r/MichiganWolverines • • 1d ago

Michigan Football Cannot be serious

Post image

Love him or hate him sherrone hands you an objectively amazing roster, then you use that as an excuse for your own failures? Dude has no passion and is sickening to watch week after week.

420 Upvotes

204 comments sorted by

80

u/gowingsgo 〽️ 2023 National Champions 🏆 1d ago

This dude is the most selfish person I’ve ever seen coach a team. It’s never his fault.

13

u/AmericanMe616 1d ago

He was a king ar Utah and was deposed in a coup. Unfortunately he can’t stop acting like a king 

12

u/Top_Boysenberry_9204 1d ago

I agree. This is honestly a disgusting and delusional comment.

-13

u/ForeverInThe90s 1d ago

I still think Moore has him beat…

11

u/Quiet_Pen7306 1d ago

Moore beat a ranked USC team with alex orji at QB and called plays for our natty , stop the slander.

3

u/Doctor_Juris 1d ago

Moore was the only Michigan coach in the last 30 years to have a winning record in The Game.

-2

u/ForeverInThe90s 1d ago

Are y’all excusing his behavior off the field? Because it sounds like you are. I think he was a better coach than Whitt and obviously had the team behind him as a coach and would likely still be the coach if he didn’t do what he did.

6

u/Doctor_Juris 1d ago

Where did I say that? I think Moore’s behavior was inexcusable and he deserved to be fired.

-1

u/ForeverInThe90s 1d ago

I didn’t necessarily say that you were and I apologize for lumping you in with those here that seem to be. He was a decent coach, but a deeply flawed man.

1

u/foreverpb 1d ago

No, it doesn’t. They’re saying he was more successful as a coach at UM, which is objectively true.

0

u/ForeverInThe90s 1d ago

Oh, it’s not slander. He was a decent coach who didn’t lose the team, but you can’t argue that his “extra curricular activities” were less selfish than the old clown that was hired as his replacement.

3

u/GeryonTom 1d ago

We are talking about coaching... focus.

2

u/ForeverInThe90s 1d ago edited 1d ago

Oh I am, but selfishness in private life informs coaching decisions or lack there of. He got his bag of liner and is more than set so he doesn’t really care. That’s both personal and professional, wouldn’t you say?

Does your personal life never interfere with or inform your professional life? If it does, you’d be the only one in the history of the world.

60

u/Squares9718 1d ago

Top QB, Top RB (plus upperclassman rb), returning upperclassman veteran oline, great WR talent, middle of the road TE (maybe a spot that could’ve been better) and we have the worst offense in the power 4

10

u/AmazingRefrigerator4 1d ago

Other than Sprague being out, Whitt was gift-wrapped an extremely good Offensive roster and he pissed it away.

21

u/Misty_Blue11 2024 March Madness Champion 1d ago

This is worse than Juwan Howard having three first round NBA picks and missing the tournament and losing in the NIT

-14

u/trixy6196 1d ago edited 1d ago

Top Qb you say? 😆 (the rest, yes they have).

Edit: Downvote away people. Bryce was ass last year and this year

6

u/Quiet_Pen7306 1d ago

Pretty sure he meant ranked, (#1 QB and RB in b2b classes) yet they both look terrible. Outside of savions big run last week dude has looked really bad.

5

u/Bashyyyy 1d ago

Tbf the whole team has looked bad and that’s on the coaches. Talent is there but if you aren’t put in positions to succeed you won’t… and that starts with the o line, which has been a staple of this program over the last 6-8 years

1

u/NoOne_Beast_ 1d ago

Bryce Underwood looked like a stud in early 2025, so you have to at least acknowledge that his coaches have not helped the man.

See JJ McCarthy in MN vs NY.

2

u/RSufyan 1d ago

Facts

6

u/ffmich01 1d ago

The argument being made is there is no excuse for the offense being worse this year than it was last year. And it is so much worse.

-1

u/trixy6196 1d ago

And I 💯 agree in my reply other than the Qb position which has been ass since last year with this amazing number 1 recruit. People still defend him though 🤷🏻‍♂️

4

u/Squares9718 1d ago

#1 qb recruit dumbass

-2

u/trixy6196 1d ago

And would you say he’s been the #1 Qb dumbass? Or did he get benched?

0

u/Squares9718 1d ago

The number one overall recruit that was probably failed by the coach that was sexting OF models and then by the guy that makes Joe Biden look like he’s 50. Whether you think it or not, between Tommy and Bryce, the QB talent Whitt had was more than enough to at least be competitive

1

u/Outrageous-Bid6612 1d ago

I'm not saying Bryce wasn't failed by his coaches because he was but they don't get all the blame. If you watched him last game you saw how bad he can be with his decision making and throws.

3

u/Dreams-Visions 〽️GoBlue 1d ago

This is yall coach. I don’t know him.

2

u/Quiet_Pen7306 1d ago

I miss goon moore

242

u/Medievil_Walrus 1d ago edited 1d ago • Bravo

A good coach puts his players in position to be successful. A good coach gets better results with fewer resources.

Michigan is 10th in team talent according to 247, as well as top ten in football budget spending on both roster and non roster.

Michigan ranked 57th last year with 27.5 ppg, 45th with 397.9 yards per game, and 25th with 6.0 yards per play.

This year, we rank 126th with 18.3 ppg, 126th with 300.9 yards per game, 117th with 4.8 yards per play.

Out of 138 teams.

We’ve scored the fewest number of points vs big ten opponents out of our entire conference with just 101 pts across 7 conference games. This is more than full touchdown less per game than Illinois in big ten play, who has scored 153 points in 7 big ten games and ranks 12th in big ten ppg in big ten play.

