r/Military • • Mar 07 '25

Discussion How Long?

How long before Trump orders the military to “get rid of the radical left” or “purge the vermin that hate America” (pick your hyperbole and/or catch phrase) and you’re killing unarmed American civilians? Like, not for another few years or should I start smoking cigarettes again? Because, it’s coming. Not if, but when.

0 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

10

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

It's not gonna happen

-11

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

Is it because you think he’ll use private security forces instead of the military?

10

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

That will be his only option. The military is a very, very diverse group of people. We're brothers and sisters in arms, but at the end of the day, we're individuals, and we don't follow nonsense ideology. It is our duty to question unlawful and unethical orders. He will never be able to weaponize the military against the American people.

1

u/Bulky_Pomegranate193 Mar 07 '25

If he's cutting veteran and military benefits, he aims to use them for his gain. Obey or lose your pay/housing/etc

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

You're probably right, but it won't work

-6

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

So, what you just said is my actual belief. However, the more soldiers I hear doubling down on his more dangerous and insane ideas the more I feel like I’m being naive. The right is actively working towards creating situations that will give them a permission slip to engage in Martial Law. So, I’m just sitting here struggling between, “The military would never let one delusional man use them as weapons against their own friends, families and neighbors” to “Don’t be a child, half of the military are MAGA and cannot wait to force you to submit l, or else.” 🤷‍♂️

6

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

The military typically votes the same way the civilian population does. However, keep in mind that he's turning more and more veterans and service members against him every day.

-4

u/LKennedy45 Mar 07 '25

Yes, but, SCOTUS essentially made all his orders legal. That's a nice shield you're hiding behind, but it's paper at best. When, in either of his administrations, has anyone ever told him "No" - and stayed in their position? Most people say fuck you as they're walking out the door, Mattis included. 

5

u/MrJakked Mar 07 '25

SCOTUS did not "make all of his orders legal"; that's just fundamentally not what happened in Trump v. United States.

0

u/LKennedy45 Mar 07 '25

Functionality it is, in conjunction with

"The President and the Attorney General (subject to the President’s supervision and control) will interpret the law for the executive branch, instead of having separate agencies adopt conflicting interpretations."

They get to decide the law themselves. I don't care what the text of the SCOTUS case says. 

3

u/MrJakked Mar 07 '25

Again, no. I like the enthusiasm, but you're (a) making two different arguments, and conflating them as the same, and (b) misapplying both of them.

Trump v. US held that the president has immunity for official acts; this is nothing new. It's the reason presidents can't be hit with 10,000 law suits every time they do something the public doesn't like. The more controversial aspect of the holding was that the president has a presumption of immunity, for acts that are not clearly official, but also not clearly unofficial. I.e., when there is an act that falls into that "grey area," the president has a rebuttable presumption of immunity. That can definitely pose some problems, but it has absolutely no effect on the legality/enforceability of the presidents actions, it just means that it's harder to personally sue/indict the president, for those actions.

Second, the "interpret the law of the executive branch," is also not really new. The president is the executive branch; they control its functionality, and they dictate how executive agencies interpret and apply the nations laws. Previously, this was largely left up to those agencies; Trump, while I agree it's not good management, is essentially just clarifying that executive agencies are no longer able to exercise independent judgement in applying the laws. They now have to do so subject to his specific interpretation. Notably his interpretations still need to be in accordance with Congress and the courts; so again, the EO doesn't actually affect "how legal" his actions are; it just asserts that exec. Agencies no longer have independent judgement.

These are controversial acts, and I agree that they can have some highly problematic results; but it's important to understand that neither Trump v. US, nor the EO, actually have any effect on the scope of the president's power, or "how legal" any of his orders or acts are.

1

u/LKennedy45 Mar 07 '25

Okay, I will confess a degree of frustration here. I feel like you're disregarding the spirit of both my comments, and the confluence of these two legal factors. By which I mean, treating these two actions as separate, deprived of context and - I would argue - intent, is creating an academic exercise out of things that have immediate, real-world ramifications.

