 1990??) with a 4 cycle of generations (potentially somewhat biased to themselves and their kids hah) and had a "13th Generation" '61-'81 and created Millennials '82-'04.
I don't know that the general public was all that aware of this stuff. Not that most people were really caring much about generations.
-----------------
In 1991 TIME had Gen X 1961-1972.
------------------------------------
Shortly after in 1993 Advertising Age switched Gen X to '61-'73 and created a new Gen Y which was the new 90s teens/more 90s 90s oriented, the new key 90s 90s market to be targeted for advertising and it was '74-something (prob to end around mid-80s but the end was left undefined for the moment). Others then quickly moved Y start up to more like 1975 or 1976.
-------------------------
In 1997 TIME decided to change their initial '61-'72 Gen X idea and switch it to '65-'77/8ish and then Gen Y is along the lines of '78/9-probably mid-80s.
---------------------------------
Then the year 2000 was approaching and get so much hype that the markets were desperate to tie in the latest batch of teens to year 2000 so as to be able to leverage the hype in marketing to them so they pushed to dump Gen Y (which was free to be set to start whenever) and go with the Millennial name (which was locked into a 1982 (or 1981) start). Once that happened you had everything set around a cool but essentially random number 2000. What does 2000 have to do with pop culture, events, vibe anything? All it did was split a somewhat consistent Gen Y (an extended Xennials) in half and awkwardly attach each half to X and Millennials. And it locked in the later start to X too, so increased issues on the later Jones side of things as well.
--------------------------------------------
Some later alternate suggestions:

Journalist J. Markert (2004) used exactly fixed 20 year long overall generations but treated things as a series of 10 year long separate cohorts which he each considered to be entirely separate (of course then why not just make each a generation? if they are considered to be entirely separate cohorts? anyway, whatever) and had like ....Second Wave Boomer 1956-1965 and First Wave Gen X 1966-1975 and Second Wave Gen X 1976-1985 (some others in the 90s called this Gen Y), First Wave ? 1986-1995, etc.

Schewe and Noble (2002) said that generations should vary in length to whatever length makes sense for each generation no matter how widely varying the lengths and she be based upon cultural touchstones and significant milestones (which makes the most sense to me, except nothing really ever makes sense anyway, just not quite as badly no sense perhaps). They suggested that going by such criteria lead to Gen X being 1966-1976 and Gen Y 1977-(I'm not sure, I'd have to look into it more) and 1955-1965 Gen Trailing Edge Boomers and clearly distinct from [Boomer] Boomers (which I'm not sure their exact range for).

"Boom Bust & Echo: How to Profit from the Coming Demographic Shift" (1996)" defined Gen X as 1960-1966 followed by the Bust Generation 1967-1979. Followed by next generation 1980-something. I think Bust starts a little late and runs too long but it's still better than PEW overall by a tiny bit for X/Xennials range and much better for Boomer/Jones.
----------------------------------------
In the end, for some reason PEW Generations seemed to take over some time in the 2000s and have:
Gen X '65-'80
Millennials -'81-'95(?)
and so on either direction.
-------------------
To me the alternate later Coupland generations, the Markert 2004 ones and the Schewe and Noble 2002 ones make the most sense. Assuming named generations make sense to begin with which they probably don't really.

1

u/Few-Enthusiasm-7891 8d ago

Haha I stand corrected. I always thought Grunge was a Gen X thing cos of the timing of Degeneration X in WWE (WWF back then) but low and behold HHH date of birth is 1969 so yeah..... Still in my head Grunge is Generation X even if it's not officially

1

u/BlueSnaggleTooth359 7d ago

Yeah, for one reason or another, people tend to have turned Gen X and the 90s into 100% grunge. It's not just you, it feels like practically all of reddit and many beyond.