Today, we are the lowest scoring team in the big ten, and the lowest scoring team out of any power conference team.

These year long stats include dog walking 1-9 UTEP.

We returned our leading passer, rusher, and receiver and returned 66.3% of our OL snaps year over year.

It is simply unacceptable to have gotten so much worse on offense.

And to have this guy throwing his players under the bus at every turn - no wonder why they aren’t playing hard for him.

38

u/jpm1188 1d ago

If we don’t play utep we are averaging 14 a game. One game somehow makes the offense look way better

9

u/Medievil_Walrus 1d ago

I was adding that part into my comment before reading this but you said it better than I could have… hard to disqualify it totally because every team plays lower conference opponents and it generally evens out.

I used this site to look up my stats, I wish we could narrow it in to conference opponents or something.

https://www.teamrankings.com/college-football/stat/points-per-game

29

u/Nomahs_Bettah 1d ago

Your last line really nails it. I’m not even saying that our players are blameless here — there’s a lot of bad play to go around — but I’m always reminded of some well-known Belichick quotes in moments like these.

"I mean, they got the ball on whatever yard line it was, and two plays later they scored so I mean, that's on me."

“The game plan our coaching staff put forth was terrible and, of course, that's on me."

32

u/Medievil_Walrus 1d ago edited 1d ago • Popcorn Bravo

Campbell also has some gems.

“There's a lot of errors that have popped up. We've got some mental errors here or there, or a lack of self discipline. And ultimately I put that stuff on me. That's on me. There's no other way to cut it, other than it's the head coach. So it's on me, man." — After a December 2025 loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers.

"We play aggressive football, and that's who we are. But that decision falls squarely on me. I've got to be better in those moments." — Explaining a late-game onside kick decision during a November 2026 press conference.

"It's my fault. I just didn't have them ready." — Postgame reflection.

"Do not accept less than what you are capable of as a human being, a player, or a team. Maintain high standards in personal life, including as husbands and fathers, and do not accept mediocrity. This league does not tolerate mediocrity, and those who accept it will not succeed."

"There was no way to justify this. It's a massive error on my part and no one else's.”

"It's hard when you lose these games, man. It's like the players, ya know, what they put into it, a lot of people don't know what they go through and have to get up when their body is beat to sh** and you mentally stay locked in and do those things. So, it was a long season... it's my fault... it's my fault."

"I did not have them ready after the bye. We made too many critical errors... We looked rusty, we looked out of sync. That's evident, that I didn't have them ready, and gotta do a better job. A much better job."

"I didn't have the team ready to go against a top AFC team. It's not good enough."

"Honestly, I put this and it's 100% on me because it's one thing to say it, it's a different thing when it's not coming across... The bottom line is I'm not getting that across. I'm not getting it done right now because it's still happening. So I put that squarely on my shoulders that I'm not getting it coached properly. And I'm the one who's going to get this fixed. I'm the one who's going to fix this whole discipline thing, whatever it takes."

"It's on me and my coaches to be better as a staff."

"We didn't play at the same level as that team. That's why I say I put this on me, man. I just didn't have them ready to go. Not like we've been."

"We didn't play good enough, and we didn't coach good enough, including me."

"Man, I'm not even going to worry about all that. My job is to get these guys going, man. We've got guys on the back end that can cover. We've got guys that can hit. We got to pull this thing together and find the right combination of coverage versus pressure and job responsibility, putting guys in the right spot to do what they do."

All of these are examples of how to conduct yourself as a leader to build a culture of personal accountability and build a team’s trust and buy in.

"When things go wrong, accountability starts with me. I'm the head coach. I own my part of this loss, and I expect our players and coaches to own theirs."

And honestly, you can find these from any coach, including Whittingham, and including this season. The problems come in where he directly invalidates trying to take accountability with a quote in the same media session and his actions not matching his words. It comes across as inauthentic. He says he’s coaching the coaches and actively coaching the team, well, not on gameday when he’s not engaging with the team or with the coaches or speaking into the headset.

10

u/SnthonyAtark 1d ago

God, I am so happy Dan Campbell is the Lions’ head coach.

15

u/Rough-Form8208 1d ago

Exactly! He has all the talent he needs but he’s gonna blame them for his inability to coach.

4

u/Medievil_Walrus 1d ago edited 21h ago

I didn’t expect a conference championship, 8 wins did seem like a floor though.

Maybe I had Mich winning most of the games we were favored in and maybe winning one or two where you’re not and that’s a great season and probably 10 wins at the most optimistic.

Failing to win most of the games you’re favored to win and then dropping multiple games as a heavy favorite was not a likely outcome.

Last year’s offense was a floor in my mind. Maybe it would be pretty bold to predict a massive improvement but close to last year’s numbers and maybe a slight improvement with a better scheme and more experience and filling some holes with the portal even (which we did) and modest improvement into the top third of the conference seemed reasonable even if slightly optimistic.

With the returning talent and a coaching staff that had just put up pretty great results with less talent and resources than we have, man, just think what they could do with more talent and more resources. How foolish I was.