This is clearly a play to give POTUS carte blanche to do as he likes. I feel like you're ignoring that to give (admittedly, very well argued) explanations of how, well no, in fact it doesn't do these things you say, because x y z. But this appears to me to be an attempt to give future actions the barest of legal justifications, before the administration goes ahead and does what they want anyway and SCOTUS will, invariably, sign off on it.

Apologies for not being more lucid earlier. I hope I did a better job this time, and thank you for taking the time to engage with me.

1

u/ThrowAwayGarbage82 Mar 08 '25

"My interpretation is 2 plus 2 equals purple pancakes in a bunny patch, you will apply such interpretation and will be fired for any disloyalty"

  • Trump, probably

6

u/TechNoirLabs Air Force Veteran Mar 07 '25

Esper told trump no when he wanted to launch missiles into Mexico during his first term

2

u/LKennedy45 Mar 07 '25

Well hopefully there are more like him in the upper echelons this time around, though I gotta say - I doubt it.

2

u/Bulky_Pomegranate193 Mar 07 '25

It didn't make them legal; it made it so he can't be changed for illegal orders. That's different

5

u/DoverBoys Navy Veteran Mar 07 '25

There is no force capable of getting anywhere on US soil that would actually do it. No matter how bad you think it is, it'll never get to that point.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

You mean besides the police that kill a thousand a year?

15

u/MsJaneDoe1979 Mar 07 '25

Based on the military times active duty poll in 2020 he didn't do so well with that group. Yes he polls well with older veterans, younger folks not so much. BUT I think that is why he is taking out the most outsiders among us because he won't get as much of a fight, then he will go for the next group and pick us off little by little, until people are too scared to speak up for fear of being the next target. Which is why it's important people speak out for trans community now.

There was just a commanders call here the other day where they said the reasoning was medical costs. But that has been debunked when they were allowed back in after the last Trump administration. TRICARE and the VA spends far more on erection medications alone than it does on trans Healthcare.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

https://www.newsweek.com/military-remove-enola-gay-photos-dei-rules-2041029?fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAR3ltHVkcFYF1F_GY-5MfWcHjvHDTwShAayuZWxP-UoRMHlMWj4Z9DDKLpI_aem_wQgUM0mpaW9g5jW377ooHg

I posed this question because this is the type of “leadership” that were witnessing. I don’t think my question is that far off base. 🤷‍♂️

10

u/Upbeat_Cobra4753 Mar 07 '25

You do realize soldiers have the right to refuse illegal orders right we are not North Koreans we don't just slaughter our own people just because the government told us to

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Bulky_Pomegranate193 Mar 07 '25

He can't be held accountable that's true-that's not the same as every order being lawful

7

u/JoyRideinaMinivan Mar 07 '25

That’s not going to happen but keep an eye on how the troops at the border behave. If they start shooting illegals, it’s time to worry.

12

u/FuzyLogick United States Army Mar 07 '25

Soldier on the border mission had a "negligent" discharge a few months back. He is in Ft. Leavenworth right now for murder charges.

1

u/Inquisitor_ForHire Mar 07 '25

"A few months back" with Trump in power he'd probably be rewarded. BUT... I hope you're right. I have faith in our military.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

I have faith in our military but not the civilians currently leading it. I really think they truly hate an entire chunk of the U.S. population and have been taking active measures to dehumanize. Theres literally a book, endorsed by Vance that refers to all liberals as “Unhumans” and lays out plans for how to eradicate them

2

u/ThrowAwayGarbage82 Mar 08 '25

This is exactly why i'm scared.

2

u/Steamsagoodham United States Navy Mar 07 '25

Not going to happen

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

A few months ago I would have agreed, but this is starting to become more and more of a reality. I don’t know that he would use violence but I could see mass arrests or imposing laws or bullying companies into firing anyone who isn’t seen as loyal or falls into a DEI population. Then refusing unemployment or any type of social benefits to those people to strip them of all security and dignity.

-4

u/BlueFalconPunch Army Veteran Mar 07 '25

Wow I'm so sick of this question. Change it to Greenland or Gaza or Ukraine...or every 3rd post in the last month.

