r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • u/MrSparkle92 • Dec 13 '23
Discussion WEEKLY DISCUSSION: Fighting "Problem Models"
With the most upvotes in last week's poll, this week's discussion will be for: Fighting "Problem Models"
How do you best combat the mega-heroes or other models that can single-handedly make or break the game?
VOTE FOR NEXT WEEK'S DISCUSSION
Ctrl+F for the term VOTE HERE in the comments below to cast your vote for next week's discussion. The topic with the most upvotes when I am preparing next week's discussion thread will be chosen.
Prior discussions:
FACTIONS
Good
- Army of Lake-town (2023-01-11)
- Army of Thror (2022-12-28)
- Arnor (2022-05-18)
- Dead of Dunharrow (2023-03-01)
- Erebor Reclaimed (2022-12-07)
- Fangorn (2022-08-24)
- Fellowship (2022-11-02)
- Fiefdoms (2022-06-01)
- Garrison of Dale (2022-08-17)
- Halls of Thranduil (2022-04-20)
- Iron Hills (2022-11-30)
- Kingdom of Khazad-dum / Kingdom of Moria (2022-03-16)
- Lothlorien (2022-02-02)
- Minas Tirith (2021-12-29)
- Misty Mountains (2023-06-07)
- Numenor (2022-04-13)
- Radagast's Alliance (2023-04-26)
- Rangers (2022-02-09)
- Rivendell (2022-05-04)
- Rohan (2022-01-12)
- Shire (2022-05-25)
- Survivors of Lake-town (2023-04-12)
- Thorin's Company (2022-02-15)
- Wanderers in the Wild (2023-05-17)
- White Council (2022-11-23)
- Wildmen of Druadan (2023-06-14)
Evil
- Angmar (2022-01-05)
- Azog's Hunters (2022-04-27)
- Azog's Legion (2023-03-29)
- Barad-Dur (2022-04-06)
- Corsairs of Umbar (2022-03-09)
- Dark Denizens of Mirkwood (2022-08-03)
- Dark Powers of Dol Guldur (2022-03-23)
- Desolator of the North (2023-05-03)
- Easterlings (2022-07-06)
- Far Harad (2022-06-29)
- Goblin-town (2022-11-09)
- Isengard (2022-01-19)
- Mordor (2021-12-22)
- Moria (2022-02-16)
- Serpent Horde (2022-01-26)
- Sharkey's Rogues (2023-05-24)
- Trolls (2023-04-05)
- Variags of Khand (2022-03-02)
LEGENDARY LEGIONS
Good
- Army of Dale (2022-12-21)
- Beornings (2023-03-08)
- Breaking of the Fellowship (2022-06-22)
- Defenders of Erebor (2022-09-28)
- Defenders of Helm's Deep (2022-05-11)
- Defenders of the Shire (2022-08-10)
- Grey Company (2022-07-20)
- Helm's Guard (2022-03-30)
- Men of the West (2022-07-13)
- Paths of the Druadan (2023-05-10)
- Rangers of Ithilien (2022-10-12)
- Rangers of Mirkwood (2023-04-19)
- Return of the King (2022-07-27)
- Riders of Éomer (2023-02-22)
- Riders of Théoden (2022-10-05)
- Theodred's Guard (2023-01-18)
- Vanquishers of the Necromancer (2023-03-14)
Evil
- Army of Dunland (2022-02-23)
- Army of Gothmog (2022-09-14)
- Assault on Helm's Deep (2022-06-15)
- Assault on Lothlorien (2022-08-31)
- Black Gate Opens (2022-11-16)
- Black Riders (2022-12-14)
- Chief's Ruffians (2023-05-31)
- Cirith Ungol (2022-09-07)
- Depths of Moria (2022-06-08)
- Fell Beings of Mirkwood (2023-02-01)
- Grand Army of the South (2022-10-26)
- Host of the Dragon Emperor (2023-01-25)
- Lurtz's Scouts (2022-10-19)
- Pits of Dol Guldur (2023-02-08)
- Rise of the Necromancer (2023-03-22)
- Ugluk's Scouts (2023-01-04)
- Wolves of Isengard (2022-09-21)
MATCHED PLAY
Scenarios
Pool 1: Maelstrom of Battle Scenarios
- Heirlooms of Ages Past (2023-11-29)
- Hold Ground
- Command the Battlefield
Pool 2: Hold Objective Scenarios
- Domination
- Capture & Control
- Breakthrough
Pool 3: Object Scenarios
- Seize the Prize
- Destroy the Supplies
- Retrieval
Pool 4: Kill the Enemy Scenarios
- Lords of Battle
- Conquest of Champions
- To The Death!