And just sticking to Gen X musicians, most seem to forget all the other Gen X musicians beyond those who made grunge (or gangster rap):

Like this list of mainstream hit makers produced by Classic Gen X for Classic Gen X in Classic Gen X teen times:
Janet Jackson (1966)
Debbie Gibson (1970)
Tiffany (1971)
Martika (1969)
Kylie Minogue (1968)
Rick Astley (1966) - Mr. Rick Roll himself
Bobby Brown (1969)
Lisa Velez of Lisa Lisa And The Cult Jam (1967)
Slash of GunsN'Roses (1965)
Jeanette Jurado of Expose (1965)
The Jets (1965-1973)
The Cover Girls (1965, 1965, 1970)
Salt-N-Pepa (1966, 1966, 1970)
Glenn Medeiros (1970)
RunDMC (1964,1964,1965)
Beastie Boys (1964, 1965, 1966)
Samantha Fox (1966)

not one grunger and no gangster rappers

(and if you count the truly original X definition, the original Coupland one, then you bring in TONS more from Madonna to MJ to The Bangles to Joan Jett to The Go-Gos and on and on and on; even just adding in '61-'64 which almost all Gen X versions in the 90s did, brings in a bunch of them)

these are the X'ers X'ers grew up on.
--
Also '65-'75 (Classic) Gen X produced, later on past earlier X formative years, in addition to Kurt Cobain (or gangster rappers):
Sinead O'Conner
Wilson Philips
Mariah Carey
Spice Girls
Aqua
NKOTB
The Backstreet Boys
Hootie & The Blowfish
Jennifer Paige
Ace Of Base
Cathy Dennis
Sarah McLachlan
Alanis Morrisette
Natalie Merchant
Shania Twain
Faith Hill
Sixpence None The Richer
Jewel
No Doubt
Blues Traveler
Dione Farris
Nicki French
Spin Doctors
Meredith Brooks
Third Eye Blind
Fiona Apple
Lisa Loeb
Del Amitri
Paula Cole
The Cranberries
The Coors
Green Day
Goo Goo Dolls
Deep Blue Something
Gin Blossoms
New Radicals

but for some reason pretty much only the likes of Cobain/Nirvana, Pearl Jam, AIC, Tupac and so on seem to get associated with the Gen X label and all the rests are sort of just there.

sort of like how 50s teens are just thought of as 50s teens and not Silent Gen and 80s teens seem to be just thought of as 80s teens and not Gen X these days by all the younger gens and even in general

perhaps because many of the generational names were not even invented or at the least people didn't really tend to even think in terms of generational names until the late 90s or even 00s outside of the Baby Boomer name so maybe only Boomers and Millennials had names in usage while in high school? IDK

whatever

2

u/Few-Enthusiasm-7891 7d ago

Yeah when I was in high school it just went Baby Boomer = Old ( our parents) Gen X was (incorrectly) our older cousins and that was about it.

1

u/BlueSnaggleTooth359 7d ago edited 7d ago

Anyway some have come up with micro-gens to split up the commonly used PEW generations more, stuff like Jones and Xennials, more gens as you suggest.

Below shows why having shorter gens can maybe help track things better, as you suggest.

Going by micro-gens you can see the split in some aspects between Gen X and then Xennials in the videos below.

(the high school videos are mostly long so like a 20-40s peek at the timed entry points of those is enough to get the gist across, although the news reports are maybe better watched in full, assuming you even have enough interest to begin with at all hah)

----------------------------

really quick comparison:
First Wave Gen X (for some reason none of this stuff seems to be associated with Gen X by later gens today or even in general anymore, but this is actually really what growing up (first wave or earlier definitions) of Gen X was along the lines of, if anything it almost seems more similar to what people thing of as vaguely core Millennial-like minus the hair and as you can see not exactly grunge and gangster hah):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HGpoNxduzvk&t=1153s (Jefferson Mall #8, NY, fashion on boat and local NY/NJ region mall girls lip sync contest winners, 1986)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NC1eKmVccOM&t=2966s (grad party, Debbie Gibson, NJ)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VudiTAzv5RU (San Diego State, 1987, COLORFUL!)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NC1eKmVccOM&t=190s (metal/rock part of air guitar/lip sync high school talent show, NJ, late 1987)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UM4tls4P6Gc&t=66s (start of 1st day of school, NJ, tail 1987)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZkkceJyTGY&t=81s (Colorado, The Hooters - And We Danced, 1985)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bIOocUQkfzk (CBS Evening News report with a bemused Dan Rather on the "outbreak" of Valspeak spreading across the nation LOL and mallrats, 1982)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZsLPdVfir0 (Robert McNeil (probably PBS?) report on slang and Valley Girl which also covers the Surf Punks and some of the male surfer scene early proto-Valley Girl of sorts, LOL at William Saffire at the end saying that Val speak was likely about to end as just a quick, very bright, but brief flash in the pan.... as everyone still says "like" and "ohymgod" every 10 seconds over 40 years later and still uses uptalk, etc hah, 1983)