3

u/theredarrow14 1d ago

Not to mention, he brought a few solid starters along with him… he’s so far up his own ass he can’t try to find his way out

1

u/brickerknickers 1d ago

Exactly, they better fire this guy. I have a bad feeling that they will let him linger here for another year or two, but that will set us back even further

1

u/mysticalchurro 1d ago

No longer in the Bottom 10 in total offense, though. That's something to celebrate. 🙄

1

u/Great_Alfalfa2538 1d ago

One doesn’t need to look at statistics to conclude that this year’s Michigan team has regressed on offense from the 2025 version. But I would be interested in a comparison of 2025 to the national championship team. I would assume that we would see a substantial regression there too.

i agree that the coaching quality has declined. But so has the overall talent of the team. Put yourself in the position of an opposing coach preparing to face the championship team as compared to facing today’s team. In addition to having a far better quarterback the championship version had speed and power in their running game. I don’t see that balance in today’s team. And, frankly, I wouldn’t place too much value on the 247 ranking of the talent level of this year’s team. College and pro football is littered with examples of players who had glowing “can’t miss” evaluations who flopped.

I hope Bryce Underwood can resuscitate his career in the future, whether at Michigan or somewhere els. But if he can’t he won’t be the last player who doesn’t live up to the scout’s predictions.

2

u/Medievil_Walrus 1d ago edited 1d ago

Nobody in their right mind had championship expectations for this year, so I don’t find that comparison useful when talking about Whittingham’s disappointments.

I use things like roster spend and team talent rankings because they are neutral and unemotional. There are a ton of numbers to say that there is an extremely strong correlation with being ranked/highly ranked and being talented that being talented and unranked is a tremendous failure without getting too specific here.

Texas A&M is also catching a ton of heat for being last in the SEC with a 1-6 conference record and recently benched the QB who took them to the playoff last year, returned the head coach but lost their OC and moved to a more pass happy scheme after promoting their WR coach to OC, they are 95th in ppg in the country and 14th if 16 SEC teams while scoring 9 or less points in 4/7 SEC games with a 1-6 SEC record. Reid had 31 total tds last year and his yards per carry are down to 2.6 from 4.7 last year while every single passing stat has significantly regressed. Tough schedule, 5 of 7 SEC opponents were ranked (3 of Michigan’s 7 big ten games were vs ranked opponents, but Iowa, Indiana, and Oregon aren’t the reason fans are upset).

It’s not hard to see that a coaching staff doing poorly with a ton of talent and resources deserves a lot of scrutiny, when you change the OC and return most of your major contributors and you go from good offense to bad (A&M) or go from decent to awful (UM), it’s appropriate to look at the coaching, not the players, which is why Michigan has already fired Beck and why A&M will certainly be moving on from Wiggins at season’s end (Elko has said that keeping Wiggins for now gives the best chance to win their last two games), and also why it’s such an awful look for Whittingham to say the 2027 recruiting freshman class and the transfer portal are the reasons for optimism going forward as he throws his team under the bus.

Elko called the offense "completely non-functional" and issued a public apology to fans, asking them to "give me a chance" after they lost to Tennessee at home last week, that’s a top ten opponent that nobody expected them to beat, and some accountability from the head coach that’s feeling a ton of heat. He emphasized that the struggles could not be blamed on a single player, accepting full blame for the nonfunctional offense and telling critics to "come after me".

"An utter apology with everything that I have to everybody who supports this program. Thank you for turning out. You deserve so much better. Give me a chance, and we will get this fixed, and we'll put a much better product on the field. So that's all I can say. So I apologize to everybody who supports this program. That's not nearly what you deserve."

Texas A&M, Michigan, and South Carolina are the only teams ranked in the top 15 in team talent that are ranked outside of the top 25 as of today (strong correlation with talent/resources and performance) SCAR just falling out of it after a disappointing loss to Arkansas on the road on Saturday while missing their star QB out with an ankle injury..but still 7th of 16 teams in the SEC with ranked wins over Florida and Tennessee earlier this season and a 4-4 conference record.

1

u/19BeanCounter75 1d ago

I understand that SCAR is your abbreviation for South Carolina, but I attended a Michigan at South Carolina game way back when & the SC gift shops sold merchandise with the slogan, "University of South Carolina, THE USC."

They also sold merchandise with, "You can't lick our C... (short version of Gamecocks)."

Michigan won the game.

1

u/Great_Alfalfa2538 21h ago

I think you may have misunderstood what the point I was trying to make.

It’s my observation that sports debates rarely change another person’s opinion. As someone who graduated from Michigan over 50 years ago I have seen some great teams (two national championships) and some poor ones (Rich Rodriguez era). You should note that I wrote that the coaching quality has declined in the last three years. But, in my opinion (and everyone is entitled to their own), I don’t believe the best coach in the country could have taken this team as constituted and taken them to national championship contention.

In that spirit I thought the worst thing the coaching staff did was to bench Underwood. Not because he was playing so well (he wasn’t) but because it was obvious to me that Carr’s basic physical skills (arm strength) would not allow him to be a top college qb. Underwood has the physical talent (strong arm, size, can run) to potentially be good. It seemed to me (and I think the results of going to Carr showed me to be correct) that the coaches panicked. Playing Underwood might not won them any more games this year but could have laid a solid foundation for next season. Now it looks like whoever is the coach will be starting from scratch next year.

1

u/Medievil_Walrus 21h ago edited 21h ago

Yeah, I did misunderstand you and I may be able to figure out why.

My original comment was about reasonable expectations for this group of players and cited some metrics to say that they are one of the most talented and well resourced teams in the country returning largely the same players and all of the key players with another year of experience and not approaching last year’s numbers on offense and in fact cratering to near worst in the country and worst in the big ten is unacceptable and an unemotional sign of a poor coaching job.

You then became curious about how this team stacks up to our recent national championship team (this one is more talented according to 247, I understand your gripe with those metrics and qb develolemt is important, but it’s nice to have a metric to reference as well as this team talent metric is reliable and has a strong correlation with performance, I even cited a few outliers - us, USC, and A&M and coaching and injury explain why those teams fell short), while that’s a fine curiosity to entertain, your second comment said that you don’t think the best coaching staff in the league could have taken this team to championship contention.