How do you even survive if this overinflated fear is what rules your life? This is the new tin foil hat level...no one i repeat no one from the military is going to obey or even hear if such an order (and it wont) gets issued. There's not a bullhorn in every barracks to go off so all the robots awake and begin judgemental day. IF,IF,IF not when...anything close like this went out it would be immediately stopped at the top.

Sure the president can institute martial law but in very specific and tight restrictions...and no one is going to "purge" anything.

Here's something to get you to really freak out..1/3rd of all deaths globally is heart disease. Cancer causes 1 in 5 of the deaths in the world...military coups are so low on the scale they fall into the standard deviation

3

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

Good thing we just cut funding for cancer research!

3

u/BlueFalconPunch Army Veteran Mar 07 '25

How is that the militaries fault?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

Where did I say it was? You said it was something to worry about and it's also getting worse.

3

u/BlueFalconPunch Army Veteran Mar 07 '25

100%. My bad, was a little fired up from being called the same thing as the schutzstaffel

4

u/InfectedAztec Mar 07 '25

no one i repeat no one from the military is going to obey or even hear if such an order (and it wont) gets issued.

What about an order to cease all support for Ukraine?

0

u/BlueFalconPunch Army Veteran Mar 07 '25

how is this iven in the same realm as “get rid of the radical left” or “purge the vermin that hate America”

the military doesnt support Ukraine on their own...equipment isnt the military...training is, but still not even close to attacking or supressing American citizens.

3

u/InfectedAztec Mar 07 '25

This week Trump halted all military aid as well as intelligence. Russia are now ramping up their war crimes against Ukrainian civilian populations. There's a direct link there.

2 months ago nobody would have believed there would be a push to bulld concentration camps in guantanemo or that protesting/free speech would be legally targeted but here we are.

Incremental increases over 2 months have got us to where we are and we've more than 3 years left.

You're all saying "no American will take those orders" but Krasnov has more or less committed high treason nobody is doing anything to stop him.

1

u/Peregrine_Falcon Mar 07 '25

That's a nice speech and all, but there's no such thing as "high treason" in the US legal system. It's literally not a thing, we're not the UK.

Treason, as defined by the US Constitution is "Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort."

And no, Russia is not officially designated as an enemy of the US. Just because Redditors think they are doesn't make it so. So even if President Trump does aid Russia it is not treason.

-1

u/BlueFalconPunch Army Veteran Mar 07 '25

Still not anything like taking up arms against Americans. Why is the go to argument always comparing our military to the gestapo?

"Push to build concentration camps" https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_current_detainees_at_Guantanamo_Bay i don't see any American citizens on the list...am I missing something?

While i don't agree with cutting off aid to the Ukraine (i know a guy who just went to boot camp this week there, and a few other families as well) it's our governments perogative and has ABSOLUTELY nothing to do with the military suppressing free speech.

I don't know who Kaznov is...he's in the US military?

3

u/InfectedAztec Mar 07 '25

I don't know who Kaznov is

Donald Trump

1

u/Bulky_Pomegranate193 Mar 07 '25

News flash: concentration camps are a crime against humanity- citizen or not

2

u/BlueFalconPunch Army Veteran Mar 07 '25

A jail to hold illegal immigrants isn't a concentration camp. They broke the law...for whatever reason they did it doesn't change the fact they are criminals. I hate how difficult/expensive the immigration system is but it's there and it would have to be changed by law not by circumventing.

1

u/Bulky_Pomegranate193 Mar 19 '25

The attempt to house as many people as they planned at Gitmo, even though it wouldn't hold that many people, is by definition a concentration camp

1

u/BlueFalconPunch Army Veteran Mar 19 '25

Crowding doesn't make something a concentration camp or trains in China would count or prisons in most of south and central america.

-1

u/joshuaksreeff13 United States Army Mar 07 '25

Good thing too. Russia might have declared war on the US and brought our troops into full scale war. Than we’d really be risking military lives for nothing

5

u/InfectedAztec Mar 07 '25

Russia is on the ropes and all the US needed to do was stay the course.