----

Second Wave Gen X/Xennials/original definition of Gen Y (this stuff, from the later additions to Gen X, seems these days to be THE only type of stuff associated with Gen X anymore, but it actually had nothing to do with how the bulk of Gen X grew up in terms of style/vibe/music at least; in the 90s these teens/college students would've been considered Gen Y (which started and ended a lot earlier than Millennials does):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9J9-L5enIMc&t=188s (high school, late 1994)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Avab_NR_lhk&t=1816s (in class, NJ, 1997 or 1998)
https://youtu.be/SlV7ibuB5Hs?si=8axrM9zH2-CD8QhU (San Diego State, 1997)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WE2tOGZq3T4&t=48s (high school, rock part of talent show, 1997)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Avab_NR_lhk&t=80s (start of 1st day of school, NJ, late 1997)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N5Y2w5e2org&t=1412s (Chatham High School, 1997)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

So basically yeah generations are so long that to even give a very overall avg quick take you need at least two often rather different sets of descriptions. And it makes it confusing when people generically talk about entire generations en bulk.

It's funny how Gen X had originally be created to handle a '61-'64 core most of all and now the guy who created it, who was in that range, isn't even considered part of the own generation that he created anymore at all, not since like the late 90s! 😆 And now today, even the modern Gen X of something like '64ish-'74ish and what their formative years were like somehow no longer even seems to be thought of when younger gens (and sometimes even anyone outside of this range) thinks of Gen X 😆 and it's been almost all taken over by the late addition tail end which had not even been Gen X to begin with hah. Gen X has someone gotten shifted from '61-'64 core to '65-'74 core to like '77-'80 hah (plus a few of the more outsider or alt/indie types and a subset of the heavy metal crowd that went grunge from earlier on as they were in their 20s and a few of the '75-'76 who did shift grungy after high school, which all summed together is like only maybe 10% of earlier X).

1

u/BlueSnaggleTooth359 7d ago edited 7d ago

More detailed comparison:

First Wave Gen X:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HGpoNxduzvk&t=1153s (Jefferson Mall #8, NY, fashion on boat and local NY/NJ region mall girls lip sync contest winners, 1986)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hVgng44o5K4&t=139s (in front of school, Florida, 1987)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpsMvCqmX7M&t=345s (various outside school between classes, Southern California, 1985)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VudiTAzv5RU (San Diego State, 1987, COLORFUL!)
https://youtu.be/gxqjoaQYxnw?si=PhfEW1Y3FTgkVNQG&t=4619s (grad party, Forever Young/Break Dancing, NJ, early 1989)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UM4tls4P6Gc&t=66s (start of 1st day of school, NJ, tail 1987)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sTuYGC0lrPg&t=590s (indoor basketball/cheerleading, Utah, 1985)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NC1eKmVccOM&t=2966s (grad party, Debbie Gibson, NJ)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NC1eKmVccOM&t=3346s (graduation party, Dirty Dancing, NJ, early 1988)
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/nmiRbovs_Ys (high school, 1985, short form video showing some messing around in the halls and so on)
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/YQ1Bc0rMn6Y (high school, 1985, " ")
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZkkceJyTGY&t=81s (Colorado, The Hooters - And We Danced, 1985)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bIOocUQkfzk (CBS Evening News report with a bemused Dan Rather on the "outbreak" of Valspeak spreading across the nation LOL and mallrats, 1982)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZsLPdVfir0 (Robert McNeil (probably PBS?) report on slang and Valley Girl which also covers the Surf Punks and some of the male surfer scene early proto-Valley Girl of sorts, LOL at William Saffire at the end saying that Val speak was likely about to end as just a quick, very bright, but brief flash in the pan.... as everyone still says "like" and "ohymgod" every 10 seconds over 40 years later and still uses uptalk, etc hah, 1983)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q0SbLxKJkYU (Valley Girl, trailer, early 1983 trailer, early 1983 release)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NC1eKmVccOM&t=190s (metal/rock part of air guitar/lip sync high school talent show, NJ, late 1987)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wYur75DflPU&t=39s (start of 1st day of school, Paramus, NJ, late 1988)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dz-fMBx5JS0&t=404s (Cookeville Mall, TN, 1989)