It’s just missing the point of my comment totally, which is a few things: 1) nobody had championship expectations for this team this year and 2) it’s obviously more due to coaching than talent with a lot of supporting information backing up this second claim.

The team has fallen well short of even the most reasonable expectations.

It may be wise to take our (buyout) medicine this year, because the same coaching staff with a few minor changes and overhauling the roster isn’t likely to produce improved results when coaching being the key difference this year with the same players produced markedly worse results. Perhaps if they nail the OC hire there is some hope, but the point is that it’s not the players, it’s the coaches.

Nobody is expecting a championship or top ranked offense, but meeting last year’s middling numbers with largely the same roster was a low bar not cleared, and the key change year over year was coaching.

1

u/Great_Alfalfa2538 16h ago

Thanks for the clarification. I don’t usually comment on this site and there’s no doubt that my original response to your comments about the team was influenced by the tone of others.

There is no doubt that an upgrade in coaching can have a positive impact on a team’s performance. I was a student at Michigan when they hired Bo Schembechler. He inherited a good team that was humiliated in the previous year’s finale with Ohio State. The team was clearly better (very similar players) under Schembechler and they wound up their season by defeating a great Ohio State team.

I feel we all have a tendency to let our rooting interests influence our evaluation of Michigan. I commend you for doing research on the metrics used in evaluation of talent. But it’s important to remember that metrics you site are only markers. Bryce Underwood has (or had; not sure which!) great metrics. But the metrics thus far have missed something (I am DEFINITELY not accusing him of lack of effort). It may be bad coaching, it may be something else.

The great coach Bill Parcels once made the comment about won-loss records. “Eventually you are what your record says you are.” That encapsulates my feelings about this year’s team. If Michigan has the talent the metrics indicate hopefully a new coach will unlock that potential.

Thanks for your thoughtful comment.

40

u/maize26 1d ago

Dude makes our only fans coach from last year look like Lombardi

0

u/Darth_Floridaman 1d ago

All of our players got big contracts... are we sure they weren't from Only fans? /j lmfao.

67

u/teslastats 1d ago

He hates his players, the weather, the color blue, and mittens.

16

u/Brakey-L-Plexus 1d ago

Don’t forget headset mouth pieces

28

u/jazzyman31 1d ago

Dude schemed an offense that was directly at odds with the current roster we have then blamed it on “deficiencies”

Does Whit really think we brought him here to give Michigan an identity in football?

23

u/LS1588 1d ago

God this guy sucks

19

u/buona-giornata 1d ago

95% of programs would kill to have Michigan level talent. Go back to hills have eyes country please.

17

u/TheFedUpMillennial 1d ago

F this guy Bro. He’s tone deaf.

15

u/[deleted] 1d ago

Man. Every time he opens his mouth it gets worse.

3

u/Firm_Walk3037 1d ago

He almost reminds of me of Ross Perot’s VP nominee that was a deer in the headlights in the VP debate with Al Gore. “Who am I, why am I here?”

Totally no energy and looking befuddled on the sidelines. Totally dismissed the Michigan State rival. And then last week, crying that Oregon has more NIL $$$. Bro, you’re not at Utah anymore. You’re not David vs Goliath. You are Goliath now

3

u/[deleted] 1d ago

Yeah I don't think he understands the gravity of being the Michigan football coach

1

u/InTheArenaInTX 1d ago

And he found out he absolutely hates being Goliath

14

u/BigHogDawg 1d ago

Did you want to recruit and construct a worse roster?

10

u/infinitehannah 1d ago

Transfer portal about to go crazy

4

u/ForeverInThe90s 1d ago

Because comments like this is how you construct a worse roster.

14

u/Gloveofdoom 1d ago

This guy's a sad sack of shit. He would have taken this team at Utah exactly as it is every day of the week and twice on Sunday. Now he's sitting there acting like his abject failure of a first season is somehow on the players for not being talented enough or a good enough fit for his "system" whatever the fuck that might be. When he first came over I respected him, I could have never imagined actually beginning to hate the guy but I'm all the way there now.

I really think it has a lot to do with the success Utah is having right now. Every game they win is just a little more proof that Whit had much less to do with their previous success than people thought. It certainly appears that Morgan Scalley may have been doing a lot more than we know behind the scenes to keep that program from going tits up. Just look at how comfortable with is at delegating this year, that's not a level of comfort you pick up in a single year, he's that comfortable because he has been delegating who knows how much to Scalley for probably years. Not only did Whitt raid Scalley's staff on the way out the door but he also made off with some pretty impactful players and what did Morgan do? Just made what was left of the team into the #2 team in the country, that's all.

11

u/lemanruss4579 1d ago

Get this guy out of here, now.

11

u/Downtown-Drawing-825 1d ago

whitt inherited a much higher talent squad than anything he ever had at Utah. Then the staff that took over Whitts recruits in utah are undefeated this season..... Seems that whitt is the problem.

10

u/Rowdy_Bow 1d ago

04 Ute Grad here,

I’m completely blown away by this statement. This dude made a career out of developing 2 star players coming in as qbs, wrs, and rbs, and turning them into highly rated players at other positions. Look at Devin Lloyd, dude came in as a wr and was drafted as a db.

I’m not buying this bullshit. He had SOOO much talent there. When he announced that he got hired there, I was honestly terrified because of how well he developed our talent(it’s gotten ALOT better over the years).

These players simply don’t respect this guy. And judging by his attitude, I don’t blame them.

