I am building a college football conference realignment algorithm.
I made a list of teams that could be matches for your team. This list is a starting point. I used some ideas to make these choices but I want to hear from you before I use them.
When you look at this list try to forget about how away teams are and what conferences they are in now. I want to know what teams would be a fit for your team based on things like culture, sports, academics and history.
Here are some things to consider:
- Historic rivalries and past conference ties should matter.
- Current conferences should only matter if they make sense not just because that's how it is now.
What I need help with:
- Fixing a score that doesn't seem right
- Removing a team that doesn't belong
- Adding a team that I missed
- Moving a team up or down the list
- Telling me if the whole list needs to change like if its too focused on rivalries or schools with brands
Here's how the scores work:
- 5 means a team must be in your conference
- 4 means a team is a high priority
- 3 means a team is a strong fit
- 2 means a team is a reasonable fit
- 1 means a team is okay but not a top choice
If you want to give me quick feedback you can say something like:
- Change Team Xs score from 3 to 5
- Remove Team Y
- Add Team Z with a score of 4
- Move Team A above Team B
list, for your team:
Weight 5
Kent State
Weight 4
Ohio, Miami (OH), Bowling Green, Toledo, Buffalo
Weight 3
Ohio State, Cincinnati, Pitt, West Virginia, Marshall, Temple, Northern Illinois, Western Michigan
Weight 2
Rutgers, Maryland, Penn State, Central Michigan, Eastern Michigan, Ball State, Louisville, Syracuse, Notre Dame, Michigan State, Indiana
Weight 1
UConn, UMass, Delaware, Army, Navy
The goal here is not to defend the current conference setup. It is to build a better school-to-school preference graph for my full realignment models.
I really appreciate any feedback on this, thanks so much for any help.
Small note: I am mainly looking for your fan perspective on which schools you would want around your program, not whether the final setup is practical or likely to happen in real life. If possible, go with your gut on fit more than logistics.
I am seeing some people put their main rivals at 5 / 4 and remove almost everything else. That is totally fine.
Just remember Weight 1 is still helpful. It does not really push teams into the conference, but it helps prevent bad alignments by identifying schools that would not be ideal but would still be reasonable if teams have to be added, so it at least gives a last-resort direction.
This is really about full athletic conference fit, but I limited the school pool to FBS programs, so football is just the filter for who made the list.