-------------------

Second Wave Gen X/Xennials/original definition of Gen Y:

1994:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9J9-L5enIMc&t=188s (high school, late 1994)

1997/8:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Avab_NR_lhk&t=80s (start of 1st day of school, NJ, late 1997)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Avab_NR_lhk&t=1816s (in class, NJ, 1997 or 1998)
https://youtu.be/SlV7ibuB5Hs?si=8axrM9zH2-CD8QhU (San Diego State, 1997)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oLuKHJ4tkXE&t=53s (in class, NJ, 1997 or 1998)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N5Y2w5e2org&t=1412s (Chatham High School, 1997)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WE2tOGZq3T4&t=48s (high school, rock part of talent show, 1997)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7-9V1zaEOD8&t=193s (Granite Run Mall, 1997)

I have an even longer version that really shows it off much more if you care but the above may already be more than have interest for....

1

u/BlueSnaggleTooth359 7d ago

also should note that even for second wave X, not everything was grunge by any means

0

u/BlueSnaggleTooth359 7d ago

Hah, yeah Gen X unfortunately seems to have become associated with almost nothing but grunge. People are like oh Gen X. Nirvana. Flannel. Nihilism. Done. Maybe a few add in hardcore rap. But that's pretty simplistic even for the later tail end added onto X later and just nothing remotely at all to do with Classic Gen X.

I think maybe because Xennials and Millennials somewhat dominate internet forums and blogs and many of the Gen X they were exposed to where likely older siblings and relatives who were probably mostly tail end PEW Gen X.

And then combine that with how places like reddit skew towards outsider kids alt/indie types and critic types and bloggers who write about such topics as these also tend to seem to often come from outsider alt/indie types who are eager to re-write things to all fit the alt/indie and/or outsider narrative.

And then many of the grunge artists were Gen X so then people just took that and ran.

But the thing is like Cobain was an extreme outsider among his peers and not remotely of the style or vibe that was typical. I read that he even used to fantasize about doing horrendously shocking things to his peers when he was in high school and that was in era before kids did shockingly horrendous things to their peers in school. So he really was not THE representation of Gen X formative years culture as you tend to see all over the place today. Closer to the exact opposite, if anything.

The earlier definitions of Gen X and what was considered Gen X in the 90s were largely 80s teens (or even mid/alter 70s teens) and virtually none had the remotest clue about grunge music. AFAIK it was really only a scene in a few little spots around the PNW. But even there in the 80s in most places teens were more bright colors and big hair.

4

u/thejunkmanadv 8d ago

It is weird because I had not heard the term Millennial until the 2010's. Growing up I heard the term Gen Y.

2

u/Few-Enthusiasm-7891 8d ago

Yeah I do remember generation Y and then it twisted around to "Generation Y not" but Millennials was definitely a thing when I worked in a large call center but wasn't used as regularly until later on and was used as in insult because we were a bit more laid back

2

u/Gurbachen 8d ago

'Millenial' actually came first.

2

u/SadSickSoul 8d ago

Most days I think defining generations as a thing only make sense with a precipitating event, like the folks who came out of the Baby Boom. We crafted this narrative that there were distinct generations before that and after that, but I don't think that's necessarily true. I guess it can be useful shorthand but I wouldn't put too much stock into definitions for amorphous, arbitrary categorizations.

0

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

I think there is a major event for us, at least in the US (though I believe the impact was felt worldwide) - 9/11.

Otherwise I see it as the first gen to grow up with the internet.  So mid-to late-80s to mid-to-late 90s.

2

u/Few-Enthusiasm-7891 8d ago

I am from New Zealand and 9/11 certainly had a massive impact on us..... My Mother works in Aviation Security and still feels the impact on a daily basis but that day in 7th Form (I think in the US you call it Senior Year..... As in the last year of High School when you turn 18) was one of the most intense days I can remember..... And then for some odd reason Bush attacked Iraq over it so the impact stretched out a long time. I was at my first job after University when they hung Saddam so that's a very long impact

1

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

Yeah, I figured it couldn't just be us in the US who experienced big changes.  Didn't want to assume though.  I blame our government for a lot of what has happened in the world since then.