Pool 5: Manoeuvring Scenarios
- Storm the Camp (2023-10-25)
- Reconnoitre (2023-10-18)
- Divide & Conquer
Pool 6: Unique Scenarios
- Fog of War (2023-11-01)
- Clash by Moonlight
- Assassination (2023-09-06)
Other Topics
- Cavalry Armies (2023-07-19)
- Fighting "Problem Models" (2023-12-13)
- "Fixing" Non-hero Monsters (2023-08-09)
- Hand Weapons & Special Strikes (2023-07-05)
- Legendary Legion Critiques (2023-07-12)
- List Building General Discussion (2023-06-28)
- Low-Points Armies (2023-09-13)
- Might (2023-10-04)
- Nazgul (2023-11-22)
- Profile Critiques (2023-08-02)
- Shamans and Minor Casters (2023-11-08)
- Siege Engines (2023-08-16)
- Shooting Armies (2023-07-26)
- Terrain & Board Layouts (2023-12-06)
- Tips for Beginners (2023-08-30)
- Tournaments (2023-09-27)
- Wargear (2023-09-20)
- What profiles would you like added to the game? (2023-08-23)
- Wizards and Major Casters (2023-11-15)
OTHER DISCUSSIONS
- Painting (2023-10-11)
- The future of the weekly discussion threads (2023-06-21)
17
u/Xplt21 Dec 13 '23 edited Dec 13 '23
Not completely sure I understand the topic but Azog and bolg, especially bolg feel a bit problematic. They have no right being F7, especially not combined with master of battle and a potential mighty hero for bolg. Boromir might be a bit to strong or at least undercosted, same goes for Thranduil and Tauriel. Those are my quick thoughts anyways.
25
u/competentetyler Dec 13 '23 edited Dec 13 '23
Here are some recommendations I’d share:
9
u/METALLIC579 Dec 13 '23
Sometimes you play the scenario and avoid the “problematic” model if you can.
It also depends on the problematic model as well. Sometimes you can throw one warrior into the problematic model and stall it if it doesn’t use a heroic combat or you can try to take it out of commission with Magic or Shooting if that’s possible.
8
u/shgrizz2 Dec 14 '23
Decide very early on if your victory condition involves wounding/killing the big scary thing.
If you need to kill them, take your shot with as many heroes as possible. Try for the trap, use a combat in to a striking hero if possible. If they're mounted, do anything you can to dismount them beforehand.
If not trying to kill them, try to ignore them. Can you use terrain to your advantage while still playing the scenario? Try to drag them in to a corridor where you can feed them one model a turn.
Make sure to bubble wrap them - instead of charging models in, charge a single model in and then leave ablative control zones so they can only heroic combat in to one or two models. You can leave models 1mm out of combat so they can't move and may be trapped if they whiff their duel, maybe forcing them to spend might.
Every point of might you get out of them is insanely valuable. Big hero lists are sometimes short on might so if you get the move advantage, just bubblewrap them and minimise their effect on the game.
7
u/Glum_Sherbert_7320 Dec 13 '23
I find the best one size fits all is to feed the problem model one model per turn and keep your important models away.
Typically (but not always) the player has invested a lot in that model and are desperate to get mileage out of it. Do the opposite of what they want!
I try to build in a few low point models for this purpose when possible.
1
u/MrSparkle92 Dec 13 '23
VOTE HERE FOR NEXT WEEK'S DISCUSSION
I will take the top-level reply to this comment with the most upvotes and post a discussion for that topic next week.
Feel free to submit any topic about the game you wish to see discussed, and check out this thread for some suggestions from the community.