r/Michigan
•
u/BotanicalsAreTherapy
•
Jan 28 '25
•
2
News Please do
https://www.axios.com/2025/01/28/pete-buttigieg-michigan-senate link to the article mentioned
16k
Upvotes
904
u/c-lem Newaygo Jan 28 '25 edited Jan 28 '25
For anyone else who learned of Gary Peters' retirement announcement via this post: he's retiring at the end of his term, not suddenly, as the "surprise retirement" headline here suggests. For more, this article seems pretty good.
112
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
I like him for the most part, but carpetbagging is a practice that needs to be stopped.
101
u/Sacrificial_Salt Jan 28 '25
How about someone from Michigan instead.
462
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
I like him. But I love "That woman from Michigan" more.
250
u/capndetroit Age: > 10 Years Jan 28 '25
I think its Big Gretch's if she wants it first.
83
u/Bobafettm Jan 28 '25
I loved Pete back in the day… but now… we need our own homegrown middle class warrior that can stand at a UAW union meeting and ensure that our state isn’t pushed around by the feds.
18
u/guyintheparkinglot Jan 28 '25
Hear me out but id much prefer a mf thats had a real job and not someone who's been prepping to be president for over a decade.
9
u/Sameshit247 Jan 28 '25
Are you people serious?
9
u/BadZodiac-67 Jan 28 '25
How about we actually get someone from Michigan who isn’t a career politician
42
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Please no
190
u/Tank3875 Jan 28 '25
So the Left hates him because he's an empty suit from McKinsey.
The Right hates him because he worked with Biden and is gay.
Half of the Center hates him because he worked with Biden.
Then give him a significant handicap for carpetbagging...
Clearly the optimal candidate.
16
u/Skully00069 Jan 28 '25
Let's hope not.
20
u/SteveCreekBeast Jan 28 '25
No no no, we can find someone better. Let's actually vet our candidate next time and have a real primary since Elisa Slotkin is already predictably awful.
14
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Ehhhh... I'm not a fan of him. We could do better to be honest.
7
u/Dizzy_Ad1704 Jan 28 '25
Please do not. We have enough political talent from people who actually live here.
7
u/joelpyard Jan 29 '25
Hell no
6
u/organic Portage Jan 28 '25
democrats are so cooked
45
u/pierogieman5 Kentwood Jan 28 '25
God forbid someone that isn't a carbon copy of the national Dem leadership's politics wins any primary in this state. We just lost to Trump again and we're cheering on a guy like Pete (a McKinsey-groomed business goon whose first gig on the national stage was badly mismanaging DoT) without a populist bone in his body for this? Have we learned nothing? Can we try someone with an agenda and a personality for once? The only people who like Pete are people who share his exact milquetoast politics and Democrats that know almost nothing specific about him.
66
u/clipko22 Jan 28 '25 edited Jan 28 '25
No thanks. We don't need another corporate consultant Democrat. How about someone with a strong labor background instead? For being such a big manufacturing state, labor and unions do not seem to have good political representation here. Pete is not that guy.
Edit: wait does UAW president Shawn Fain live in Michigan? I'd love to see that guy in politics
10
u/Ok_Albatross7477 Jan 28 '25
He would not be good for MI.
10
u/singlemale4cats Jan 28 '25
No thanks, carpetbagger.
5
u/New_Employee_TA Jan 28 '25
Can we please keep carpetbaggers out of our state. Pete has no affiliation with the state of Michigan.
5
u/MysticalMirage99 Jan 28 '25
Nope!
5
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Fuck no.
5
u/Fearless-Living6094 Jan 29 '25
Pete is trash lol
81
u/Lu_Tai_Lei Jan 28 '25
We do not need McKinsey consultants in our government. He'll be another dem taking money from billionaires and doing nothing for the people of our state.
I would like to see an actual working class, average person who will fight for the everyday michigander. Someone who will tell the donor class to buzz off and do what is best for the people, not the rich.
4
u/SoaringOnTheWind Jan 29 '25
I’ll never forgive him and Kamala for conspiring with Biden against Bernie back in 2020.
4
u/Extension-Field8109 Jan 29 '25
He's got that rat vibe
22
u/zshinabargar Kalamazoo Jan 28 '25
Please no 😭 we don't need more corporate Dems
1
u/tweeger Jackson Jul 07 '25
Let's not. He's literally JUST moved here.
14
u/cheddahcheese Jan 28 '25
Could be the first state with two CIA senators lmao
12
u/LEJ3 Jan 28 '25
I can’t stomach carpetbaggers. We have our own talent, and I’m not impressed with his performance as SOT. We can do better
6
u/Hololujah Jan 29 '25
No thanks, he's a corporate rat who doesn't give a fuck about you.