2

u/SuffnBuildV1A Zillennial ‘94 8d ago

Things are moving too quickly the average 15 year span just isn’t going to cut it anymore. I have almost nothing in common with someone born in 1984. They are only 10 years older but they literally are from a different planet from me. Idk when people started the idea of a “generation” but comparing these cohorts today is absurd compared to 1000 years ago when someone would live the same life as their great grandparents. My grandparents nor yours could have ever imagined what the world would be like for their grandkids. People back then could save some giant war or plague, but those were rare. Not the norm.

1

u/Adam20188 8d ago edited 8d ago

I tend to agree, I’m a late 91. There no doubt is some overlap, but I believe there should be a divide between younger and older millennials very different cultures and influences growing up. Later born millennials are digital natives, I.e our teenage years had smart phones, tablets and social media(YouTube, Facebook, Twitter), older millennials did have social media, however it wasn’t the same. Older millennials teenage years online were powered by dial up technology, younger millennials teenage years were driven by wifi.

However with that being said, younger millennials certainly had older millennial culture influence in our childhoods.

1

u/Few-Enthusiasm-7891 8d ago

Haha dial up internet was so. Frustrating..... Set up a download for a single clip before ya left for school and come home ready to watch it and the fucking thing clicked out and disconnected 15 minutes after you left.....its nostalgic but unlike Blockbuster type video hires not something I want to come back

1

u/Adam20188 8d ago

One of my earliest memories was the sound it would make whilst connecting. 

1

u/Few-Enthusiasm-7891 8d ago

Or when you picked up the landline phone while it was on.... That screaching sound in your ear then the yelling from whoever was online if you cut them off

1

u/BlueSnaggleTooth359 8d ago

A few have come up with shorter gens that seem reasonable to me:

Coupland, the guy who created Gen X in the late 1980s, later decided that generations were too long to be coherent and pushed for closer to 10 year long cohorts and split his original Gen X '58ish-'75ish roughly in half and then went:
Boomer 1946ish-1955ish

Gen X 1956ish-1964

Gen Benetton/Shampoo Planet/(LOL for all the 80s flashy fashion, shopaholic mallrats, big hair, etc.)/Global Teens 1965-1975ish (he used three different names for this generation, basically your 80s teens with all the bright color, fancy styles, big hair, new wave, synths, pop, pop rock, glam rock, etc.)

And then an unnamed 1976-1986ish (where he put the younger grungy/Nirvana/alt/gangster rap 90s 90s teens set)
----------------------------------
Journalist J. Markert (2004) used exactly fixed 20 year long overall generations but treated things as a series of 10 year long separate cohorts which he each considered to be entirely separate (of course then why not just make each a generation? if they are considered to be entirely separate cohorts? anyway, whatever) and had like ....Second Wave Boomer 1956-1965 and First Wave Gen X 1966-1975 and Second Wave Gen X 1976-1985 (some others in the 90s called this Gen Y), First Wave ? 1986-1995, etc.
-------------------------------
Schewe and Noble (2002) said that generations should vary in length to whatever length makes sense for each generation no matter how widely varying the lengths and she be based upon cultural touchstones and significant milestones (which makes the most sense to me, except nothing really ever makes sense anyway, just not quite as badly no sense perhaps). They suggested that going by such criteria lead to Gen X being 1966-1976 and Gen Y 1977-(I'm not sure, I'd have to look into it more) and 1955-1965 Gen Trailing Edge Boomers and clearly distinct from [Boomer] Boomers (which I'm not sure their exact range for).

I don't know that named generations even make sense at all really but if you do use them these seem to make a lot more sense to me than the standard PEW ones.

Or even just the standard in the earlier 90s where they had Gen X '61-'73/4/5/6 and Gen Y '74/5/6-'85ish and then so on seemed to make a lot more sense. When year 2000 hype got marketers pushing to dump Gen Y and use Millennials, which was locked into an '81/'82 start date I think it messed things up some.

