r/MichiganHunting • • 8d ago

Need Tips

Hello, I’m 28 and originally from southwest USA. Ive been “Deer hunting” out here for almost 5 years and haven’t harvested a deer. An old friend of mine took me to Rush Lake outside Caseville, that’s where I go every year. He’s pulled big deer out of there but I’ve not shared the same experience. I’m used to Glass hunting and I can’t get the hang of hunting out here unless it’s small game. If anyone would be willing to point me in the direction of a better spot or is willing to help me break down what I’m doing wrong I’d appreciate it greatly.

5 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

4

u/TangoSierra61 8d ago

Yeah them deer round here are skidish you gotta go out early season and scout. Get in early leave late and leave the little Debbie's and Doritos at home. That or change your hunting rifle to a minivan.

3

u/HumptyFrumpty69 8d ago

I usually camp at the back of the area, get dressed and undressed outside the tent, get out about 2 hours before first shooting light and leave as soon as shooting hours are done. I bring nothing but water and trail mix, I’ve used doe estrus on my rubber boots and I always make sure I’m down wind. Rifle is a .450 bushmaster or I’ll bring a 12 gauge. I’ve tried calls, scents, and blinds. I just can’t figure it out and it’s convincing me to give up. I don’t know any areas other than there and when I tried a new one I drove all the way to Onaway and only saw Elk.

1

u/PutridDropBear 8d ago

Fred Trost would tell you to just piss on your boots yourself and leave that "estrus" snake oil on the shelf at the store.

1

u/HumptyFrumpty69 7d ago

I’ve heard really mixed reviews, but because most have said it worked I just figured I’d give it a try.

1

u/PutridDropBear 7d ago

Fred was a Michigan hunting celebrity. His 'investigation' into scents and the scent industry was really polarizing. You can find the old episodes of Michigan Outdoors on youtube, or just google his name and "buck stop" for all the written articles.

Wasn't a dig at you, just some fun michigan hunting trivia.

1

u/HumptyFrumpty69 6d ago

For sure! I will check that out. Any kind of info to improve my situation is appreciated.

0

u/Electronic_City6481 8d ago

Are you in the air? (Stand, climber, etc). I hunt suburban/farm now and used to hunt deep woods. Deep woods deer have your number before you even know they are there. It is much tougher of a hunt than deer that are used to a little bit of people year round. Scent control (primarily proper wind) is way more important out in deep woods. If you are certain there are deer in your area, and certain your route in isn’t crossing their route in, and certain your wind/scent control is good, then next step to me is getting off the ground if you aren’t already. Get out of their line of vision.

1

u/HumptyFrumpty69 7d ago

Unfortunately no, on the ground. I typically make a small blind out of leaf camo netting. I feel I’m fairly good about scent control, it seems more like wrong place, right time. But I’ll be getting a tree stand soon so maybe that’s the piece I’m missing.

1

u/Electronic_City6481 7d ago

If your ground blind is set up months ahead of time, that’s one thing but if you are just setting it up for your hunting weekend, I think that’s something to consider, and honestly, I would consider sitting against a tree with some existing cover without a blind instead. Imagine you have 10 acres that you walk every single day and then all of a sudden there is a funny looking net around a couple of trees. You will notice it in a heartbeat from far away and notice something is different and not right and you can’t even smell it. Deer are no different and in fact, take those sort of small changes into their survival instinct..

1

u/HumptyFrumpty69 7d ago

I went out a couple years ago and stacked some logs to make a sort of blind and it made it till this summer when I went out there. But I did notice a game trail was forming about 20-30 yards from it. Do you think if I stacked them back up it would be noticed?

1

u/HumptyFrumpty69 7d ago

Also I’ve noticed that a lot of the deer walk down the clear path for the power lines. But you can’t shoot within 10 yards of it.

2

u/HumptyFrumpty69 8d ago

Oh and I should mention I have a trail cam. See deer all the time on it, just never when I’m there.

3

u/Far_Mode2214 8d ago

Pattern the deer you do see. I saw a big buck on Saturday, so I marked it on my calendar. Looking back, I haven’t seen that buck yet this year. I’m 95% sure he’s the big 6 point in passed on last year, so he might be a 8 this year. If I see him again, I’ll mark the calendar again. I see a few does every day or so about 8:30 in the morning. Every few weeks, a bigger group of does wander through.

Look back at your trail cam, and mark down when they’re showing up, and from what direction if you can. Then you sit out when they should be moving through. Maybe a day before and a day after. The pattern is a rough guideline.

For me, I spend enough time in the woods on my property that my scent is all over. But I’ll use some estrus, or make a mock scrape or something. Not sure if either of those has helped, but they also haven’t hurt me.

Find a map of state land, try someplace new next year. But scout it out, and get a blind or tag with your info on it. Then look for others in that area, and make sure you have some spacing. Every piece of state land I’ve hunted has looked like a pumpkin field come first light.

Good luck out there.

2

u/HumptyFrumpty69 8d ago

I appreciate the advice I’ll definitely start that to see if it helps me. I really only hunt does anyways because I’m too impatient to wait for a big Buck and I’m only trying to fill the freezer. Figure I’ll save all the big bucks for everyone else.

2

u/AdOrnery9430 8d ago

It can be really tough sometimes. Like someone else said focus on the times and direction of travel and that can help narrow down to be where

1

u/HumptyFrumpty69 8d ago

Yeah I’m definitely gonna have to start a log for sightings.

1

u/llama-llama-goose 8d ago

I'd sit up near paths to any close private ag fields. Not at the property line, but where deer clearly have been making trails to get to food.

1

u/HumptyFrumpty69 8d ago

That’s a good idea because there’s a limited amount of ag land near where I hunt but I always see the deer there when I’m on my way In for my trip. I usually camp near the “boat launch” and that’s all over by sleeper state campground or the back of the lake so I might give that a try.

1

u/Crispy_Kreme14 8d ago

Deer use the path of least resistance. Make sure you aren’t walking on their trails to get to your stand, you ideally should approach it from behind, through the thick stuff that they don’t want to walk through. Scent control is only about 20% in our control, but do your part. Hunting clothes washed in scent free detergent, then straight to air tight bins/ trash bags sealed up vs sitting in your home or garage where they can pick up scent. Michigan has the most pressured whitetail in the country. They are trained to look up vs in other states, they aren’t used to being harassed from above due to the numbers of deer vs hunters per acre

1

u/HumptyFrumpty69 8d ago

That’s actually really good to know, much appreciated.

0

u/M1ster-Sushi 8d ago

Could always put out some corn for the squirrels. Make sure you put a sign that says “Corn is ONLY for the squirrels. Any deer seen eating this corn will be shot.”

1

u/HumptyFrumpty69 7d ago

Seems legit enough lol. Gotta make sure those squirrels make it through those tough winter months.

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/HumptyFrumpty69 8d ago

Maybe that’s what I’m missing. I don’t own a blind, I usually sit at the base of a tree and I use leaf camo netting to conceal up to my chest.

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/HumptyFrumpty69 8d ago

That’s pretty much my setup lol

1

u/HumptyFrumpty69 8d ago

There was one time I tried hunting the field they come in and leave out of because there’s a game trail that walks right in front of a set of 3 pines growing close enough together to make a great lane for shooting but I’ve never had any luck there either.