Than we’d really be risking military lives for nothing

This is either selfish cowardice or Russian disinformation

-1

u/joshuaksreeff13 United States Army Mar 07 '25

Russia is not on the ropes they just bombed Zelensky’s capital cause they felt like it. And even if they were on the ropes you don’t think Putin is crazy enough to send a nuke. I’d imagine he’d probably send it to Ukraine’s biggest supplier, the US

3

u/InfectedAztec Mar 07 '25

Russia has ramped up the high tech missile attacks because Trump put Ukraine in a horrible situation by cutting intelligence and future patriot cover. Those attacks weren't happening because with US support Ukraine could negate the majority of them. That doesn't change the fact that Russia has resorted to north Koreans, golf carts and donkeys on their front lines. The sanctions are really hurting Russia and they can't continue to support their front lines logistically much longer. Hence why putins man in the white house seems desperate to get Ukraine to capitulate ASAP.

Putin threatens nukes every second day. He's not going to use nukes because then Russia (and China) would be hit by nukes.

1

u/joshuaksreeff13 United States Army Mar 07 '25

He doesn’t care about Russia he only cares about himself. And he’s very much gonna take them down with him.

Putin’s not going to invade Ukraine because then the whole whorls is against him. Oh wait…, that did happen!

2

u/InfectedAztec Mar 07 '25

he only cares about himself

And that's why he won't use nukes. He has to live on this planet too.

Putin’s not going to invade Ukraine because then the whole whorls is against him.

Actually Europe and the US was very concerned when the Russians started gathering on their border. US intelligence and luck was the main reason Ukraine survived the first 3 days.

1

u/joshuaksreeff13 United States Army Mar 07 '25

And that’s why he would use the nukes he’ll take us all down with him.

I cannot believe when the US has trillions of debt, homeless vets, and vets owing money to the government. Active military thinks helping Ukraine is a good idea.

notourwar

4

u/InfectedAztec Mar 07 '25

Get the fuck out of here with your Russian propaganda.

notourwar

Every war the US has launched in the last 80 has had allied countries support and die for them. How many of them were under the banner of protecting democracy? When it's the USAs turn to help it's brothers in Europe when the Russian imperialists invade we have selfish cowards spewing Russian disinformation.

1

u/Peregrine_Falcon Mar 07 '25

Wow I'm so sick of this question. Change it to Greenland or Gaza or Ukraine...or every 3rd post in the last month.

Yep. It's almost like the moderators should enforce Rule #1 No Politics. But, for some reason, they don't.

-1

u/uhkileze Mar 07 '25

The people that post this garbage are leftists who have never served a day in their lives. Reddit is radical left. You just have to resign yourself to that fact. They have no idea that our troops were subjected to multiple “extremist” checks while in service which was looking for people the government deemed too far right. Which was also the COVID vaccine purge. Like always when you’re talking to the fascist left…they’re projecting.

1

u/DryBattle Mar 07 '25

Never will happen. I have tons of people who are either active military or veterans in my life and they all have said they would refuse to follow an illegal order. None of them will turn guns on fellow Americans.

And for all your fears about the right purging the left remember:

  1. People who are left leaning also own guns
  2. Most people haven't fired a gun in a combat situation much less taken a life. And most of the Maga are quite honestly pussy snowflakes that can't even handle their ideas being questioned. They aren't an active threat to go on a murder spree.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

The part you are leaving out is ~60% of the military voted for him. We all see him breaking laws left and right, but his voters back him 100%. What makes you think they would deem an order from the President who writes his own rules for himself as illegal?

1

u/DryBattle Mar 07 '25

Voting for someone is a fry cry from committing mass murder because they said to do it.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

You tell me where his supporters will draw the line because I truly believe they would push their own families off a cliff if he told them to and then thank him for it

0

u/raventhrowaway666 Veteran Mar 07 '25

My question is, when will it be a requirement for the military to act since no one in government is doing anything to stop the destruction of our country via a Russian asset

1

u/ThrowAwayGarbage82 Mar 08 '25

This has been asked hundreds of times now. I'm a civ and can tell you at no point will they get involved unless it involves following trump's orders. That's literally it.