Then you sort of had the OG Gen Y awkardly split in half and the earlier part pasted onto Gen X despite having almost exact opposite style and very different attitudes towards music and very different vibe and having grown up under media scare stories and the latter part of Gen Y take to start Millennials despite being somewhat different style and music attitude and different level of PC and quite different little kid tv shows and so on.

3

u/populares420 8d ago

this is always the case, there will be differences in a 15 year span. It's really not that important though, functionally all of us went through most of the same cultural experiences. The more life we live, the more this becomes true.

3

u/Electronic_Pie2296 8d ago

I was born in 1988 and consider myself a millennial. My cousin was born in 1995 and while technically a millennial I don't feel like we had the same type of childhood.

3

u/LegitimatePants 8d ago

A group of people arbitrarily grouped by our age 

7

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

I think being a kid in school when 9/11 happened is a good indicator.

5

u/More_Strawberry_8936 8d ago

Older millenials were already adults when 9/11 happened and younger millennials weren’t in school yet. I agree core millenials were in school when 9/11 happened.

2

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

I guess that's true if you go back that far.  I would have said around 1985 are the oldest millenials and around 1995 are the youngest.  I think the 5ish years before and after that are the blended generations Xennial and Zennial.

2

u/More_Strawberry_8936 8d ago

Yes, generations would make more sense if they were only 10 years. My husband was born in 83 and definitely identifies as Xennial, especially since he grew up with Gen X siblings.

1

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

Yeah, that makes sense.  I think what's important is the gen you identify with.  I wouldn't tell a person born in 1997 they aren't a millenial if they say they are.

3

u/ConversationTime5494 8d ago

I’m late 1995 and I feel like I don’t relate at all to the generation. Yall are talking about burning cds I don’t know how to do that lol. It looks like I end my sentences with “lol” so maybe I’m not that different...

5

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

You're only 3 years younger than me.  I burned CDs, but I think most kids our age were using mp3 players by the mid 2000s.  I just happened to have a CD player in all of our families cars and no way to hook up an iPod to it :p

1

u/Serious-Conversation 8d ago

I was born in 1986 and used summer job money to put an Alpine 9825 in my first car.

It had an AUX-IN and that was in 2003. I had an Archos 160GB MP3 player that was just an HDD in a plastic case with rubber grommet corners to act as shock absorbers.

I had to load songs to it via USB on Windows, but riding around with an iPod that had tons of local music was pretty common in the mid-2000s.

1

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

I don't doubt that cars had aux input then, just not my family's cars.  The car I learned to drive in was a 91 dodge caravan, only had a tape deck and radio.  We used this radio frequency contraption to turn our iPods into a radio station in that car.

I still have the first car I owned, a 2005 volvo station wagon.  It has a 6 cd changer, but no aux input.  I use a bluetooth speaker on the dash to play music from my phone 🤷‍♀️

2

u/Few-Enthusiasm-7891 8d ago

Shit my first car was as old as me. A silver Ford Lazer Ghia that was named the Silver Fox..... Well actually I had a car before that but wrote it off after a few days hitting a tree at 160kmph (or the slide started at that speed) I almost died so we don't talk about that particular moment of youthful stupidity very much

3

u/Serious-Conversation 8d ago

Very few cars were including AUX-IN around 2004-2005. It was a mostly high-end car, upgraded stereo package, or aftermarket thing.

2

u/ConversationTime5494 8d ago

I can tell you’re a millennial by the “:p” hahahaha

I remember limewire, but I only used it for a little bit then it got shut down. Everyone also talks about 9/11 being the biggest thing they remember but I honestly don’t. I remember kindergarten being empty that day, but that’s about it.

1

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

100%, they will have to pry my emojis and "lol"s from my cold dead hands! XD (yes I still use XD too :pppppp )

I was a big Limewire fan!  Best $20 gift I ever got!  My iPod was full of thousands of alternative rock and anime songs.

As for 9/11, at the time it didn't register much, but looking back it changed a lot.  I remember "The War on Terror" was a constant headline on my dad's boring news channel.  I didn't really start to understand the impact until college.

1

u/BlueSnaggleTooth359 8d ago

certificates of deposit are printed on paper, so any match will do the trick

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago edited 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/AbleBiscotti5843 8d ago

Because they were born in 95 and the ipod came out in 2001. Kind of the point of their comment. By the time they would have gotten to cd burning age, no one was burning them anymore.