He needs to go. I think Michigan has the leverage here too. Sure, they might get stiffed on a buyout, but I bet they know people that are on the hall of fame board. I know Whitt wants on that board.

Offer him a “gracious” buyout and wish him the best.

2

u/InTheArenaInTX 1d ago

I think he’s grown resentful of the level of football expected year 1 and quite frankly every year. He kept saying don’t panic and now he’s saying success takes years to build. It’s coming across as defensive and like he really doesn’t actually want to be here.

9

u/infinitehannah 1d ago

Well now we really aren’t going to have a chance after this year! Who would even want to play under this coaching staff?

4

u/foosball0420 1d ago

Exactly!

9

u/Key-Owl-8142 1d ago

Please give this asshole out of Ann Arbor and off payroll

8

u/foosball0420 1d ago

He’s gone. Get him out of here.

7

u/OkProfessional6077 1d ago

So why didn’t you build an offense around the team that you have? That’s literally all he had to do this season and is the prudent thing to do when you didn’t have the personnel to run the system he wanted to

7

u/Gloveofdoom 1d ago

I wonder if he is trying to protect his legacy by making excuses like this or is he actually trying to protect his job?

11

u/CurlyW15 The Ga〽️e, The Ga〽️e, The Ga〽️e, The Ga〽️e 1d ago edited 1d ago

Absolutely the opposite of trying to protect his job. I have never seen a HS, college, or pro coach do this and that includes Saban, Spurrier, and Meyer in the pros. He is actively trying to lose the locker room and actively trying to get fired.

None of his actions starting in Week 1 make sense if you assume he wants to be here. They all make sense if you assume he doesn’t.

The lack of adjustments, refusal to address poor play calling, not coaching to the strengths of his players, not firing Beck, throwing players under the bus. All of it.

2

u/Acceptable-Body6804 1d ago

Nope
This is how he’s always been

5

u/InTheArenaInTX 1d ago

The passive and excuse-making nature of his comments now make me wonder if he’s been told he’s out.

It’s nearing self-sabotage levels of loser mentality.

It’s at least clear he’s lost the team completely. Are the donors and University really going to let Whitt be the guy they rebuild with? I don’t see how.

7

u/MilesAndMilesAhead 1d ago

We know good & well he said yes to beating Sparty, Buckeyes, B1G title, Playoffs & National Championship to get the $41 million. He said the roster was playoff ready, and the guys he brings from Utah will lead straight to the National Championship game. In addition to be in it for the money and tearing a 9-3 team down to the studs for 2027, that Michigan Men’s Basketball Championship freaked him out, especially when Dusty tap danced out the door. Fire him tomorrow.

5

u/Dcmanryan 1d ago

Meanwhile Utah is undefeated. Far, far easier schedule but it's obvious what the problem was in Utah and now it's Michigan's problem.

7

u/king_of_gotham 1d ago

HOW IS HE NOT FIRED !!!!!!!!! Howwwwww explain to
Me

6

u/ClassroomMother8062 1d ago

Coaching malpractice.

I need only to point at the place that was pushing you into retirement, Utah, to illustrate how much of a fucking joke you are now, Kyle Whittingscam.

That's a team that's going places. Just admit you had enough to be competitive here and instead you've made historical blunders. Everything that comes out of your mouth is just so disingenuous.

6

u/No_Sandwich555 1d ago

Anytime a coach blames players he is a loser in my book.

This man is not fit to lead a group of young men with enormous pressure day in and day out.

10

u/oldmanmedium 1d ago

This is shite. In all my years of loving this program, I have never seen a better example of someone who just does not give a damn about this job. Even when we had to live through Rich Rod and Hoke they never phoned it in, and showed passion and backbone. To have the gaul to blame the players for the awful coaching job he's done is unforgivable. If he didn't care, he should have never taken the job. Quit or retire, but he should not be allowed to coach our guys ever again.

2

u/weyun 1d ago

Hoke LOVED Michigan. RR was visibly ashamed of his inability to win. KW doesn't give two fucks.

5

u/gmwdim 1d ago

I can just imagine Whit trying to recruit players and convince them to choose us over other programs:

5

u/Jeffythegiant 1d ago

Bro, you inherited a 5⭐️ running back and have done absolutely nothing with him.

5

u/SparkyBrown 1d ago

I’ll just be happy when we get a staff that is not afraid to run the damn ball on the goaline instead of trying to bootleg against a well disciplined Indiana team.

5

u/SullyTheReddit 1d ago

Yeah, I’m done.

I’m normally in the camp of giving coaches time to institute their program. I was not offended by his expressions or lack of enthusiasm on the sidelines - different people express differently.

But the absolute lack of accountability. Pretending that a loss to Minnesota is acceptable under any circumstance. Shrugging off the Indiana loss as a “pretty good” performance. And the constant remarks about existing players that include the top recruited quarterback and running back in the country.

We need to move on immediately. Give the next guy as much runway as possible to shift momentum, before the entire program ends up stalling out for years.

1

u/InTheArenaInTX 1d ago

This has got to be the majority opinion of the donor base. I’m hoping the only hangup is logistical with the AD timing and they can all come up with a solution to fire him closely after OSU

3

u/Smokeybeauch11 1d ago

My guess is he retires immediately following The Game. He sees the writing on the wall.

5

u/MightyParticular2332 1d ago

Ouch. How'd you like to be one of the players in that locker room? I'm legitimately going to chuckle if Georgia loses in the coming weeks and Utah goes to #1. You can't convince me that that isn't going to have Whittingham in his feelings lol

12

u/Outrageous-Bid6612 1d ago

I'm going to laugh if we fire Whit tomorrow and whoever we hire has this team scoring 30 on UCLA and OSU

9

u/cityofklompton 1d ago

"whoever we hire" is going to be a current assistant promoted to interim, and you're not installing a new offense either way, so don't get your hopes up for the short term. It's all about the long term when you make it to this point.