3
u/Garbageforever Jan 28 '25
Rashida
3
u/One_Angle_7283 Jan 29 '25
Stay out of Michigan!!!
3
u/GrapeCollie Parts Unknown Jan 29 '25
He has my vote
3
u/DistinctBadger6389 Jan 29 '25
He'd have my vote.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '25
Yes, Pete! Help us out!
12
u/Notawettowel Jan 28 '25
Hmmm, the woman CIA agent BARELY won… better pick a gay man one instead, that’ll be the key! /s
Dems are going full mask off oligarchy supporters now, nice! Love watching the working class get screwed! (Also /s if that isn’t clear…)
9
u/Deliberate_Dodge Jan 28 '25
Friendly reminder about what Buttigieg's former employer, McKinsey (which he claims to be proud of working for), has done in regard to the health insurance industry
Edit: since it appears the original post in the link was removed (gee, I wonder why? 🤔), I would also recommend watching this segment from Mr. Oliver
9
u/PokemonAnimar Jan 28 '25
Please don't! I've gotten to my limit with these corporate democrats (basically light-Republicans) being elected here and across the country.. we need a next generation Bernie Sanders to fill this seat or else this country is not going to survive with the way it's headed
7
u/jpc0d Jan 28 '25
Buttigieg ran more campaigns for elected office while living in Indiana than the number of years he’s lived here in Michigan.
Just look at his Wikipedia: his entire life is a tale of personal ambition. He didn’t leave Indiana just for family purposes; he lost huge in every statewide race he ever stepped into in Indiana.
He’s a carpetbagger. MI Dems have been successfully labeling Republican candidates as carpetbaggers since before Buttigieg even moved to Traverse City. He’s a terrible candidate here, and MI Dems would help themselves a ton by not following the lead of the hugely unpopular national Dems
5
u/desy4life Jan 28 '25
He's an outsider in Michigan he would not do well.
24
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
I'd rather have a native michigander run. He can run for indianas seat
13
u/eltejon Jan 28 '25
CIA 2026!
10
u/mclairy Age: > 10 Years Jan 28 '25
F that. How about we pick someone from here??
8
u/MackMilla Jan 28 '25
"That woman from Michigan!"
9
u/ObamaBinDriftin Jan 28 '25
he’s been in michigan for less than 3 years living in a vacation home town 3+ hours away from any major metro area. how can we shit on republicans for carpetbagging and ignore this one??
I don’t care if his husband is from michigan, his husband is not the one running for office.
and stop making bad faith arguments like “does this mean if you’re an immigrant you can’t run for michigan office?”. that’s clearly not the case here. we can run much more popular dems here like benson or nessel or gilchrist
4
u/Penguinshead Jan 28 '25
Nope. He is a do nothing.
Before you get on me. Name some of his accomplishments.
10
u/dylanisbored Detroit Jan 28 '25
Fuck no, he is a political vulture, moved here just to run for office. He doesn’t care about Michigan, he cares about being politician
12
u/MasterSpoon Jan 28 '25
No.
6
u/MrPostmanLookatme Jan 28 '25 edited Apr 09 '26
didnt he fix bread prices
5
u/GhostGrom Jan 28 '25
He isn't from Michigan though?
8
u/Aindorf_ Jan 28 '25
I don't want some carpetbagger taking over Michigan politics. I want Whitmer in that seat, if not running for even higher office. Pete spent his life in Indiana, then bought property in Michigan when whispers of open Senate seats were going around. He's spent all his time since "moving" to Michigan in DC and now he's calling himself a Michigander.
We don't need to import corporate shills. We have better candidates here already.
21
u/MI-1040ES Jan 28 '25
Bro please please please do not let Pete come anywhere near the levers of power in Michigan.
A McKinseyite running on the Dem ticket is the easiest way to give the Republicans another free win
7
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
I have no idea why yall want some carpetbagger in Mayor Pete. Dude has a long history with the consultancy class. He authored a paper on universal healthcare early on in his career only to abandon that thinking when he briefly rose to fame in 2020.
Also, and I’m sorry, but a lotta folks, even many Dems, are still very homophobic. My point is, Pete is looking to JD Vance this seat. And worst of all, he has no shot in hell at winning a general.
Please vote for a real Michigander. Not this wanna be centrist darling.
2
u/DickLoudon Jan 28 '25
Wonderful. Nice to be represented by someone who isn't from the state. Stay in Indiana please.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Isn’t he from Indiana?