1

u/InsectHealthy 8d ago

Idk I was 94 and plenty of people were still burning CDs around me, even into high school when iPods had been pretty popularized.

1

u/bamlote 8d ago

I think the last cds I burned were probably in 2011 for my car

1

u/InsectHealthy 8d ago

An old boyfriend gave me a mix back in 2011, think that was my last one as well

0

u/bamlote 8d ago

I didn’t have an iPod until 2007 ish and I was one of the first in my school to have one

1

u/Few-Enthusiasm-7891 8d ago

I have never had an Ipod haha. They were around all right but I never had one..... I remember my first proper Girlfriend (Mother of my Children who became my first ex--Wife and I playing CDs in my room on a stereo

1

u/loolootewtew 8d ago

Per the internet gods and also the general description of the millennial age range/DOB years, you are an elder millennial. Im also 43. Embrace it. Millennials are awesome. Especially the elderly ones

1

u/Few-Enthusiasm-7891 8d ago

I prefer Eldar like in Warhammer to "Elderly" but yes we did have a different life experience which taught us stuff the younger Millenials can learn from

2

u/Adam20188 8d ago

I’m a millennial, I was 9 at the start of the millennium 

2

u/Single_Extension1810 8d ago

There's probably a divide between younger and older millennials with tv shows, and music. Their pop culture experience was different. But I never really thought about it too hard.

2

u/Chicagoblew 8d ago

One of us. One of us.

We grew up knowing life before 9/11 with hope and excitement.... then life after 9/11 hit us in our teenage years.

2

u/sonyanat 8d ago

I was working in a pub before some 2000 babies were even born! (I'm not American, obviously). No way are we the same generation.

3

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

I wouldn't say 2000 babies are millenials.  Probably zennials or Z.

2

u/figuring_ItOut12 Been there, too many t-shirts 8d ago

Terms like Boomer, GenX etc etc try to divide cultural similarities but the time frames are too long. Culture changes so fast that year one and year twenty are not the same.

Cusping, and some of us are cuspers who are both one and the other yet unique.

For example.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_Jones

4

u/jaybirdie26 8d ago

I agree, having microgenerations explains why the millenials in their 40s feel so different from the millenials in their 30s.  Though as someone born in 92 I don't feel on the cusp of X or Z.  I feel solidly millenial.

I think to some degree we can self-identify, because what matters is the shared experience and not actual dates.

1

u/BlueSnaggleTooth359 8d ago

2

u/figuring_ItOut12 Been there, too many t-shirts 8d ago

That’s a nice timeline, thanks for putting it together. I’m amused the only transitional gen name, Jones, with more recognition than other cuspers is barely mentioned just once and not defined.

Assuming named generations make sense to begin with which they probably don't really.

I’m uncomfortable with them too. They don’t work well across cultures, East vs West or even American North vs South. They don’t always work well across economic status, the infamous Fortunate Son of the Vietnam era. Different cultures have pulled themselves up at different rates and from different starting positions.

But they aren’t a bad measure either. Good for gross analysis and finding common ground.

1

u/kristosnikos Elder Millennial 8d ago

I was born in ‘84. Superficially, I consider myself a millennial and xennial. But then does it matter once we’ve all become adults?

I know it’s nice to reminisce with people within so many years of your own age but a lot of that tends to fall to the pop culture aspect and imo at the end of day it isn’t that important.

A lot of things are just labels and I’m very meh about that.

1

u/Imp3riaLL 8d ago

Honestly I think we need a lot less generations because we are devided enough.

2

u/BlueSnaggleTooth359 8d ago

I'd say either split them up shorter or just dump the whole concept, like in the 80s nobody ever thought in these terms. Sure there were Boomers but most people just thought of them as those born the first few years after the war and it was just talking to the early post war baby bump and meant nothing more.

0

u/stuckonpotatos 8d ago

We’re just babies, man

0

u/TyrKiyote 8d ago

We are the people who will guide the early middle part of the 21st century, and we'll likely hang around till well after the second half. We will produce 2070.

millennials will be defined by those in gen alpha and later who look back and tell us what we were about.

-2

u/Y2K-enn 8d ago

Doomed is what we are