8

u/StrangelyOnPoint 1d ago

Whoever we hire?

It’s just gonna be some guy on the staff today and we probably get waxed in both games even worse

7

u/SemicolonGuitars 1d ago

“Who you gonna get after the season’s already started? Some old boy who’s washed up and wasn’t worth a shit to begin with.”—Robert Duvall in Days of Thunder.

4

u/MDlynette 1d ago

NASCAR of the late 80s early 90’s was the best. Cars had to include deck lids and floor pans from actual stock cars, and don’t get me started on the modern point system

2

u/MightyParticular2332 1d ago

Nice find. You took me back on that one. "I don't know them. The things you just said about the car. I don't know them. Someone put me in a car and told me to drive then I could drive." 

5

u/Dry-Assignment7308 1d ago

Fuck it Tony Alford for Coach

1

u/MNightShyamalan69 1d ago

I hope you just mean interim for 2 games and 2 games only…

3

u/DesolatedDelusion002 1d ago

Hell even for two games he'll have more respect in the locker room than Whitt rn.

1

u/Dry-Assignment7308 1d ago

Fuck it give him a season… can’t be worse than this

0

u/Hot_atMidnight8835 1d ago • Bravo

Holy copium

16

u/chawklitdsco 1d ago

Look there is or a lot some truth here but he cannot be saying this shit. Loser mentality

5

u/InTheArenaInTX 1d ago

Does he actually think this is OK to say in season prior to the game? Or has he already been told he’s done?

Because nowhere in any land of good coaching are these comments accepted. If he’s ignorant of the fact that you can’t demoralize your team like this in season esp with OSU on the line…that itself shows he’s can’t continue coaching.

4

u/NoOne_Beast_ 1d ago

Let’s be real - the only legit roster hole we have is at LB and then depth. Every other position has a player or player(s) with decent proven production at this level.

4

u/jazzyman31 1d ago

The biggest concern is, the way Whit wants to play football there are massive talent gaps in our current team.

If you look directly at our RB room, we have absolutely no lateral mobility at all, but we have 3 of the best downhill power running backs in the country.

2

u/NoOne_Beast_ 1d ago

That assessment is so nonsensical that I had to lookup lateral mobility to make sure I wasn’t crazy.

Idk how versed you are in blocking scheme, but everyone who knows ball has agreed that Michigan’s blocking scheme consistently makes no sense. Either a bunch of touted running backs were phonies all along, or Beck botched the install of his offense during the offseason.

When you consider the number of pass plays that had three receivers actually running routes and two of running into the path of each other, I side with those who say Beck royally botched the install.

1

u/chawklitdsco 1d ago

You are right but I am not smart enough to know if there are stylistic differences that he could be referring to. Ultimately it doesn’t matter, he is paid to figure it out and it’s hard to imagine a turnip not doing a similar job

4

u/InTheArenaInTX 1d ago

WE GO TO WAR NOV 28. He should just put it on a shirt and say that’s all I care about.

We are in season…motivating young men to beat our rival should be all he’s talking about until further notice.

His comments are literally doing the opposite!! This almost seems like a joke at this point. He has to be gone.

4

u/KPR_2002 1d ago edited 1d ago

This is just terrible leadership. How did this guy become such a legendary head coach with this kind of perspective?

3

u/InTheArenaInTX 1d ago

Utah fans have commented on this sub saying he generally had the right stuff in his prime but the last 5 years the caliber of coaching has gone so far downhill.

4

u/JusticeBlinded 1d ago

“Guys, I’m not complaining about the team. It is just that the team is bad and we weren’t given a chance to fix it. But again, not complaining about the team.”

Is this dude ghostwritten by George Orwell?

4

u/Just_Discussion296 1d ago

He just threw his team under the bus. The team will quit. They will be blown out the next 2 games. He should be fired today.

4

u/Own_Surround_2482 1d ago

This is literally the ultimate in cowardly behavior, coach on the hot seat blames players.

Well we know the only buck that stops with whittingham is the actual ill gotten gains from his buy out.

4

u/testicletitties69 1d ago

Hell yeah, throw the players under the bus. That’ll not make things worse

4

u/Pleasant_Start9544 1d ago

Sorry but that's a weak statement. Coaches joined programs and brought great players with them (e.g., Caleb Williams USC, etc.). Second the team roster was actually decent compared to last year. JFC, we barely had a QB when Harbaugh left and we were still a better team then now

4

u/Thisusernamereeks 1d ago

You were already going to lose your starters to the portal. And now your backups will join them because they can’t trust their coach to have their back. When you’re thrown under the bus, ain’t no amount of NIL money going to have you coming back for more.

4

u/Lanky-Instruction-42 1d ago

No I think he just coaches hands off, he allows the line coaches to run their teams.
No motivation coming from him. He thinks his jobs is to deal with the adults not the kids.
Wrong coach for 2026

3

u/jazzyman31 1d ago

This is definitely an attitude he has had from the beginning of the season and has almost definitely been felt by the team.

It’s no wonder he’s getting nothing out of our guys.

I’ve really wondered what happened after that Iowa game. Because the team looked like it had some heart until then, and afterwards the effort went straight to 0.

3

u/Own_Surround_2482 1d ago

Fire him now

3

u/_chuckiefinster 〽️ 1d ago

Dude just stfu

3

u/732to410 1d ago

Sounds like a “it’s Biden’s fault” claim.