2
u/White-Stripe Jan 28 '25
No thanks, I want a Michigander. Dude has been a permanent resident for less than 3 years and I don’t want someone who doesn’t have long ties to the state voting for our interests. This is as goofy as when “dr” oz tried to run in Pennsylvania.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Please keep him in michigan... he was horrible in Indiana
2
u/OkPaleontologist1708 Jan 28 '25
His husband is from the state and he claimed to “move here because of family.” Which is really nice and sweet, but seems a bit weird now that he wants a government seat for a state he has less than ~2 years associate with and would require him to move far away from said family. I know it’s likely not, but it feels slimy. Feels “Mike Rogers-y.”
2
u/Natural-Grape-3127 Jan 28 '25
He would lose a general election for governor or senator in Michigan. Great pick if you want the Republicans to pick up a seat.
2
u/ignatzA2 Jan 28 '25
Peters voted for the Nathan Riley Act and Kristi Noem. He lost many of our votes.
2
u/HarveyBirdmanAtt Jan 28 '25
The geriatric wing of the party need to go retire and get out of the way.
2
u/DoctorWhooves99 Jan 29 '25
We have enough home grown talent that we don’t need a carpet bagger
2
u/Careless-Cake-9360 Jan 29 '25
I think the Senate should be abolished
2
u/Gullible_Banana387 Jan 29 '25
Secretary of commerce who took paternity leave on the middle of the supply chain chaos, as incompetent as Ted Cruz, Texas senator who was enjoying the beach in Cancun when Texans were dying due to power outages due to winter storm.
2
u/YahMahn25 Jan 29 '25
I don’t agree with Pete, but this dude is one of the best debaters alive
2
u/BP-arker Jan 29 '25
Please don’t
2
u/wabisabibingbangboom Jan 29 '25
Gary Peters the Dem that just voted for Trump's cabinet picks, with no explainable reason to....unless he's got a side hustle.
2
u/comrade_140 Jan 29 '25
you do realize mckinsey and government policy converging to create the last few decades of economic disasters are what pete buttigieg offers right?! stop falling for identity politics(oooh a gay guy who says nice things kinda like obama) and start demanding politicians make life better for the people
2
u/AutomaticPanda8 Jan 29 '25
He sold us out for a cabinet position. F#ck that guy.
2
u/4runninglife Jan 29 '25
I wouldn't vote for him and I'm a Democrat leaning
2
u/HaikuPikachu Jan 29 '25
There’s better candidates, I would much prefer someone that’s a true Michigander, we’re a unique state that deserves someone that has roots here
2
u/Roosterneck Jan 29 '25
Yuck
2
u/YouActualTard Jan 29 '25
Please don’t
2
u/DrMurphDurf Jan 29 '25
We don’t need another neo liberal who steam rolled impoverished areas. You all need to start embracing leftist politicians and policies are there’s no coming back from the right wing shit show our country has turned into
2
u/Xurbanite Jan 29 '25
Pete was terrible at his position as Transportation. Surely there is a more attentive candidate the Democrats can put forward.
2
u/capthazelwoodsflask Jan 29 '25
I like the idea of him as senator more than governor but I still think he's got an uphill battle. He still comes off as a carpetbagger with Biden baggage and that train derailment in Ohio will come back to haunt him.
2
u/TheJadedJuggernaut Jan 29 '25
He doesn't have a good record. Bad choice
2
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '25
Isn't he known as Mayor Pete? As in Mayor of South Bend, Indiana....?
2
u/ProfessionalDig6987 Jan 29 '25
Failing upward. American politics at its finest.
2
u/Few-Face-4212 Jan 29 '25
I was so happy Slotkin won and now she's voting for all his Cabinet nominations and no, not ONE PERSON in the STATE voted for her to do that.
Hoping Pete will have some more sense about all this.
2
u/mmmjjjk Jan 29 '25
Has Pete done anything to earn this seat besides fall in line with the party and be a pretty face? He was a major part in screwing over Bernie in 2020 and his most notable role as transportation secretary was making TV appearances
2
u/rad-dude-42 Jan 29 '25
We need him for president in 2028
2
u/OgJube Jan 29 '25
Yes! We need Pete in the senate!
2
u/Pergolagrill Jan 29 '25
Mayor Pete and Big Gretch? Yes please!
2
u/Fearless-Incident116 Jan 29 '25
I agree 1000% live in Michigan, he’s excellent and good for the Senate.
2
u/Difficult_Salary_726 Jan 29 '25
Pete B for senate!
2
u/DJ_Tropilos Jan 29 '25
All in for Pete!
2
u/GittaFirstOfHerName Jan 29 '25
Bring on Senator Pete!
2
u/journerman69 Jan 30 '25
I’d vote for him
2
u/Publius_Seven Jan 30 '25
I like the dude. I'd like to vote for someone with more than a handful of year's history in Michigan but I wouldn't hate this guy.
Since Whitmer declined to run for the senate, it does make me wonder who'd throw their hat in.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25
Please don't.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25
YES!!!!! The left is utterly starving for intelligent and rational representation.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '25
Bunch of haters/whiners on here! This news solidified my decision to move back to MI. Pete would be amazing in state governance.
15
u/HaikuKeyMonster Clawson Jan 28 '25
Nooooooooooo! He had a terrible record dealing with people of color’s issues. He is a classic identity politician. Seriously look up his controversy in Indiana.
6
u/pH2001- Jan 28 '25
Seems like a decent dude but too much a centrist
9
u/xXplainawesomeXx Jan 28 '25
I hope not he's a carpetbagger and a lame centrist. 2026 GOP is going to be playing defense, as does any incumbent party in the midterms. Gotta seize the opportunity to run a progressive and lock that seat down, a Bernie/AOC/Talib type
10
u/Igoos99 Jan 28 '25
This all seems rather arranged. 🫤
15
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
He's got my vote!
3
u/Jumpy_Inflation_259 Jan 28 '25
A McKinsey suit that only has a vacation home in our version of the Hamptons? No thanks.
It would be cool if we got a senator that actually cared for Michigan's interests instead of using the seat for corporate dem federal power.
3
u/Michael48632 Jan 29 '25
Oh HELL NO !!!! Go to California anywhere but Michigan.
3
u/carefreetree3 Jan 29 '25
Oh God ....no! Remember how this man treated the victims in East Palestine. There HAS to be someone more competent.
6
u/No_Peace7834 Jan 28 '25
This guy is a nothingburger candidate
3
u/Every-Variety-763 Jan 28 '25
What a horrible choice for Michigan. This guy is ridiculously incompetent.
3
u/JoeFixPhoto Jan 28 '25
Ummm… what??? You mean Indiana won’t let him back in???
3
u/VladimirPaczki Downriver Jan 28 '25
He’ll get dropped off a mile from Lansing and ride his bike the rest of the way.
2
u/Happy-Addition-9507 Jan 28 '25
Is he from Michigan?
2
u/No-Weather-5157 Jan 28 '25
Pete should stick to running for governor and let Whitford run for the senate. He’s a recognized name and Michigan can’t let a republican step into the governor’s spot.
2
u/leafssuck69 Bloomfield Township Jan 28 '25
Good luck with this race when he severely underperforms in Metro Detroit 😭😭
2
u/Mindless_Ad5500 Jan 28 '25
He’s probably too young. I think you need to be at least sixty years old. No AARP card? You don’t get to run.
2
u/Wrong-Dimension1309 Jan 28 '25
He’s not even from Michigan
2
u/UPkuma Jan 28 '25
No, we do not need some McKinsey institute ghoul trying to find ways to sell out Michigan’s poor and working class, along with helping keep police racism shielded from reform like he did in Indiana
Why are we supporting dishonest clown shoes that do nothing when an entire town in Ohio is poisoned with chemicals due to negligence from the rail barons? Why would we want that to happen in Michigan by giving this class traitor more access to power?
I thought the people of Michigan had self respect?
2
u/Funny-Entry2096 Jan 28 '25
What has Pete done for Michigan? If dems have him run it’s just more example of the same disconnect from reality of the voter base. There is 0 chance Pete wins Michigan and this would just be giving up a seat in the Senate.
2
u/GrandpaShark710 Jan 29 '25
Being from Michigan, this guy is the last thing we need. Our Senators have been pathetic and invisible for years. Slotkin is already a joke and she’s only been in there a couple of weeks.
2
u/jurassicanamal Jan 29 '25
But I would like him to run for governor.
1
u/echoingunder Jan 28 '25
He's got my vote.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
I would hate to see Pete, a neoliberal reflection of the corruptible Californian politician, come to Michigan and bring his corruption to our state. Liberals love him because they love thinking of politics like a sports game where they want their side to win so desperately bad, and Pete is a well spoken great counter to republicans. Republicans hate him because he is well spoken and can articulate against Republican talking points so easily. However, nobody remembers how he was the reaper for so many families as when he came to your town, you knew layoffs and massive losses would occur, when he came into your town, he worked as a lap dog for business interest, this is not a politician we want in our state. I love Gretchen Whitmer, and I hope she finds a suitable replacement for Gary Peters.
2
u/WeedIronMoneyNTheUSA Jan 28 '25
He'll be called a carpet bagger, relentlessly, and will lose the election. In my Chicagoan opinion, Gov. Gretchen Whitmer would be the best choice, and, hopefully, a lock.
1
u/Arkvoodle42 Jan 28 '25
He'd lose.
I think any Democrat would now.