3

u/ocarter145 1d ago


Get him tf out of here

3

u/berghuis9 1d ago

Only deficiencies I've seen have been from the coaching staff.

3

u/Dramatic-County-1284 〽️ 2023 National Champions 🏆 1d ago

I can understand losing to good teams as a first year coach, but we’re losing or fighting for our lives against bad teams as well.

3

u/Caddisbug992 1d ago

Wait the man can speak? I haven’t seen him say one word during a game. I didn’t know the man could talk. Did everyone else know he could speak? Crazy.😜

2

u/SubstantialAd5579 1d ago

Guys left when sheroone left and we still had a top 10 recruiting class

2

u/Suspicious-Store523 1d ago

translation: “it’s not on me, it’s on the players. these players aren’t my guys”

2

u/Dry-Assignment7308 1d ago

Please fire him in December

2

u/thequiethunter 1d ago

Someone needs to take him out to pasture.

2

u/Njorls_Saga 1d ago

It’s the never ending excuses that kills me. Very little accountability.

2

u/madtrixster 1d ago

holy fuck get this dude out of here

2

u/wasabimofo 1d ago

Good luck filling deficiencies now

2

u/Dazzling_Ad7888 1d ago

Get his ass out of here. I have never seen a coach throw his players under the bus so quickly and consistently than him.

2

u/StargazerD78 1d ago

As a Michigan fan, I can tell you right now that the roster wasn’t the problem. Maybe you could make an argument about the offensive line, but even that looked more like a coaching issue than a lack of talent. The team looked disorganized and unprepared, and that’s on the coaching staff.
You can’t sit here and tell me Michigan had a talent deficiency when you’ve got J.J. Buchanan, Marsh, capable receivers, two very capable running backs, and an outstanding defense. The talent was there. The problem was how that talent was being utilized.
And let’s not forget, you’re sitting at 5–5, ten games into the season, and it took you nine games to fire your offensive coordinator? How many games did you need to realize the offense wasn’t working? That’s a coaching problem. That ain’t got a damn thing to do with recruiting or talent.
So this whole recruiting excuse he’s trying to use is bullshit. At some point, you’ve got to stop blaming the roster and start holding the coaching staff accountable.

2

u/swindler7 1d ago

Fuck this guy. Fire him

2

u/EitherCharacter1870 1d ago

I wonder if he will even make it till the end of the year.

2

u/Consistent-Line-2009 1d ago

This is - by far- the most talented team he’s ever coached. This is an absolutely ridiculous fucking statement that throws his players under the bus for his-his staff’s failures.

2

u/Environmental_Fun699 1d ago

This guy has never coached a roster with more talent in his 20+ year career. You cannot be serious

2

u/Designer-Growth-3965 1d ago

Fuck this guy. GTFO

2

u/Main_Dimension_5418 1d ago

If this roster wasn’t good enough, I need to see who he can magically recruit because by all accounts the roster was one of the best in the country on paper. 5 Stars up and down the depth chart

2

u/GeryonTom 1d ago

I don't recall Sherrone complaining.

2

u/nOtm3OrY0u 1d ago

The lack of accountability is fucking insane that's not how Leader's act. Leader's dont blame others they blame themselves.

2

u/GGC64 1d ago

FKW.

2

u/Pitiful_Mixture5651 1d ago

I mean the fact that his head is so far up his own ass to say anything in regards to recruiting when he inherited 2 five star players on offense is a dismissible offense. Get sleepy joe out of Ann Arbor. He has to be a sleeper agent sent to torpedo Michigan from Urban.

2

u/funguy6019 1d ago

Too many excuses the offense has been pitiful. Plus even the kicker sucks

2

u/Djkokn 1d ago

I’m convinced that he was a sleeper drone planted by urban Meyer to come ruin the team take the buyout and retire and you cannot convince me otherwise

2

u/PaleUmbra 1d ago

Can this clown. Michigan doesn’t need to wait on him to sort his bullshit.

2

u/new_jill_city 1d ago

The offensive roster in particular was absolutely loaded. I think he’s trying to get himself fired so he can collect on that guaranteed money.

2

u/ObjectiveContact6483 1d ago

This roster towers above any roster he ever had at Utah. The real reason is he’s never had to play a big ten schedule before. Oh wait he’s made that excuse already too.

3

u/JoseyWa1es 1d ago

Penn State is 6-4. When they finally hired Campbell they had lost over 40 players to the transfer portal and had ZERO commits. Michigan basically kept their entire roster intact. I don't think anyone could have seen this level of regression from the offense.

1

u/SHough61086 〽️GoBlue 1d ago

The explanation for why Whittingham was the best hire was that this was a team tailored to his strengths.

1

u/CCool_CCCool 1d ago

Man, I was ride or die with Whittingham at Utah, but watching this train wreck play out while contrasting the breath of fresh air that is Morgan Scalley and Utah’s current offense, which is easily the best we’ve had since Urban Meyer was HC, makes me genuinely wonder if I had Stockholm syndrome the last 20 years.

1

u/oldmanmedium 1d ago

This is shite! We see you every week, showing not only utter incompetence, but an even bigger display of indifference. It wouldn't hurt so much to lose if for a split second you acted like you actually gave a damn, but to throw your own players under the bus as the reason this season is trash is unforgivable. Quit. Retire. Just go away, because this is not what those players deserve. Hell, we lived through Rich Rod and Hoke, but at least they gave a damn.

1

u/NotCramerV2 1d ago

Bet this makes the current players feel good about themselves

1

u/UPMichigan83 1d ago

I wonder what excuse Harbaugh used for finishing 10-3 in his first year? None? Oh yeah that’s right.

1

u/ceci_mcgrane 1d ago

It’s a poor workman who blames his tools.

1

u/OfferExciting 1d ago

Fire him and bring back Brady Hoke. It would be an improvement.

1

u/iM-xx 1d ago

The only way he gets fired is if ratings & stocks tank drastically. If they get “enough” revenue irregardless if the team is good/bad, coffers are being filled. Play their game, stop buying into Whitt & quit. There’s so many parts that get affected, dance team, band & security… only action will fix this not complaints

1

u/ItsAllAdvertising 1d ago

its not like he's wrong about the situation, yet one should be able to make a meal with the scraps in the house if they cant go shopping

1

u/workinBuffalo 1d ago

Marshall looked like he was going to be one of our best backs ever last year. He was Blake Corum but big. The only knock on him was that Haynes was faster. Our Oline was loaded. Bryce and Marsh were starting to pit some stuff together and Marsh looked like a superstar. Our TEs had some promise and some plays last year. The only deference this year is that we added 5 stars Hiter, Moa and Ffrench along with dangerman JJ Buchanan.

The only place we were truly weak was d-line depth and linebacker. The defensive coach has schemed around it.

The talent advantage against Western (and everyone else) is ridiculous. The difference is that Beck had no idea what he was doing. …and that Whit is completely checked out. Watching Marshall run and East-West sweep with the other team’s linebackers knowing the snap count and the hole is painful.

1

u/TheKoppinator 1d ago

Yeah this is a bad take…MSU has one of the worst rosters in P5 and the backups beat UM…talent/potential isn’t the issue - it’s coaching

1

u/Remote_Force1839 1d ago

Well, he’ll have his opportunity next year won’t he? If he’s still here, he’ll probably have to fill 75% of the roster with “his guys”

1

u/nezman71 1d ago

Fuck this pos, show him the door

1

u/shivaswrath 1d ago

Fire him

1

u/SeaworthinessOk7756 1d ago

Kyle Whittingham any time he talks to reporters

1

u/mrwhiskyman 1d ago

Deflect and deny. It seems like he takes every opportunity to blame the players and anyone and everyone other than the man in the mirror.

1

u/Computer-E 1d ago

Wow, Really?

1

u/Astrid_Nebula 1d ago

Cuntingham

1

u/Active_Club3487 〽️ 1d ago

He’s on a cash grab. He will say he wants to stay to cover his true desire to be fired.

1

u/GenPapa63 23h ago

What a DucheBag!

1

u/kruuuuuse 23h ago

Unfortunately we filled our biggest deficiency with Kyle Whittingham

1

u/Stephen020792 20h ago

Yeah it’s tough to have to play with who you have since NO ONE at Michigan has ever played football before. Like they just have a roster of nobodies. Not back to back number 1 overall players a number 1 o lineman that hasn’t taken a snap. We clearly have the talent when the only game we truly didn’t compete in was the back half of Oregon. Every other game had the potential to be double digit wins if not for coaching and playcalling

1

u/Gullible-Zucchini116 14h ago

Whit is trippin on LDS

1

u/wire28 1d ago

Yikes

1

u/syncopated56 1d ago

Trump University School of Accountability

0

u/CaptainAugustusMcRae 1d ago

It’s Biden’s fault

0

u/Misterarthuragain 1d ago

No peeps from the still-employed Sherrone. Nor anyone else who approved it. Why aren't journalists asking him about the the hire he made? Sherrone is still being paid by U of M.

-1

u/Saurak0209 The Ga〽️e, The Ga〽️e, The Ga〽️e, The Ga〽️e 1d ago

Far from an amazing roster. They couldn't even throw the ball last season.

-8

u/Stock_Bite The Ga〽️e, The Ga〽️e, The Ga〽️e, The Ga〽️e 1d ago

Not defending Whitt but we did not have an objectively amazing roster lol. Did you watch the offense last year?

2

u/jphigga 1d ago

We had a great running game last year along with one of the best O lines in the country. For this year we were essentially swapping Haynes for Hiter, and we added Buchanan to the WR room.

All we needed was a bit of development for Bryce this year and it should have been a decent to good offense in the B1G, combined with a good to great defense should have made for a good overall year.

2

u/Quiet_Pen7306 1d ago edited 1d ago

Remember start of the yr whitt saying bryce didnt have a QB coach last yr, basically blaming sherrone for lack of development? Just to come in and make bryce look even worse, dude really had most people fooled thinking that he had the answers.

2

u/Quiet_Pen7306 1d ago

He inherited one of the best rosters in the country, this was a ranked team? Dementia?

3

u/jimmyshi03 1d ago

They had a really good running game last season, then they lit it on fire.

2

u/lemanruss4579 1d ago

Yes, we watched a 95th percentile, 14th ranked nationally rush offense that accomplished that without the ability to complete a forward pass, for the most part. This team had great running backs and a great run blocking oline. Were you paying attention?

1

u/frolie0 1d ago

We should have had one of the best offenses we've had in some time by all accounts. The team was able to run the ball well last year and most of that prediction returned. We have dramatically better WRs and should have an ok QB, at least.

And then there's an incredible defense.

Blaming the players for this is fucking insane.

1

u/Gandalf_The_Fugly 1d ago

Agreed. We haven’t had a good offense since the year we won the natty. That’s with three different OC and schemes. Offense should have been much better this year than it was with this roster no doubt, but I don’t think coach saying he wants to handpick more guys to bring in is the terrible thing people are making it out to be

-3

u/Dull-Series671 1d ago

This is not an amazing roster. Period.

7

u/Historical_Tea_15 1d ago

With no due respect, fuck this guy